LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

MR. JOSEPH JOHN OTU & ANOR v. PASTOR ELISHA JOHN OTU & ANOR (2018)

MR. JOSEPH JOHN OTU & ANOR v. PASTOR ELISHA JOHN OTU & ANOR

(2018)LCN/12003(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Friday, the 20th day of July, 2018

CA/C/61/2014

 

RATIO

EVIDENCE: WHERE TRIAL COURT FAILS TO EVALUATE EVIDENCE

“…Consequently where this is done the Appeal Court should always be reluctant to differ from the trial Judge’s finding. It is only where the trial Court failed to evaluate such evidence properly that an appellate Court can re-evaluate evidence. See DAKOLO VS. REWANE-DAKOLO (2011) 16 NWLR (PT. 1272) 22 and OGUNDALU VS. MACJOB (2015) LPELR  24458 (SC).” PER STEPHEN JONAH ADAH, J.C.A.

LAND LAW: WAYS TO DETERMINE FAMILY PROPERTY

“A family land simply put is a land that is of common collective ownership by all the members of the same family. The law is that a family land remains a family land irrespective of allotment. It can only change its structure if it was well agreed upon by the family. In OLORUNFEMI VS. ASHO (2000) 2 NWLR (PT. 643) 143; the Supreme Court held: ‘There is no doubt that one of the methods by which family property can be determined is partition by which property which belonged to the family is split up into ownership of the constituent members of the family. The property may be, but is not invariably, divided among individual members of the family so as to vest absolute ownership in individual members. The division may be among constituent branches of the family. Where the division is among constituent branches of the family a new family ownership is created in as many places as the property is divided, each branch becoming the owner of the portion partitioned to it.'” PER STEPHEN JONAH ADAH, J.C.A.

 

JUSTICES

IBRAHIM MOHAMMED MUSA SAULAWA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

STEPHEN JONAH ADAH Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

JOSEPH OLUBUNMI KAYODE OYEWOLE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

1. MR. JOSEPH JOHN OTU
2. MAJOR ANIEDI EDET Appellant(s)

AND

1. PASTOR ELISHA JOHN OTU
2. MR. JACOB ASUQUO OBONG Respondent(s)

 

STEPHEN JONAH ADAH, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment):

This appeal is against the judgment of the Akwa Ibom State High Court sitting at Uyo, in Suit No. HU/213/2008.

The Appellants were the Defendants at the Court below while the Respondents were the Plaintiffs.

The suit is in respect of a parcel of land known as ‘Ndon Owok’ situate at Usung Urua Edemetaha in Nung Oku Ibesikpo in Ibesikpo Asutan Local Government Area of Akwa Ibom State. The suit was originated through a writ of summons issued out by the Court below on 14th day of May, 2008. The reliefs of the Respondent against the Appellant were couched as follows:-
(a) A DECLARATION that the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs are the persons entitled to statutory or customary right of occupancy over the parcel of land known as and called ‘Ndon Owok’ situate being and lying along Usung Urua Edemetaha at Nung Oku in Ibesikpo Asutan Local Government Area of Akwa Ibom State.

(b) A DECLARATION that the transfer of interest on the said land by the 1st Plaintiff to the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs was proper and in order, he being the beneficial and bona-fide owner of the said parcel of land.

(c) A perpetual injunction restraining the Defendants, their agents, servants, workmen or privies from committing any further act of trespass on the said land, or interfering in whatever manner with the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs? right to use and develop the said land.

(d) Special and general damages in the sum of Five Million Naira (N5m) for unnecessary interferences with the rights of the Plaintiffs to use the said land.

The Court below heard the case of the parties and on 24th January, 2011 entered judgment for the Plaintiffs who are now Respondents on appeal.

Aggrieved by the lower Court’s decision the Appellants filed a notice of appeal on 19th day of November, 2013 with the leave of Court. The record of appeal was transmitted on 17th day of February, 2014. The Appellants’ Brief was filed on 5th day of May, 2014 but deemed properly filed and served on 11th day of June, 2014. The reply Brief was filed on 10th of October, 2014. The Respondents filed their Brief on 14th day of July, 2014.

At the hearing of this appeal the Appellant adopted his Briefs and urged the Court to allow this appeal. The Respondents adopted also their own Brief and urged the Court to dismiss this appeal.

The Appellants in their Brief distilled two issues for determination. The Respondents in their own case framed eventually two issues. The issues of the Appellants were couched as follows:
1. Whether parties are bound to lead evidence to establish their case as contained in their pleadings filed before the trial Court?

2. Whether the trial Court had jurisdiction to grant both Statutory and Customary Rights of Occupancy to the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs over the same parcel of land in dispute, before it?

