EZE OGIDI ONWUNEME & ORS v. DR. A. K. AMAH
(2018)LCN/11711(CA)
In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
On Thursday, the 14th day of June, 2018
CA/OW/80/2014
RATIO
DUTY OF A CLAIMANT IN A LAND CASE
The law is trite, that a Claimant in a land dispute (and in every declaratory reliefs) has the duty and legal burden to establish his claims, and on the strength of his own case, not on the weakness of the defendant’s case per ITA GEORGE MBABA, J.C.A.
JUSTICES
RAPHAEL CHIKWE AGBO Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
AYOBODE OLUJIMI LOKULO-SODIPE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
ITA GEORGE MBABA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
Between
- EZE OGIDI ONWUNEME
2. MR. OZIOMA ONWUNEME
3. MRS. CECILIA ONWUNEME Appellant(s)
AND
- A. K. AMAH Respondent(s)
ITA GEORGE MBABA, J.C.A.(Delivering the Leading Judgment):
Appellants filed this Appeal against the decision of the Abia State High Court in Suit No. HU/122/2010, delivered on 19/2/2013 by Hon. Justice A.U. Kalu, wherein the Learned Trial Judge gave judgment to the Claimant (now Respondent).
The Claim at the Lower Court was for:
(a) A declaration that the Claimant is entitled to the Statutory right of Occupancy of the piece or parcel of land traditionally known as and called Mgbegwu Ukwugyara being and situate at Umuana Ndume Ibeku, Umuahia North LGA of Abia State, within the jurisdiction of the Court.
(b) N1,000,000.00 (One Million Naira), being general damages for trespass on the said land by the Defendants.
(c) Injunction permanently restraining the Defendants, their privies, servants, agents and or workers from entering into the land in dispute and or in any manner whatsoever interfering with the Claimants enjoyment of the said land.
At the end of the pleadings, and consideration of the evidence and addresses of Counsel the trial Court held:In the present case, to appreciate and understand the terms of the contract between the Claimant and the defendants regarding the Mgbegwu land, we can only try to read and understand the contents and terms of the Exhibit B. I have diligently read the same and it is abundantly clear and leaves no room for doubt that the defendants sold their entire interest in Mgbegwu land, subject of this Suit to the Claimant. It is a lie that the defendants pushed forth, that they sold only one plot of 50 feet by 100 feet of their Mgbegwu land to the claimant. The Exhibit B is clear that the defendants sold their entire land holding represented in the Survey Plan No. MG2/ABS022/2009 of 11/3/09 attached to the Exhibit B to the Claimant and that was what the Claimant got the (sic) bargain and duly paid for. The 2nd Defendant, whom I will describe as a sufficiently honest man, was clear when he told the Court that it was the 1st Defendant who brought the Exhibit B to him and the 2nd Defendant testified that on the occasion the 1st Defendant told him that the Exhibit B represented the entire agreement the Defendants had with the claimant regarding the Mgbegwu land dispute. Based on any position above, I proceed to enter judgment for the Claimant. (Page 126 of the Records).
Dissatisfied with the above decision Appellants (who were Defendants at the Lower Court) filed their Notice of Appeal on 2/5/2013 (pages 127 to 131 of the Records), disclosing 4 grounds of Appeal. They filed a brief of Argument on 28/4/2017 and distilled three (3) Issues for the determination of this Appeal, namely:
(1) Whether Exhibit B, the power of Attorney, made in 2009, when juxtaposed with Exhibits E and F, is genuine and valid title documents, to warrant a declaration of title to the land in dispute. (Ground 2).
(2) Whether the Learned Trial Judge, in giving judgment for the Claimant/Respondent, based on Exhibit B erred in his conclusion and the application of the law to the facts, as it concerns the title document of the Claimant/Respondent. (Ground 3).
(3) Whether the Claimant/Respondent proved his case for declaration of title to the land in dispute, damages for trespass and injunction on the preponderance of evidence or discharge (sic) his burden of proof (Grounds 1 and 4) The Respondent filed his brief on 25/5/17 and adopted the Issues distilled by the Appellants for the determination of the Appeal.
