LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

MICHAEL E. ABURIME v. UNITED BANK FOR AFRICA PLC & ORS (2018)

MICHAEL E. ABURIME v. UNITED BANK FOR AFRICA PLC & ORS

(2018)LCN/11714(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Thursday, the 14th day of June, 2018

CA/B/80/2013

RATIO

EXERCISE OF JURISDICTION

It is however trite that the grant or refusal of stay of execution of judgment by the Court is purely discretionary, though the discretion must be exercised both judicially and judiciously but certainly not arbitrarily per MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI, J.C.A.

JUSTICES:

PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

MICHAEL E. ABURIME
(Trading as Tempair Nigeria Enterprises) – Appellant(s)

AND

1) UNITED BANK FOR AFRICA PLC
2) EDO STATE GOVERNMENT
3) ATTORNEY GENERAL, EDO STATE
4) CHIEF REGISTRAR, HIGH COURT, EDO STATE – Respondent(s)

MUDASHIRU NASIRU ONIYANGI, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): 

This appeal is against the ruling of the High Court of Edo State sitting in Benin City delivered on 7th day of February, 2013 in Suit No. B/333/2011 between Michael Aburime (Trading as Tempair Nigeria Enterprises) as Judgment/Creditor/Respondent and (1) Edo State Government (2) Attorney General, Edo State (3) Chief Registrar, High Court as Judgment/Debtor/Garnishee Applicants in an application by the United Bank for Africa Plc, the garnishee before the trial Court. Consequent upon the judgment of the trial Court in favour of plaintiff. The plaintiff in the substantive suit which was registered under the undefended list procedure sought for the following reliefs against the defendants.
The plaintiffs claim against the defendants is for the sum of N23,131,533.00 (Twenty-three million, one hundred and thirty one thousand, five hundred and thirty three Naira) being the amount due for payment to the plaintiff with respect to a contract awarded to the plaintiff by the 1st defendant and which said sum the defendants have failed, refused and or neglected to ensure is paid to the plaintiff inspite of repeated demands and appeals.

Issues were joined and in the end the learned trial judge concluded as follows: (See page 110 of the record of appeal)
Finally, in the sum and in view that the plaintiffs claim is undisputed both in law and on the facts, judgment is hereby entered for the plaintiff against the defendants as follows:
(1) The defendants shall pay the plaintiff the sum of N23,131,533.00 (Twenty-three Million, One Hundred and Thirty-One Thousand, Five Hundred and Thirty-three Naira) being the amount due for payment to the plaintiff with respect to a contract awarded to the plaintiff by the 1st defendant.
(2) The defendants shall also pay cost of N5,000.00 (Five Thousand Naira) to the plaintiff.

When the defendant/judgment debtor defaulted in paying the judgment sum as ordered by the Court to the Judgment Creditor/Respondent, the latter commenced a garnishee proceeding vide an ex-parte motion dated 2nd day of April, 2012 against the judgment debtor and United Bank for Africa Plc as a garnishee, attaching the funds of Edo State Government internally generated account No. 01990040000582. The learned trial judge after due consideration of the said motion ex-parte, ordered as follows: (see page 15 of the record of appeal)
I have carefully considered the application and the affidavit in support of same. It is my considered view that this application ought be granted and it is granted on the following terms:
I hereby grant Order Nisi against the Garnishee United Bank for Africa Plc to show cause why an order that the judgment debt of N23,131,533 (Twenty-three Million, One Hundred and Thirty-one Thousand, Five Hundred and Thirty-three Naira) and cost of N5,000.00 (Five Thousand Naira) awarded in the Bank Account No. 01990040000582 with sort code No. 033040488 maintained by the judgment/debtor Edo State Government at Akpakpava Road Branch of United Bank for Africa Plc, Benin City be paid to the judgment creditor should not be made.
I further order that this Order be served on the judgment/debtors. Case adjourned to 14th June 2012 for hearing.