The issues framed by the Respondents are as follows:

ISSUE NO. 1
Whether or not from the totality of evidence adduced at the trial in the lower Court, the Plaintiffs therein were able to prove partitioning and not allotment of the Otu?s family land?

ISSUE NO. 2
Whether the trial Court had jurisdiction to grant both Statutory and Customary Rights of Occupancy to the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs over the same parcel of land in dispute before it?

The parties’ respective issue two is the same. It is only their respective issue one that differs one from the other. The Appellants issue one is truly more of an academic question. From the grounds of appeal, issue one as framed by the Respondents represents more of the complaint of the Appellants in this appeal.

In the reply Brief the Appellants raised the issue of the Respondent framing an issue outside the one framed by the Appellants. The law is settled that issues to be framed must originate from the grounds of appeal. The issue of partitioning raised by the Respondents was the complaint of the Appellants in ground 3 of the notice of appeal. See page 194 of the record. For ease of reference, I want to capture ground three (3) of the notice of appeal which reads as follows:

GROUND 3
The trial Court erred in law by holding that with the partitioning of Otu’s family land, the family’s right over the land in dispute was extinguished. The family had nothing to sell, ‘nemo dat quod non habet, the 2nd Defendant has therefore failed to establish his right over the land’.

PARTICULARS OF ERROR
i. The issue of partitioning was mentioned for the first time in the Counsel’s submission before the Court and Counsel’s submission is not evidence.
ii. The issue of allotment is pleaded in paragraphs 8, 9, 10 and 11 of the Amended Statement of Claim filed on 20th July, 2009, evidence adduced thereafter is geared at establishing fact contained therein.
iii. By the allotment, the right of the family was reserved and not extinguished as the trial Court rightly found out but applied the finding and principle wrongly.

This Court has the power under the Rules to re-formulate issues and where necessary identify which of the parties’ issues are within the scope of the complaint in the grounds of appeal of the Appellants. Having looked into the grounds of the appeal and the issues framed by the parties, I believe the two issues framed by the Respondents will serve the interest of justice better in the instant appeal.

I will therefore flag down the two issues as distilled by the Respondents for consideration.
I shall start with the first issue.

ISSUE ONE
This issue deals with whether from the evidence adduced at the trial, the Plaintiffs now Respondents were able to prove partitioning and not allotment of the Otu family land.

The learned Counsel for the Appellants canvassed in his Brief that there was evidence to establish the fact of allotment pleaded by the Plaintiffs in paragraphs 8 to 12 of their amended statement of claim. He contended that the Plaintiff pleaded allotment not partitioning in the amended statement of claim and that they are bound by it. He referred to the case of AYANWALE VS. ODUSAMI (2012) VOL. 204 L.R.C.N. 198 and ATANDA VS. ILIASU (2012) VOL. 214 L.R.C.N. 220, 254. He further canvassed that the trial Court relied on the DW1?s evidence using the word ?sharing? to mean allotment as pleaded by the Plaintiff. That the Court was relying on the weakness of the defense?s case to declare title to the land.

The learned Counsel further canvassed that the Plaintiff never raised the fact of partitioning in their pleadings. That it was the issue of allotment that was pleaded. That the Court was therefore wrong to conclude that what happened in Otu’s family in 1987 was partitioning and not allotment. That the Court occasioned a serious miscarriage of justice. He urged the Court to resolve the issue in favour of the Appellant.

The Respondents in their own Brief canvassed that the amended statement of claim and the evidence placed before the Court show that Otu’s family land was partitioned and shared to the family members including the 1st Respondent. That the Court below looked into the issues joined by the parties before coming to the conclusion it reached.

The Respondents in their Brief relied on the case of KAYEPE VS. AKAYEPE (2009) 175 LRCN 175, 202 laying down the legal effect of partitioning of a family land. They urged the Court to resolve the issue in favour of the Respondents.

A family land simply put is a land that is of common collective ownership by all the members of the same family. The law is that a family land remains a family land irrespective of allotment. It can only change its structure if it was well agreed upon by the family. In OLORUNFEMI VS. ASHO (2000) 2 NWLR (PT. 643) 143; the Supreme Court held:
”There is no doubt that one of the methods by which family property can be determined is partition by which property which belonged to the family is split up into ownership of the constituent members of the family. The property may be, but is not invariably, divided among individual members of the family so as to vest absolute ownership in individual members. The division may be among constituent branches of the family. Where the division is among constituent branches of the family a new family ownership is created in as many places as the property is divided, each branch becoming the owner of the portion partitioned to it.”

What is then described as partitioning of a family land is a question of fact. There must be averments in the pleadings, supported by cogent and positive evidence to buttress the partitioning. In the instant case arguments have been raised about whether the land was allotted and by which means the land still retains its family status. But the situation is different if the land is partitioned. If the land is partitioned, the ownership structure changes to that of individuals owning his own partitioned lot.