Arguing the appeal, on 18/4/18, Counsel for Appellants, Chief Augustine Ndife, who settled the brief, on Issue one, said that although production of document of title to land is one of the five (5) ways of proving title to land, yet a Claimant who based his claim to title upon such document, has a duty to establish the validity and genuine of the document. He argued that the Exhibit B, upon which the trial Court based its decision, was not valid or genuiness; that it contained three contradictory or inconsistent dates of execution. Counsel also said that the Exhibit B did not carry illiterate jurat, in view of the fact that the 3rd Donor, thumb printed the document. Counsel relied on the case of Michael Ojibah Vs Ubaka Ojibah (1991) 6 SCNJ 156 at 165; Francis Anaeze Vs Ude Anyaso (1993) 5 SCNJ 151 at 178.
Counsel argued that Exhibit B, therefore, had no forensic and evidential value; that no right can be hoisted upon it. He relied on Elias Vs Suleimon & Ors (1973) 1 ALL NLR (Pt.11) 282 at 295; Ojibah Vs Ojibah (supra).
Counsel added that the Survey Plan, attached to Exhibit B, was made on 11/3/2009, whereas the Exhibit B was signed on 6/10/2006! That, he said, questioned the genuiness of the Exhibit B. He also argued that the identity of the land was in issue as the parties disputed the area or size of the land on the Survey Plan; he said that the mere production of Survey Plan was not enough evidence to establish the identity of the land in dispute. He relied onEzeudu Vs Obiagwu (1986) 3 SC 1 at 27,30; Omoregie & Ors Vs Idugienwanye & Ors (1985) 2 NWLR (Pt.5) 41 at 60; Atolagbe Vs Shorun (1985) 1 NWLR (Pt.2) 360 at 365,367.
On Issue 2, Counsel said it was wrong to grant a declaration of title to land, when the certainty of the area in dispute was not clear, or was in doubt. He relied on Okosun Vs Jonny (1972) 10 SC 53; Fabunmi Vs Agbe (1985) 3 SC 28 at 94; Ezeudu Vs Obiagwu (1986) 3 SC 1. He added that the Claimant must rely on the strength of his own case, not on the weakness of the defence; that the trial Court had a duty to pronounce on the validity of the Exhibit B, and relied on Olaloye Vs Balogun (1990) 5 NWLR (Pt.148) 24 at 34; that the Court failed to do so, ignoring the complaint that the document was tampered with, by adding the measurement and Survey Plan, without their (Appellants) consent, authority or approval; that the trial Court did not also consider the contradictions or inconsistencies in the dates in Exhibit B and the effect of lack of illiterate protection jurat for the 3rd Donor.
Counsel relied on the Exhibit E tendered by the DW1, which showed that the receipt issued by Appellants to the Respondent on the sale of the land was for the sum of N590,000.00 paid by two installments, and it was in respect of a 50ft by 100ft plot; he said that the Appellants retained a copy of Exhibit B, when they signed it (before the tampering and registration of the same); he relied on a similar document, tendered as Exhibit F, by the DW1; he said that the alleged price of the land in the Exhibit B was N700,000.00; and said that the Respondent never denied or challenged the Exhibits E and F; thus Exhibit B, had serious issues of credibility, in the face of Exhibits E and F.
Counsel asserted that the trial Court erred, when it relied on the Exhibit B to give judgment to the Respondent, and urged us to interfere with that conclusion, and review the decision. He relied on Nwaga Vs Registered Trustees, Recreation Club (2004) ALL FWLR (Pt.190) 1360; Fari Vs Fed. Mortgage Finance Ltd (2004) ALL FWLR (Pt.235) 27.
On Issue 3, whether Respondent proved his case on the preponderance of evidence, and/or discharged the burden of proof laid on him by law, Counsel answered in the negative. He stated, again, that the identity of the land was not proved; that the trial Court failed to appraise and evaluate, properly, the evidence of CW1, CW2, and the evidence of the Defendants on the measurement of the land sold to the Respondent. He adopted the earlier submissions that Exhibit B was tampered with and was invalid. He urged us to resolve the issues for Appellants and to allow the appeal.
