LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

CHIEF S.A. DADA & ORS. V. OTUNBA ADENIRAN OGUNSANYA & ANOR.(1992)

CHIEF S.A. DADA & ORS. V. OTUNBA ADENIRAN OGUNSANYA & ANOR.

In The Supreme Court of Nigeria

On Friday, the 10th day of April, 1992

SC.287/1990

RATIO

ACTION – LOCUS STANDI: THE MEANING AND EFFECT OF NOT HAVING LOCUS STANDI 

“It is settled law that locus standi is the legal capacity to institute an action in a Court of law- Thomas v. Olufosoye (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt.18) 669, and if a person had no legal standing to institute an action, the Court will have no jurisdiction to entertain his claims – See Madukolu v. Nkemdi!im (1962) 1 All N.L.R. 587 at 595, (1962) 2 SCNLR 341.” PER KAWU, JSC

ACTION- CAUSE OF ACTION: RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS WHEN CONSIDERING THE ISSUES OF DISCLOSURE OF A CAUSE OF ACTION

“It should however be pointed out that when considering the issues of disclosure of a cause of action, it is irrelevant to consider the weakness of the plaintiffs’ claims as the learned trial judge would appear to have done in this case. What is important is to examine the averments in the pleadings and see if they disclose some cause of action or raise some questions fit to be decided by a judge. See Thomas v. Olufosoye (supra).” PER KAWU, JSC

APPEAL- ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION: WHAT IS REQUIRED OF A PARTY WHO IS RELYING ON THE SAME ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION IN THE SUPREME COURT AS RELIED UPON IN THE LOWER COURT 

“… if a party is relying on the same issues for determination in this Court, as he relied upon in the court below, such issues must be set out in full in its brief filed in this Court.” PER OMO JSC

ACTION-PLEADINGS: EFFECT OF FAILURE OF A PARTY TO LED EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF THE AVERMENTS IN THEIR PLEADINGS 

“The rules made thereunder and any rules of court are designed to guide the conduct of cases to eliminate surprises and to ensure quick dispensation of justice. Where pleading has been filed, a party resorting to Order 22 must ensure that the pleading discloses no reasonable cause of action. Pleading is not like the game of hide and seek. It gives due notice of the case each party proposes to present to the court and short of admission of some paragraphs of the pleading or facts pleaded each party must lead evidence in support of the facts. Paragraphs 26, 27, 29, 30, 13, show reasonable cause of action. If at the trial no evidence is led, or no credible evidence in support of these averments, then the case may fail. As to when the court is obliged to strike out a statement of claim which discloses no cause of action. See: IBRAHIM v. OSIM (1988) N.S.C.C. (Vol 19 Pt. 1) 1184; (1988) 3 NWLR (Pt.82) 257 ADIMORA v. AJUFO (1988) N.S.C.C. (Vol 19 Pt.1) 1005 (1988) 3 NWLR (Pt.80) 1.”PER OLATAWURA

 

 

JUSTICES

SAIDU KAWU    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

SALIHU MODIBBO ALFA BELGORE    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

ABUBAKAR BASHIR WALI    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

OLAJIDE OLATAWURA    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

UCHE OMO    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

Between

 

  1. CHIEF S.A. DADA
    2. CHIEF I. O. AJAYI
  2. RT. REV. OLUWOLE AJEDITI (ACTING PRIMATE AFRICAN CHURCH
    4. CHIEF S.A. AYOKO (CONFERENCE SECRETARY AFRICAN CHURCH) Appellant(s)

AND

  1. OTUNBA ADENIRAN OGUNSANYA (NOMINATED LAY PRESIDENT AFRICAN CHURCH
  2. OTUNBA J. OLUNFUNMIWA AWOPEJU (VICE LAY PRESIDENT AFRICAN CHURCH) Respondent(s)