Thereafter and on the 11th day of June 2012, the judgment creditor/Respondent by a motion on notice dated 8th, June 2012 asked the trial Court to make the order nisi absolute consequent upon the failure of the garnishee Respondent to file any process in opposition to the Order nisi nor show cause why the Order should not be made absolute. After due consideration of the said motion on notice, the learned trial judge in his considered ruling concluded as follows: (see pages 22-31 of the record of appeal)
Consequently, from the foregoing the Garnishee/Respondent has failed to show cause why the Garnishee Order Nisi should not be made absolute.
In sum, after due consideration, this application is meritorious and it is hereby granted on the following terms:
I hereby grant an order absolute against the Garnishee United Bank for Africa Plc to pay the judgment debt of N23,131,533 (Twenty-three million, One hundred and thirty-one thousand, five hundred and thirty-three Naira) and cost of N5,000.00 (five Thousand Naira) awarded in the Bank Account No. 01990040000582 with sort code no. 0330040488 maintain by the 1st judgment debtor Edo State Government at Akpakpava Road Branch of United Bank for Africa Plc, Benin City to the judgment creditor forthwith.

There shall be no order as to cost.

Against the foregoing ruling and order, the garnishee, United Bank for Africa by way of a motion on notice dated 23rd November 2012 sought for an order of stay of execution of the garnishee order absolute made on 8th November 2012 pending the determination of appeal. Issues were joined and on the 7th day of February 2013, the learned trial judge ruled as follows: (see pages 33-63 for the application and the counter process and pages 64-84 of the record of appeal for the ruling).
In sum after due consideration, it is my considered view that to meet the justice of this application, I will grant a conditional stay of execution.
Accordingly, the Garnishee/Applicant is hereby ordered to pay the judgment debtor N23,131,533.00 (Twenty-three million, One Hundred and Thirty-one Thousand, Five Hundred and Thirty Three Naira) and cost of N5,000.00 (Five thousand naira) awarded in Bank Account No. 01990040000582 with sort code No. 033040488 maintained by the 1st judgment debtor Edo State Government at Akpakpava Road Branch of United Bank for Africa Plc Benin City to the Edo State Judiciary, High Court of Justice, Benin City forthwith.
It is further ordered that the said judgment debt and cost awarded be paid by the Assistant Director, High Court of Justice, Benin City into an interest yielding account with Guaranty Trust Bank Plc, Sapele Road, Benin City, pending the hearing and determination of the appeal filed by the Garnishee/Applicant.
There shall be no order as to cost.

Aggrieved by the foregoing ruling by the trial Court hence this appeal by the Judgment Creditor/Appellant vide the Notice of Appeal dated 10th day of February 2013 and filed on 11th February 2013. It contains two grounds. They are:
GROUNDS OF APPEAL
(1) The learned trial judge erred in law in granting a stay of execution of a money judgment at the instance of a garnishee to deny the judgment creditor the fruit of his judgment in an action under the undefended list procedure.
(2) The learned trial judge erred in law when he relied on a reason which was not available to the garnishee to grant a stay of execution of the judgment of the Court which a garnishee order nisi had been made absolute.

RELIEF SOUGHT
To allow the appeal and set aside the order granting the stay of execution. This Honourable Court should order that the judgment debt be paid to the Appellant.

The record of appeal was transmitted on the 26/2/2013. The initial Appellants brief of argument dated 19/3/2013 was filed same date. By the order of this Court, an amended Appellant brief of argument was filed on 31/5/2017. Neither of the Respondents filed any brief of argument. Based on that premise, the Appellant sought and was granted an order to set down the appeal for hearing based on the Appellants brief of argument alone on the 22/2/2017.

In the amended appellants brief of argument, authored by S. Iredia Osifo Esq., the following two issues were distilled for the determination of this appeal.

APPELLANTS ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
(1) Whether the learned trial judge was right in granting a stay of execution of the judgment obtained under the undefended list procedure at the instance of a garnishee whose only duty was to obey and pay the judgment debt to the judgment creditor (Ground 1).
(2) Whether the reason for granting the stay of execution by the learned trial judge was available  to the Respondent as a garnishee/Applicant (Ground 2).

I have carefully read all the processes filed in this appeal, the amended Appellants brief inclusive. This appeal therefore would be determined on the Appellants brief of argument. Both issues one and two would be taken together.

