LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

MR. FREDRICK MORDI & ANOR v. MR. NWANKWO UGBAH (2018)

MR. FREDRICK MORDI & ANOR v. MR. NWANKWO UGBAH

(2018)LCN/11957(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Friday, the 13th day of July, 2018

CA/B/244/2015

 

 

RATIO

EVIDENCE: WAYS TO PROVE OWNERSHIP OF LAND

“Generally, title to ownership of land can be proved by any of the following five ways:
(1) By traditional evidence
(2) By production of documents of title which are duly authenticated.
(3) By act of selling, leasing, renting out all or part of the land, of farming on it or in a portion of it.
(4) By acts of land possession and enjoyment of the land and
(5) By proof of possession of connected or adjacent land in circumstances rendering it probable that the owner of such connected or adjacent land would, in addition be the owner of the land in dispute.
See the following cases IDUNDUN & ORS V. OKUMAGBA (1976) 9-10 SC. 140; LASISI MORENIKEJI & ORS V. LALEKE ADEGBOSIN & ORS (2003) 65 CM 41; PETER C. OJOH V. ODWUALA KAMALU & ORS. (2005) 12 SCM 332; MEMUDU AJIBOYE V. ALHAJI OLOYEDE ISHOLA (2006) 6 SCNJ 180; FRANCIS ADESINA AYANWALE V. OLUMUYWU OLUMIDE ODUSAMI (2011) 12 SC (Pt.111) 59; MRS. MARGARET OSIDELE & 2 ORS V. IBIKUNLE SOKUNBI. (2012) 7 SC. (Pt.11) 30.” PER MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI, J.C.A.

EVIDENCE: EVALUATION OF EVIDENCE

“It is long settled that evaluation of evidence is the duty of the trial Court to receive all relevant and admissible evidence. This process is referred to as perception. After the trial Judge will weigh the evidence received from both sides and decide where the scale tilts on qualitative and compelling evidence. This second process is what is referred to as evaluation. Where all the foregoing are properly done, it is not the duty of the Appellate Court to evaluate except where the trial Court fails to evaluate. It is also trite that where evaluation of evidence entails issues of credibility of witnesses, the Appeal Court should be reluctant to differ from the trial Judge’s finding of fact based on credibility of witnesses.” PER MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI, J.C.A.

LAND LAW: DECLARATION OF TITLE TO LAND

“Therefore for a claim for a declaration of title to land to succeed the Court must be satisfied as to the precise nature of the title claimed. That is to say, whether it is title by virtue of original ownership, customary grant, conveyance, sale under customary law, long possession. The evidence must establish the nature of the title. See ADETUTU ADESANYA V. ALHAJI S.D. ADERONMU & ORS (2000) 6 SC. (Pt.11) 18 at 24.” PER MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI, J.C.A.

 

JUSTICES

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

1. MR. FREDRICK MORDI
2. MR. ISAAC MORDI Appellant(s)

AND

MR. NWANKWO UGBAH Respondent(s)

 

MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): 

This judgment is predicated on the appeal by the Appellant against the judgment of the High Court of Delta State, Ogwashi-Uku Judicial Division delivered on 19th December 2014.

The fact of the case as can be gathered from the evidence of both parties is that one Chief J.D. Mordi, the Ihaza of Ogwashi – Uku now deceased sometime in 1981 and in accordance with the prevailing custom in Umu-Okwe quarters was said to have requested from the principal family members (the Diokpa) for a grant of a piece of land from the family land and was so granted. It is the claim of the Appellants that upon his demise, he inherited the land from their father Chief J.D. Mordi (Deceased).

They took possession of the land and in the year 2005 they noticed a trespasser on the land in person of Chief Dr. C.O. Enujeilo on the land and which they resisted. In 2010 again they noticed another trespasser on the land who are now identified as the Defendant. In order to resist and remove the trespasser from the land hence the suit by the Appellants at the High Court Ugwashi-Uku against the Respondent wherein the Appellants in paragraph 21 of their statement of claim sought against the Respondent as follows:
(1) A declaration that the claimant are entitled to statutory right of occupancy over the land in dispute discernible on survey plan No. MWC/1186/81.
(2) Perpetual injunction restraining the Defendant by himself, his agents and privies from selling, building and or tampering with the said land.

Issues were joined before the trial Court and the matter went through a full trial. In the end, the learned trial Judge in his considered judgment dismissed the suit by the Appellant.

Dissatisfied with the outcome of the trial, hence this appeal which is initially predicated on the Notice of Appeal filed on 3rd day of March 2015. By the order of this Court granted on the 17th day of January 2018, the Appellants amended notice of appeal filed on the 27th day of June 2016 was deemed as properly filed and served on the 17th day of January 2018. The amended notice of appeal contain two grounds. I herein under reproduce the two grounds but without the particulars.

