LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

MRS. OLU SOLANKE (ATTORNEY O. OBISANYA) V. G. SOMEFUN & ANOR (1974)

MRS. OLU SOLANKE (ATTORNEY O. OBISANYA) V. G. SOMEFUN & ANOR

(1974) LCN/1973(SC)

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Friday, January 11, 1974


Case N
umber: SC. 185/1971

RATIO 

COURT RULES: RATIONALE FOR STIPULATED RULES OF COURT

Rules of court are made to be followed. They regulate matters in court and help parties to present their case within a procedure made for the purpose of a fair and quick trial. It is the strict compliance with these rules of court that makes for quicker administration of justice. Some exceptions, for example, amendments of proceedings are provided for, but such exceptions should be resoned to where absolutely necessary. See:-
“(a) Malmo v. Olushola 15 W.A.C.A. 12;
(b) Dako II v. District Commissioner, Birim 3 W.A.C.A. 68; (c) Somade v. Ogunbiyi 3 W.A.C.A. 48 and (dd) England v. Palmer 14 W.A.C.A. 659.” Per Sowemimo J.S.C

JUSTICES:

COKER, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

SOWEMIMO, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

IBEKWE, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

 

APPELLANTS

MRS. OLU SOLANKE (ATTORNEY O. OBISANYA)

 

RESPONDENTS

G. SOMEFUN MADAM SOMEFUN

 

 

SOWEMIMO, JSC. (Delivering the Judgment by the Court)

This appeal from the High Court of Lagos State raises the question as to whether an Application to substitute a fresh Statement of Claim constitutes an amendment of a pleading under Order 33 of the former Supreme Court (Civil Procedure) Rules Cap. 211 in Volume X of the 1948 Edition of the Laws of Nigeria which were then applicable in that State. The relevant rule reads:-    “The court may at any stage of the proceedings either of its own motion or on the application of either party, order any proceedings to be amended, whether the defect or error be that of the party applying to amend or not, and all such amendments as may be necessary or proper for the purpose of eliminating all statements which may tend to prejudice, embarrass, or delay the fair trial of the suit, and for the purpose of determining in the existing suit, the real question or questions in controversy between the parties, shall be made upon such terms as to costs or otherwise as shall seem just.”

The writ of summons in this suit IK/134/66 with the necessary endorsements was issued at the instance of the plaintiff’s attorney on 14/11/66. The case came before the court for the first time on 6/1/67 and after four other listings pleadings were ordered on 3/4/67 for reasons stated in the record of proceedings. The Statement of Claim and plan were ordered to be filed within 60 days and the Statement of Defence to be filed within 60 days ‘after service’. The Statement of Claim was however not filed until 13/11/67 instead of 3/6/67 when it was due. The Counsel who settled the Statement of Claim was Mr. Olajide Solanke. As at the date of filing the time for filing had expired and an application for extension of time within which to file and serve the Statement of claim and plan was later granted up to 20/12/67.

A consequential order was made that the Statement of Defence be filed and served within 60 days after service of the Statement of Claim.   The Statement of Defence was not filed within the prescribed time and an application for extension of time was granted up till 13th May, 1968. The Statement of Defence was filed on 11/5/68 by defendant’s counsel Mr. E. A. Ntia. The case which had been fixed for hearing for 2 days, that is, for 26th and 27th November, 1968, did not proceed as the plaintiff’s attorney did not appear and new hearing dates were fixed for 20th and 21st May, 1969. The case, however, did not appear, according to the records, on the cause list until 2nd June, 1969, and in the meantime the Counsel for both parties had changed. Chief F.R.A. Williams, whose brief was held by Mr. Solesi, appeared for the plaintiff, and Mr. Alaka, whose brief was held by Mr. Allen, appeared for the defence. After two further adjournments the case was fixed for hearing by Beckley, J., for 11th and 12th of February, 1970. On the 9th of February, 1970, an application was filed on behalf of the plaintiff by Chief F.R.A. Williams “for an order for leave to amend the Statement of Claim, by substituting for the one filed another Statement of claim a copy of which is attached to the affidavit in support.”

The only relevant paragraph in the affidavit filed in support is paragraph 8 thereof and reads thus:- “That Chief Williams has advised and I verily believe that in order to enable all matters in controversy between the parties to be properly determined and also in order to enable him to bring before the court all the relevant facts concerning the Plaintiff’s claim it is necessary to amend the Statement of claim in the manner set forth in the document attached herewith and marked Exhibit “A”. On 10/2/70 the case was again listed and Mr. Akesode was recorded as appearing for plaintiff and Mr. E.O. Alaka for defendants; but the case was then adjourned for 2/3/70 for mention. On the latter date the motion to amend the Statement of Claim was moved by Mr. Akesode. The relevant record of the proceedings for that date reads:- “Mr. Akesode moves motion under Order XXXIII of the Supreme Court Rules Affidavit in support. Refers to paragraph 8 of the affidavit. Refers to Exh. “A”.