The argument of the Appellant on the two issues is that under the Nigeria Law, a garnishee proceedings is essentially between the garnishee and the judgment creditor. He relied on the case of UBA Plc v. EKANEM (2010) 6 NWLR (PT. 1190) 207 at 221 paragraph H. He posed the question whether the reason by the garnishee/Respondent which was the only one acted upon by the learned trial judge in granting a stay of execution of the order absolute available to the garnishee/Respondent having regard to the fact of that judgment rendered under the undefended list procedure. He submitted that if any party was entitled to rely on this reason as a defence in this case, it was the judgment debtors. But they did not raise this as a defence. The inability of the Appellant to refund the judgment debt it paid to him was not raised in the affidavit of defence filed by the judgment debtors because they knew that there was no basis for it.

He argued that in a garnishee proceeding, the work or job of the garnishee is well cut out once the order nisi is made absolute. The garnishee is duty bound to pay the judgment creditor from the judgment debtors money in the hands of a garnishee. He relied on the case of GOVERNOR, OYO STATE VS. AKINYEMI (2003) 1 NWLR (PT. 800) 1 AT 13. He argued that after the order nisi was made in this proceedings and served on the garnishee to show cause why the order should not be made absolute, the only relevant reason advanced by the garnishee was that the account attached was not kept exclusively for the Edo State Government but that there are also 3rd parties who also pay money into the account for the purpose of purchasing houses. This was rejected by the Court because the garnishee did not give particulars of those 3rd parties hence the order was made absolute. Agreeing that the grant or refusal of an application for grant of stay of execution of judgment is a matter for exercise of Courts discretion. He relied on the case of KASUNMU V SHITTA-BEY (2006) 17 NWLR (PT. 1008) 372. He submitted that the grant of a stay of execution of the order absolute in this case amounts to an improper exercise of the lower Courts discretion. The grant of stay at the instance of the garnishee after the order nisi has been made absolute is a product of an improper exercise of the Courts discretion. He relied on the case of NWADIOGBU V. A.I.R.B.D.A. (2010) 19 NWLR (PT. 1226) 364 at 387 where the Apex Court said thus:
It is settled law that an appellate Court is usually very slow to interfere with the exercise of discretion by the lower Court and would only do so if the appellant shows or satisfies the Court that the lower Court acted entirely on wrong principle or failed to take all the circumstance of the case into consideration and that it is manifest that the order would work injustice to the Appellant.

Further to the foregoing, he also relied on the case of UNION BANK OF NIGERIA PLC V. ASTRA BUILDERS (WA) Ltd. (2010) 5 NWLR (PT. 1186) 1 at 29 where Adekeye JSC said thus:
An Appellate Court will however reverse an exercise of discretion by a trial Court where there has been a wrongful exercise of discretion by the trial Court because it did not give the weight to relevant considerations upon which judicial discretion is exercised.

He submitted that the exercise of discretion by the learned trial judge in granting a stay of execution of the garnishee order absolute to the garnishee was completely misconceived neither was the exercise done judicially nor judiciously. He contended that the issue upon which a garnishee can appeal against a garnishee order absolute are matters which have to do with the status of the money it is holding to the credit of the judgment debtor. Any matter which goes to the root of how the judgment debt was incurred by the judgment debtors has nothing to do with the garnishee. That is why the stay of execution granted to the garnishee by the lower Court is in bad faith and for all the wrong reasons. It is wrong for a trial Court to award judgment to a party with the right hand and then take it back with the left hand deliberately and without just cause or out of sheer pretence of ignorance. He urged the Court to allow the appeal, set aside the order by the lower Court granting a conditional stay of execution of the garnishee order absolute and order the garnishee to pay the judgment debt to the Appellant within 24 hours or the Appellant should proceed to levy execution on the garnishee.

In the light of the foregoing argument by the learned counsel representing the Appellant, the first pertinent question is: who is a garnishee or what is the meaning of the word garnishee
Let me say first that a garnishee proceeding is usually set in motion by a judgment/creditor against a disclosed account of a judgment debtor. The word garnishee is derived from the French word GARNISH which simply connote to warn. Put in another way, it is the process by which execution or enforcement of monetary judgment whereby the money belonging to a judgment debtor in the possession of a third party called the Garnishee is attached or seized by a judgment creditor. See also the Black Law Dictionary 8th edition at page 703. See UBN PLC V. BONEY MARCUS INDUSTRIES LTD. & ORS. (2005) ALL FWLR (PT. 278) 1037 at 1046-1047.