KAWU, J.S.C. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): This is an appeal against the judgment of the Court Of Appeal, Lagos Division, delivered on the 5th day of June, 1990, allowing the appeal from the ruling of Adeyinka, J dated 15th April, 1988 striking out the claim of the plaintiffs in the High Court for disclosing no cause of action. As stated in paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the plaintiffs’ Amended Statement of Claim, at all the times material to this case, both the plaintiffs and the defendants were members of the African Church.
The claims of the plaintiffs in the High Court, who are respondents herein, as contained in paragraph 62 of the Amended Statement of claim are as follows:-
“1. A declaration that the time-honoured convention of appointing Lay President of the African Church from the Lagos Division namely any African Church member who is ordinarily resident in Lagos Division which accommodates the Headquarters of the African Church and of Vice Lay President rotationally from Divisions outside the Lagos Division ought to operate in this Election year of 1987 and ought not now to be disturbed having regard to the fact that the Vice Lay President for the period of 1987-1992 has this year been appointed from outside Lagos Division, to wit from Ijebu Division.
2. A declaration that until this time-honoured convention of appointment of Lay President and Vice Lay president has been changed or otherwise altered by a motion passed at the Annual convention of the African Church no individual or group of individuals can alter the position:
3. A declaration that the nomination of Chief Adeniran Ogunsaya of the African Church Cathedral (Bethel) Lagos in the Lagos Division of the African Church for the office of Lay president on 9th May, 1987, at the 86th Session of the Conference of the African Church held at Ijesha was valid, proper, conventionally constitutional, wherefore any other nomination from any Division of the African Church outside Lagos is invalid, irregular, null and void and of no legal effect being in flagrant violation of the convention of the African Church since or about the year 1982.
4. A declaration that the 1st Defendant is estopped from competing with the 1st Plaintiff or otherwise contesting against him for the office of the Lay President of the African Church in the year 1978 having in writing by letter dated 12th August, 1986, indicated to the African Church and the 1st Plaintiff as Chancellor, inter alia, that he had after a long deliberation finally and irrevocably decided not to stand for the said post of Lay President in 1978.
5. Consequentially, an order that Chief Adeniran Ogunsanya be declared the only candidate validly nominated as candidate for the office of Lay President, wherefore he be deemed to have been appointed unopposed as Lay President of the African Church with effect from 9th May, 1987, when Otunba J, Olu Awopeju was by convention of the African Church appointed Vice Lay President of the African Church and when 1st Defendant ceased to hold office both as Vice Lay President and Acting Lay president of the African Church.
6. An injunction to restrain the 2nd Defendant his servants and/or agents from taking order from 1st Defendant to damnify or impede the administration of the African Church and/or otherwise acting in concert with the 1st Defendant or independently to block or freeze the Account of the African Church with the First Bank of Nigeria Ltd., at Odunlami Street, Lagos, or in any other place wheresoever.
7. An injunction to restrain the Defendants their servants collaborators and/or agents from holding any meeting of the Conference of the African Church either as planned by them for 28th August, 1987, or for any other date at all pending the determination of the action herein.
8. An order that pending the determination of the action herein the 2nd Plaintiff as Vice Lay President of the African Church be at liberty to function, act as and perform the office of the Lay President of the African Church.
9. N250,000.00 general damages against the Defendants jointly and severally for falsely parading themselves as Acting Lay President and General Treasurer respectively, whereby the 1st and 2nd Defendants successfully blocked or froze the Account of the African Church at First Bank at Odunlami Street, Lagos, and thus prevented the African Church from paying the wages and emoluments of their staff and pensioners, namely the Primate, retired Bishops and other Clergy and workers of the African Church generally and also for inhibiting 2nd plaintiff from functioning as a duly and unanimously elected Vice Lay president of African Church. ”
The defendants, who are appellants herein, entered a conditional appearance after the commencement of the action and subsequently filed a motion dated 30th November, 1987 praying for the following reliefs:-
“(a) An order pursuant to Order 22 of the High Court of Lagos (civil Procedure) Rules and Order18, Rule 19 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1965, striking out the plaintiffs endorsement on the writ of summons, and the statement of claim, and dismissing the action on the ground that it is frivolous, vexatious and it discloses no reasonable cause of action.
(b) For such further and/or other orders as this Honourable Court may deem fit to make in all the circumstances.”
The ground for the application was that
“Even if all the averments in the Statement of Claims are proved, they do not support the Claim.”
After hearing submissions of counsel on the motion, the learned trial judge, on the 15th April, 1986 delivered his ruling, striking out the plaintiffs’ claims, holding, in the concluding part of the ruling as follows:-
“Whatever may be the convention the plaintiffs have not established in their Amended Statement of Claim that the convention had created a contract among the members of the African Church and that it was a term of the contract that the convention can only be changed or altered by a motion. There is also no authority for the relief sought that the convention can only be changed or altered by a motion, not by conduct, acts or omissions. Conventions are by their nature susceptible to change even by time.