Responding, Counsel for the Respondent, H.A. Nwokocha Esq, who settled the brief, on Issue one, said that Appellants had agreed that there was land transaction between them and the Respondent, and that they all endorsed the Exhibit B (Power of Attorney) for the transfer of the land in Exhibit B. Thus, Counsel said, the argument of Appellants, challenging the validity and genuiness of the Exhibit B, cannot therefore arise; that the argument could have been considered, if Appellants had denied endorsement of the document, or said that the signatures on the document were not theirs. He referred us to paragraph 7 of the Statement on Oath by the 1st Appellant (on page 36 of the Records), and submitted that Exhibit B was genuine and valid. He relied on the case of Awojolu Vs Odeyemi (2013) 14 WRN 97. Counsel also referred us to the evidence of the 1st Appellant, under cross examination, when he said (on page 91 of the Records):
(I, my brother and my mother signed a Power of Attorney in favour of the Claimant in respect of the land I sold to him. I read the Power of Attorney before I signed it.
Counsel also referred to the evidence of the 3rd Appellant, who said on page 97 of the Records:
I did not partake in the negotiation leading to the sell (sic) of this Mgbekwu land to the Claimant, but I was aware of it. Yes, I signed Exhibit B.
Counsel said the fact that the Defendants/Appellants created, endorsed and signed Exhibit B in favour of the Claimant/Respondent, confirmed the transaction between the parties concerning the Mgbegwu land in dispute was made through the Exhibit B. Thus, the validity and genuiness of the Exhibit B was not in doubt. He added that facts admitted need no further proof, and relied on the case of Ayoke Vs Bello (1992) 10 NWLR (Pt.218) 380; Adike Vs Obiareri (2002) 4 NWLR (Pt.758) 537; Ogbenevu Vs FRN (2013) 11 WRN 94.
Counsel added that Exhibit B was admitted, without objection and so, Appellants cannot come to object to it, on appeal, being bound by it. He relied on Union Bank (Nig.) Plc Vs Alhaji Idrisu (1999) 7 NWLR (Pt.609) 121.
Counsel also said that Exhibit B did not say that only one plot of the land was sold. Rather that it explained and referred to Mgbegwu land and not part of it, and so it refers to the entire land! On the issue of different dates on the document, Counsel said this cannot affect its validity, since the Appellants had admitted the document and raised no complaint about it at the trial. He relied, again, on Union Bank (Nig.) Plc Vs Alhaji Idrisu (supra), and said that there was no doubt that the transaction took place on 6/4/2006, the date the payment was made for the sale. He relied on Patrick Ottih Vs Gregory Nwanekwe (1990) 3 NWLR (Pt.140) 553; Allas Nig. Ltd Vs Steve Rhods (1961) 1 NWLR 348.
On the allegation of failure to endorse illiterate jurat to protect the 3rd Appellant who thumb printed on the process, Counsel said there was no evidence that the 3rd Appellant was an illiterate, because he thumb printed the document; he said that such evidence is not presumed, but proved with concrete facts. Counsel relied on Chief Lawson Agbara Vs Aloysius Amara (1995) 7 NWLR (Pt.410); Igbum Vs Nyarinya (2007) 9 WRN 15; Anaeze Vs Anyaso (1993) 5 SCNJ 151. Counsel further argued that Appellants cannot, in law, raise objection and challenge against a document (Exhibit B), which they, themselves, made, and that the Illiterate Protection Law does not apply to a document prepared by a legal Practitioner, as Exhibit B, was prepared by a legal Practitioner. He relied on Union Bank (Nig.) Plc Vs Alhaji Idrisu (1999) 7 NWLR (Pt.609) 121.
On the conflict between Exhibits B, E and F on the size of the land sold, Counsel said the Appellants had admitted selling other lands of theirs to the Respondent; that DW3 said under cross examination:
Yes, we sold our land at Okpulauwa and at Mgbegwu land to the Claimant; we sold our entire land at Okpulauwu to the Claimant.