Bearing the foregoing in mind, the next question is what is the duty or responsibility of a garnishee in a garnishee proceeding? This Court in a plethora of decided cases concluded that it is the duty of a garnishee is to pay money in its bank to the credit of the judgment debtor after he might have disclosed the true status of the account of the judgment debtor. See U.B.A. V. FRANCE APPNO SAS & ORS (2015) LPELR-40394; OCEANIC BANK PLC V. OLADEPO (2012) LPELR 19670; SKYE BANK PLC V. OKENE A. DAVID & ORS. (2014) LPELR 23731; ZENITH BANK V. GEORGE C. IGBOKWE & ANOR. (2013) LPELR 21975. Having said these, one should add it is not the business of the garnishee to play the role of an advocate for a judgment debtor by acts that would amount to shield or protect the money of the judgment debtor. At the time an order nisi is made against a given bank or financial institution, the duty of secrecy owned by the bank to his customer who is the judgment debtor is broken. The bank becomes duty bound to disclose to the Court the state of the named account of the judgment debtor. I find solace in the dictum of Akintan JSC in the case of UNION BANK OF NIGERIA, PLC V. BONEY MARCUS INDUSTRIES LTD. & ORS. (2005) 13 NWLR (PT. 943) 654 at 666 E-H where His Lordship said:Application for garnishee proceedings are made to the Court by the judgment creditor and the order of the Court usually come in two steps. The first is a garnishee order nisi. Nisi is a Norman French word and it means unless. It is therefore an order made at that stage, that the sum covered by the application be paid into the Court or to the judgment creditor within a stated time unless there is some sufficient reason why the party on whom the order is directed is given why the payment order should not be made. If no sufficient reason appears, the garnishee order is then made absolute and that ends the matter in that the party against whom the order absolute is made is liable to pay the amount specified in the order to the judgment creditor. The Court thereafter becomes functus officio as far as that matter is concerned in that the judge who decided the matter is precluded from again considering the matter even if new evidence or argument are presented to him. See CHOICE INVESTMENT LTD. V. JEROMNION (MIDLAND BANK LTD.) garnishee (1981) 1 ALL ER 225 at 328 and Words and Phrases legally defined vol.2 page 301.

From the foregoing therefore, it is crystal clear that the garnishee Bank has the onerous task and duty to make disclosure to the Court the position and state of the account attached vide an order nisi made by the Court.

The other aspect of the argument by the Appellant is whether or not the garnishee is competent to seek for an order of stay of execution. My understanding of the decision in U.B.A. V. HON. IBORO EKANEM (MD PARAGON ENG. LTD.) & ANOR. (2009) LPELR 8428 is that it is the garnishee that has the power to challenge the order absolute. The reason for this is simple. In a garnishee preceding the judgment debtor is a silent and dormant party. He is only served with the processes in the garnishee proceedings but he is not a party. Therefore, it is the garnishee Bank that can initiate an order of stay or an appeal. In addition to this, the order of the trial Court making an order nisi absolute is a final order and appealable by any aggrieved party to the proceeding i.e. the judgment creditor and the garnishee in particular. But definitely a judgment debtor is incompetent to initiate a process for stay nor that of an appeal. This will now lead me to the question whether the trial Court is right having regard to the fact antecedent to this appeal to grant the order of stay at the instance of the Respondent, the Garnishee Bank. In providing answer to this question, I will have a peep on the Ruling of the Court delivered on the 7th day of February 2013 with a view of the fishing out the reason for the order granted. (See pages 64-84 of the record). At page 73 of the record, the learned trial judge posed the following question:
Whether there are materials in the Applicants application that would warrant this Court in exercising its discretion in granting the application.