The declaration of estoppel by the 1st defendant’s letter of 12th August, 1986 is also not justiciable. The Plaintiffs did not plead the consideration they had given for the 1st defendant’s letter which prevented him from changing his mind. It may well be unconscionable, immoral or even unchristianly of the 1st defendant to change his mind to contest the office of the Lay President in 1987, having decided in 1986 in the names of Christ not to do so but the Court is not concerned with morality or christianity but under Sec. 6(6) (b) 1979 Constitution, with the adjudicating for the determination of any question as to the civil rights and obligations of persons. If nine out of the eleven divisions of the African Church ganged up to change the convention, that shows an intention to change or alter the convention.
If the convention is not justiciable in a Court of law, the Court cannot restrain the defendants from changing it. The Plaintiffs’ action based on convention, estoppel by letter morality and Christianity is not enforceable in Court of law. The Plaintiffs’ action therefore discloses (sic) no reasonable cause of action.”
He thereafter advised the parties “to go back to the African Church to settle their disputes amicably in the name of Jesus Christ.”
Being dissatisfied with the Ruling of the learned trial judge, the plaintiffs appealed to the Court of Appeal, Lagos judicial Division, which Court, as previously staled, allowed the appeal on 5th day of June, 1990 and set aside the ruling of the trial Court. This appeal is from that decision. With the Notice of Appeal, the appellants have filed three grounds of appeal and arising from those grounds of appeal, the following issues were formulated for determination:-
“(i) Whether the issue of locus standi could be raised for determination at the time and in the manner in which the Defendant did at the trial court.
(ii) Whether the Plaintiffs’ locus standi is an issue relevant to the determination of a Motion under Order 22 of the Lagos High Court Rules.
(iii) Whether the plaintiffs’ pleadings disclosed a reasonable cause of action.”
Now, the provisions of Order 22 of the High Court of Lagos (Civil procedure) Rules, 1972 arc as follows:-
“Proceedings [n Lieu of Demurrer
1. No demurrer shall be allowed.
2. Any party shall be entitled to raise by his pleading any point of law and, unless the Court or a judge in Chambers otherwise orders, any point so raised shall be disposed of by the judge who tries the cause at or after the trial.
3. If, in the opinion of the Court or a judge in Chambers, the decision of such point of law substantially disposes of the whole action, or of any distinct cause of action, ground of defence, set-off, counterclaim. or reply therein, the Court or Judge may thereupon dismiss the action or make such other order therein as may be just.
4. The Court or a judge in Chambers may order any pleading to be struck out, on the ground that it discloses no reasonable  cause of action or answer, and in any such case or in case of the action of defence being shown by the pleadings to be frivolous or vexatious, the Court or a judge in Chambers may order the action to be stayed or dismissed, or judgment to be entered accordingly, as may be just.
5. No action or proceeding shall be open to objection, on the ground that a merely declaratory judgment or order is sought thereby, and the Court may make binding declarations of right whether any consequential reliet is or could be claimed, or not.”
It is settled law that locus standi is the legal capacity to institute an action in a Court of law- Thomas v. Olufosoye (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt.18) 669, and if a person had no legal standing to institute an action, the Court will have no jurisdiction to entertain his claims – See Madukolu v. Nkemdi!im (1962) 1 All N.L.R. 587 at 595, (1962) 2 SCNLR 341. The main question raised in issues I and 2 for determination in this appeal is whether the issue of locus standi, which is admittedly an issue of law, can properly be raised under Ord.22, Rule 4 of the High Court of Lagos (Civil Procedure) Rules, 1972 (supra). I think the Court of Appeal, in its judgment fully dealt with matter and, in my view, correctly construed the provisions ofthe Rules when in its judgment is stated as follows:-
“The question here is whether locus standi can be raised in a motion under Order 22 Rule 4, as appears to have been done in this case. Although the Appellant was said to have been heard in reply, was the issue of locus standi really before the trial judge on a motion under Order 22 Rule4 I do not think so. Order 22 had five limbs.
The first abolished demurrer, the second and third provide for points of law to be raised by pleadings and disposed of by the judge, if successful. Under Rules 2 and 3 therefore, an issue of locus standi or jurisdiction, may be so raised and disposed of. They cannot however, be so raised under Rules 4, which deals with the striking out of a claim and pleadings where no reasonable cause of action or answer is disclosed. or where the action is shown to be frivolous or vexatious. In other words, the issue of locus standi being a point of law to be disposed of before trial, was not before the trial judge.”
As to whether the plaintiffs’ pleadings disclose a reasonable cause of action, having carefully perused their Amended Statement of Claim, I have no doubt at all that they did. It should however be pointed out that when considering the issues of disclosure of a cause of action, it is irrelevant to consider the weakness of the plaintiffs’ claims as the learned trial judge would appear to have done in this case. What is important is to examine the averments in the pleadings and see if they disclose some cause of action or raise some questions fit to be decided by a judge. See Thomas v. Olufosoye (supra). I am in complete agreement with the Court of Appeal that the learned trial judge was in error when he held that the plaintiffs’ claim disclosed no cause of action. I see no substance in this appeal. The appeal fails and it is accordingly dismissed. The judgment of the Court of Appeal setting aside the Ruling of Adeyinka, J., delivered on 15th April, 1986 is hereby affirmed with N1000.00 costs awarded to the respondents.