Counsel said Exhibit F was the agreements (Power of Attorney) in respect of the Okpulauwu land, and that means they also sold the entire Mgbegwu land, and the same did not say that only part of Mgbegwu was sold. Counsel admitted that Exhibits B and F were on the same land; that Exhibit F was the copy of the unfilled document given to him (DW3) by the Claimant/Respondent! Counsel referred to the evidence of 1st Appellant on page 90 of the Records, who said, under cross examination:
I am saying that the document is not the one I issued because of difference in price stated. I state that the signature, certainty is my signature.
On the incorporation of particulars of Survey Plan, made in 2009, into a Power of Attorney, made in 2006, and using same to register the land, Counsel said that was not evidence of fraud, as the same was explained by the Claimant and his Surveyor (CW3) on page 15 of the Records. He urged us to resolve this in his favour.
On the 2, whether the trial Court, in giving judgment based on Exhibit B, erred in his conclusions and application of the law to the facts, as it concerned the title document of the Respondent, Counsel answered in the affirmative. He said that Exhibit B was clear, that Appellant sold the entire land as shown on the attached Survey Plan to the Respondent. He referred us to page 128 of the Records of Appeal and said that the case of Okon Vs Jonny (1972) 10 SC 28; OLALOYE Vs BALOGUN (1990) 5 NWLR (Pt.148) did not apply to this case. Counsel claimed that Appellants were trying to deceive the Court, when they said they sold only part of the land (Mgbegwu land) as indicated in the receipt (Exhibit E) to the Respondent. He argued that the boundaries of the land they claimed to have sold, as per Exhibit D, did not tally with boundaries described by the 1st Appellant on page 35 of the Records. Counsel denied the allegation of tampering with the original copy of Exhibit B by the Respondent, to bring about the registered Exhibit B; he said that the 1st Appellant had admitted reading the document, before he signed it!
On the Issue 3, whether the Respondent proved his case, on the preponderance of evidence or discharged the burden of proof, Counsel answered in the affirmative. He said the six boundary neighbors were mentioned, as contained in the Survey Plan and in the pleadings, were mentioned by the Respondents witnesses; he said that the trial Court accepted the principles on the evaluation of the case and explained how it arrived at its conclusion, and in accordance with the law. He relied on Akintola Vs Balogun (2000) NWLR (Pt.642) 532.
Counsel asserted, again, that:
The Power of Attorney (Exhibit B) did not contain anything to suggest that it was only one plot of land that was sold, rather the Power of Attorney referred to Mgbegwu land. If it were one plot of land, the Power of Attorney could have said so, as there is no such description on it; issue of one plot cannot be implied or read into it. As we cannot read into the document what was not. See paragraph 10.8 (page 22) of the Respondents brief.
He urged us to affirm the decision of the trial Court and dismiss the Appeal.
RESOLUTION OF THE ISSUES
I think the three (3) Issues distilled by the Appellants for the determination of the appeal appear to relate to the same cardinal issue, namely:
Whether the Exhibit B, relied upon by the trial Court to give judgment to the Respondent, was valid and genuine, to warrant such decision, awarding title to him in respect of the entire Mgbegwu land, as per the Survey Plan No. MG2/ABS022/2009 of 11/3/2009, attached to the Exhibit B.
I shall therefore consider this appeal on the Issue summarized, above.
The facts of this case, as disclosed in the Records of Appeal, show that the Appellants and the Respondent had some land transactions, namely, sale of their (Appellants) land called Okpula Uwa at Umuana Ndume, Ibeku and another Mgbegwu at Mgbegwu, Ndume Ibeku, all in Umuahia North Local Government Area of Abia State. Appellants, in respect of the 2nd sale, disposed of the said land at Mgbegwu, by way of donation of Power of Attorney in favour of the Respondent, prepared by Respondents Lawyer, Kingsley O. Kalu Esq of Kalu G. Agabi & Associates. Legal Practitioners, No. 1 Edet Eyo Cresent, Calabar, Cross River State of Nigeria.
