VINCENT OBIORA OBIOZO & ANOR v. UAC NIGERIA PLC & ORS
(2018)LCN/11995(CA)
In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
On Wednesday, the 18th day of July, 2018
CA/E/555/2017
RATIO
APPEAL: WHETHER A COURT HAS JURISDICTION TO ENTERTAIN APPEAL
“It is also their contention that the appeal, being one of mixed law and facts, leave of this Court was necessary as a condition precedent. Circumstances under which it is necessary to obtain leave of this Court or the trial High Court to appeal a decision or ruling of Court are stated in the Supreme Court case in Faith Enta Ltd Vs. BASF (Nig.) Ltd (2010) 4 NWLR (Pt. 1183) 104 (SC). A Court has no jurisdiction to entertain an appeal on a ground of fact or mixed law and fact unless of course, leave has been obtained. One of the obvious results of the state of the law is that where an appellant’s grounds of appeal are only of facts or mixed law and facts the grounds, and hence the appeal must be struck out unless leave had been obtained. All grounds of facts or mixed law and facts must be struck out.” PER SAIDU TANKO HUSSAINI, J.C.A.
JUSTICES
OYEBISI FOLAYEMI OMOLEYE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
JAMES SHEHU ABIRIYI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
SAIDU TANKO HUSSAINI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
Between
1. VINCENT OBIORA OBIOZO
2. JONATHAN CHIEDU OBIOZO
(Suing for themselves and as representing Late King Obi Anazonwu family, Obeoza, Onitsha) Appellant(s)
AND
1. UAC NIG. PLC
2. UACN PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT CO. PLC.
3. YOUNG SHALL GROW LTD
4. NNABYELUGO J. ONONYE
5. NNAJI OBANYE
(For themselves and on behalf of Mgbekekeke family of Onitsha) Respondent(s)
SAIDU TANKO HUSSAINI, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment):
This appeal revolves around the ruling or the order made on the 28th July, 2017 at the High Court of Anambra State sitting in Onitsha wherein the appellants were foreclosed from further Cross-examination of Pw1. The background facts leading to this ruling or order can be recounted:
‘The appellants had commenced action as plaintiffs and claimed against the respondents several reliefs by way of the Writ of Summons and the Statement of Claim dated the 18th September, 2006. The 3rd, 4th and 5th respondents, as defendants filed a joint Statement of defence and counter-claim wherein the counter-claimants sought several declaratory and injunctive reliefs. Appellants’ Motion for extension of time to file Appellants’ reply to respondents’ Statement of defence and defence to counter-claim was dismissed on the 5th June, 2007. The trial High Court sitting on the 10th November, 2011 further struck out the claim brought by the Appellants for want of diligent prosecution of his case, thus leaving the 3rd, 4th and 5th respondents’ Statement of defence and counter-claim to be defended by the appellants.’
The 3rd, 4th and 5th respondents, in the bid to prove their case (counter-claim) before the trial Court, called evidence of Pw1 who testified on their behalf having also adopted his earlier statement on Oath as his evidence in chief.
The appellants commenced their Cross-examination of Pw1 almost immediately after the close of his evidence in chief on 20th February, 2017. See page 1436 (vol. 2 of the record of appeal). The Cross-examination of Pw1 continued until the 28th July, 2017when the trial Court put an end to it by the order drawn up in the following words:
‘The cross-examination must come to an end at this stage. Learned counsel is merely repeating questions to prolong the cross-examination which has now spend more than 4 days. A question takes a minimum of 10 minutes to be put to the witness. Litigation is not conducted in this manner. The cross-examination for today started at 9.20 am and now it is 12 noon and question asked on the first day of the cross-examination are merely being repeated in various ways.
I have been patient but this is the far I can go. Further cross-examination is accordingly but (sic) to an end.’
Not pleased with this Order or ruling of the court, the defendant, by the Notice dated the 9th August, 2017 and filed on the 10th August, 2017 lodged an appeal to this Court on the lone ground contained in the Notice of Appeal at pages 1470 – 1472 of Vol. 2 of the record of appeal.
The appellants and the Respondents filed and exchanged their briefs of argument wherein the appellant by their brief of argument dated the 10th October, 2017 and filed on the 11th October, 2017 formulated 1 (one) issue from the only ground of appeal for determination of Court thus:
Whether the trial Court in shutting out the Appellants from further Cross-examination is not a denial of the Appellants’ right of fair hearing in the circumstances of this case?
The 3rd, 4th and 5th respondents, by the brief of argument filed on their behalf on the 7th December, 2017 raised 2 (two) issues for determination one of which relate to the point of objection raised by way of Notice of Preliminary Objection dated and filed on the 7th December, 2017, wherein the 3rd -5th respondents sought for:
(i) An Order of Court striking out the appeal for being incompetent.
(ii) And for such further order(s) as the Honourable Court may deem fit to make in the circumstances.
The 2 (two) issues for determination raised in 3rd – 5th respondents’ brief of argument at page 4 are as follows:
(i) Whether the Court has jurisdiction to entertain the appeal, the leave of Court having not been first sought and obtained? (arising from the Preliminary Objection)
(ii) Whether the appellants were denied their right to fair hearing?
The 1st and 2nd respondents did not file any brief of argument. They are deemed to have conceded to the outcome of this appeal.
There is also no reply brief from the appellants as their response to respondents’ Preliminary Objection and arguments canvassed thereto by the respondents.
The appeal came up on the 26th April, 2018 for hearing. Counsel present, adopted their respective briefs of argument.
Relative to Preliminary Objection taken, we were urged to strike out the appeal for being incompetent and this Court lack jurisdiction to entertain same so far as leave to appeal the interlocutory ruling or order made at the trial court had not been sought and obtained.