GROUNDS OF APPEAL
(i) The judgment is against the weight of evidence.
(ii) The learned trial Judge erred in law when having regards to the pleadings and evidence led, he dismissed the Appellants case when he ought to have non-suited the Appellants to meet the justice of the case.

Consequent upon the transmission of the Record of Appeal on 28th day of August 2015 out of time but deemed as properly compiled and transmitted on 27th day of June 2018 by the order of this Court, granted after the hearing of the application by the Appellant dated and filed on 14th December 2015. This opened the gate for the filing of brief of argument by respective party.

APPELLANT’S BRIEF OF ARGUMENT
The Appellant’s brief of argument was filed on 4th day of August 2016 and vide the order of this Court. It was deemed as properly filed and served on 17th day of January 2018. He also filed a reply to the Respondent’s brief of argument on 21/1/2018. The learned counsel representing the Appellant, E.F. Osifo Esq formulated the following issues for determination of the appeal.
(1) Whether having regard to the pleadings and totality of the evidence adduced at the trial, the learned trial Judge was right when he dismissed the Appellants’ case.
(2) Whether having regard to the peculiar facts proved at the trial, an order of non-suit would not have served the justice of this case rather than an order of dismissal.

RESPONDENT’S BRIEF OF ARGUMENT
S. Keledu Nnadi Esq authored the Respondent’s brief of argument dated 10th day of October 2016 and filed on the 24th day of October 2016, same was deemed as properly filed and served vide the order of this Court granted on 17th day of January 2018. He formulated the following issues for determination.
(1) Whether the learned trial Judge was right to have dismissed the Appellants’ case for their inability to establish their root of title.
(2) Whether the order of non-suit is an appropriate remedy to the Appellants having regards to the facts and circumstance of this case.

Respective counsel adopted their brief of argument on 3/5/18. The Appellant urged the Court to allow the appeal and set aside the judgment of the lower Court. On his own part the learned counsel representing the Respondent urged the Court to dismiss the appeal and affirm the judgment of the lower Court.

Be that as it may and upon a careful reading and after comparing the respective issues formulated, it is my finding that the issues are same but differ in choice of words used in the composition. Therefore, I adopt the issues formulated by the Appellant for the determination of this appeal.

Having said this, I have also decided to take the two issues together.

The Appellant submitted that it is trite that in an action for declaration of title, the onus is on the claimant to satisfy the Court on the evidence that he is entitled to the declaration sought and in that regard he must succeed on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the Defendant?s case although he can utilize any aspect of the Defendant’s case that supports his case. He relied on the case of OTUKPO V. JOHN (2012) 7 NWLR (Pt. 1299) 357. At 376 ? 377 para H-A; MOGAJI V. CADBURY NIGERIA LIMITED (1985) 2 NWLR (Pt. 7) 393.

He also added that in an action for declaration of title it is the claimant’s case that must be considered first and decided upon before a consideration of the Defendant’s case such that where the claimant fails to establish a prima face case in support of the declaration sought, his case must be dismissed without recourse to the Defendant’s case.

He cited in aid the case of DIM V. ENEMUO (2009) 172 LRCN 206 at 230 (F). referring to the finding of the learned trial Judge on page 147 of the record of appeal, he submitted that a thorough assessment of the totality of the case as advanced by the Appellants in their pleading and evidence adduced will reveal that the learned trial Judge was not right in his finding as it appears to have been born out of a perfunctory evaluation of the Appellants case and not its totality.

He contended that the land tenure system of Ogbeakwu village in paragraphs 1 to 8 of the statement of claim, the Appellant pleaded that both parties are indigenes of Ogbeakwu village in Ogwashi-Uku and that Ugbeakwu is made up of four quarters. The four quarters have their separate farm road, (Lands) founded by their respective ancestors. Any member of Ogbeakwu can farm on any of the farm land belonging to any of the quarters but cannot claim land outside his quarter as of right.

The Appellants are from Umu-Okwe quarters while the Respondent is from Umu-Onicha quarters and that the land in dispute is on the right hand side of Uzo-Ogholi farm road which belong to Umuokwe quarters. He reproduced paragraph 1 – 8 of the Appellant’s statement of claim and submitted that at the trial, the said paragraph of the statement of claim were funishably proved and established. He referred to the Respondent in paragraphs 2 & 3 which he said did not deny the averment in paragraph 7 of the statement of claim. He relied on the case of UGOCHUKWU V. UNIPETROL (NIG) PLC. (2002) 7 NWLR (Pt.765) 1 at 12 para C-H. He also refered to paragraphs 1 ? 8, 16, 17, 19 and 20 of the 1st Appellant’s written deposition on oath.