The said Power of Attorney (Exhibit B) was allegedly prepared on 6th April 2006, but the alleged date of execution was stated as — day of October, 2006; and the Donors, signed the document on different dates! While the 1st Donor (Mr. Eze Ogidi Onwuneme) signed the Power of Attorney on 6/10/2006, the 2nd Donor (Mr. Obioma Onwuneme) signed it on 6/4/2006 and the 3rd (Mrs. Cecilia Onwuneme) thumb printed, on it without stating the date. They had two witnesses (Mr. Okeke O. Peter and Mr. Obeuto Solomon) who endorsed the witness columns.
There is evidence that some blank spaces were left (and underlined) for the Survey Plan number and particulars, to be filled, as well as for the measurement (size) of the land donated (or sold) by the Appellants. The said blank spaces were later filled, many years, after the signing of the document, as follows:
Survey beacon No. SC/ABF3130, SC/ABF3131, SC/ABF3132, SC/ABF3133, SC/ABF3134, SC/ABF3135 and SC/ABF3136. Measuring 4984,923, Sq Meters, respectively.
Particularly shown and delineated and verged red in Plan No. MGZ/ABS022/2009 (Fund lack (sic) delayed Survey). And prepared by SURV. D.C.N. CHUKWU, No. 62 School Rd. Umuahia. (The underling showing the blank spaces that were filed) (See pages 19 of the Records).
The said Survey Plan, made on 11/3/2009, was attached to Exhibit B, and the whole document registered at the Lands Registry, Umuahia as 34/34/45.
There is also Exhibit E, (on page 50 of the Records) a hand written document, titled:
RECEIPT ON SALE OF LAND,
made on 6/10/2006 by the 1st Appellant for the family, saying:
I, Eze Ogidi Onwuneme, my Jur. brother and my mother, hereby acknowledge the receipt of the sum of five hundred and ninety thousand naira from Dr. A.K. Amah, being payment for the plot (one) of land which we sold to him at Mgbegwu Umuana Ndume. He made the first payment of (N300,000) thousand; Now has competed the second payment of two hundred and ninety thousand naira. The (sic) is measured (50ft x 100ft) i.e. width fifty feet by hundred feet length. Signed.
Whereas, Appellants asserted that they sold one plot of land (50ft x 100ft), and that the Exhibit B was tampered with, by the filling of the particulars of the Survey Plan by the Respondent (claiming the entire land was donated/sold), after Appellants had signed the Power of Attorney (as in Exhibit F) and released it to the Respondent, and that the Respondent also increased the consideration for the sale (from N590,000.00 to N700,000.00) and registered the same as Land Instrument as No. 34/34/45 in his name on 19/1/2010, without their (Appellants) knowledge/consent, the Respondent said there was no tampering with the document and that the Appellants sold the entire Mgbegwu land!
The trial Court elected to believe the Respondent, and held:
In the bid to prove that they sold only a plot measuring 50feet by 100feet to the Claimant, at the cost of N590,000.00, the defendants have tendered the Exhibit E, which is a photocopy of the document titled Receipt of sale of land Exhibit E seemed to have been written by the 1st Defendant and suggests what the defendants have been contending that they sold one plot of land measuring 50feet by 100feet at Mgbegwu land to the Claimant. The Exhibit E can at best be described as a worthless piece of paper, the Claimant did not sign it. It seems to me to be a piece of paper deliberately crafted by the 1st Defendant in a bid to drew red herring over the eyes of the Court by creating a completely different state of affairs. My position on the Exhibit E is because we have seen the Exhibit B tendered by the Claimant. The Exhibit B is titled Power of Attorney is granted by Mr. Eze Ogidi Onwuneme to Dr. Akuma Amah. The land subject matter of the Exhibit B is described as the defendants Mgbegwu Ukwuayara land situate at Umuana Ndume Ibeku. In the Exhibit B, the Defendants conferred on the Claimant, among other powers, the power to take power possession of the land described in Survey Plan No. MAZ/ABS022/2009. The 1st and 2nd Defendants signed the Exhibit B and the 3rd Defendant thumb printed the Exhibit B on 6/10/06 and 6/4/06, respectively. The Exhibit B was lodged and registered with the Land Registry Umuahia on 19/1/2010. (See page 123 of the Records of Appeal).
