LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

OBA ILIASU AJALA v. THEOPELUS AKANDE & ORS (2018)

OBA ILIASU AJALA v. THEOPELUS AKANDE & ORS

(2018)LCN/11717(CA)

In the Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Thursday, the 14th day of June, 2018

CA/AK/112/2012

RATIO

PROOF OF TITLE TO LAND

In a declaration of title to land, the law is trite that the claimant must prove any of the following five ways in order to succeed in his claim:
1. By traditional evidence.
2. By production of documents of title duly authenticated and executed.
3. By acts of ownership extending over a sufficient length of time numerous and positive enough as to warrant the inference of true ownership.
4. By acts of long possession and enjoyment.

5. By proof of possession of connected or adjacent land in circumstances rendering it probable that the owner of such connected or adjacent land would in addition be the owner of the land in dispute. per MOHAMMED AMBI-USI DANJUMA, J.C.A.

PLAINTIFF’S CLAIM DEPENDENT METHOF OF ESTABLISHING TITLE

The law is also settled that the claim of the plaintiff and the facts and circumstances of each case will be dependent on the particular way or method being sought to be proved in establishing his claim to title.  per MOHAMMED AMBI-USI DANJUMA, J.C.A.

TRADITIONAL EVIDENCE

The law is trite that where the case is fought on evidence of traditional history which in other words becomes a matter of hearsay upon hearsay which is the nature of traditional evidence, the trial Court in its traditional role of an umpire has a duty to examine the evidence of the parties and come to the conclusion which is more probable in the circumstance of the case, by testing it against the other evidence. per MOHAMMED AMBI-USI DANJUMA, J.C.A.

 

JUSTICES

UZO IFEYINWA NDUKWE-ANYANWU Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MOHAMMED AMBI-USI DANJUMA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

OBANDE FESTUS OGBUINYA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

OBA ILIASU AJALA
(Adoo of Idoo, Egbedore Local
Government) Appellant(s)

AND

  1. THEOPELUS AKANDE
    2. JIMOH FALADE
    3. SHITTU LAWAL
    4. TAFA OLAOYE FALADE SANUSI
    (For themselves and on
    behalf of Oyewole Royal Family of Idoo Egbedore Local Government, Osun State) Respondent(s)

MOHAMMED AMBI-USI DANJUMA, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): 

This is an appeal against the judgment delivered by Hon. Justice J. O. Ogunleye J. of the High Court of Osun State sitting at the Ejigbo Judicial Division on the 6th day of March, 2012.

The plaintiffs herein the respondents commenced this action against the defendant/appellant by a writ of summons accompanied by a statement of claim dated and filed 14/04/2010. The plaintiffs claimed against the defendants for the following reliefs:
1. A declaration that all the piece or parcel of farmland consist of palm trees at Oroorun along Origo Village, Idoo, Egbedore Local Government of Osun State is, according to Native Law and Custom, joint properties of Oyewole Royal House and Ajala Royal House of Idoo Village in respect of which the Oyewole and Ajala Royal Family of Idoo are jointly entitled to the customary right of occupancy as inheritance from their descendant i.e Oyewole and Ajala who are sons of Oyesojo and Akinyanju respectively.
2. A declaration that the 1st defendant has no right to sell the said joint properties of Oyewole and Ajala

 

Royal House i.e a piece or parcel of farmland measuring approximately 250 Acres known and situate at Oroorun along Origo Villiage, Idoo, Egbedore Local Government, Osun State of Nigeria without the consent and approval of the entire Oyewole and Ajala Royal Family i.e the Plaintiff family who are joint owner of the farmland with Ajala Royal family of Idoo Village.
3. A declaration that the purported sale of the family properties i.e piece or parcel of farmland consist of palm trees, cocoa trees, kolanut trees known and situate at Oroorun along Origo Village, Idoo Egbedore Local Government Osun State, by the 1st defendant to the person unknown is illegal, null and void and of no effect whatsoever and therefore be set aside.
4. An injunction restraining the 1st defendant by himself or his servant and agents from further dealing with the said farmland to the exclusion of the plaintiff’s family.

The defendant’s statement of defence dated 12/10/2010 was filed 13/10/2010. Both sides filed their witnesses written deposition on oath at the trial, the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs testified as PW2 and PW1 respectively.

Both witnesses adopted their written statements on oath.

The defendant on his part testified as the PW2 and called 4 other witnesses who gave evidence as DW1, DW3, DW4 and DW5. These witnesses also adopted their respective statements on oath. No exhibits were tendered by both sides.

At the close of hearing of the case, counsel on both sides filed their written addresses and the court delivered its judgment in favour of the plaintiffs.

On being dissatisfied with the decision of the learned trial Court, the appellant came before this Court by a notice of appeal dated and filed 04/05/2012 containing six grounds of appeal.

In compliance with the rules of this honorable Court, appellants brief of argument dated 21/01/2014 was filed on 18/02/2014 while respondents brief was filed on 08/04/2014. Appellants Reply Brief is dated and filed on the 30/04/2014. All briefs of arguments were deemed filed on 06/11/2014.