The Plaintiff claims as per writ of summons.” Learned Counsel for the defendants opposed the application for leave to amend on the grounds:- (a) that there was nothing in the affidavit and in the Statement of the Counsel who moved the application, indicating what paragraphs of the original Statement were to be amended and the nature of such amendments; and (b) the grant of the application will cause undue delay to a fair trial of the case.   Mr. Akesode was then called upon to reply as to whether the substitution of a fresh Statement of claim for one previously filed constitutes an amendment under the rule. The counsel replied thus:- “Substitution is an amendment. It is correct to substitute a Statement of claim for another one. This could still be an amendment. Mr. Akesode states that what has been done in this case is a correction of the old Statement of Claim. Everything remains substantially the same. Submits that paragraph 10 of the amended Statement of Claim is the same as paragraph 6 of the Statement of Claim dated 13/11/67. Paragraph 11 of the proposed amendment is substantially the same as paragraph 7 of the old Statement of Claim dated 13/11/67.

Also compares paragraph 3 of the Old Statement of Claim with paragraph 2(11) of the old Statement of Claim with paragraph 11 of the new amendment. Submits that in both Statements of Claim, the claim is still the same. The amendment was only an adding and surbodinating excuse. The court will not refuse to allow an amendment reply (merely) because its substitutes a new case. There is nothing stopping a litigant from “a” new fact or re-arrangement of facts.’ The learned trial judge considered the arguments in the application and in a considered ruling dated 17/3/70 stated inter alia:   “The question that falls to be determined is whether this, in effect, is really an application for an amendment. WHARTONS Law Lexicon, fourteenth edition, defines an amendment as follows:- “A correction of any errors in the writ or pleadings in actions, suits, or prosecutions.” “In this case the question is whether what is proposed is an amendment. Is this really an amendment to a defect or error on the Statement of Claim, There is no specific mention in the proposed amended Statement of Claim of the errors or omissions in the original Statement of Claim which are sought to be corrected. An amendment, in my view, presupposes the continued existence of what is proposed to amend. You amend a defect or error in a document which is still existing. You do not, in my view, amend a document by withdrawing the document in its entirety and substituting a new one.”

The learned trial judge then rejected the application to amend. Three grounds of appeal were filed against the ruling and they are:- “1. The learned trial judge erred in law in holding that the proposed amendment is one which he has no power to grant. 2. The learned trial judge erred in law in failing to observe that the proposed amendment is one that ought to have been granted. 3. The decision of the learned trial judge in refusing to grant the amendment prayed for is unreasonable, unprecedented and not justified by the rules of Court.”   Chief Williams, learned Counsel for the appellant, submitted before us that the question which the learned trial judge had to decide was whether by substituting the amended Statement of Claim for the original one, such substitution constitutes an amendment within the provision of Order 33. It is his contention that such substitution is an amendment to the Statement of Claim and that it ought to have been allowed by the learned trial judge. Mr. Alaka, learned counsel for the respondent countered that before any amendment of a Statement of Claim can be granted, the nature of the amendment should be specifically shown to be such as is competent in the terms of Order 33 and that such amendment is intended to cure a defect or error.

As the learned trial judge quite rightly said, it is, in our view, the duty of any party applying for leave to amend any proceedings to bring such an amendment within the provisions of Order 33. In the lower court, the counsel who appeared for the appellant drew attention to three paragraphs of the Statement of Claim as being the same as those in the fresh Statement of Claim sought to be filed, no indication was given as to what the other paragraphs in the new amended Statement of Claim were intended or expected to cure in the original one. Rules of court are meant to be complied with and therefore any party or counsel seeking the discretionary power of a judge to be exercised in his favour must bring his case within the provisions of the Rules on which he purported to make his application. If Counsel fail to discharge their duties in that respect, it is but fair and right that a court should refuse to exercise its discretionary power. Paragraph 8 of the Affidavit in support of the application in the lower court did not set out the nature of the amendment proposed in the fresh Statement of Claim; all it did was to indicate that the amended Statement of Claim sought to be filed will determine in the existing suit the real question or questions in controversy between the parties.

In the original Statement of Claim, dated 6/11/67 the root of title of the plaintiff, is out in paragraphs 2 to 5. In the fresh Statement of Claim, intended as an amendment to the original Statement of Claim, the root of title is set out in paragraphs 1 to 6. To compare both it is clear that whilst t