LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

IRENE A. ADEBAJO VS L.A. ADEBAJO-1973

IRENE A. ADEBAJO VS L.A. ADEBAJO

(1973) LCN/1742(SC)

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Wednesday, April 18, 1973


Case Number: SC. 8/1972

 

RATIO 

WILL: CONDITIONS FOR A VALID WILL

“We think that, considering the circumstances of the making of this will as well as its detailed provisions for all his relations in addition to members of his own immediate family, the will was that of a fair-minded man solicitous of their welfare and anxious about their future happiness; See Powell v. Streatham Manor Nursing Home [1935] A.C. 243, at p. 255. Walter Loeb v. Solomon Nasser (1937) 3 W.A.C.A. 227, at p. 228 and Kojo II v. Bonsie and Anor. (1953) 14 W.A.C.A. 242, at p. 243. We also think that just as the contents of the will reveal a clear and coherent mind, so do the cogent pieces of evidence of Mr.Osijo and Mr. Omirin show the due execution of the will on June 25, 1969. The learned Chief Justice took great care to define quite clearly where the onus of proof lies in a probate action of this kind and apply the well-known principles to the present case.” Per ELIAS, C.J.N.

JUSTICES

ELIAS, CHIEF JUSTICE, NIGERIA

FATAYI-WILLIAMS, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

IRIKEFE, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

 

 

APPELLANTS

IRENE A. ADEBAJO

 

 

BETWEEN

 

RESPONDENTS

L.A. ADEBAJO LUKE

ADEPEJU ADEBAJO

OBAFEMI YANTUGA

ADEOLA ADEBAJO

5. OLABISI ADEBAJO (For herself and on behalf of her Children Adekunle Adebajo and Adenrele Adebajo)

ADUNNI ADEBAJO (For herself and on behalf of her Children Adetilewa Adebajo, Adekeye Adebajo and Adefemi Adebajo)

ALFRED ADEBAJO ADEYEMI BADEJO CHRISTOPHER ADELAJA

 

 

 

This is an appeal against the judgment of Taylor, C.J., in Suit No. LD/22/70 delivered in the Lagos High Court on November 12, 1971 in which he dismissed the action of the plaintiff and pronounced in favour of the will of Israel A. O. Adebajo (deceased) dated January 21, 1969 and made and executed on June 25, 1969 by the said deceased. On January 13, 1970, the plaintiff issued a writ against the first three defendants in these terms;

“1. The plaintiff is the widow and one of the persons entitled to share in the estate of Israel Adebayo Ogunyeade Adebajo (deceased) who died on the 25th day of July, 1969 in the event of an intestacy and to have as such a grant of letters of administration of the estate of the said intestate.

2. This writ is issued against you as the executors named in a pretended will of the said deceased dated the 21st day of January, 1969 against which the plaintiff asks the court to pronounce in this action.

3. The plaintiff accordingly claims a declaration that Israel Adebayo Ogunyeade Adebajo died intestate.”

 

 

 

On February 25, 1970 a Statement of Claim was filed while on March 12, 1970 the Statement of Defence was also filed. On April 10, 1970 and on the plaintiff’s application the court granted an order joining the 4th to the 8th defendants. The 6th and the 7th defendants are the deceased’s brother and sister respectively of the full blood while the 8th defendant is a cousin and a beneficiary under the will. It was agreed by both sides at the commencement of the hearing that the question whether or not the plaintiff was married to the deceased was not in issue in the present suit. Because of the importance of the issue and of the nature of the order made in the judgment, we think it convenient to set out here the portion of the judgment appealed from dealing with the settlement of the issue agreed to be tried between the parties:

“When hearing commenced on the 16th September, 1971 both learned counsel agreed to settle issues and Chief Williams for the plaintiff is recorded as saying that:-