Learned counsel for the appellant submitted the following four issues for the determination of the appeal. They are:
i. Whether the learned trial judge of the lower Court was right when he held that Respondents proved the identity of the alleged land in dispute on the twin account that the Appellant did not join issue with the Respondent in his pleadings and that the Respondents gave adequate description in their evidence. See Ground 1.
ii. Whether the learned trial judge of the lower Court was right when he held the Respondents proved joint ownership of the alleged land in dispute with the Appellant by their evidence and also because of the failure of the Appellant to specifically deny paragraphs 23 and 26 of the Plaintiffs/Respondents statements of claim. See Grounds 2 and 3.
iii. Whether the learned trial judge of the lower Court was right when he held that the Appellant has no power to re allocate a jointly owned family land. See Ground 4.
iv. Whether the learned trial judge adequately evaluated the evidence of the Appellant by his failure to see that the Appellants case preponderates over that of the Respondents. See Grounds 5 and 6.

On the part of the respondents, three issues were formulated by counsel which are:
a. Whether the learned trial judge was wrong when he held that the respondents proved the identity of the land in dispute owing to the description given by the plaintiffs in their pleading and the corroborative evidence by the defendant’s witnesses.
b. Whether the learned trial judge was wrong when he held that the respondents claims succeeded on the legal admission of same by the Appellant.
c. Whether the learned trial judge was wrong when he held that the appellant has no right to re-allocate lands (whether jointly owned or not) already allocated by him or his predecessors flowing from the evidence of the witnesses called by the appellant himself.

The issues raised by counsel on both sides are similar. The issues formulated by the learned counsel for the appellant will sufficiently determine the appeal. They are thus adopted.
ARGUMENTS:
ISSUE ONE:
Whether the learned trial judge of the lower Court was right when he held that respondents proved the identity of the alleged land in dispute on the twin account that the appellant did not join issue with the respondent in his pleadings and that the respondents gave adequate description in their evidence. (Ground 1).

On this issue, learned counsel for the appellant referred to Sections 131(1) & (2); 132 and 133 of the Evidence Act in contention that burden of proof rests on the plaintiff who seek reliefs before the Court especially where such reliefs are declaratory. He cited Akinyemi v. Odua Invest. Co. Ltd (2012) ALL FWLR (Pt. 620) 1215 @ 1237; Akande v. Adisa (2012) ALL FWLR (Pt. 635) 250 @ 273. He argued that the first duty of such a party seeking a declaratory and injunctive reliefs before the Court is to show with accuracy the identity of the land in dispute. Counsel referred to paragraphs 6 and 8 of the respondents pleadings, 8 and 11 respectively of the written depositions on oath of the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs where the land in dispute was described by the plaintiffs; that these descriptions were not reflected in the writ of summons and the reliefs stated at the end of the statement of claim.

He contended that the respondents apart from the above points, failed to call a boundary man as a witness and, that no survey plan was tendered in evidence. He referred to the position of the learned trial Court on pages 84 and 85 of the record to submit that the defendant under paragraphs 2 and 42 of his statement of defence denied paragraphs 6 and 8 of plaintiffs/respondent’s pleadings. He referred to pages 20 and 23 of the record.

Counsel further referred to the evidence in chief and the oral evidence given before the Court of the DW1, DW2, DW3, DW4 and DW5 on the record to buttress his point that the defendant/appellant denied knowing the identity of the land in dispute as given by the respondents. That the position of the learned trial judge in that regard was correct but says, curiously, the Court held otherwise.

He submits there was joinder of issues contrary to the finding of the lower Court. He cited Ogun v. Akinyelu (2005) ALL FWLR (Pt. 243) 601; Ezerioha v. Ihezuo (2010) ALL FWLR (pt. 540) 125.

It was further submitted by counsel that the findings of the learned trial Court on the issue of identity and joining of issues by parties are inconsistent and in conflict with the evidence on record. He asserted that the identity of the land claimed by the respondents which is approximated at 250 acres cannot be proved by mere ipse dixit of the respondents. That claim of the respondents to approximately 250 acres is not specific.

He insisted that the defendants did join issue with the plaintiffs/respondents on the identity of the land in dispute. That the land claimed by both parties are not the same and can only be resolved by a survey plan or map, none of which was done. He referred to Eke v. Okwaranyia 6 NSCOR 239 @ 260 to argue that it is the attitude of the Court not to believe ridiculous evidence even if not challenged.

Counsel also posited that the measurement of the land in dispute at 250 acres was not given by experts but by illiterate farmers. That the defendants having given a different description of the land in dispute has joined issues with the respondents who now have the onus of proof by filing a survey plan. He cited Atolagbe v. Shorun (1985) 1 NWLR (pt. 2) 360.

He maintained the view that respondents do not know the area and extent of the land granted by the appellant for the establishment of a university and as such cannot say anything about it. He cited Ansa v. Ishie (2005) ALL FWLR (pt. 276) 651. Counsel submits that in granting declaratory and injunctive reliefs, all the essential elements including the description of the land must be proved with particularity. He cited the following cases; Akingbe v. Shenogor (2003) FWLR (Pt. 1860) 568; Ibekwe v. Imo State Education Management Board (2007) ALL FWLR (pt. 488) 297; Sanya v. Sauman (2012) ALL FWLR (Pt. 618) 917.

ISSUE TWO:
Whether the learned trial judge of the lower Court was right when he held that respondents proved joint ownership of the alleged land in dispute with the appellant by their evidence and also because of the failure of the appellant to specifically deny paragraphs 23 and 26 of the Plaintiffs/Respondents statement of claim (Grounds 2 & 3).