After a careful review of submission from respective counsel, the provision of Order 52 Rule 2(2) of the High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules of Edo State 2012 on striking out of applications withdrawn, the ground of appeal in the notice of appeal filed by the Respondent Garnishee, the learned trial judge concluded as follows. (See pages 83-84 of the record of appeal).
From the judgment creditor/Respondents own showing the question of paying back the judgment debt does not arise which in essence means he will not be able to pay back the judgment sum if the appeal succeeds as the judgment debt, is a debt and he sourced for fund to execute the contract.
It has been held that where there is apprehension as to the inability of the Respondent to secure a refund or the judgment debt, the practice of the Court is to exercise its discretion of granting a conditional stay upon the payment of the judgment debt into the Court. This discretionary power is exercised judicially and judiciously depending very much on the peculiar fact and circumstance of each case. In such condition a payment of the judgment debt into an interest yielding account will more often meet the justice of the case as the winner in the appeal will not suffer any loss. See the following cases of GOVERNOR OF OYO STATE V. AKINYEMI (SUPRA) P. 19; ORIENT BANK LTD. V. BILANTE INTERNATIONAL LTD. (1996) 5 NWLR (PT. 447) 166.
In sum, after due consideration, it is my considered view that to meet the justice of this application, I will grant a conditional stay of execution.
Accordingly, the Garnishee/Applicant is hereby ordered to pay the judgment debt of N23,131,533.00(Twenty-three million, One Hundred and Thirty-one Thousand, Five Hundred and Thirty-three Naira) and cost of N5,000.00 (Five Thousand Naira) awarded in Bank Account No. 0990040000582 with sort code No. 033040488 maintain by the 1st Judgment Debtor Edo State Government at Akpakpava Road Branch of United Bank for Africa Plc, Benin City to the Edo State judiciary, High Court of Justice, Benin City forthwith.
It is further ordered that the said judgment debt and cost awarded be paid by the Assistant Director, High Court of Justice, Benin City into an interest yielding account with Guaranty Trust Bank Plc, Sapele Road, Benin City pending the hearing and determination of the appeal filed by the Garnishee/Applicant.
There shall be no order as to cost.