I am surprised by those findings and holdings by the learned trial Judge, which, in my view, (and with the greatest respect), appear to turn the law and logic on their heads.
The law is trite, that a Claimant in a land dispute (and in every declaratory reliefs) has the duty and legal burden to establish his claims, and on the strength of his own case, not on the weakness of the defendant’s case. SeeMomoh & Ors Vs Umoru & Ors (2011) LPELR 8130 SC:
In a claim for declaration of title to land, the onus is on the Plaintiff to establish his claim upon the strength of his own case and not upon the weakness of the Defendant. The Plaintiff must satisfy the Court that, upon the pleading and evidence adduced by him he is entitled to the declaration sought. Gbadamosi Vs Dairo (2007) 3 NWLR (Pt.1021) 282; Dada Vs Dosunmu (2006) 18 NWLR (Pt.1010) 134; Onisaodu Vs Elewuju (2006) 13 NWLR (Pt.998) 628; Faleye & Ors Vs Dada & Ors (2016) LPELR 40297 SC.
It appears the learned trial Court misplaced the burden of proof in this case, when it held that Exhibit E, which the respondents produced, to show that the land they sold or donated to the Respondent on 6/10/06, for the sum of N590,000.00 (Five Hundred and Ninety Thousand Naira) at Mgbegwu, Umuahia Ndume, was measured 50feet by 100feet, was worthless, because it was not signed by the Respondent; and that it appeared to have been crafted by the 1st Appellant in a bid to draw red herrings over the eyes of the Court, by creating a completely different state of affairs. I have not seen any evidence by the Respondent to suggest that conclusion. Exhibit E was admitted without objection by the Respondent, same having been pleaded. The original copy of E was with Respondent, and he never denied the same! See pages 35, 36, 90 and 91 of the Records.
The duty to establish that Appellants sold or donated the entire land called Mgbegwu to him (Respondent) at the said transaction, for the sum of N700,000.00, was that of the Respondent who filed the Suit. Appellants had asserted that they sold/donated one plot of their said land at Mgbegwu (not the entire Mgbegwu) to Respondent and that they signed a document (Exhibit B, without the later fillings, which claimed the whole land for N700,000.00!) Appellants had pleaded that the Respondent tempered with the document they, innocently, signed (with blank spaces) for the Respondent, and had led evidence to establish what, in my opinion, amounted to fraudulent distortion of the said document (Exhibit B) by the Respondent, turning the one plot of land sold at Mgbegwu to the entire Mgbegwu land! The evidence of the Surveyor (CW3) shows the Respondent was the one who showed the entire land of the Appellants measuring 4,984.923 square meters to be surveyed, without the Appellants consent and presence! See pages 87 and 88 of the Records. He said:
The claimant did not tell me the number of plots I was going to survey I was not there when the parties transacted over the land. The Claimant was present when I planted the beacons. Exhibit B represents the measurement I took.
I find it quite strange that Exhibit B, produced by the Respondent and said to have been prepared on 6/4/2006, carried different dates, 6/10/2006 (as the dates of signing (execution) by the 1st Appellant) and 6/4/06 (as the date by the 2nd Appellant); and in the document, the Respondent filled, in long-hand writing, the particulars of Respondents Survey Plan, prepared for him on 11/3/2009, wherein he claimed 4,984.923 Square Meters of Appellants land, as what was sold/donated to him. It is unthinkable, that the said Survey Plan, made on 11/3/2009, could become part of the land transaction, delineated and sold on 6/4/2006 (or 6/10/06) It is stranger, that same was used to register the land in favour of the Respondent, at the Lands Registry. That, in my view, could only be done, deceitfully and fraudulently!