On this issue, learned counsel for the appellant referred to paragraphs 10, 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 of the respondent’s pleadings to assert that the land in dispute as claimed is jointly owned by the plaintiffs. That their ancestors Oyewole and Ajala were brothers begotten by Odukunle, their father. That the issue of common ancestry of the respondents if not proved conclusively, their case must fail.
Learned counsel referred to paragraphs 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 and 36 of the appellants pleadings to contend that appellant not only denied the above paragraphs of the respondents statement of claim but went ahead to state a contrary traditional history of the land in dispute. That the respondents failed to file a reply and issues were joined on facts relating to traditional history of the land in question. Counsel is of the contention that respondents should have called independent witnesses in proof of their case (traditional history). He cited Section 121(c) of the Evidence Act on proof of fact.

Appellants counsel further submitted that it is not enough to conclude that the respondents have a common ancestry on the basis of their respective titles as heads. That respondents admitted that the Timi of Ede is the Customary Overlord over Idoo Village. He referred to the evidence of the PW1 and PW2 on pages 69 and 70 of the record. That respondents did not deny the averments in paragraphs 27, 30 and 36 respectively of the appellants pleadings and his written deposition on oath on page 38 of the record.

Counsel explained that the appellant denied joint ownership of the land in dispute with the respondents. He referred to paragraphs 17, 18 and 19 of the appellants pleadings, contending that under Ede native laws and customs, all unallocated Idoo land is vested in the head. That settler as customary tenants in Idoo land pay tributes to the Village head who transmit same to the Timi of Ede. He further referred to paragraphs 17, 18, 19, 20, 28, 29, 35, 27, 38 and 42 of the appellants evidence in chief on pages 38 and 39 of the record. He also referred the Court to paragraphs 3, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, and 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 11, 14 and 15 of the statements on oath of the DW1 and Jacob Ojo respectively to submit that the averments in the appellants statement on oath were not denied.

It was further argued by counsel that the evidence on record of the respondents under cross examination on pages 69 and 70 supports the case of the appellant on the issue relating to allotment of land by the Adoo subject to the consent of the Timi of Ede. That parties also differ on the crops on the land in dispute casting the onus of proof on the respondents who according to him have failed. He cited Giwa Osagie v. Giwa Osagie (2011) ALL FWLR (Pt. 555) 363; Olawore v. Ojo (2006) ALL FWLR (Pt. 341) 1383, 1386.

He also cited Sanya v. Sauman (supra) to submit that the plaintiff as claimant must rely on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the case of the defence. That the admission made by the PW1 and PW2 was not considered by the learned trial Court which according to counsel is a serious misdirection. He referred to Savannah Bank Plc. v. CBN (2009) ALL FWLR (Pt. 485) 939 and urged us to set aside the judgment of the Court below.

It was also argued by counsel that the respondents having admitted to paying tributes to the Timi of Ede, their traditional history of joint acquisition of the land in dispute by first settlement at Idoo by Oyesojo and Akinyanju is disproved. He submitted that the nature of the assertion naturally dictates the nature of rebuttal.
He referred to Ige v. Fagbohun (2002) FWLR (Pt. 127) 440; First Bank of Nigeria Plc. v. Excel Plastic Industries Ltd (2003) FWLR (Pt. 160) 1624; T. O. M. Co. Ltd. V. Bank of the North Ltd (2002) FWLR (pt. 112) 10, 31; Ojeh v. CAC (2010) ALL FWLR (Pt. 542) 1723.

That paragraphs 23 and 26 of the respondent’s pleadings are facts not known to the appellant and thus shifted the onus of proof on the respondents.

That the respondents in view of the above paragraphs which were denied by the appellant, failed to call Aafa Bakare as a witness. That declaratory reliefs are not granted by way of admission or default. He cited Akhigbe v. Shenogor (supra); Olubodun v. Lawal (2008) ALL FWLR (Pt. 434) 1468. He stressed the point that a plaintiff must succeed on the strength of his own case. He referred to Adeniran v. Alao (2002) FWLR (Pt. 90) 1285).

Learned counsel further contended that based on the evidence adduced by the PW1 and PW2, they submitted a case of original settlement but admitted to a case of grant under cross examination. He cited Oyediran v. Amoo 1970 ALL NLR 313. He also referred to the evidence of the PW1 on page 69 of the record.

Counsel is of the view that by the evidence of the respondents as adduced, the right of the appellant to grant land was proved.

Another argument put up by the learned counsel for the appellant was that the case of the respondents runs contrary to their pleadings and their written statements on oath which they adopted as their evidence in chief.

He referred to the evidence of the 2nd plaintiff on page 70 of the record. He stated that a claim of exclusivity was put up by the respondent’s contrary to their claim for joint ownership in their pleadings. That parties must be confined to their pleadings. He cited Nsiegbe v. Mgbemena (2007) ALL FWLR (pt. 372) 1769, 1776; Oyediran v. Amoo (supra); Yusuf v. Adegoke (2007) ALL FWLR (Pt. 385) 384, 387.

He submits that the claims of the respondents are declaratory and injunctive which required clear proof. He cited Akhugbe v. Shenogor (supra).

ISSUE THREE:
Whether the learned trial judge of the lower Court was right when he held that the appellant has no power to re-allocate a jointly owned family land (Ground 4).

Appellants counsel contended that the issue arises from the findings of the learned trial judge on page 87 of the record which according to him were in error. That the findings of the trial Court in view of power to allocate land by appellant just like the king of Ede, which conform with the traditional history of the evidence of customary law as given by the appellant that land in Idoo is vested in the successive Adoos, the appellant inclusive.