‘The main issue is validity of the Will and out of this will arise matters arising in paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 of the amended statement of claim.’  Mr. Kehinde Sofola, leading counsel for the defendants is also recorded as saying that:- ‘I want to be included the ‘interest’ issue raised in paragraph 1 of the 2nd amended statement of claim.’  It was finally agreed and settled and recorded as follows:-

‘It is agreed that the issue as to whether the plaintiff was or was not married to the deceased is not in issue in this action and that the issues are those set out by Chief F.R.A. Williams above.” The plaintiff called only one witness apart from herself, and the defendants, eleven. She gave evidence as to the health, appearance and general activities of the deceased, and her only witness was Dr. Ekpo Edet Eyo, a medical specialist who treated and looked after the deceased almost until his death. Among the eleven defence witnesses were the 6th defendant who claimed to be the deceased’s third and last wife, Dr. A.O. Laja (a medical pathologist who had from time to time carried out blood and urine tests on the deceased at the request of Dr. Eyo), one Mr. James Omirin who was one of the deceased’s employees and who was one of the attesting witnesses, and a Mr. Adeyanju Osijo, the solicitor who prepared the disputed will.  The trial lasted several days. The first question was to decide the date of the will. The plaintiff complained that, although the will was expressed to have been made on January 21, 1969, it could not have been so made because on that day, Yakubu Gowon Street which was referred to in the will had not yet been so renamed from the Broad Street as it was known up to and beyond that date. On the evidence of both the plaintiff and of Mr. Osijo, the learned Chief Justice said as follows: “On the evidence as a whole, i.e., on the evidence of Mrs. Irene Adebajo and Mr. Osijo there is no doubt at all that the day 21st January had some particular fascination for the deceased. I accept the evidence of Mr. Osijo that the Will was in fact made not on the 21st day of January, 1969, but on the 25th June, 1969 and executed on that day.” He thereupon held: “It is then settled that if I accept the evidence of Mr. Osijo as to the date of the execution, the fact that it differs from the date of the Will is of no consequence. I repeat that I do accept without reservation the evidence that this Will was executed on the 25th day of June, 1969 for in addition to the evidence already quoted as deposed to Mr. Osijo he went further to say that:-

 

‘The date I inserted on the Will was done on 25th June, 1969’.” The next question considered by the learned Chief Justice was that of the onus of proof. In this connection we note that paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 of the Amended Statement of Claim read as follows:

“4. At the time when the alleged Will was executed the testator did not know and approve of its contents.

5. The nature of the case on which the plaintiff intends to rely is as follows:

(i) That the deceased has not been in very good health and has from time to time had professional medical consultations locally since January, 1965.

(ii) That the deceased went to the United Kingdom on at least two occasions between 1965 and 1968 and consulted with other medical practitioners and specialists.

(iii) That the condition of the deceased’s health progressively deteriorated especially from April, 1969 and in June, 1969, he was advised to proceed to the United Kingdom for more highly specialised attention.

(iv) That the bodily illness which affected the deceased in the last few months of his illness was such as to impair his mental ability and concentration. (v) In view of

(iv) above, he could have been unable to give detailed and sensible instructions of the nature required for the dispositions contained in the alleged will or to understand and approve its contents.

(vi) Whoever procured the signature of the deceased must have or ought to have been fully aware of the facts pleaded in sub-paragraphs (i), (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) or at least of the facts pleaded in sub-paragraphs (iv) and (v) hereof.

(vii) The date shown as the date of the alleged Will was put there in order to set up a false representation that the deceased executed the Will at a date when the state of his health had not deteriorated to what it was around the time when it was in fact executed.

6. The deceased at the time when the said alleged will purports to have been executed was not of sound mind, memory and understanding.

 

 

Particulars:

(i) At the time the deceased executed the said alleged Will he was suffering from – (a) Hepatic failure; (b) Gastro-Intestinal Bleeding; (c) Cirrhosis of Liver; and (d) Diabetes Mellitus.

(ii) The plaintiffs repeat paragraphs (i) – (vii) of t