It is also their contention that the appeal, being one of mixed law and facts, leave of this Court was necessary as a condition precedent. Circumstances under which it is necessary to obtain leave of this Court or the trial High Court to appeal a decision or ruling of Court are stated in the Supreme Court case in Faith Enta Ltd Vs. BASF (Nig.) Ltd (2010) 4 NWLR (Pt. 1183) 104 (SC). A Court has no jurisdiction to entertain an appeal on a ground of fact or mixed law and fact unless of course, leave has been obtained. One of the obvious results of the state of the law is that where an appellant’s grounds of appeal are only of facts or mixed law and facts the grounds, and hence the appeal must be struck out unless leave had been obtained. All grounds of facts or mixed law and facts must be struck out.
The only ground of appeal in this case, is set out in the Notice of appeal, particularly at page 1471 of Vol. 2 of the record of appeal. Notwithstanding that the said ground of appeal was couched as a ground of error in law, a close reading of the said ground along with the particulars indicate that the complaint is against the trial Court’s exercise of its discretion to put an end to further Cross-examination of Pw1. Such is a ground of mixed law and fact for which prior leave is required to legitimize the ground of appeal. See: ACB Vs Obmiami Brick and Stone(1993) 5 NWLR (Pt. 294) 399.
Otherwise such ground of appeal is incompetent and perforce must be struck out. Every Court sitting as an Appeal Court lack jurisdiction to entertain appeals based on such incompetent grounds of appeal as it is in this instant appeal case. There is nothing on pages of the record of appeal before us that suggest that prior leave had been sought and obtained in line with Section 242 (1) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended).
This appeal not being an appeal within the meaning of Section 241(1) of the Constitution, the Notice of Appeal containing the lone ground of appeal is incompetent, the appellants having failed to comply with the conditions precedent for filing of a valid appeal by first seeking leave to appeal. See the case of Okereke vs. Yar?adua (2008) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1100) 118; Madukolu Vs. Nkemdilim (1962) All NLR 587.
In line with my discourse as above, the lone issue formulated in the appellants’ brief of argument which is similar to Issue No. 2 formulated by the 3rd – 5th respondents in their brief in relation to the question whether or not there has been a breach to appellants’ right to fair hearing by reason of the order of Court handed down on 28th July, 2017 does not arise. It is academic or moot question and such questions should be discountenanced so far as this Court lack jurisdiction to entertain same. In effect I uphold the Preliminary Objection of the 3rd – 5th respondents hence Appeal No. CA/E/555/2017 is struck out.
Cost in the sum of N50, 000. 00 is assessed against the appellant in favour of the 3rd – 5th respondents.
That is the Judgment and order of Court.
OYEBISI FOLAYEMI OMOLEYE, J.C.A.: I had the privilege of reading in draft form the leading judgment in this appeal just delivered by my learned Brother, Saidu Tanko Husaini, J.C.A.
The preliminary point of law raised by the 3rd to 5th Respondents to the competence of this interlocutory appeal, not responded to by the Appellants, is quite germane as it goes to the foundation of this Court’s jurisdiction to entertain same.
I agree that the appeal is incompetent as it does not fall within the categories of appeals as of right under Section 241(1) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 as amended. For the lone ground of appeal contained in the Appellants’ Notice of Appeal is one of mixed law and facts, thereby requiring the prior leave of this Court sought and obtained to file in deference to Section 242(1) of the said Constitution, which leave the Appellants failed to obtain, the appeal must without any reservations be struck out forthwith.
Hence, with the devastation of the Notice of Appeal, it follows that the substantive appeal in the main has become spent as this Court equally lacks the platform by way of jurisdiction to mount on and determine same. See the cases of: (1) Dr. Okey Ikechukwu v. F.R.N. (2015) 7 N.W.L.R. (Pt. 1457) p.1; (2) Nwazuruike v. A. G., Federation (2007) 2 SCNJ p.369; (3) N.E.P.A. v. Ango (2001) 15 N.W.L.R. (Pt. 737) p. 627 and (4) Onyemeh v. Egbuchulam (1996) 5N.W.L.R. (Pt.448) p. 255. In the case of: Dr. Okey Ikechukwu v. F.R.N., Nweze, J.S.C., at page 21, paragraphs B- G and page 22, paragraph C, stated as follows:
As a general rule, an intermediate court, like the Court of Appeal has a duty to pronounce on all the issues before it. However, there are exceptions to the foregoing rule. Thus for example, where the Court of Appeal decides that it lacks jurisdiction in an appeal before it, it becomes unnecessary for the Court of Appeal to consider other issues. In this case, the Court of Appeal upheld the 1st Respondent’s Preliminary Objection to the competence of the Appellant’s appeal. In the circumstance, it was unnecessary for the Court of Appeal to consider the arguments in support of the issues for determination distilled by the parties in the appeal. (The underlining is mine for emphasis).
Consequent upon my foregoing analysis, this Appeal No. CA/E/555/2017 is hereby struck out for being incompetent.
The 3rd to 5th Respondents are entitled to the costs of this appeal which I assess in the sum of Fifty Thousand Naira to be paid to them by the Appellants.
JAMES SHEHU ABIRIYI, J.C.A.: I AGREE.
Appearances:
C. H. Asiegbu, Esq. with him, Uchenna Omenaukipi, Esq.For Appellant(s)
Steven Onyechi Ononye, Esq. with him, Oliver I. Ugwu, Esq. for the 3rd – 5th Respondents.
1st and 2nd Respondents unrepresented
For Respondent(s)