He argued that the traditional history of the respondents relating to joint founding of the land in dispute was false and that the Court below failed to give cognizance to the admission of the appellants case by the respondents. That the respondents case ought to be dismissed. He cited Omotayo v. COOP Association (2010) ALL FWLR (Pt. 537) 608.

Further on the finding of the trial Court on allocation of land by the respondents, counsel argued that they (respondents) neither pleaded nor proved when the land in dispute came to be jointly owned, who allocated the land to them and the names of heads that held same since it was allocated to them. That the respondents merely placed reliance on traditional history of Ido communal land which according to him was disproved.

Another point argued by counsel was that the respondents did not show in evidence that the land in dispute was an allocated land but rather claimed exclusive ownership contrary to their pleadings.

That they failed to prove that the land in dispute was a joint family land founded by their common ancestor.

He submitted that the finding of the trial judge that the plaintiffs have proved their case is perverse.

ISSUE FOUR:
Whether the learned trial judge adequately evaluated the evidence of the appellant by his failure to see that the appellants case preponderates over that of the respondents (Grounds 5 & 6).

Learned counsel for the appellant referred to page 87 of the record to contend that the finding of the learned trial judge presupposes that the plaintiffs/respondents have proved their case despite their admissions of the case of the appellant and failure of their traditional history and their claim for exclusive ownership as against joint ownership. That respondents conceded that Idoo land is vested in the traditional head (Ido) and that the said heads have been making grants of Idoo land to individuals and families. That they did not prove how they jointly owned the land in dispute, who granted it and the names of the successive joint heads of the two families were not shown. Counsel adopts his arguments under issues 2 & 3 above and urged the Court to set aside the learned trial Courts conclusion. He submits that where traditional history fails, the Court can no longer have recourse to issue of possession which he says was neither pleaded nor proved herein. He cited R. T. D. A. v. Nkume (2002) FWLR (pt. 90) 1285, 1772; Yusuf v. Adegoke (supra).

That where the plaintiff asserts joint ownership of a property with the defendant, he is deemed to have admitted that the defendant own same.
He contended that the onus of proof of joint ownership is on the respondents. He referred to Ewo v. Ani (2004) ALL FWLR (pt. 200) 1484.

It was also the contention of learned appellants counsel that the Court below failed to appraise the appellants traditional history. That the trial Court did not compare the traditional history of the appellant alongside that of the respondents in reaching its decision. That the Court below merely recited the appellants and his witnesses’ evidence without appraising. He referred to Wulima v. Goniram (2004) ALL FWLR (Pt. 228) 151.

Counsel is of the view that from the facts on record as to grant of land by successive Ados and the admission by the respondents that Ido community pay tribute to the Timi of Ede, the trial judge ought to deduce that the defendant/appellant has the right to grant land. He cited Agbanelo v. Union Bank Plc (2000) ALL FWLR (pt. 13) 2197; Woru v. State (2011). He argued that the trial Court did not evaluate the traditional evidence of parties before accepting that of the respondents.

He submits that the respondents by their admission succeeded in proving customary tenancy to the Timi of Ede; that successive Adoos were appointed by him, the overlord since the existence of Ido. That being customary tenants, the trial Court was wrong to have granted their reliefs. That a customary tenant is only entitled to possession which can be forfeited in the event of breach of the overlord’s authority. He referred to Yusuf v. Adegoke (2007) ALL FWLR (Pt. 385) 384, 387; Olubodun v. Lawal (supra); Anyaduba v. NRTC (1992) 5 NWLR (pt. 243) 536; Isiba v. Hanson (1968) NMLR 76.

Learned counsel noted that a customary tenancy notwithstanding the length of possession cannot ripen into ownership. He cited Akintoye v. Eyiyola (1968) NMLR (Pt. 92); Adewale v. Oyegbade (1967) NMLR (Pt. 136). He submits that where traditional evidence of the respondents is conflicting and there is no evidence outside of their own evidence in support of their case, a declaratory and injunctive reliefs ought not be granted to them. He referred to Oyediran v. Alebiosu (1992) 6 NWLR (Pt. 249) 550; Lambe v. Jolayemi (2002) FWLR (Pt. 96) 414 @ 417.

In reaction to appellants issue one, counsel to the respondents submitted that a plaintiff may succeed in his claim for a declaration of title to land only if he has a better title and he must succeed on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the case of the defence. He cited in support the cases of Dakolo v. Rewane  Dakolo (2011) 50 WRN 1 @ 20 lines 20  25 SC; Kodilinye v. Mbanefo Odu (2003) 36 WRN 162; (1935) 1 WLR 231; (1935) 2 WACA, 336.

That by the writ of summons and the statement of claim of the plaintiffs/respondents, they showed that they were from the same ancestor with the defendant/appellant which forms the basis for their being the two ruling families in Ido land. That respondents showed in evidence how the two families came to settle on the land in dispute and how each of the families produced leaders i.e Ado of Ido over time.

That except for the general Ido land, parties never sold parcels of land belonging to each other until the appellant ascending the throne. Counsel referred to Order 15 Rules 5 (1) & (2) of the High Court of Osun State Civil Procedure Rules, 2008 contending that the above claims of the respondents were not denied by the appellant.

That a general denial as did the appellant, in law, amounts to admission. That the appellant failed to comply with the law by denying specifically each and every claim of the respondents.