S. M. A. BELGORE, J.S.C.: I have read in advance the judgment of my learned brother. Kawu J.S.C. and I agree that this appeal has no merit. For the reasons advanced by him, which I adopt as mine, I also dismiss this appeal with N1000.00 costs to the respondent.

A. B. WALI, J.S.C.: I have had the advantage of reading in advance, a copy of the lead judgment of my learned brother Kawu, JSC. I entirely agree with the reasoning and conclusions arrived at by my learned brother, Kawu J.S.C.
I wish only to add the following by way of contribution on the issue of “cause of action”.
On the issue as to whether the plaintiff/respondents have disclosed a reasonable cause of action, the amended Statement of Claim is replete with facts to that effect. See particularly paragraph 26, 27 and 29 of the amended Statement of Claim which provide thus –
“26.   1st Defendant in spite of the fact that he has ceased to hold office as Vice Lay President and Acting     Lay President since 9th May, 1987, persisted and still, falsely and wrongfully persists to parade himself as Acting Lay President of the African Church.
27     1st Defendant and 2nd Defendant under the false assumption of the offices of Acting Lay President     and General Treasurer respectively freezed and embargoed the General Fund Accounts current Account 01019925 by letter dated 11th May. 1987 addressed to the Manager, First Bank of Nigeria Ltd., Odunlami Street, Lagos.
28. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
29. By the action of the 1st and 2nd Defendants complained of the primate, the pensioners and staff of the     African Church could not be paid their wages and emoluments whereby great hardships were caused to Sundry persons.”
These facts in my view sufficiently reveal a reasonable cause of action. See NASIRU BELLO v. ATTORNEY-GENERAL, OYO STATE (1986) 12 SC 1 (1986) 5 NWLR (Pt.45) 828 FAWEHINMI v. AKILU (1987) 4 N.W.LR. (Pt.67) 797 and JACKSON v. SPITTAL (1970) L.R. 5 C.P. 542. On this issue, I entirely agree with Court of Appeal wherein it said in its judgment –
“As to whether or not a reasonable cause of action is disclosed, Obaseki, JSC, stated as follows in Chief Dr.    Irene Thomas & Ors. v. The Most Rev. Olufosoye (1986) 2 S.C 325 at 344 (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt.18) 669:-
‘So long as the statement of claim or the particulars disclose some cause of action or raise some question fit     to be decided by a judge or jury, the mere fact that the case is weak and not likely to succeed is no ground for striking it out (Moore v. Lawson, 91 T.L.T 418, C.A.; Wenlock v. Moloney (1965) 1 W.LR 1238; (1965) 2 All E.R. 871 C.A). Where the statement of claim discloses no cause of action and if the court is satisfied that no amendment, however ingenious, will cure the defect, the statement of claim will be struck out and the claim dismissed. Where no question as to the civil rights and obligations of the plaintiff is raised in the statement of claim for determination, the statement of claim will be struck out and the action dismissed.’
What the learned judge appeared to have done in the instant appeal is to go into the question of whether or     not the claim of the plaintiff would succeed, as it appeared to be weak.”
XXX XX XXXXX XXXX XXXXXX XXX X XXX XX
“If the learned judge were dealing with only the writ of summons, he may well have been correct in the     position he took. But there was also before him a Statement of Claim and an Amended Statement of Claim,which also called for scrutiny by him. There are 61 paragraphs in the Statement of Claim, as amended, some of which are neither based on convention, estoppel by letter, morality nor christianity. In paragraph 54, the amended statement of claim stated as follows:-
‘Plaintiffs say that neither the 3rd defendant nor the 4th defendant nor any other person so ever apart from the general committee has any right to convene a meeting of the conference of the African Church pursuant to Section V1(a) of her constitution.’
This was followed by paragraph 55, to wit:-
The 3rd defendant in defiance of the aforesaid Section V1(a) of the African Church (Constitution) has     wrongfully arrogated to himself the power to convey a conference and has in the process by pass the General Secretary of the African Church who is the Secretary to the General committee, and without consulting the 2nd plaintiff at all as Vice Lay President of African Church’ .
According to paragraph 1,2,3,4, of the amended Statement of Claim, both the Plaintiff and the Defendants are members of the African Church. This fact is not denied. One of the reliefs sought by the Plaintiffs (i.e the 7th) is for:-
‘An injunction to restrain the defendants, their servants, collaborators and/or agents from holding any        meeting of the conference of the African Church either as planned by them for 28/8/87 or for any other day at all, pending the determination of the action herein ..
Thus, a careful examination of the amended statement of claim, deemed admitted only for the purpose of     determining the issue of non-disclosure of a cause of action, shows from the paragraphs quoted above, a cause of action,”
It is for these and the fuller reasons contained in the lead judgment of my learned brother, Kawu, JSC that I also hereby dismiss the appeal. The judgment of the Court of Appeal is hereby confirmed. I endorse the order contained in the said judgment that the present appellants who were the respondents in that court are to file their Statement of Defence within 30 days from the date of this judgment if they have not already done so as ordered by the Court of Appeal. Thereafter, the trial will resume before another judge of Lagos State judicial Division. N1,000.00 costs is awarded to the plaintiff/respondents against the defendants/appellants.