Testifying as CW2, the Respondent said, under Cross examination:
The Survey was not done 4 years after the purchase and the defendants were present and showed the Surveyor the extent of land, I purchased from him. The first Defendant did not sell only one plot of land to me, but the defendants sold all the area of land in dispute to me. My lawyer prepared the power of Attorney and I brought it to the Defendants who signed same. It is incorrect to say that the particulars, and measurement of the land were not included in the power of Attorney, tendered as Exhibit B, before it was signed by the Defendants. The measurement of the land was written in, because I needed to inquire and be sure of the boundary neighbors There was no arbitration over this dispute. The intended arbitrators demanded that I offer them a bribe so I declined and immediately said so to them in writing. When the arbitration commenced and I saw that the arbitrators mutilated my evidence to them, I decided not to participate any more in it. I am not aware of any decision by the panel See pages 82 to 83 of the Records of Appeal.
I think the Respondent is a horrible, dangerous liar and land grabber. The CW3 (Surveyor) did not say Appellants were present, when he surveyed the land. It is sad that a lot of times litigants think that the Court is a place where lies are hawked, and so people, without conscience, play it as game, aided by corrupt and/or unprincipled Counsel, expecting their wishful tales to escape the sharp lenses/scrutiny of the Court!
How can the Respondent claim that the Appellants showed the Surveyor the boundaries of the land, surveyed about 4 years, after the alleged sale, that the said Survey Plan dated 11/3/2009, was done as part of the land sale of 6/4/2006 or (6/10/2006) (Exhibit B), before the Appellants signed it in 2006 That is a very unintelligent lie!
The Respondent also claimed there was no concluded arbitration report on the dispute over the land; that he decided not to participate or continue with the arbitration, when he discovered the Arbitration Panel mutilated his evidence and/or demanded a bribe from him!
Pages 51 to 66 of the Records of Appeal carry the full Arbitration proceedings and report of the Umuana Ndume Ibeku, between the parties in this case, and pages 51 to 53 carry Respondents testimony at the Arbitration, where he said (among other things):
Later, Eze Ogidi and Ozioma settled the price with me I paid the first installment of N500,000.00. Later I paid the 2nd installment of N200,000, bringing the total to N700,00 (sic) all of us signed the agreements, handed over the money to Ozioma to give to his mother, the mother prayed over the money. We entertained ourselves that day Eze Ogidi came to me again that they have another land at Lodu Ukwuayara Mgbegwu Umuana. I asked Mama Cecilia Ogidi to go and show me the land and we went to the land. The land was divided into three parts Eze Ogidi said he wants to sell the middle land and the last land. I told him that the middle land is small, we agreed that I will buy the middle and the last because the assembly Church has delayed him. At the last I paid Eze Ogidi N440,000.00. Eze Ogidi came to me again to come and buy the first land and we agreed for the first land N150,000 and I paid him N150,000, making total of N590,000. Obiuto Solomon was there, Peter Okeke was there and they went round the land. We prayed over the money. (See pages 51 and 52)
Of course the above evidence of the Respondent at the Arbitration shows some consistency and agreement with the evidence of the Appellants in respect of the 1st sale of their Okpula Uwa Land to Respondent for N700,000.00 (Exhibit F) and the 2nd sale of Exhibit E, of one plot of land for N590,000.00, which, in my opinion, the Respondent later doctored, as Exhibit B, to accommodate the entire land of the Appellants, at the Mgbegwu!
The findings of the Arbitration, as per pages 64 and 65 were as follows:
Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah failed to collect receipt for the middle plot and the last plots of the land, therefore, this evidence did not support that Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah bought the entire portion of land, but made it known to the panel that Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah paid him N590,000 for the middle plot without collecting receipt from Eze.
The two witnesses statement by name Mr. Peter Okeke and Pastor Obiuto Solomon whom Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah called, did not prove his claim that he bought the entire portion of land, as he has acknowledged earlier that the entire portions of land was shown to him. After due consideration of the statement from both the Plaintiff and the Defendant and that of the witnesses of these case, we hereby give the following verdict to this case as follows:
(1) That the access roads as shown, given by the defendant/landlord, Mr. Eze Ogidi and acknowledged by plaintiff (Dr. Amah) Stands as access road.
