LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

MR. S. A. OMOROGBE & ORS v. MR. MICHAEL ENEHIZENA & ORS (2018)

  1. S. A. OMOROGBE & ORS v. MR. MICHAEL ENEHIZENA & ORS

(2018)LCN/11772(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Tuesday, the 26th day of June, 2018

CA/B/327/2011(R)

RATIO

THE COURTS AND SENTIMENTS

The law is that Courts do not decide causes or matters on the basis of sentiments or sympathy per MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN, J.C.A.

THE IMPLICATION OF PERFORMING AN ACT A DAY AFTER THE DEADLINE WHEN IT FALLS ON A PUBLIC HOLIDAY

When a party is required by law to do or perform a particular act or thing within a specified period of time, where the last day of the period falls on a holiday, the act or thing is deemed as properly done or performed if it is done or performed on the next following day which is not a holiday per MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN, J.C.A.

JUSTICES

PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

  1. MR. S. A. OMOROGBE
    2. MR. JOSEPH OMO EHIWE
    3. MR. ISAAC AGBONZE
    {For themselves and on behalf of Ohoghobi Village, along Benin Sapele Road, Benin City}
    -APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS Appellant(s)

AND

  1. MR. MICHAEL ENEHIZENA
    2. MR. GEORGE IDEMUDIA
    3. MR. MICHAEL OGBOMWAKAN
    4. MR. JOHN OBAZE
    {For themselves and on behalf of Obe Village, along Benin Sapele Road, Benin City}
    -RESPONDENTS/APPLICANTS Respondent(s)

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN, J.C.A. (Delivering the Lead Ruling): 

By a motion on notice filed on 16/08/2016, the respondents/applicants are seeking:
AN Order of this Honourable Court to dismiss Appeal No. CA/B/327/2011  MR. S.A. OMOROGBE & ORS. V. MICHAEL ENEHIZENA & ORS. for failure to compile and transmit the Record of Appeal within the time prescribed for so doing by the Rules of this Honourable Court.

The respondents/applicants anchored their application on the following two grounds:
1. The appellants/respondents herein instituted this appeal vide a notice of appeal filed on 29th July, 2011 but the record of appeal were transmitted to the registry of this Honourable Court on 9th November, 2011.
2. That the time within which the said records were transmitted is clearly outside the time prescribed for so doing by the Registrar of Court below and/or the appellant/respondent in line with the provisions of Order 8 Rules 1 and 4 of the Court of Appeal Rules 2011; hence this application.

The application is supported with an affidavit of five (5) paragraphs.

At the hearing of the motion on notice, the learned senior counsel for the applicants adopted and relied on the said application together with the affidavit in support thereof and urged the Court to grant it. Relying on Order 1 Rule 3 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2016 he contended as follows:
The simple issue is whether the record of appeal was transmitted within time.
The reasons given in the appellants counter affidavit are reasons why the record was transmitted out of time and not that the record was transmitted within time.

In response, the learned senior counsel for the appellants/respondents relied on the counter affidavit filed on 24/10/2016 and urged the Court to dismiss the motion on notice. The learned Senior Advocate of Nigeria, representing the appellants/respondents, submitted as follows:
Time does not run during the vacation of the Court of Appeal. See Federal Gazette of 14/07/1988  Government Notice No. 288 of 14/07/1988 signed by Nasir, PCA.
The Court takes judicial notice of public holidays  See AUTO IMPORT EXPORT V. ADEBAYO (2002) 18 NWLR (Pt. 79) 554 at 577, paras. B-D.

When the holidays are deducted, the record of appeal was transmitted within 59 days.

I have read the motion on notice with the affidavit in support thereof. I have also carefully read the appellants/respondents counter affidavit. In addition, I have adverted my mind to the legal arguments of the two eminent Senior Advocates of Nigeria.

It is true that the Supreme Court held in the case of Auto Import Export v. J.A.A. Adebayo & 2 Ors. (2002) 18 NWLR (Pt. 799) 554 that the Courts can take judicial notice of public holidays.

When a party is required by law to do or perform a particular act or thing within a specified period of time, where the last day of the period falls on a holiday, the act or thing is deemed as properly done or performed if it is done or performed on the next following day which is not a holiday. See Section 15(2)(b) and (3) of the Interpretation Act and Auto Import Export v. J.A.A. Adebayo & 2 Ors. (supra).

Although the learned senior counsel for the appellants/respondents relied on and referred to Government Notice No. 288 of 14/07/1988 published in the Federal Government Gazette, he failed to make a copy of the said Gazette available to the Court. The Court itself has searched for the alleged Gazette and it has not been able to find it. Since the said Gazette has not been submitted to the Court, I cannot speculate on its existence or even its contents. The law is that Courts have a duty not to act on mere conjecture, guesswork or speculation. See Pele Ogunye v. The State (1999) 5 NWLR (Pt. 604) 548; Ikenta Best (Nig.) Ltd. v. Attorney-General, Rivers State (2008) 8 NWLR (Pt. 1084) 612; Ayo Adegbite v. The State (2018) 5 NWLR (Pt. 1612) 183P and Olabisi Olakunle v. The State (2018) 6 NWLR (Pt. 1614) 91.