At page 184 of the record of appeal, the lower Court in its judgment found as follows:
In the case at hand, 1st Plaintiff as PW1 gave evidence of how late Ime Effiong Otu gave him the land in place of the one his mother allegedly said in the presence of PW2 who also confirmed this in his evidence before the Court. These pieces of evidence were neither challenged nor controverted by the Defendants. This Court is certainly bound to believe it and act on it as true; moreso when there is evidence that 1st Plaintiff transferred part of the land to 2nd Plaintiff in the lifetime of late Ime in 2001, without any complaint from him. The Defendants produced no evidence to the contrary. They also did not challenge 1st and 2nd Plaintiff at that time.

Sequel to this finding of the Court, the Court below had found in the instant case that the land had been partitioned and no long enjoyed its erstwhile family status. A look at the record before us in this case will reveal that the Plaintiffs evidence was found credible and the Court below found that the evidence remained uncontroverted and unchallenged in their claim. There is therefore real basis for the findings of the Court below in this case.

In the case of GAJI & ORS. VS. PAYE (2003) 38 NWLR (PT. 823) 583; Edozie, JSC endorsing the earlier decisions of the Supreme Court held:
”In SAMUEL AGBONIFO VS. MADAM IROBERE AIWEREOBA & ANOR. (1988) 1 NWLR (PT. 70) 325; (1988) 2 SC (PT. 11) 64 @ PAGE 80, the Supreme Court observed thus:- ‘In my judgment, the function of an appellate Court on a question of facts is mainly limited to seeking whether or not there was evidence before the trial Court upon which its decision on facts was based, whether it wrongly accepted or rejected any evidence tendered at the trial; whether evidence called by either party to the conflict was put on either side of an imaginary balance and weighed one against the other, in other words whether the trial Court properly evaluated the evidence, whether the trial Court correctly approached the assessment of the evidence before it, whether the evidence properly admitted was sufficient to support the decision upon the inference drawn therefrom. These are the results of all the decided cases on the point. See for example, ANACHUNA ANYAOKE & ORS. VS. DR. FELIX ADI & ORS (1986) 3 NWLR (PT. 31) 731 @ PAGE 724; OGBODA VS. ADULUGBA (1971) 1 ALL NLR 68 PAGE 71; MBO NTA & ORS. VS. EDE NWEDE ANIGBO & ORS. (1972) ALL NLR (PT. 2) 74, 80; MOGAJI & ORS. VS. ODOFIN & ORS. (1978) 4 SC 91 and a host of other cases”

Muhammad, JSC in VAB PETROLEUM INC. VS. MOMAH (2013) 14 NWLR (PT. 1374) 284, held on the function of the appellate Court thus:
Finally, on this issue, I may have to reiterate the function of an Appellate Court on question of facts. It is mainly limited to seeking whether or not there was evidence before the trial Court upon which its decision on facts was based, whether it wrongly accepted or rejected any evidence tendered at the trial; whether evidence called by either party to the conflict was put on either side of the imaginary scale and weighed one against the other. In other words, whether the trial Court properly evaluated the evidence, whether the trial Court correctly approached the assessment of the evidence before it and whether the evidence properly admitted was sufficient to support the decision upon the inference drawn therefrom. This is the only way and procedure open to an appellate Court in the consideration of an appeal brought before it.

The appellate Court such as ours cannot be at large over the decision of the lower Court. The role of the appellant Court is to scrutinize to see if in the case at hand, the Court below gave a proper assessment and evaluation of the evidence placed before it and properly apply the necessary laws to excavate from the rubbles of evidence the justice of the matter. Once the lower Court properly received evidence and properly evaluated same, this Court will not disturb or unsettle the findings of the Court below bearing in mind the fact that evaluation of relevant evidence before the trial Court and the ascription of probative value to such evidence are the primary functions of the trial Court. This is so since that Court saw, heard and watched the demeanour of the witnesses when they gave evidence. Consequently where this is done the Appeal Court should always be reluctant to differ from the trial Judge’s finding. It is only where the trial Court failed to evaluate such evidence properly that an appellate Court can re-evaluate evidence. See DAKOLO VS. REWANE-DAKOLO (2011) 16 NWLR (PT. 1272) 22 and OGUNDALU VS. MACJOB (2015) LPELR  24458 (SC).

In the instant case, the Court below’s evaluation of the evidence before it is unassailable. This Court has no business tampering with it. The Plaintiffs were able to prove their case as required before the lower Court. Issue one is therefore resolved in favour of the Respondents.

ISSUE TWO
This issue is whether the trial Court had jurisdiction to grant both statutory and customary rights of occupancy to the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs over the land in dispute.