On the identity of the land in dispute, learned counsel referred to page 74 of the record to submit that the appellant in his evidence admitted that respondents own so many parcels of land scattered around Ido. That DW3, DW4 and DW5 admitted in their evidence in chief to knowing the land in dispute. He referred to pages 28, 30 and 34 of the records. He further referred to the evidence of the DW3 on pages 75 and 76 of the record in support of his argument.

Counsel contended that the land in dispute is known to the respondents and have described same under paragraphs 6 and 8 of their pleadings. That the evidence of the DW3 and the descriptions given by the respondents in the above paragraphs of their pleadings is enough to satisfy the appellant and the Court on the identity of the land in dispute. He referred to Dakolo v. Rewane – Dakolo (supra) to assert that the land in dispute was known to both sides. Counsel also referred to the case of Nwokidu v. Okanu (2010) 26 WRN 23 @ 53 to 54 to further buttress the point that respondents by paragraphs 6 and 8 of their statement of claim did describe the location and boundary men to the land in dispute and it was believed by the learned trial Court. He urged us to resolve issue one in favour of the respondents and against the appellant.

On the second issue raised and argued by the learned counsel for the respondents which issue is similar to the appellants issue two, he again referred to Order 15 Rules 5 (1) and (2) (supra) to submit that the failure of the appellant to specifically deny each and every allegation of facts stated in the respondents pleadings amounts to admission of the said facts. That general denial cannot operate as a denial of any specific facts in the opposing party’s pleadings. He referred to paragraph 2 of the statement of defence of the defendant/appellant.

Counsel re-stated his argument under issue one above that the appellant under cross  examination admitted that respondents land are scattered in Ido which include the one granted to their forefathers by the Timi of Ede; that appellant never denied the said lands to be different from that which is claimed by the respondents. Learned counsel cited the cases of Kayode v. Odutola 1 SC LLAC 225 @ 234 and Ironbar v. Fedmorigage FIN (2009) 46 WRN 146 @ 159 to submit that the Court can act on evidence elicited during cross examination not pleaded.

Further on failure of the appellant to specifically deny the facts put forward by the plaintiffs/respondents in the pleadings, counsel urged us to hold that the decision of the learned trial judge on same was right; he relied on the following cases: Popoola v. Owena Press Ltd (2011) 52 WRN 85 @ 112 lines 15  40; A. O. Amuzie v. Asonye (2011) 6 NWLR (pt. 124) 19 @ 53.

On the 3rd issue which is similar to issue three of the appellant, learned counsel for the respondent referred to the position of the learned trial Court on page 87 of the record to submit that the trial judge was in order when he held that the appellant who is the Ido of Idoo lacked the power to re-allocate unallocated family or jointly owned lands in Ido. Counsel referred to the appellants evidence on page 74 of the record where he testified that Timi gave land to the respondents forefathers, he also referred to the evidence in chief of the DW3, DW4 and DW5 on pages 28, 30 and 34 of the record to back his argument in support of the position of the learned trial Court on the issue. He further referred to the oral testimony of the DW3 in that regard on pages 76 and 77 of the record and also that of the DW5 on page 77 of the record, all to the effect that the Ido of Idoo has no authority to re-allocate or take back lands already allocated to persons in Idoo.

Learned counsel maintained that the appellant who said the plaintiffs land which he sold was given to their forefathers by the Timi of Ede who under the native law and custom had power to so do called DW3, DW4 and DW5 to give evidence in support of such custom. That the learned trial judge saw and heard the testimony of witnesses on both sides before reaching his decision which according to counsel was proper.

He cited the case of S & D Construction Co. Ltd v. Ayoku (2011) 46 WRN 1 SC to assert that there is no evidence stronger than the appellants admission. That a Court is able to decide at the conclusion of evidence who is a witness of truth. He cited Wachukwu v. Owunwanne (2011) 25 WRN 1 @ 25.

Counsel urged this Court to resolve this issue in favour of the respondents, dismiss the appeal and uphold the lower Courts decision.

In reply to the arguments of the learned counsel for the respondents on issue one appellants counsel contended that none of DW3, DW4 and DW5 testified to knowing the land in dispute as argued by the respondent’s counsel. That counsel only relied on Order 15 Rules 5(1) and (2) of the High Court of Osun State Civil Procedure Rules, just like the Lower Court contending that defendant failed to specifically deny facts in their pleadings thus amounting to admission. He is of the view that defendant by his statement of defence did deny the facts contained in the respondent’s pleadings but that respondents fell into error by reading same in isolation. He cited Etim v. Clasen Ventures (2012) ALL FWLR (pt. 646) 596.

It was contended by counsel that by the statement on oath of the DW3 who under paragraph 4 acknowledged that he knows the land granted by the 1st defendant at Idoo, denied under paragraph 12 the features on the land as claimed by the respondents. He further referred to the evidence on oath of the PW1, PW2 DW3, DW4 and DW5 to add that they stated that the land granted to Pastor Bamidele was a virgin land, contrary to the features stated by the plaintiff which are food crops. That issues were joined on identity of the land in this regard. That the averments in the statement on oath of defendants be read a whole and not in isolation. That parties differ on the features of the land in dispute constituting denial of identity of same. He cited Eke v. Okwaranyia (2001) 6 NSCQR 239; Orji v. Emovon (1991) 1 NWLR (Pt. 168) 476.