O. OLATAWURA, J.S.C.: I had a preview of the judgment of my learned brother Kawu J.S C. just delivered. I agree that the appeal should be dismissed and the consequential order for a trial before another judge of the High Court of Lagos State should stand. I also abide by the order for costs.
The application made under Order 22 of the High Court of Lagos (Civil Procedure) Rules 1972 has already been set out in the lead judgment of my learned brother Kawu, J.S.C. The rules made thereunder and any rules of court are designed to guide the conduct of cases to eliminate surprises and to ensure quick dispensation of justice. Where pleading has been filed, a party resorting to Order 22 must ensure that the pleading discloses no reasonable cause of action. Pleading is not like the game of hide and seek. It gives due notice of the case each party proposes to present to the court. and short of admission of some paragraphs of the pleading or facts pleaded. each party must lead evidence in support of the facts. Paragraphs 26, 27M 29, 30, 13, show reasonable cause of action. If at the trial no evidence is led, or no credible evidence in support of these averments, then the case may fail. As to when the court is obliged to strike out a statement of claim which discloses no cause of action see: IBRAHIM v. OSIM (1988) N.S.C.C. (Vol 19 Pt. 1) 1184. (1988) 3 NWLR (Pt.82) 257 ADIMORA v. AJUFO (1988) N.S.C.C. (Vol 19 Pt.l) 1005 (1988) 3 NWLR (Pt.80) 1.
It is for this reason and for the fuller reasons contained in the lead judgment of my learned brother, Kawu J.S.C., that I will dismiss the appeal. The order of the lower court to the effect that the Respondents should file their Statement of Defence within 30 days is hereby affirmed.