He argued that the communal land tenure system whereby the quarters in Ogbeakwu own their respective lands is also adumbrated in the written statement on oath of Emmanuel Okafor (CW1) in paragraph 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8, in addition, the Appellant tendered Exhibit CE1 and CE6. He argued that the significance of the foregoing are in two folds
(a) The land in dispute, being on a right hand side of Uzor- Ogboli farm road is undisputedly the property of Appellant?s Umuokwe quarter.

(b) Since the Respondent is from Umu-Onicha quarters, he has no and cannot have a bonafide claim of Ownership to the land even if his ancestors from Unu-Onicha farmed on the land.

So the Respondent under the Ogbeakwu Customary Land tenure system, is disqualified and absolutely incapacitated from laying claim to Ownership of the land as of right. He contended that the appellant’s case was not given the deserved attention and consideration by the trial Court. The learned trial Judge’s assessment and evaluation of Exhibit CE1 and CE6 is perfunctory and unsatisfactory as he failed to attach relevance to them. He referred to the finding of the learned trial Judge on pages 144 – 145 of the record of appeal.

He submitted that in dismissing the Appellant’s case the learned trial Judge misapprehended that aspect of the Appellant’s case and in relevance to the location of this subject matter.

Secondly, he contended that the Appellants’ case is pleaded in paragraphs 9, 10, 11 and 12 of the statement of claim to the effect that in accordance with the custom in Umu-Okwe, their father J.D. Mordi approached the head and principal members of Umu-Okwe quarters with drinks and kola nut for a grant of the land in dispute and the land was granted to him in 1981 after which he took possession and surveyed the land as per Exhibit CE2 and upon his death the Appellants inherited the land. He conceded that the Appellants having traced the title to their late father, they have a burden to prove how the derivative title of their late father was acquired in line with existing authority. He submitted that it is this aspect of the Appellants’ case that attracted the attention of the learned trial Judge and which led to the order of dismissal. (See pages 146 – 147 of the record of appeal).

He submitted that the finding of the Court is infested with some legal errors that made it unjustifiable on unjudicious to dismiss the Appellants’ case. He contended that the evidence of the 1st Appellant as to how his late father acquired the land from Umu-Okwe elders and principal members of the quarters was not challenged by way of any cross examination. He submitted that when a party fails to cross examine his adversary on a very material issue, he is deemed to have admitted the evidence. He relied on the case of CAMEROON AIRLINE V. OTUTUIZU (2011) 4 NWLR (Pt. 1238) 512 at 545. Para A-C; ERESIA – EKE V. ORIKOHA (2010) 8 NWLR (Pt.1197) 42 at 44; BORISHADE V. FRN (2012) 18 NWLR (Pt.1332) 347. At 405 para E-H.

Further he argued that the learned trial Judge finding that Chief J.D. Mordi got the land from allocation by central land committee in 1981 and paid a token like other allottees contradicts the Appellants’ averment in paragraph 10 of their statement of claim is perverse in law as the allege contradiction actually does not exist. He contended that there are two legal defects in the evidence elicited under cross examination. (1) Neither party pleaded facts about the said Chief J.D. Mordi’s transaction with the central land committee. He submitted that evidence elicited under cross-examination on fact not pleaded is inadmissible and goes to no issue. He relied on the case of OKWEJIMINOR V. GBAKEJI (2008) 5 NWLR (Pt.1079) 172; OLORA V. ADEGBITE (2013) 1 NWLR (Pt.1334) 40 at 60. para F-G. The evidence of CW1 under Cross Examination therefore goes to no issue for want of pleading.

Further he argued that CW1’s admission under Cross Examination that he was not a witness to the transaction between Chief Mordi and the central land committee makes evidence elicited from him under Cross Examination to be hearsay and offends Section 38 of the Evidence Act hence it is in admissible in law. He relied on the case of OKHUAROBO V. AIGBE (2012)9 NWLR (Pt. 771)29 at 70 para B-C. He submitted that a trial Court is enjoined to give weight and consideration to only legally admissible evidence in its appraisal of the evidence adduced in a trial. He relied on the case of SHANU V. AFRIBANK NIGERIA PLC. (2002) 17 NWLR (Pt.795) 185 at 222 para D-E; SUNTAL V. TUKUR (2003) FWLR (Pt. 57) 1128 at 1145 para H; NWABUOKU V. ONWORDI (2006) 5 SC. (Pt. 111) 103 at 105.

On the order of dismissal he argued that it has a very serious and unprecedented impact on the justice of the case and led to miscarriage of justice against the Appellant. A dismissal of the Plaintiff’s case implies a successful defence which in itself is an act of possession in ascertaining title to the land. He relied on the case of APATA  V. OLANLOKUN (2013) 17 NWLR (Pt.1383) 221 at 245 para A-B; DIKE V. OKOLOEDO (1999) 71, LRCN 7970 at 7987 A-B and G.

