LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

HAIGHTONS (W.A.) LIMITED V. ADEROGBA AJAO & ORS(1975)

HAIGHTONS (W.A.) LIMITED V. ADEROGBA AJAO & ORS

In The Supreme Court of Nigeria

On Monday, the 6th day of January, 1975

SC.58/1974

RATIO

WHAT A PERSON RELYING ON WAIVER MUST PROVE 

.……..the authorities on this are clear that the person relying on waiver must prove that the other party well knew of the existence of the misfeasance and despite this knowledge unequivocably accepts future rents. PER COKER, JSC.

JUSTICES

GEORGE BAPTIST AYODOLA COKER    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

GEORGE SODEINDE SOWEMIMO    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

DANIEL O. IBEKWE    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

Between

 

HAIGHTONS (W.A.) LIMITED  Appellant(s)

AND

ADEROGBA AJAO & ORS  Respondent(s)

B. A. COKER, J.S.C. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): The plaintiffs’ action in this case had succeeded on the ground that the defendants in breach of their contract made structural alterations or additions to the property without the consent of the landlords and that they did not maintain the premises in good and tenantable condition and repair.These lapses were matters for the eye, and both parties and the court went to the  premises and the learned trial Judge accepted the evidence given of these matters. No argument of any substance has been urged on us to disparage the findings on these issues, which depend not only on his acceptance of the evidence given before him but also on the use he had made of his own eyes on the visit to the locus.

Some attempts were made by learned counsel for the appellants to rely on waiver, but the authorities on this are clear that the person relying on waiver must prove that the other party well knew of the existence of the misfeasance and despite this knowledge unequivocably accepts future rents.

These points dispose of all the argument canvased before us on appeal. The appeal fails and it is dismissed. The appellants will pay to the respondents the costs of the appeal fixed at N100.00.

 

Appearances

  1. O. Ojosipe For Appellant

 

AND

Chief F.R. A. Williams For Respondent