U. OMO, J.S.C.: I have had preview of the lead judgment of my learned brother, KAWU, J.S.C. just delivered, and I agree with him that this appeal should be dismissed. I propose however to make a few comments of my own.
The respondents, (as plaintiffs) sued the appellant (as defendants) in the High Court of Lagos claiming under nine (9) heads consisting of four declarations, two other orders, two injunctions and N25,000.00 as general damages. The details of these claims are fully set out in the lead judgment and will not be repeated here.
The respondents have brought this action to establish the validity of the appointment of the 2nd respondent as the Lay Vice- president, and the nomination of the 1st respondent as the Lay president of the African Church of Nigeria, at its Conference in 1987. It also seeks to challenge the nomination of the 1st appellant as Lay President of the same Church at the same Conference in competition with the 1st respondent, and his subsequent usurpation of the office of Lay President without a valid appointment to that post.
The respondents (as plaintiffs) filed their pleading (amended statement of claim), whilst the appellants without filing any pleading moved the High Court pursuant to Order 22 Rule 4 of the High Court of Lagos (Civil Procedure) Rules 1972 praying for
“(a) An order………..striking out the plaintiffs endorsement on the writ of summons, and the statement of     claim, and dismissing the action on the ground that it is frivolous, vexatious, and it discloses no reasonable     cause of action.
(b) For such further and/or other orders as this Honourable Court may deem fit to make in all the     circumstances”
The ground for this application, as stated, is that even if all the averments in the statement of claim are proved, they do not support the claim. The issue of locus standi was not adverted to on the face of the application, which was not supported by any affidavit.
After hearing counsel for the parties, the learned High Court judge, agreed with the appellants and struck out the action of the respondents on the ground that (a) it does not disclose a cause of action and (b) the respondents have no locus standi to institute the action filed.
Aggrieved by this decision, the respondents appealed to the Court of Appeal.
In the Court, the main issues canvassed on which its decision turned were:
(a) Whether the procedure under Order 22 Rule 4 of the Lagos High Court Civil procedure Rules 1972 is     appropriate for a consideration of the issue of locus standi
(b) Whether that issue was properly raised for consideration by the defendants (present appellants) in the     trial court In any event, were all the claims adversely affected by the plea of locus standi; and
(c) In the event, were all claims adversely affected by the plea of locus standi; and
(d) Whether the writ of summons/amended statement of claim disclosed no cause of action.
The Court of Appeal answered the first three questions in the negative and fourth in the affirmative. Having so found the Court of Appeal set aside the ruling/judgment of the High Court and remitted the action to the High Court of Lagos for trial by another judge.
The appellants are dissatisfied with this judgment and have appealed against same to this Court raising three issues for determination:-
“(i) Whether the issue of locus standi could be raised for determination at the time and in the manner in     which the Defendant did at the trial court.
(ii) Whether the Plaintiffs’ locus standi is an issue relevant to the determination of a Motion under Order 22     of the Lagos High Court Rules.
(iii) Whether the plaintiffs’ pleadings disclosed a reasonable cause of action.”
The respondents in their brief purported to rely on the issues for determination set out by them in the brief they filed in the Court of Appeal without setting same out in their brief in this Court. Such practice is certainly not acceptable in purported compliance with the rules governing the contents and filing of brief in this Court, if a party is relying on the same issues for determination in this Court, as he relied upon in the court below, such issues must be set out in full in its brief filed in this Court. Luckily the respondents have advanced arguments in their brief on the issues raised by the appellants.
On the date to which hearing of this appeal was adjourned in this Court, the respondents, who are both lawyers and who had been physically present when the appeal was adjourned, were neither present nor represented by counsel. Since this appeal had been granted accelerated hearing, appellants’ counsel’s brief oral submissions were heard, and the case of the respondents has beef) considered on the basis of the briefs filed by them pursuant to the provisions of order 6 Rule 8 of  the Rules of this Court. Appellants’ counsel mainly relied upon the appellants’ brief filed by him, inviting this Court to answer the three issues set out in it for determination in the affirmative for the first two, and negative for the third. Counsel also drew attention to the fact that the grounds of appeal filed by him do not cover the issue whether there was reasonable cause of action before the High Court, but only deal with the issue of locus standi. The three grounds of appeal filed confirms this, and are set out (without their particulars) in the notice of appeal dated 4/9/90 as follows:-
(1) The Learned Court of Appeal erred in law when it held that the issue of Locus Standi could not be raised     at the trial Court, during the hearing and determination of a Motion under Order 24 rule 4 of the Lagos High Court Rules.