He argued further that the order of dismissal of the Appellants’ case implies that judgment was given for the Respondent. The miscarriage of justice in the judgment is that against the ancestral customary land tenure system of Ogbeakwu, the Respondent who is from Umu-Onicha quarters becomes the owner by right of the land on the right side of Uzor-Ogboli farm road which belong to Umu-Okwe quarters. He argued that it is like telling a thief to retain the property he has been known and found to have stolen simply because the likely owner produced no sufficient evidence of ownership so that the thief goes home rejoicing while the owner is left crying, if the Respondent was from the same quarters (Umu-Okwe) as the Appellants, perhaps the order of dismissal would have been right and met the justice of the case.

By Ogbeakwu customary land law, only two members of the same quarters can bonafide contest ownership of land as of right within the quarter. It is not possible with a non member.

A grave dispute over ownership of the land in dispute can only be between the Appellants and other members of Umu-Okwe or the quarters itself. He then posed the question, what was the learned trial Judge supposed to do in the light of these compelling facts and circumstance? His answer is that the trial Judge ought to have exercised his discretion in the interest of justice to consider non- suiting the Appellant and invite the parties to address him on it.

He refer to the case of EFETIROROJE V. OKPALEFE II (1991) 5 NWLR (Pt.193) 517 at 537 para A-B where the Supreme Court gave the condition governing the making of an order of non suit as follows
(a) Where the Plaintiff has not failed intoto or entirely to prove his case.
(b) Where defendant is not in any event entitled to the Courts judgment and
(c) Where no wrong or injustice to the defendant would be caused by such order.

He also relied on the case of AKINSUROJU V. JOSHUA (1991) 4 NWLR (Pt.187) 542; OLAGBEMIRO V. AJAGUNGBADE III (1990) 3 NWLR. (Pt. 136) 37; ADELUSOLA V. AKINDE (2004) 12 NWLR (Pt.887) 295 at 317; IBEKWE V. NWOSU (2011)9 NWLR (Pt.1251) at 17 para G. He argued further that to make an order of non- suit will not wrong or cause injustice to the Respondent in anyway. He contended that by the commercial land tenure system of Ogbeakwu, any member of Ogbeakwu irrespective of his quarters can farm on Ogbeakwu land but cannot claim ownership of such land as of right. So there is no way the Respondent could be entitled to judgment. Both in his pleading and evidence before the Court, the Respondent has not stated that he has crops on the land, so an order of non-suit which will give the Appellants’ opportunity to a second bite at the cherry will not cause injustice to the Respondent.

He urged that Court to so find.

The contention of the Respondent is that the learned trial Judge was right to have dismissed the Appellants case when it became crystal clear that the Appellants could not establish their root of title to the land in dispute by credible evidence. He reiterated that the case of the Appellant before the Court below is that the land in dispute was granted to their father, late Chief J.D. Mordi by the Umu-Okwe quarters Ogwashi-Uku sometimes in 1981. He referred to paragraph 10 of the 1st Appellant evidence on oath contained at page 16 of the record where he aver as follows-

”That sometimes in 1981 our (claimants) father (J.D. Mordi) who was the Ihaza of Ogwashi-Uku and the senior Chief of Umu-Okwe quarters approached the head and principal members of Umu- Okwe quarters with drinks and kolanut for a grant of the land in dispute and after tabling the matter before Umu-Okwe quarters, same was obliged.”

He contended that this was contradicted by the sole witness of the Appellant (Emmanuel Okafor CW1) while under Cross Examination and he said
”Chief J.D. Mordi got the land from an allocation by the central land committee in 1981. He paid a token amount like other allottees. He must have paid between N50.00 – N 100.00

This piece of evidence, he argued is contrary to the fact pleaded in their statement of claim. He submitted that it is trite that a plaintiff or claimant is not legally permitted to make a case contrary to his pleadings. He relied on the case of EDWARD EGONU & 3 ORS V. MADAM EZIAMAKA EGONU & 3 ORS (1978) 11 – 12 SC. 82 at 103 para 1-15.

He contended that the consequence of the contradictory and contradicted evidence of the Appellants regarding their root of title, particularly, on how their late father (Chief J.D. Mordi) became the owner of the land in dispute, is that such piece of contradictory evidence is rendered unreliable and incapable of belief. He refer to the case of ABATAN V. AWUDU (2004) ALL FWLR (Pt.236) 215 at 225, paragraph E. He submitted that where the evidence of a witness is shown to be contradictory, the credibility of the witness is cast in serious doubt. He refered to the case of AYANWALE V. ATANDA (1988) 1 NWLR (Pt. 68) 22 at 35. Paragraph D-E.