In reply to issue three of the respondents, learned counsel again contended that it is not allowed by law to interpret a specific sentence or a witness answer in isolation. He referred to the evidence on record of the appellant on page 74 that the land that belongs to the plaintiff was granted to them by our forefathers to farm Timi gave the land to their forefathers does not constitute an admission that the respondents have land at Ogbe farm, his evidence quoted above cannot be interpreted to the alleged land in dispute. That respondents interpreted the appellant and his witness’s testimonies in isolation and failed to prove their case. He cited Echi v. Nnamani 2 SCNQR 728.

It was also the contention of counsel that the respondents argued for exclusive ownership of the land in dispute contrary to declaration of joint ownership claimed by them.
He urged us to allow the appeal and dismiss the claims of the respondents.

RESOLUTION OF ISSUES:
In a declaration of title to land, the law is trite that the claimant must prove any of the following five ways in order to succeed in his claim:
1. By traditional evidence.
2. By production of documents of title duly authenticated and executed.
3. By acts of ownership extending over a sufficient length of time numerous and positive enough as to warrant the inference of true ownership.
4. By acts of long possession and enjoyment.

  1. By proof of possession of connected or adjacent land in circumstances rendering it probable that the owner of such connected or adjacent land would in addition be the owner of the land in dispute. See Idundun v. Okumagba (1976) 9 10 SC 227; Nwokidu v. Okanu (2010) 1 SCNJ 167 @ 195; Nruamah v. Ebuzoeme (2013) 1 SCNJ 128 @ 144 145.
    The law is also settled that the claim of the plaintiff and the facts and circumstances of each case will be dependent on the particular way or method being sought to be proved in establishing his claim to title. See Nruamah v. Ebuzoeme (supra); Mogaji v. Cadbury (Nig.) Ltd (2004) 23 WRN 54; (1985) 2 NWLR (Pt. 5) 41.

In a claim for a declaration of title like in the instant case and like in all civil matters, the onus is on the plaintiff to prove his case with credible and convincing evidence, he must in doing so rely on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the case of the defence. This is more so where the defendant did not file a counter claim. The plaintiff must convince the Court by credible, consistent and reliable evidence that he is entitled to the declaration sought.

See Nwokidu v. Okanu (supra); Odofin v. Ayoola (1984) 11 SC 72 @ 119; Okafor v. Idigo (1984) 1 SCNLR 481 @ 198190.

The plaintiffs who are respondents herein claimed by their pleadings for declaration and injunction. In order to succeed the law, require of them in view of order for injunction to clearly identify the area of land to which their claims relate since the Court cannot grant an order for injunction in respect of an undefined area. Failure of the plaintiff to so identify the area of land he claims, his claim must fail. See Nwokidu v. Okanu (supra); Makanjuola v. Balogun (1989) 3 NWLR (pt. 108) 192.

The 1st issue for determination as raised by the learned counsel for the appellant which I have adopted border on the identity of the land in dispute. It is to be noted that from the facts of this case, both parties in this appeal in a bid to establish title to the land in dispute relied on traditional history which is one of the methods established in Idundun v. Okumagba (supra).
The plaintiffs/respondents under paragraph 6 of their statements of claim on page 4 of the record described the land in dispute to be known and situate at Oroorun along Origo Village, Idoo, Egbedore Local Government Area, Osun State and measuring 250 acres. This description was corroborated by the evidence in chief of the 2nd and 3rd respondents under paragraphs 8 on pages 11 and 16 respectively of the record. The respondents under paragraph 8 of the statement of claim described the boundaries of the land in dispute as follows:
– On the first side bounded by Aaro River
– On the second side bounded by Elemila Village
– On the 3rd side bounded by Adegbile Family land
– On the 4th side bounded by Osun River.
See page 5 of the record. The above description is also the same with the boundary description of the land in dispute given by the 2nd and 3rd respondents under paragraphs 11 of the averments contained in their written depositions on oath.
The argument proffered by learned counsel for the appellant on this issue is that the descriptions as given by the respondents above in their pleadings and statements on oath were not reflected in the writ of summons and in the reliefs stated at the end of the pleading. The law is that parties are bound at all times by their pleadings.

