CHIEF LAITO AJAGBE VS OYEGADE AKANNI
(1973) LCN/1675(SC)
In the Supreme Court of Nigeria
Friday, November 23, 1973
Case Number: SC. 278/1973
RATIO
PLAINTIFF MUST REPLY ON THE STRENGTH OF HIS CASE
The plaintiff in this case must rely on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the defendants case. If this onus is not discharged, the weakness of the defendants case will not help him and the proper judgment is for the defendant, he not having sought the declaration- per ELIAS, CJN
JUSTICES:
ELIAS, CHIEF JUSTICE, NIGERIA
SOWEMIMO, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT
IRIKEFE, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT
APPELLANTS
CHIEF LAITO AJAGBE
RESPONDENTS
OYEGADE AKANNI
ELIAS, CJN. (Delivering the judgement of the Court)
This appeal against the judgment of the Western State Court of Appeal in Suit No. CAW/19/71 delivered on January 26th, 1973, originated from the judgment of the Oshun North-West Grade “B” Customary Court, Ogbomosho, in which the plaintiff claimed against the defendant for (i) “declaration of title to the piece or parcel of land lying, situate and being at Elewede, Alagodo and Kesa Idewure village, Ogbomosho, (ii) an order granting possession of the said ……… land to the plaintiff, (iii) injunction to restrain the defendant, his servant or agents from further trespass on the said piece of land.”
The President of the court found for the plaintiff and the defendant, being dissatisfied with that judgment, appealed to the High Court, Oyo, in which in Suit No. HOY/9A/69 Ogunlami, J., dismissed the defendant’s appeal in his judgment delivered on April 9th, 1970. Against that decision, the defendant appealed to the Western State Court of Appeal. Briefly stated, the facts of the case are as follows. The plaintiff claimed that the land in dispute consisting of Elewede, Alagbado and Kesa in Idewure village of which his father Ola was the first head who is usually given the official name of Onidewure. He claimed that his father gave him the land several years before his death, and that there had been four successive Onidewures named Adegbite, Madandola, Gboyega and the defendant. The evidence of his witnesses was that they had been his tenants on the land for many years during which they had been paying him ‘ishakole’ as tribute.
Plaintiff said that the defendant was claiming the land in dispute as stool land, that is, as attaching to the stool of Onidewure, but that the first two Onidewures, Adegbite and Madandola, who reigned immediately in succession after his own father, never challenged his title to the land. He said that the first Onidewure to question his right to the land was Gboyega with whom he unsuccessfully contested the Onidewere stool before Gboyega died. He again unsuccessfully contested for the stool of Onidewure against the defendant. He admitted that both the late Gboyega and the defendant laid claim to the land in dispute as stool land attached to the Onidewure Chieftaincy. The defendant, on the other hand, called evidence in support of his claim that the land in dispute was stool land, and that whoever was the Onidewure for the time being was entitled to enjoy the use of the land by collecting tributes from the tenants of the land. He called witnesses, one of whom testified that he paid tributes to the defendant. He denied that the land ever belonged to the plaintiff as his private property. When the High Court dismissed the defendant’s appeal from the Customary Court, he appealed to the Western State Court of Appeal on the following nine grounds: “1. The learned trial President erred in law in giving judgment to the plaintiff ‘as per writ’ when the evidence of plaintiff disclosed he was not suing Onidewure family and the learned Judge on appeal erred in law in upholding that judgment. 2. The learned trial President erred in law in giving plaintiff judgment ‘as per writ’ when the plaintiff’s evidence disclosed that the defendant had not disturbed his possession 3. The learned Judge on appeal erred in law in holding that S. 209 of the Evidence Act cannot be used for the purpose of evidence without complying with S. 208 of the Evidence Act. PAGE| 3 4. The learned Judge on appeal misdirected himself on the evidence when he held that: ‘Some of the boundary-men were called’ whereas no boundary-man was called by either party. 5.