He submitted further that it is in consideration of the consequences of the failure of the Appellants to prove, by credible evidence, their root of title that crystallized in the unimpeachable conclusion of the learned trial Judge at pages 146 – 148 of the record which resulted in the dismissal of the Appellant’s case for their failure to establish their root of title. He urged the Court not to disturb the finding of the trial Court.

On the contention of the Appellants at paragraphs 5.02 -5.04 of the Appellant’s brief regarding inadmissibility of the contradictory evidence of CW1 as well as the authorities cited in support of same, he submitted that such contention is totally misconceived and do not hold water as it tends to overlook the essence of cross examination of a witness in a trial proceedings. The significant aim of cross examination has been held to be in two folds thus:
(a) To weaken quality or destroy the case of the party being cross examined and,
(b) To establish the party own case by means of his opponent’s witness.

He relied on the case of TYONEX (NIG) LTD. V. PFIZER LTD (2011) ALL FWLR (Pt.564) 175 at 184 – 185 paragraph H-A; GAJI V. PAYE (2003) FWLR (Pt. 163) 1 at 16 paragraph D-G; BAMGBOYE V. OLAREWAJU (1991) 4 NWLR (Pt.184) 145 at 155. He contended that it was through the fire of cross examination of CW1 that the contradiction which destroyed the Appellants evidence in proof of their root of title to the land in dispute arose, and same is admissible to controvert and discredit any evidence of the Appellants.

He submitted that the learned trial Judge did not rely on the ‘Inadmissible Evidence’ to enter judgment in favour of the Respondent who did not file a counter claim rather the Court consider the effect of the contradicting evidence in proof of the Appellant root of title and came to the irresistible conclusion that the Appellant’s evidence lacks credibility having being shown to be contradictory.

He submitted that it is settled law that in a claim for declaration of title to land, a Plaintiff has the burden of proving his case on his evidence and can succeed or fail on his evidence alone. Where a plaintiff fails to prove his root of title or make out a prima face case to entitle him to the declaration sought, the Defendant who have no counter claim need not answer the claim upon a defective evidence. He cited the case of ELEGUSHI V. OSENI (2006) 133 LRCN 263 and DIKE V. OKOLOEDO (1999)71 LRCN 2970 at 2987.

On the request by the learned counsel representing the Appellant to the effect that an order of non-suit be made by this Court to enable the Appellant have a second bite at the cherry, he submitted that the fact of the present appeal did not meet the conditions stipulated and settled for making such order. The Appellant having failed woefully to prove their root of title and or establish the case put forward in their pleadings cannot be heard to make such a tall request. He reiterated the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of EGONU V. EGONU (supra) that where a Plaintiff fails to establish a case put forward in their pleadings as a result of contrary credible evidence the proper order to make in the circumstance is an order for dismissal.

He cited the case of FIRST BANK OF NIGERIA PLC V. OKON (2010) ALL FWLR (Pt.546) 527 at 540 paragraph G-H. on the contention by the Appellant that he inherit the said land from his late father (Chief J.D. Mordi) who are owners of the land, the Respondent contended that it is not the case of the Appellant that title to the land in dispute belong to Umuoke quarters of Ogwashi-Uku. He argued further that even if the Appellants proved that the land in dispute is situate at Umuokwe quarters, the Appellant did not succeed in proving and establishing how the land became a personal property of late Chief J.D. Mordi (the Appellant’s father) this rendering their root of title very defective and indefensible.

The evidence produced by the Appellant was satisfactorily found by the trial Judge to be contradictory and as such was manifestly unreliable and resulted in the dismissal of the Appellant’s case. The dismissal of the Appellant’s case was based on outright lack of proof. He submitted that the authority of the case of IBEKWE V. NWOSU; ADELUSOLA V. AKINDE cited by the Appellant do not enure in their favour having regard to the fact and circumstance of their case. He therefore submitted that there is no bases calling on parties to address the Court on the proprietary of non-suit by the lower Court nor is there any basis for the grant of such order by this Court. Referring to the finding of the learned trial Judge on page 145 of the Record of Appeal, he urged the Court to refuse the invitation of temptation to consider an order of non-suit as a gratuitous remedy to the Appellants whose case is patently weak and lacking proof. He urge the Court to resolve the two issues in favour of the Respondent and dismiss the appeal.

I have carefully read and considered the submission of the respective counsel and all other process in the record of this appeal. The pertinent question arising from the two issues is whether the learned trial Judge properly evaluated the totality of the evidence before it before dismissing the suit by the Appellants rather than granting an order of non-suit.