The description of the boundaries and area of the land in dispute stated above are averments in the pleadings of the plaintiffs/respondents and the appellant under paragraph 2 of his statement of defence on page 20 of the record only gave a general denial of the said averments. The law is trite that Where the material facts pleaded by a plaintiff are not properly traversed, no issue is joined thereby and there is therefore no dispute on the issues. See Atanda v. Iliasu (2013) 6 NWLR (pt. 1351) 527 @ 566; Mandilas and Karaberies Ltd v. Apena (1969) 2 SCNLR 293; Omorhirhi v. Enatevwere (1988) 1 NWLR (pt. 73) 746.
The denial by the appellant under paragraph 2 of his pleadings of the identity and description of the boundaries of the land in dispute by the respondents was not specific and therefore on the above authority, it was improper. The above provision of the law is in tandem with Order 15 Rules 5 (1) and (2) of the High Court of Osun State Civil Procedure Rules, 2008 which provides that:
5(1)  Every allegation of facts in any pleadings if not specifically denied in the pleadings of the opposite party shall be taken as admitted. 5(2)  A general denial in any pleadings shall not operate as denial of any specific fact in the pleadings of the opposite party.
Relying on the above authorities and in view of paragraph 2 of the pleadings of the defendant/appellant denying inter alia paragraphs 6 and 8 of the averments of the plaintiffs/appellants in that unspecific manner, he has in law admitted such facts. It was further held in Atanda v. Iliasu (supra) that Facts admitted need no proof, and the Court is expected to act thereon. In the instant case with the absence of a denial of the appellants averment in paragraph 8 of the statement of claim, it was in law deemed admitted by the respondent. For the respondent to have joined issue with the appellant thereon, he was expected to have clearly, specifically and outwardly registered his denial on the identity of area of the land in dispute. ….. See also Fatuade v. Onwoamanam (1990) 2 NWLR (Pt. 132) 322; Owosho v. Dada (1984) 7 SC 149 @ 550  551.
My finding above is in agreement with the position of the learned trial Court on pages 84 – 85 of the record that; the identity of land in issue as stated by the plaintiffs was not disputed by the defendants who merely gave entirely different boundaries as related to the conquest of Timi of Ede in paragraph 10 of their statement of defence. No issue was joined in respect of the boundaries by the defendant with the plaintiffs.”
It is my opinion therefore that the plaintiffs/respondents had the duty to show clearly and unequivocally the area to which their claims relate as did they in their statement of claim supported by their evidence on oath; the said duty of the respondents does not even arise since the defendant in his statement of defence did not specifically dispute the identity or location of the land in dispute as claimed by the respondents. He (defendant) must specifically make it an issue in his pleadings by disputing the description or location of the property as given by the plaintiffs. See Mohammed v. Mohammed (2012) 11 NWLR (Pt. 1810); Dada v. Dosunmu (2006).

On their oral evidence before the Court, the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs who gave evidence as PW2 and PW1 respectively adopted their written statements on oath which support their pleadings.

The defendant on his part who failed to specifically traverse the description of the land in dispute as given by the respondents testified as the DW2 that he does not know the land in dispute. See page 73 of the record where he stated as follows:
I do not know the location of the land in dispute. The plaintiffs are from Oyewole Royal House. I know they have land in Ido the land of the plaintiffs are scattered and many at Ido. I do not know the exact one they are claiming that I sold. I know all the land at Ido and I know all the farms and the owner of the farms at Ido because I was born there.”

On another hand, this witness who is the defendant and serving head of Ido testified on page 74 of the record as follows:
I know Oyewola Family has land in Ido. I know their land on Ogbe Farm road. That is the only one I know.

The above piece of evidence in my view is contradictory of the one earlier excerpted where the witness clearly stated that the respondents have many lands scattered in Ido and that he knew all the farms and their respective owners, being the head of Ido.
The defendant in his pleadings gave a different description of a land in his pleadings and having not filed a counter claim against the respondents, the land, the description and identity of which was pleaded by the plaintiffs/respondents is regarded as the land in dispute between the parties. In view of the facts of this case and the authorities cited, I hold that the finding of the learned trial Court on the identity of the land in dispute was proper, I agree with it.

Issue one is resolved against the appellant and in favour of the respondents.

The 2nd issue before this Court deals with joint ownership of the land in dispute. The issue relates to traditional history of the land in dispute which, as can be gleaned from the facts of this case, the method through which both parties herein made effort to establish their title to the land in question.

According to the plaintiffs who are respondents herein, the original owners of the land in dispute was Akinyanju and Oyesojo the sons of Odekunle who migrated from Ile-Ife about 200 years ago. That both brothers farmed on the land in dispute where Oyesojo had a son named Oyewole while Akinyanju also had a son called Ajala. That both families farmed on the land called Oroorun.

That Oyewole being the eldest became the first king of Idoo and at his death Ajala took over the throne. That Akande of the Oyewole family took over from Ajala and at his death, the present defendant became the king of Ido. That until the reign of the current head of Ido, the land in question was never partitioned. See the statement of claim and the written deposition on oath of the respondents on pages 4 to 19 of the record.

On the part of the defendant, his story is that all the land in Idoo originally belonged to a warrior Timi Agbale Olafa Ina, who became the ruler of Ede and other surrounding communities. He gave the boundary description of the land owned by Timi Agbale as following:
– On the 1st side with Iwo at Edero River
– On the 2nd side by Ogbomosho at Oke
– On the 3rd side by Ife at Saasa River
– On the 4th side by Ijesha at Osun River

That all the community rulers within the boundaries stated above including the present Alawo Awo were installed by the Timi Agbale Olafa Ina and his successors. That it is the custom from time immemorial in Ede and throughout Yoruba land that all the community land is vested in the king who has the right to alienate it to individuals and authorities for developmental purposes. That Timi Ajeniju over 200 years ago settled Orisamuwagun as a customary tenant on the land now called Idoo and in return, the said Orisamuwagun paid tribute (Ishakole) to the Timi. That Kunrumi who begat Akinyaju succeeded his father Orisamuwagun and after him, Akintaju was made the head by Timi Lagunju. That Akinyaju was succeeded by Onifade after whom Ajala took over the mantle of leadership and was later succeeded by Akande. Under paragraph 34 of the defendant’s pleadings he averred that he succeeded Akande in the year 2000.

Under paragraph 33 of the pleadings of the defendant he averred that Akande succeeded Ajala as the Baale and was installed by Timi Adetoyese Laoye and under cross examination on page 72 of the record he testified to knowing Oba Oyewole the respondents ancestor who ruled before him and proceeded to confirm there are two ruling houses in Ido. Hereunder is an excerpt of the evidence of the DW2 on the page above: I know Oba Oyewole. He rules before me, Oyewole has a compound. Akande was the king from that compound that reigned before me. We have 2 ruling houses in Ido. Oyewole and Ajala.