In this case, Order 8 Rules 1 and 4 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2011 applicable to this case provided that:
Rule 1: The Registrar of the Court below shall within sixty days after the filing of a notice of appeal compile and transmit the record of appeal to the Court.
Rule 4: Where at the expiration of 60 days after the filing of the notice of appeal the Registrar has failed and or neglected to compile and transmit the records of appeal in accordance with the preceding provisions of this Rule, it shall become mandatory for the appellant to compile the records of all documents and exhibits necessary for his appeal and transmit to the Court within 30 days after the Registrars failure or neglect.
By the combined provisions of Order 8 Rules 1 and 4 of the Court of Appeal Rules, the maximum period of time for the compilation and transmission of record of appeal from lower Courts to the Court of Appeal is 90 (ninety) days after the filing of a notice of appeal.
In this case, the appellants/respondents filed their notice of appeal on the 29th day of July, 2011 and the record of appeal was transmitted to this Court on the 9th day of November, 2011. By a simple arithmetical calculation, the record of appeal was compiled and transmitted to this Court more than 100 (one hundred) days after the appellants/respondents filed their notice of appeal in the Registry of the High Court of Edo State, Benin City.
In paragraph 12 of their counter affidavit, the appellants/respondents deposed as follows:
12. That the Registrar of the lower Court transmitted the records of appeal within 59 days from the day of the filing of the notice of appeal. The Court went on annual vacation on the 8th day of August, 2011 and resumed on the 19th September 2011. Between 19th September 2011 and 9th November, 2011, the Federal Government declared three days as public holidays from 3rd, October, 2011 for independent day celebration and 7th and 8th of November, 2011 as Muslim holidays.
There is no provision in Order 8 Rules 1 and 4 of the Court of Appeal Rules, that the periods for the compilation and transmission of a record of appeal from a lower Court will cease to run during the annual vacation of the Court of Appeal. In the case of Auto Import Export v. J.A.A. Adebayo & 2 Ors. (2002) 18 NWLR (Pt. 799) 554 at 580 per Iguh, JSC; the Supreme Court made the point very clear by stating as follows:
At all events, I need, perhaps to stress that neither Practice Directions nor, indeed, Rules of Court can override Statutory Provisions. Section 27(2)(a) of the Supreme Court Act, Cap. 424, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria, 1990 which makes provision in respect of the periods of time within which to appeal has neither stipulated nor suggested that the times therein prescribed shall cease to run during periods of vacation and I do not conceive it the duty of this Court to usurp the legislative powers of the National Assembly under whatever guise by amending laws enacted by them other than to interpret them in accordance with the laws of the land.
The appellants/respondents have also not shown that the time for compilation and transmission of the record of appeal in this case ended on any holiday or public holiday, either as deposed to in paragraph 12 of their counter affidavit or at all. By the provisions of Section 15(4) of the Interpretation Act, holidays shall be left out of account in computing the period for doing any act stipulated by law, only where the particular period does not exceed six days. In this case, holidays or public holidays will not be left out in the computation of the time to compile and transmit record of appeal from the lower Court, because each of the periods of time stipulated exceeds six days. In a situation like this, holidays and public holidays become relevant only when the act to be done expires on a holiday or public holiday.
The record of appeal, in this case, was compiled and transmitted outside the period of time stipulated by the Rules of this Court and there is no competent record of appeal before the Court.

While one may sympathize with the appellants/respondents, the law is that Courts do not decide causes or matters on the basis of sentiments or sympathy. See Federal Republic of Nigeria v. Senator Adolphus N. Wabara (2013) 5 NWLR (Pt. 1347) 331 at 357; Olu Ode Okpe v. Fan Milk PLC & Anor. (2017) 2 NWLR (Pt. 1549) 282 at 310. Per I.T. Muhammad, JSC; Chief Nimi Barigha-Amange v. Hon. Justice M.A.A. Adumein & Anor. (2016) 13 NWLR (Pt.1530) 349 at 397 per Eko, JCA (as he then was) and Mr. Ime Ime Umanah Jnr. v. Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation (2016) 14 NWLR (Pt. 1533) 458 at 484 per Nweze, JSC.

The conclusion of the matter is that this motion on notice is meritorious and it is hereby granted.

This appeal  Appeal No. CA/B/327/2011 between: MR. S.A. OMOROGBE & 2 ORS V. MR. MICHAEL ENEHIZENA & 3 ORS. is hereby dismissed for the failure by the appellants to compile and transmit the record of appeal within the time prescribed by the Court of Appeal Rules.
There is no order for costs PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE, J.C.A.: I had the privilege of reading in draft the ruling just delivered by my learned brother M.A.A. ADUMEIN, JCA. I am in total agreement with the reasoning and conclusions reached therein.

I also tow the line of my Lordship’s reasoning that the record of appeal was compiled and transmitted outside the period of time stipulated by the Rules of this Court and there is no competent record of appeal. Therefore, the motion on notice is meritorious and it is hereby granted. Appeal No. CA/B/327/2011 Between: MR OMOROGBE & 2 ORS V. MR MICHAEL ENEHIZEN & 3 ORS is hereby dismissed for the failure by the Appellants to compile and transmit the record of appeal within the time prescribed by the Court of Appeal Rules.
I abide by the order as to costs

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, J.C.A.: My learned brother M.A.A. ADUMEIN, JCA has afforded me the opportunity of a prior perusal of the Ruling just delivered.

He has adequately dealt with the issues in contention and I am in agreement with the reasoning and conclusion reached therein.

In the circumstance, I also hold that the Respondents application is meritorious and it is hereby granted. I abide by the consequential orders made in the lead ruling including order as to costs.

Appearances

Chief A.O. Eghobamien, SAN with him, P.O. Osemwenkha, Esq.For Appellant

 

AND

J.O. Aghimien, SAN with him, F.E. Aghimien, Esq. and S.O. Ifaluyi, Esq.For Respondent