The law is that a Plaintiff must establish the case he put forward by credible evidence. That is to say that he must satisfy the Court by preponderance of credible evidence for the Court to grant the relief sought. Hence the burden of first proving the existence or non existence of a fact lies on the party against whom the judgment of the Court would be given if no evidence were produced on the either side. See Section 131(1) of the Evidence Act 2011. See the following cases ODOFIN V. ONI (2001) 1 SC (Pt.1) 129; OLAIYA V. OLAIYA (2002) 5 SC. (Pt. 1) 122; OGOLO V. FUBARA (2003) 5 SC. 141; VINCENT. U. EGHAREVBA V. DR. OROBOR OSAGIE (2009) 12 SC. (Pt. 111) 123.

Having said this, I consider it apt to distinguish the nature of the claim of the Appellants with a view of ascertaining the requirement of proof of such claim and which will assist in determining whether or not the learned trial Judge properly evaluated the evidence of the Appellants in prove of the reliefs sought. To do this recourse has to be made to the writ of summon and statement of claim. In the record of appeal, the writ of summons is on pages 1 and 2 while the statement of claim is on pages 3 ? 5. Both in the endorsement on the writ of summons and paragraph 21 of the statement of claim the Appellants are claiming a declaration that they are entitle to a statutory right of occupancy over the land in dispute discernible on survey plan No. MWC/1186/81 and in addition perpetual injunction restraining the Defendant. The question therefore having regard to the ground of appeal is whether the Applicant has established his case to deserve an award of a declaratory order over the land in dispute.

Generally, title to ownership of land can be proved by any of the following five ways:
(1) By traditional evidence
(2) By production of documents of title which are duly authenticated.
(3) By act of selling, leasing, renting out all or part of the land, of farming on it or in a portion of it.
(4) By acts of land possession and enjoyment of the land and
(5) By proof of possession of connected or adjacent land in circumstances rendering it probable that the owner of such connected or adjacent land would, in addition be the owner of the land in dispute.
See the following cases IDUNDUN & ORS V. OKUMAGBA (1976) 9-10 SC. 140; LASISI MORENIKEJI & ORS V. LALEKE ADEGBOSIN & ORS (2003) 65 CM 41; PETER C. OJOH V. ODWUALA KAMALU & ORS. (2005) 12 SCM 332; MEMUDU AJIBOYE V. ALHAJI OLOYEDE ISHOLA (2006) 6 SCNJ 180; FRANCIS ADESINA AYANWALE V. OLUMUYWU OLUMIDE ODUSAMI (2011) 12 SC (Pt.111) 59; MRS. MARGARET OSIDELE & 2 ORS V. IBIKUNLE SOKUNBI. (2012) 7 SC. (Pt.11) 30.

Now to go into the specifics, i.e. the claim of the Appellants which is for declaration of title to land. Declaratory relief is most commonly seen in proceedings of who is legitimately entitled to be designated owner of disputed land. For this type of claim the Plaintiff must discharge the legal burden of proof as well as the evidential burden that is proof on the balance of probabilities which is also called preponderance of evidence. Such evidence must also be credible. See ORAETOKA V. MACLAM AJIA & ANOR (2006) ALL FWLR (Pt.321) 1312 at 1326 to 1326; ADDA V. JASSEN & ANOR (2004) ALL FWLR (Pt.230) 1011 at 1034. For a party claiming a declaratory title to land, he must show the Court clearly the area of land to which his claim relates. That is, to describe the land with certainty. See the case of OLOKOTINTIN V. SARUMI (1999) 1 NWLR (Pt. 480) 222; ODESANYA V. EWEDEMI (1962) 2 SC. 23; EPI V. AIGBEDION (1972) 10 SC. 53; EMMANUEL IRHABOR & ANOR V. OGAIAMIEN (1999) 6 SC. (Pt.11) 151; AKULAKU & ORS V. YONGO (2002) FWLR (Pt.100) 1228 at 1249.

Therefore for a claim for a declaration of title to land to succeed the Court must be satisfied as to the precise nature of the title claimed. That is to say, whether it is title by virtue of original ownership, customary grant, conveyance, sale under customary law, long possession. The evidence must establish the nature of the title. See ADETUTU ADESANYA V. ALHAJI S.D. ADERONMU & ORS (2000) 6 SC. (Pt.11) 18 at 24.

The question that come to mind is whether the Appellant has satisfied the foregoing requirement. The evidence of the Appellant and his witness as can be captured in the record of appeal is that his father was granted the land in issue in 1981 by the head and principal members of Umu-Okwe quarters. See paragraph 10 of the 1st Appellants statement on oath contained on page 16 of the record where he said –
”That sometimes in 1981 our (claimant) father (J.D. Mordi) who was the Ihaza of Ogwashi-Uku and the senior Chief of Umu-Okwe quarters approached the head and principal members of Umu- Okwe quarters with drinks and kolanut for the a grant of the land in dispute and after tabling the matter before Umu-Okwe quarters same was obliged.”