To my understanding what the Court did was to exercise its discretionary power in granting the conditional stay. The pertinent question is whether or not the Court has exercised the discretionary power judicially and judiciously. Let me start by saying that execution simplicita is the process of carrying into effect the direction in a judgment. It is also trite that a Court from which an appeal lies as well as the Court to which an appeal, both have common duty to preserve the res for the purpose of ensuring that the appeal, if successful is not nugatory. See the case of KIGO (NIG.) LTD. V. HOLMAN BROS. NIG. LTD. (1980) 5-7 S.C. 60 at 70-72; ANDU MAKINDE (HEAD OF FAMILY) & ORS. V. DAWUDU AKINWALE & ORS. (1995) 6 NWLR (PT. 399( 1; GOVERNMENT OF GONGOLA STATE V. TUKUR (1989) 4 NWLR (PT. 117) 592. In the case of INTEGRATION (NIG.) LTD. V. ZUMAFON NIGERIA LTD. (2014) LPELR 22012, Ariwoola JSC has this to say on what a Court should take into consideration before granting an application of stay of execution:
It is settled law that a stay of execution of a judgment will only be granted by the Court, if it is satisfied that there are special or exceptional circumstances to warrant doing so. The reason being that the law is that a judgment of a Court of law is presumed to be correct and rightly given until the contrary is proved or established. The Court have refused to make it a practice of depriving a successful litigant of the fruit of his success in Court. See MARTINS V. NICANNAR FOOD CO. LTD. (1988) SC 429; SHODEINDE V. TRUSTEE IN ISLAM (1981) 2 SC 165; VASWANI TRADING CO. LTD. V. SAVALAKH & ORS (1972) 12 SC 77; AMADI & ORS. V. CHUKWU & ORS. (PT. 12) 12 SCM 18.
His Lordship said further
It is however trite that the grant or refusal of stay of execution of judgment by the Court is purely discretionary, though the discretion must be exercised both judicially and judiciously but certainly not arbitrarily. See OKAFOR & ORS. V. NNAIFE (1987) 4 NWLR (PT. 64) 129.
Finally, let me add that the Appellate Court will only interfere with exercise of discretion of the lower Court where the exercise of discretion is manifestly wrong, arbitrary, reckless and injudicious. See UNIVERSITY OF LAGOS V. OLANIYAN (1985) 16 NSCC (PT. 1) 98 at 113; ERONINI V. IHEUKO(1989) 2 NSCC (PT. 1) 503 at 513; OBI EZE V. ATTORNEY GENERAL, RIVERS STATE (2001) 12 SCNJ 35.
Upon a careful perusal of the ruling of the trial Court while granting the order absolute, the Court put into consideration the affidavit to show cause by the garnishee. See pages 50-51 of the record of appeal. The said affidavit was sworn to by Victor Enemare, a business manager with the garnishee. In paragraph 6c of the said affidavit the garnishee aver as follows:
That funds in the account sought to be garnished are jointly owned by the 1st Judgment Debtor and Innocent 3rd parties who have deposited into the said account for purposes of owning their own houses under the State Government Housing Scheme which has not been birthed.
The learned trial judge in his considered ruling delivered on 8th November 2012 concluded as follows:
Thus in the instant case, both the garnishee Respondent and the Judgment Debtor/Respondents have failed to establish from the affidavit evidence before this Court that the account sought to be garnished is jointly owned by the 1st judgment Debtor and Innocent 3rd parties and that 3rd parties deposited money into the said account for purposes of owning their own houses.
Accordingly, this Court cannot order the unnamed or unknown 3rd parties to appear before her to state the nature and particulars of their claim upon such debt.
Consequently from the foregoing the Garnishee/Respondent has failed to show cause why  the Garnishee Order nisi should not be made absolute.
In sum after due consideration, this application is meritorious and it is hereby granted on the following terms?.
From the foregoing, it is clear that the Court rejected the fact contained in the averment of the garnishee herein before reproduced. The Court granted the order absolute.
Again, in the application for an order staying the execution of the garnishee order absolute made on 8th November 2012 pending the determination of the Garnishee/Applicants appeal against the said order, the Applicant Garnishee in paragraph 4c of the supporting affidavit deposed to by Edith Eleta, a litigation clerk in the law firm of Messrs Oboro-Umeh & Co. aver as follows:
The Garnishee/Applicant filed an affidavit which was uncontroverted stating that the account No. 01990040000582 is a joint account operated by both the Edo State Government and the 3rd parties who have deposited money into the said account for purposes of owning their own houses under the State Government Housing Scheme. A photocopy of the said affidavit is hereby attached and marked as Exhibit B.

