LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

SODEINDE BROTHERS (NIGERIA) LTD V. AFRICAN CONTINENTAL BANK LTD(1982)

SODEINDE BROTHERS (NIGERIA) LTD V. AFRICAN CONTINENTAL BANK LTD

In The Supreme Court of Nigeria

On Monday, the 28th day of June, 1982

SC.99/1981

RATIO

POWER TO RESTORE APPEAL THAT HAS BEEN DISMISSED

The appellant’s appeal was dismissed on 10th May, 1982 for want of prosecution under Order 9 rule 7 because he had failed to file Brief within time as required by Order 9 rule 3 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1977. He now applies for an order to re-store the appeal and to  have it re-listed for hearing on the merit. The respondent opposes the application. This court has consistently decided since Ogbu v. Chief Urum (1981)4 S.C.1 that we have no power to restore an appeal that has been dismissed for want of prosecution under Order 9 rule 7. PER M. BELLO J.S.C.

POWER TO GRANT AN APPLICATION THAT HAS BEEN DISMISED

There is no statutory or inherent jurisdiction in this court to grant the application seeking that the appeal which has been dismissed by this court to be restored: See Chief Iro Ogbu & ors. v. Chief Ogburu Urum & Anor. (1981) 4 S.C. p.4 particularly as per Obaseki, JSC., on pp. 3-15. This case has been dismissed for want of prosecution and I agree it stands dismissed. I cannot find any distinction between Iro Ogbu’s case and this case. There is no merit whatsoever in the application to empannel a full court to reconsider the Iro Ogbu case as the authorities cited to us thereupon by learned counsel Mr. Sofola are, all, with respect, irrelevant. PER ESO J.S.C.

JUSTICES

AYO GABRIEL IRIKEFE    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

MOHAMMED BELLO    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

KAYODE ESO    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

AUGUSTINE NNAMANI    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

MUHAMMADU LAWAL UWAIS    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

Between

 

SODEINDE BROTHERS (NIGERIA) LTD  Appellant(s)

AND

AFRICAN CONTINENTAL BANK LTD  Respondent(s)

 

  1. G. IRIKEFE, J.S.C. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): This appeal was dismissed by this court on 10th May, 1982 for want of prosecution, the actual default relied upon for dismissal being the fact that the appellant/company had not filed its brief within time as stipulated by the rules of this court (Supreme Court Rules – 1977). The company has now moved that notwithstanding the order of 10th May, 1982 aforesaid, the appeal should again be re-entered. Mr. Kehinde Sofola, SAN., on being told that this application would appear to be on all fours with the decision of this court in Ogbu v. Urum (1981) 4 S.C. p. 1 submitted that the instant application could be distinguished from the facts upon which this court relied in the Ogbu case aforesaid. Alternatively he submitted that on the basis of the following cases:- (a) U.B.A v. Nworah (1978) 11 & 12 S.C. p.1 at p.10; Ojikutu v. Odeh (1954) 14 WACA 640 at 641, Ikwere v. The State (1981) 9 S.C. p.4, Ogunmola v. Igbo (1941) 7 WACA p. 137, we should hold that Ogbu v. Urum was wrongly decided and accordingly afford him an opportunity of having the matter argued afresh before a full court. Mr. Aguda for the respondents opposed the application.
    It is plain beyond argument that all the authorities relied upon by Mr. Sofola, barring one, predate the rules of court (Supreme Court Rules 1977) upon which the decision in Ogbu v. Urum was anchored. To that extent the said authorities would not appeal to be helpful in regard to the line of action being urged upon us by learned counsel. The only other case falling within the rules, that is Ikwere v. The State was a criminal case which was merely struck out and as such is not directly relevant to the application before us. It is significant that this matter was struck out on 10th May, 1982 soon after the coming into force of practice directions issued by the Chief Justice of Nigeria on 26th April, 1982, designed no doubt, to put at rest the laxity in the approach of litigants to appeals pending before this court. No ground has been shown for reversing the said decision of 10th May, 1982, assuming that this could be done, which clearly cannot be done by a panel such as this with equal and concurrent jurisdiction with the former panel. Equally, no valid grounds have been shown to persuade me that Ogbu v. Urum was wrongly decided to enable this panel recommend that this is a fit and proper matter for further argument before a full panel of this court. In the result, this application is refused. It is dismissed with N25 costs in favour of the respondent.M. BELLO, J.S.C.: The appellant’s appeal was dismissed on 10th May, 1982 for want of prosecution under Order 9 rule 7 because he had failed to file Brief within time as required by Order 9 rule 3 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1977. He now applies for an order to re-store the appeal and to  have it re-listed for hearing on the merit. The respondent opposes the application. This court has consistently decided since Ogbu v. Chief Urum (1981)4 S.C.1 that we have no power to restore an appeal that has been dismissed for want of prosecution under Order 9 rule 7. With regard to the informal application for this matter to be referred to a full court for a re-consideration of the decision in Ogbu v. Chief Urum, learned counsel has not shown to my satisfaction any decision of this court which is in conflict with Ogbu’s case. I agree the application should be dismissed with N25 costs to the respondent.