The witness of the Appellant Emmanuel Okafor while under cross examination said: (See page 100 of the record)
”Chief J.D. Mordi got the land from an allocation by the central land committee in 1981, he paid a token amount like other allottees. He must have paid between N50.00 – N100.00.”

On his own part the Defendant in his paragraph 5 aver as follow in response to paragraph 10 of the Appellants.

The Defendant denies paragraphs 10, 11 and 12 of the claimant’s statement of claim and avers that his father Pa. Samson Okeibunor Ugbah inherited some from his later father, Pa. Okolie Ugbah and has been in possession of the land in dispute prior 1981. That the survey plan No. MWC/1186/81 which the Defendant (Sic) anchored his claim upon was without beacon numbers. The said survey plan has no bearing or relationship with the land in dispute.

In the light of the foregoing, averments and evidence before the Court, the learned trial Judge from pages 146 did his consideration and evaluation. The Court said:
”It is clear that the ownership of the land by the claimant’s alleges predecessor in title is being challenged. The onus is therefore on the claimants to prove the alleged grant of the land in dispute to their father. Both the claimant and his witness testified in line with this averment. Counsel for the Defendant submitted that for many reasons, declaration of title to land cannot be based on the testimony of the claimant and his witnesses. In this regard, counsel submitted that no evidence was called for any witness to the transaction and that there is contradiction in the evidence of the CW1. As to how Chief J.D. Mordi got the land. Counsel for the claimants did not address this specific issues. The contradiction has to do with the evidence of the CW1 under cross examination, where he testified thus:
Chief J.D. Mordi got the land from allocation by central land committee in 1981. He paid a token amount like other allottees .”

This piece of evidence certainly contradicts the averment in paragraph 11 of the claimants:

pleadings, the evidence of the 1st claimant and the evidence in Chief of the witness all of which are to the effect that the land in dispute was granted to Chief J.D. Mordi by the diokpa and principal members of Umu-Okwe quarters. The CW1 also admitted under cross examination that he was not a witness to the transaction. The name of any of the principal members of Umu-Okwe family who approved and made the grant. No evidence was called of anyone who witnessed the transaction. The Court cannot fault the conclusion of the Defendant’s counsel, that the claimants’ root of title has not been established.

The claimants counsel attached the case of the Defendant on several grounds: failure to establish his root of title and/or contradictions on the issue, the evidence of PW3 which puts his age at less than 12 at the time when he became a tenant on the land. Admittedly, the Defendant’s case is weak but the weakness of the Defendant’s case cannot strengthen the claimants’ case since they have failed to establish their root of title. The onus is therefore, on them to satisfy the Court on the evidence adduced by them that they are entitled to the declaration. It is for these reasons that the case of a claimant is considered first in a claim for declaration of title so that if he is unable to make out a prima facie case, the Defendant will not be obliged to defend the case.

The Court relied on the case of DIKE V. OKOLOEDO (1999) 71 LRCN 2970 and ELEGUSHI V. OSENI (2006) 133 LRCN 263. In the end the Court said thus:
”Having failed to establish their root of title, I fail to see how the weakness in the Defendant’s case can help the claimant’s case. In the circumstances of this case, since the Defendant has no counter claim he is not obliged to answer the claimant defective claim.

The reliefs sought by the claimant have been set out in this judgment. The claim for declaration ought but as the claimants have failed to make out a case to entitle them to same. Having failed in the action for declaration, the Court cannot grant the relief of injunction.
Upon a thorough consideration of the fact before me, the Court hold that the claimants are not entitled to any of the reliefs sought. In the result their claim ought to be and is accordingly dismissed.”

In the light of the foregoing the question is whether or not the learned trial Judge properly evaluated the evidence placed before the Court to arrive at the decision reached.

It is long settled that evaluation of evidence is the duty of the trial Court to receive all relevant and admissible evidence. This process is referred to as perception. After the trial Judge will weigh the evidence received from both sides and decide where the scale tilts on qualitative and compelling evidence. This second process is what is referred to as evaluation. Where all the foregoing are properly done, it is not the duty of the Appellate Court to evaluate except where the trial Court fails to evaluate. It is also trite that where evaluation of evidence entails issues of credibility of witnesses, the Appeal Court should be reluctant to differ from the trial Judge’s finding of fact based on credibility of witnesses.