(2) The learned Court of Appeal erred in law when it held that the question of Locus Standi could not be     raised in a Motion under Order 22 rule 4.
(3) The Learned Court of Appeal erred in law in its decision that it was not proper for the High Court to have     entertained and determined the issue of Locus Sandi at the time and in the manner it did.”
Since counsel is relying solely therefore on the issue of locus standi it is necessary to consider whether that issue was properly before the High Court.
Order 22, Rule 4 which is relied on in support of the application of the appellants’ under consideration provides as follows:-
“Proceedings In Lieu of Demurrer
1. No demurrer shall be allowed.
2. Any party shall be entitled to raised by his pleading any point of law and, unless the Court or a judge in     Chambers otherwise orders, any point so raised shall be disposed of by the judge who tries the cause at or after the trial.
3. If, in the opinion of tile Court or a judge in Chambers, the decision of such point of law substantially     disposes of the whole action, or of any distinct cause of action, ground of defence, set-off, counterclaim, or     reply therein, the Court or judge may thereupon dismiss the action or make such other order therein as may be just.
4. The Court or a judge in Chambers may order any pleading to be struck out, on the ground that it discloses no reasonable cause of action or answer, and in any such case or in case of the action of defence being shown by the pleadings to be frivolous or vexatious, the Court or a judge in Chambers may order the action to be stayed or dismissed, or judgment to be entered accordingly, as may be just.
5. No action or proceeding shall be open to objection, on the ground that a merely declaratory judgment or     order is sought thereby, and the Court may make binding declarations of right whether any consequential relief is or could be claimed, or not.”
Although the appellants set out three issues for determination, they appear to have argued the first two issues together in their brief, the difference if any between the issues therefore being blurreds Both issues have been dealt with’ together in the Court of Appeal and in the lead judgment, and I completely agree with my learned brother KAWU, J.S.C. that the Court of Appeal correctly construed the provisions of Order 22 (supra) when it held, in the following words which can bear repetition that:-
“The question here is whether locus standi can be raised in a motion under Order 22 Rule 4, as appears to     have been done in this case. Although the Appellant was said to have been heard in reply, was the issue of locus standi really before the trial judge on a motion under Order 22 Rule 4 I do not think so. Order 22 has five limbs. The first abolished demurrer, the second and third provide for points of law to be raised by pleadings and disposed of by the judge, if successful. Under Rules 2 and 3 therefore, an issue of locus standi or jurisdiction, may be so raised and disposed of. They cannot however, be so raised under Rule 4, which deals with the striking out of a claim and pleadings where no reasonable cause of action or answer is disclosed, or where the action is shown to be frivolous or vexatious. In other words, the issue of locus standi, being a point of law to be disposed of before trial, was not before the trial judge.”
All that the trial judge is required to do under Rule 4 is to ascertain if the pleading discloses no reasonable cause of action and/or that it is shown to be frivolous and vexatious. If it has any or both these defects, the action may then be dismissed (or stayed). The issue of locus standi was obviously not before him under Rule 4, and it was therefore wrong of him to have considered it thereunder. It is also no answer for the appellants to contend that the respondents are to be deemed to have waived any objection to wrong procedure under Order 22 Rule 4 because they argued the issue of locus standi. Locus Standi is a threshold issue, the absence of which terminates the action since the court is thereby bereft of jurisdiction vide Madukolu v. Nkemdilim (1962) 1 All N.L.R. 587 (595) (1962) 2 SCNLR 341. It therefore behoves a party raising it not to do so under a completely wrong procedure, even though it can be raised at any stage of the proceeding.
Having regard to the view which I have taken, to wit, that the issue of locus standi was not properly before the High Court, the appellants having come under Rule 4 of Order 22 (supra), it will be improper for me to proceed to consider all the submissions of appellants’ counsel, which are mainly predicated on that issue. This is not because I cannot express firm views therein, but because it is still a “live” issue which can still be canvassed in further hearing between the parties. Any view expressed by me therefore is likely to be prejudicial to a proper and independent adjudication thereon by the trial High Court. This is enough to dismiss this appeal.
On the third issue, on which there was no appeal, it is sufficient to say that the decision of the court below therein is correct. The High Court having held that the action is neither frivolous nor vexatious, the application under Order 22 Rule 4 must fail. The court below was therefore very right to have set aside the ruling of the High Court, and made the consequential order for a retrial before another judge. This appeal therefore fails and it is hereby dismissed. The judgment of the court below is hereby affirmed. I also award N10,000 costs to the respondents.
Appeal dismissed.

 

Appearances

S.B. Candide – Johnson, Esq. (with him, N.C. Nwabuko, S.T. Ohia and K.O.K Agbowa) For Appellant

 

AND

Respondent absent and unrepresented For Respondent