The learned Judge misdirected himself on the record when he held: (i) ‘The learned President gave reasons for his disbelieving the evidence of the appellant and his witnesses and showed why he believed the evidence of the respondent and his witnesses.’ Whereas no reasons were given by the learned President for believing the evidence of the plaintiff and his witnesses. (ii) ‘In arguing the omnibus ground, the learned counsel for the appellant contended that Oyetunde Akanji and Ogunkunle Aremu were not sworn before they gave evidence. It is plain from the record that their names appear during the inspection and the learned President did not rely on their evidence in arriving at his decision.’ Whereas the learned President not only referred to them as constituting part of his judgment but said he believed them. 6. The learned Judge, having rejected the traditional evidence of the plaintiff, erred in law in giving judgment to plaintiff for declaration of title based upon acts of user when the judge could not ascertain upon which evidence (traditional evidence or acts of user) the trial President based his belief of plaintiff and his witnesses. 7. The learned Judge misdirected himself on the evidence when he held: (i) ‘There is evidence that he was and he is still receiving Ishakole from some of his tenants.’ Whereas two of the three tenants called by the plaintiff gave evidence that they have not paid Ishakole for a long time and (ii) ‘His tenants gave evidence in his favour.’ Whereas one of the tenants called by the plaintiff gave evidence that he was paying Ishakole to the defendant. 8. The learned Judge, having held that Exhibit ‘A’ was not properly tendered, though it had been admitted in evidence by the trial president, erred in law in not ordering a retrial rather than confirming the learned President’s decision. PAGE| 4 9. The judgment is against the weight of evidence.” That court allowed the appeal only to the extent that the plaintiff’s claim for recovery of possession was struck out, his claim for declaration of title to Elewede, Alagodo and Kesa land as well as his prayer for the grant of an order of injunction being dismissed. Against this decision of the Western State Court of Appeal, the defendant/appellant brought this appeal on the following five grounds: “1. The learned Judges of the Western State Court of Appeal erred in law by merely considering the written grounds of appeal filed instead of the submissions urged in support of the particular grounds argued. 2. The learned Judges of the Western State Court of Appeal misdirected themselves in law and in fact when they held that the respondent’s writ of summons does not show the appellant as representing Onidewure family thereby confirming the judgment ‘as per writ’ whereas the writ of summons in truth and in fact defined the capacity in which the appellant was sued. 3. The learned judges of the Western State Court of Appeal erred in law and on the facts by holding that ‘the President reviewed the evidence before him and held that he believed the plaintiff which he was entitled to do’ when there was neither a proper or serious review of the evidence nor identification of the issues joined by the parties. 4. The learned judges of the Western State Court of Appeal misdirected themselves in law and on the facts when they held that ‘the learned Judge from the printed evidence was of the view that the traditional evidence was confusing but that the evidence of acts of ownership was sufficient on which the President COULD give judgment in favour of the plaintiff’- whereas the President made no findings on any acts of ownership and the plaintiff’s claim should have been dismissed. 5. The decision is against the weight of evidence.” Mr. Omisade learned counsel for the defendant/appellant (hereinafter called appellant) asked and was granted leave to argue the five grounds seriatim. His main contention against ground 1 is that the Western State Court of Appeal did not consider the particular grounds which he had argued before it, and that the language employed by the court would seem to amount only to the making of a series of what the various grounds of appeal amounted to without any attempt at a resume and evaluation of the arguments. PAGE| 5 He submitted that the judgment merely stated in precis form what the grounds of appeal were in a mechanical sort of way; for example, the judgment included a mention of ground 8 which, according to p. 74, 1.8 of the record, he, learned counsel, never argued at all before the court.
Again, the court observed in its judgment that the defendant was not sued in his representative capacity as Onidewure, whereas it had recorded the following in its notes of evidence: “Fatoki: Concedes that the action was instituted against the defendant in a representative capacity. From the evidence led, the plaintiff was suing the Onidewure in his official capacity. Therefore action must be regarded as representative action.” It was learned counsel’s contention that the record of the Western State Court of Appeal contradicted their finding in this respect. With regard to ground 2, Mr. Omisade argued that, in addition to his contention that the appellant was sued in a representative capacity, he would point out that the respondent in this appeal now argued that he was not suing the appellant in a representative capacity, and yet he maintained, and it was so held by the Western State Court of Appeal, that he, the respondent, was only suing as ‘per the writ of summons.’ Learned counsel further pointed out that even the High Court found that the record of proceedings in the Customary Court Grade ‘B’ were not properly got up, and that there were many mistakes therein. Learned counsel submitted that it was wrong of the Customary Court to have given judgment, as it did, “as per the writ of summons” and that the Western State Court of Appeal was equally wrong to have followed suit, he further submitted