The reason for this is that, it is the trial Court that had the opportunity of hearing and watching the demeanour of the witnesses as they testify an opportunity the appeal court doesn’t have. See MR. ADEMOLA ADEWUMI ODUTOLA & 11 ORS V. PROFESSOR AKIN MABOGUNJE. & 4 ORS. NSCQR Vol. 53 (2013) page 31, at 36; ADEYERI II V. ATANDA (1995) 5 NWLR (Pt. 397) 612; IBANGA V. USANGA (1982) 5 SC (REPRINT) 49; OSUAGWU V. THE STATE (2013) 1-2 SC (Pt. 1) 37. In the light of the foregoing and considering the process which the learned trial Judge went through in arriving at the conclusion appealed against, I feel hesitant to come to the conclusion that the learned trial Judge has not properly evaluated the evidence placed before it by both parties and in particular the Plaintiff/Appellant. The claim of the Appellant is for a declaration order. To me it appears that the learned counsel to the Appellant misconceived the fact. Looking at the evidence adduced by the Appellant and his witness, they deal more on the ownership of the land by Umu-Okwe quarters whereas it is their evidence that the Umu-Okwe quarter allegedly granted ownership to Chief J.D. Mordi of Ogwashi-Uku.

What is in contest is the alleged ownership of J.D. Mordi and not the ownership of the four quarter.

A declaratory relief as I said before is a discretionary remedy and Plaintiff seeking the order has the legal burden of proof as well as the evidential burden. That is to say that he has to proof his case on the balance of probability that is proof by preponderance of evidence. See ADDA V. JASSEN & ANOR. (2004) ALL FWLR (Pt. 230) 1011 at 1134-5. It is also trite that the first duty a person claiming a declaration of title to land should do is to show the Court clearly the area of land which his claim relates. See the case of OLOKOTINTIN V. SARUMI (1997)1 NWLR (Pt. 480) 222; ETIM V. OYO (1978) 6 SC. 91; EPI V. OGAIAMIEN (1999) 6 SC. (Pt.ii) 151.

I also align myself with the finding of the Court because the Appellant has failed to proof with certainty the land that they said was granted to their late father. No Court would grant declaration to an uncertain area. See CHIEF M. EJEBU V. CHIEF N.T. OKOKO. (2001) FWLR (Pt. 79) 1350 at 1264; GBADAMOSI V. DAIRO (2007) 3 NWLR (Pt. 1021) 282; DADA V. DOSUNMU (2006) 18 NWLR (Pt.1010) 134. In the appeal at hand the survey plan provided by the Appellant Exhibit CE2 does not provide the demarcations of the land. A Plaintiff should provide a precise area of the land he is claiming. The combined effect of the foregoing is that it is my candid view that the learned trial Judge properly evaluated the evidence placed before the trial Court.

If that is so, it is also my vavent view that the learned trial Judge is right to dismiss the claim of the Plaintiff for failure to proof with certainty the area of the land to which he sought a declaratory relief. It is also trite that where a Plaintiff claims a declaration of title to land as in this appeal at hand, and fails to give the exact extent and identity of the land he is claiming his action should be dismissed. See GBADAMOSI V. DAIRO (2007) 3 NWLR (Pt.1021) 282; ARABE V. ASANLU (1980) 5-7 ? SC. 78. As I said before, it is the duty of the Plaintiff in a claim for declaration of title to land to establish with certainty and accuracy the identity of land he claims. It is a condition precedent to the success of the claim. See ADENIRAN V. ASHABI (2004) 2 NWLR (Pt.857) 375; OTANMA V. YOUDUBAGHA (2006) 2 NWLR (Pt.964) 337.

In the  circumstance of the fact of this case and the evidence before the Court, I concur with the finding and conclusion of the learned trial Judge that the case of the Appellant should be dismissed and I have no reason whatsoever to change and substitute the conclusion with an order of non-suit suggested by the learned counsel representing the Appellant. Let me add that the order of dismissal of the Plaintiff claim does not automatically mean that the land in dispute belong to the Defendant. (Respondent) See SALAU V. ARABA (2004) ALL FWLR. (Pt.206) page 88 at 125 -126.The two issues therefore are resolved against the Appellants.

In consequence, the appeal is unmeritorious and same be and is hereby dismissed.

The judgment of the High Court of Delta State Ogwashi-Uku Judicial Division in suit No. 0/18/2011 delivered on 19th December 2014 is hereby affirmed. There shall be no order for cost.

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, J.C.A.: I had the privilege of reading a copy of the judgment just delivered by my learned brother, M.N. ONIYANGI, JCA. I am in complete agreement with the reasoning and conclusion contained therein and for the same reasons articulated in the lead judgment which I admit as mine. I also hold that this appeal lacks merit and it is accordingly dismissed.

I abide by the consequential orders made in the lead judgment including order as to cost.

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN, J.C.A.: I had the privilege of reading before now the judgment of my learned brother, ONIYANGI, JCA; just delivered. I agree with the reasons given by my learned brother for dismissing this appeal. For the elaborate reasons advanced by my learned brother I also dismiss the appeal.

I make no order for costs.

 

Appearances:

E. F. OSIFOFor Appellant(s)

S. K. NNADIFor Respondent(s)