The learned Counsel for the Appellants on this issue contended that through the evidence of the Plaintiffs none of them adduced evidence as to how they were entitled to the two rights they wanted. That the lower Court gave the Plaintiffs the two speculative rights despite lack of evidence. He canvassed further that the Plaintiff did not tender any of the documents to be entitled to the declaration sought. That the right on the land can either be covered by certificate of occupancy issued by the state or certificate of customary right of occupancy depending the location of the land. That any land transfer must be according to the Land Use Act. That there was transfer of the land to 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs in 2001 and 2003 respectively but that the transfer was without Governor?s consent. That it was the duty of the Plaintiffs to prove that the land was vested in them immediately before the commencement of the Land Use Act 1978. That if that was not done any declaration as the Court below did was void. He also canvassed that the land in dispute was situate within the local government area and that the question is whether the land is in urban area or non-urban area.

The Counsel canvassed that by Edict 13 of 1988, which is Uyo Capital City Development Authority Law in the schedule thereto, Nung Oku Ibesikpo is Village No. 43 and it has been designated urban area. That the Plaintiffs at the Court below did not lead any evidence of this. That the judgment of the Court below was not certain as to which of the rights the Plaintiff were granted and that the judgment of the Court was speculative. That the judgment must be set aside as the Court had no jurisdiction to grant both statutory and customary rights of occupancy to the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs over the same parcel of land in dispute before it. He urged the Court to allow this appeal.

The learned Counsel for the Respondent in his Brief canvassed that the Court below did not grant both rights. He pointed out that the Court need to differentiate between the two. That the use of ‘or’ in the Court?s order is to show that whatever right of occupancy inures to the land in dispute be it customary or statutory, the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs are entitled to it. That the word ‘or’ was used disjunctively and not conjunctively by the learned trial Judge. That this contention of whether the land was urban or non-urban was not in contention between the parties at the trial Court. He urged the Court to resolve the issue against the Appellants. He urged the Court to dismiss this appeal.

On this issue, the order of the Court below was called in for interpretation when the Appellant is alleging that the Court in its judgment gave both statutory and customary right of occupancy to the Respondents. This without hesitation cannot represent the order of the Court below in this case.
The Court below ordered as follows:
”It is hereby declared that the 2nd and 3rd Plaintiffs are persons entitled to customary or statutory right of occupancy over the parcel of land known as and called ‘NDON OWOK’ situate, being and lying long Usung Urua Edemetaha at Nung Oku in Ibesikpo Asutan Local Government Area of Akwa Ibom State”. (Highlight mine).

This order with due respect does not suggest conferring double rights as insinuated by the Appellants. The word ‘or’ is not conjunctive but disjunctive. To give it any other colouration will lead to absurdity. This is so having regard to the fact that judgments and orders are usually determinations of rights in the actual circumstances of which Court has cognizance, and give some particular relief capable of being enforced. See OKOYA VS. SANTILLI (1990) NWLR (PT. 131) 172. In the instant case, the primary claim of the Respondents before the trial Court was a declaratory relief entitling the Respondent for the statutory or customary right of occupancy. This was clearly spelt out in the amended statement of claim. See page 56 of the record of appeal. The Court below did not go outside the relief of the Respondent and it did not grant both statutory and customary right in respect of the same parcel of land. This issue therefore is resolved in favour of the Respondent.

From the foregoing therefore, it is very straightforward and clear that this appeal is completely devoid of merit. The appeal is hereby dismissed The judgment of the High Court of Akwa Ibom State in Suit No. HU/213/2008 delivered on 24th January, 2011 is hereby affirmed.

No order as to costs.

IBRAHIM MOHAMMED MUSA SAULAWA, J.C.A.: I had a preview of the judgment just delivered by His Lordship, Adah, JCA. Having equally read the records of appeal, including the briefs of argument of the respective learned counsel, I concur with the reasoning reached in the said judgment, to the conclusive effect that the instant appeal is completely devoid of merits. Thus, the appeal is hereby dismissed by me on terms of the judgment.

JOSEPH OLUBUNMI KAYODE OYEWOLE, J.C.A.: I had the privilege to read the draft of the lead judgment just delivered herein by my learned brother STEPHEN JONAH ADAH, JCA and I totally endorse the reasoning and conclusions therein.

Where the evaluation of evidence and findings of the trial Court accord with the evidence adduced, an appellate Court will not interfere. I equally agree with my learned brother that this appeal is devoid of any merit and I dismiss it accordingly.

I adopt the consequential orders in the lead judgment as mine.

 

Appearances:

Effiong Udofia, Esq.For Appellant(s)

Francis Ekanem, Esq. with him, Sikan Usanga, Esq.For Respondent(s)