Further to this is the affidavit sworn to by Henry Asemota a litigation clerk in the Edo State Ministry of Justice, Benin city. In paragraph 8, the deponent aver as follows:
That the Garnishee/Applicant filed an affidavit which was uncontroverted stating that the account No. 01990040000582 is a joint account operated by both the Edo State Government and the third parties who have deposited money into the said account for purposes of owning their own houses under the State Government Housing Scheme. A photocopy of the said order is hereby attached and marked as Exhibit C.
The learned trial judge in his considered ruling in the application for stay of execution and in granting same gave favourable consideration to the averments in paragraph 4c of the supporting affidavit of the Applicant. See pages 79-80 paragraph 4c contains the averment on 3rd party interest. The averment in paragraph 4c is the basis for ground 3 in the notice of appeal. All these were considered and which made the Court conclude that there are recondite point of law to support the pending appeal. My worry here is that the totality of the foregoing suggests to me that the Court is blowing hot and cold. In the consideration of the application to make order nisi, absolute, the learned trial judge rejected the fact on 3rd party interest. In the consideration of the motion for stay of proceeding, the Court consider the ground which is predicated on paragraph 4c as recondite. This to my mind constitute a double standard. It constitute an instance where this Court will interfere with the exercise of judicial discretion of the trial Court. Further to this, is the reason of whether the judgment creditor would be able to repay back the money if the appeal succeed. In the circumstance of this appeal where the judgment creditor was awarded a contract for construction of offices in the High Court, sourced money, executed the contract and delivered same to the beneficiary (Edo State High Court) but the State Government neglected and refused to pay the contract sum, the issue of whether or not the judgment creditor would be able to refund the money should not be used against the judgment creditor. If nothing, the judgment creditor has display prudence, diligence and competence to finance the contract and execute same. That then put the judgment creditor above board. The issue of impecuniosity should not stand against the judgment creditor in the circumstance and fact of this case. It is trite that the Court does not ordinarily interfere with the exercise of discretionary power by the trial Court but the Court will only interfere with the exercise of discretion of the lower Court where it is found to be manifestly wrong, arbitrary and injudicious. See UNIVERSITY OF LAGOS V. OLANIYAN (1985) 16 NSCC (PT. 1) 98 at 113; ERONINI V. IHEUKO (1989) 2 NSCC (PT. 1) 503 at 513;OBI EZE V. ATTORNEY GENERAL, RIVERS STATE (2001) 12 SCNJ 35.
Going by the guidelines laid down in the case of VASWANI TRADING CO. V. SAVALAKH & CO. (supra) for the grant of stay of execution, which among other is that the condition should be special or strong, the fact relied upon by the trial Court in the circumstances of this appeal is feeble not in existence but speculative. It is not justifiable in the case to grant a stay of execution. The effect of the foregoing is that the Court ought not to grant the stay of execution. The grant is like allowing a debtor to walk away after enjoying the services rendered to him without making payment of the agreed due contract sum. The Court should not be used to shield a debtor from paying for the services rendered to him.
In Blacks Law Dictionary, 8th Edition, edited by Bryam Garner at page 409, Judicial discretion is given the meaning thus:
The exercise of judgment by a judge or Court based on what is fair under the circumstances and guided by the rules and principle of law, a Courts power to act or not to act when a litigant is not entitled to demand the act as a matter of right.
In the New International Comprehensive Dictionary of the English Language Encyclopedia edition at page 365, the word discretion is defined as:
the act or the liberty of deciding according to justice and propriety and ones idea of what is right and proper under the circumstance without willfulness or favour.
See also the case of AJUWA & ANOR. V. S.P.D.C. (2011) 12 SC (PT. IV) 118 at 17-173.
On the other hand judicious has been described as a proceeding from or showing sound judgment, having or exercising sound judgment, marked by discretion, wisdom and good sense.

See ERONINI V. IHEUKO (supra). Having said all these, I am left with no other option than to come to the conclusion that the learned trial judge has not in the circumstances of this case exercised his judicial discretion judiciously. I therefore resolve the two issues against the Respondents and in favour of the Appellant.

The appeal is therefore meritorious and it is accordingly allowed.

In consequence, the ruling of the High Court of Justice, Edo State, Benin Judicial Division in Suit No. B/333/2011 delivered on 7th day of February 2013 granting a conditional stay in favour of the Garnishee/Respondent (United Bank for Africa Plc) is hereby set aside.

In its place order is made that the judgment debt of N23, 131,532.00 (Twenty-three million, One Hundred and Thirty-One Thousand, Five Hundred and Thirty-two Naira only) and cost of N5,000.00 (Five Thousand Naira) should be paid forthwith to the Judgment/Creditor by the Garnishee United Bank for Africa Plc from the attached account No. 01990040000582 with sort code No. 033040485.

The Garnishee Respondent shall pay a cost of N100, 000.00 to the Judgment Creditor/Appellant.

PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE, J.C.A.: I had a preview of the lead judgment just delivered by my learned brother M.N. ONIYANGI, JCA and I am in complete agreement with my Lords reasoning and conclusion reached in this appeal.

Having resolved the two issues in favour of the Appellant as against the Respondents, I am also of the ardent view that the appeal is meritorious and it is accordingly allowed.

I abide by his Lordship’s order as to cost of #100,000.00 in favour of the judgment Creditor/Appellant.
Appeal allowed.

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN, J.C.A.: I read before now the judgment just delivered by my learned brother, Mudashiru Nasiru Oniyangi, JCA.
I agree that this appeal has merit and I allow it.
I abide by all the orders made by my learned brother.

Appearances

S.O. ATOE ESQ. with him, H.I. ABDUL-RASHEEDFor Appellant

 

AND

No Representative for the Respondents.For Respondent