    K. ESO, J.S.C.: There is no statutory or inherent jurisdiction in this court to grant the application seeking that the appeal which has been dismissed by this court to be restored: See Chief Iro Ogbu & ors. v. Chief Ogburu Urum & Anor. (1981) 4 S.C. p.4 particularly as per Obaseki, JSC., on pp. 3-15. This case has been dismissed for want of prosecution and I agree it stands dismissed. I cannot find any distinction between Iro Ogbu’s case and this case. There is no merit whatsoever in the application to empannel a full court to reconsider the Iro Ogbu case as the authorities cited to us thereupon by learned counsel Mr. Sofola are, all, with respect, irrelevant. The application is dismissed with N25.00 costs.

    A. NNAMANI, J.S.C.: On the 10th May, 1982, this court dismissed the application of the applicant for extension of time within which to file its brief of argument. Its appeal was also dismissed. The dismissal for want of prosecution was pursuant to Order 9 Rule 7 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1977. The applicant has now brought another application mainly to re-enter the already dismissed appeal. Although an affidavit is attached raising new and substantial issues, the question is really whether in the face of the judgment of this court dated 10th May, 1982, which was final judgment, this panel has jurisdiction to grant such an application. I am of the view that it hasn’t. The matter was fully considered by this court in Chief Iro Ogbu & Ors. v. Chief Ogburu Urum & Ors. (1981) 4 S.C pp. 1-23. Once a final judgment of this court is given under Order 9 Rule 7, it cannot be reviewed or set aside except on any of the grounds set out in Order 7 Rule 30 of the  Supreme Court Rules, 1977. The applicant has not shown that its case falls under any of these grounds. The judgment may also be set aside if there is a fundamental defect which goes to the issue of jurisdiction. The applicant raised the fact that in this case no application for dismissal of the appeal was made by the respondent. I agree with Mr. Aguda that it is not mandatory for  the respondent to make such an application, and in any case the court in such circumstances has the jurisdiction to act. See Order 9 Rule 7. Mr. Sofola raised the point that unlike in the Urum case he had not previously applied for extension of time. I would only say that his application was caught by the Practice Directions of this court given on 26.4. 82. I would with respect say, as I did in the Urum case, that I agree that it may be necessary to re-examine the rigours of Order 9 Rule 7 and make provisions analogous to Order 7 Rule 23 (2), Order 7 Rule 19(4) and Order 7 Rule 25 of the Supreme Court rules 1977. I agree that the application be refused. I also dismiss it. N25 costs to respondent.

    M. L. UWAIS, J.S.C.: I agree that there is no merit in this application since the appeal was dismissed under Order 9 rule 7 of the Supreme Court Rules 1977 for want of prosecution and following our decision in Chief Ogbu v. Chief Urum (1981) 4 S.C. 1. There is also no substance in the application to refer the case to a full panel of this court as no other decision of this court has been cited which conflicts with our decision in Chief Ogbu’s case. I too will therefore dismiss the application with N25 costs to the respondents.

 

Appearances

  1. Sofola SAN., (with him, K. S. Sofola) For Appellant

 

AND

  1. O. Aguda For Respondent