These facts given under cross-examination by the DW2 himself support his pleadings and the averments contained in the pleadings of the plaintiffs/respondents as to the relationship between the two ruling houses of the Oyewole and the Ajala families. It is common for two or more ruling families to have and exercise joint ownership over a family property such as in the instant case. This the plaintiffs consistently stated in paragraphs 7, 9, 11, 12, 14, 15, 17, 18 and 19 of their pleadings and in paragraphs 9 and 10 respectively of the evidence in chief of the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs who gave evidence as the PW2 and PW1. The averments in the said pleadings of the respondents were traversed under paragraph 2 of the appellants pleadings. On general traverse, I refer to my earlier findings in this case to avoid repetition. The learned trial Court held in its judgment as contained on page 85 of the record saying —- I am satisfied that the issue of joint ownership was clearly stated in paragraphs 7 and 14 of the statement of claim and in paragraph 10 of the statements on oath of 3rd and 2nd plaintiffs who testified orally in Court as PW1 and PW2 respectively.

The law is trite that where the case is fought on evidence of traditional history which in other words becomes a matter of hearsay upon hearsay which is the nature of traditional evidence, the trial Court in its traditional role of an umpire has a duty to examine the evidence of the parties and come to the conclusion which is more probable in the circumstance of the case, by testing it against the other evidence. See Nwokidu v. Okanu (supra)

It is also settled that an appellate Court should not ordinarily disturb or tamper with the findings of facts made by the trial Court, particularly if such findings and conclusions reached are supported by credible evidence. SeeAchilihu v. Anyatonwu (2013) 1 SCNJ 332.

In view of the evidence before the Court, I am convinced that the plaintiffs/respondents proved joint ownership of the land in dispute with the defendant/appellant. Both families are descendants of Odukunle and by the pleadings of the respondents which were not specifically denied as required by the law, the land in dispute was never partitioned.

38

I resolve this issue in favour of the respondents and against the appellant.

On the 3rd issue, I have already held above that the respondents have indeed proved joint ownership of the land in dispute. I have gone through all the evidence on record of the witnesses. While DW1 gave a contrary evidence on page 71 of the record that the Timi of Ede has the right to grant unalloted land to people and can sell land upon which people are farming, the DW2 who is the appellant and DW3, DW4 and DW5 corroborated each other on the fact that the Ado lacks the power to take back land he already granted to people. On page 73 the DW2 stated as follows: We do not claim any land upon which people are already farming.
See pages 75  77 of the record for the evidence of the DW3, DW4 and DW5 corroborating the above fact all of which contradict the evidence of the DW1 on pages 71  72 of the record of appeal. This Court will not disturb the findings of the learned trial judge on this issue who had the opportunity of hearing and seeing those witnesses testify in Court. See Achilihu v. Anyatonwu (supra); Nsirim v. Nsirim (2002) 2 SCNJ 46.

The learned trial Court held in its judgment on page 87 of the record that:
…..It is wrong for the defendant to re-allocate a land jointly owned by his family and the family of the plaintiffs to any other person for whatever reason and under or using whatever power or authority.

I agree with the above position as there is no justification for so doing.

Issue three is also resolved against the appellant and in favour of the respondents.

The 4th issue before us dwells on evaluation of evidence. I have read grounds 5 and 6 of the grounds of appeal from which this issue emanated and, having gone through the evidence on record and the judgment of the learned trial Court spanning from pages 79 to 88 of the record, the Court below properly dealt with all the issues raised and reached a reasonable conclusion.

The grounds of this appeal complains majorly on the traditional history as presented by parties, I have succinctly dealt with this issue in my resolution of issues 1 & 2 above and therefore, it will be pointless to reiterate my opinion.

The facts and evidence presented by the respondents before the learned trial Court was not properly challenged by the defendant/appellant. It constitutes sufficient proof of the respondent’s case and was rightly accepted by the trial judge in reaching his judgment. Section 134 of the Evidence Act, 2011 provides that the burden of proof shall be discharged on the balance of probabilities in all civil proceedings.

The evidence adduced by the plaintiffs/respondents in support of their case preponderates over that of the defendant/appellant and thereby tilting the scale of justice in their favour.

This issue is resolved in favour of the respondents and against the appellant.

The four issues raised for the determination of this appeal have all been resolved against the appellant and in favour of the respondents. It follows that the appeal is unmeritorious and it is hereby dismissed.

The judgment of the learned trial Court delivered on the 6th day of March, 2012 in Suit No. HEJ/01/2010 is affirmed by me.

UZO IFEYINWA NDUKWE-ANYANWU, J.C.A.: I had the privilege of reading in draft form, the judgment just delivered by my learned brother, Mohammed Ambi-Usi

Danjuma, JCA. I agree with his treatment of the four issues articulated by the Appellant. They were all resolved against him

This appeal is therefore unmeritorious. It is dismissed. I abide by all the orders contained in the lead judgment.

OBANDE FESTUS OGBUINYA, J.C.A.: I had the privilege to read in advance, the leading judgment delivered by my learned brother; Mohammed A. Danjuma, JCA. I am in total agreement with the reasoning and conclusion in it. I too visit a deserved dismissal on the appeal. I abide by the consequential orders decreed in it.

 

Appearances

  1. A. Akande; Esq. For Appellant

 

AND

  1. M. Nworie; Esq. For Respondent