(2) That the panel discovered that there was one transaction involved in the said purchased of land, which goes to buttress the point that there was only one plot of land involved, which the landlord acknowledged, the middle plot, sincerely, there was no receipt shown to the panel backing up the transaction.
(3) The panel therefore finally rules that, the middle plot of land was actually sold by the landlord and purchased by Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah or (the Buyer).
(4) We hereby warn that, on no account should Eze enter that plot of land sold to Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah, and in the same vain, Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah should leave the entire portion of land in the said area for Eze. If Dr. Amah is interested, he should now negotiate with Eze.
(5) Mr. Eze Ogidi did not raise an objection on Dr. Akuma Kalu Amahs statement concerning the N80,000 given to him. After all true cross examinations over the N80,000 given to him for the exchange of land, we therefore ask Eze Ogidi to present his expenses to Dr. Akuma Kalu Amah for reconciliation and that they should still remain as friends.
All these were before the learned trial Judge and yet it elected to believe and place such heavy reliance on the discredited Exhibit B, to say It is abundantly clear and leaves no room for doubt, the Defendants sold their entire interest in Mgbegwu land, subject of this Suit to the Claimant. (Page 128 of the Records).
That was perverse, in my opinion, in the face of the distortions in Exhibit B and admissions by the Respondent, that he paid N590,000.00 on the portion of land sold by the Respondents at Mgbegwu.
The Respondent had argued, strongly, that Exhibit B did not contain anything to suggest it was only one plot of land that was sold, rather that the power of Attorney referred to Mgbegwu land; that if it were one plot of land, the Power of attorney would have said so. In the same way, the Respondent appears to shoot himself in the foot, because that argument would operate much more against him (the Claimant), to the effect that if the said sale was about the entire Mgbegwu land, the Exhibit would have stated so, and the Survey Plan of 2009 would not have been required to be forced into the agreement of 2006, to explain the land size!
As it is, the only authentic evidence of the sale of the portion of Mgbegwu land is the Exhibit E, with which the Appellants, graciously, admitted the sale/donation of one plot of their land measuring 50feet by 100feet to the Respondent. And that portion of land was, according to evidence, clearly identified and marked out with access Road by the Appellants to the Respondent. The Respondent is entitled to only that portion, as stated by Exhibit E, at Mgbegwu Land, Umuana Ibeku.
The Exhibit B, being tainted with fraud, is hereby nullified, together with the attached Survey Plan No. MGZ/ABS022/2009 of 11/3/2009 and their said Registration as 34/34/45 of 19/1/2010, the same having been unlawfully done/obtained. See the case of Ojibah Vs Ojibah (1991) LPELR 2374 SC; (1992) 5 NWLR (Pt.191) 296 on the need for a party to prove due execution of a document he relies on as land instrument, to pass title to him.
Of course, by law, fraud vitiates even the most solemn of all transactions, and so a document or purported land instrument, tainted with fraud, like Exhibit B, in my opinion, cannot transfer interest in land, claimed by it. See Ugo Vs Obiekwe & Anor (1989) LPELR 3319 (SC); 1989) 1 NWLR (Pt.999) 566.
I therefore find merit in this appeal and resolve the issues for the Appellants. The Exhibit B, having been plagued by Vice, was vitiated and is hereby nullified. The decision of the Lower Court in HU/122/2010 is hereby set aside, and the Respondents Suit, claiming the entire land of the Appellants called Mgbegwu at Umuana, Ibeku, Umuahia North L.G.A of Abia State, is hereby dismissed.
Appellants are entitled to the cost of this Appeal, assessed at N100,000.00 (One Hundred Thousand Naira), against the Respondent.
RAPHAEL CHIKWE AGBO, J.C.A.: I agree.
AYOBODE OLUJIMI LOKULO-SODIPE, J.C.A.: I agree.
Appearances
CHIEF AUGUSTINE NDIFE For Appellant
AND
H.A. NWOKOCHA ESQ For Respondent



