LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

BETTY STEPHEN v. THE STATE (2018)

BETTY STEPHEN v. THE STATE

(2018)LCN/11817(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Monday, the 2nd day of July, 2018

CA/B/52C/2017

 

RATIO

EVIDENCE TO PROVE CHARGE OF MURDER

“It is imperative to refer to the case of ABOKOKUYANRO V. STATE (2011) ALL FWLR (PT. 597) 700 @ 719 – 720 PARAS B – A, where this Court quoted the words of Ogundare JSC in ADEPETU V. STATE (1998) 9 NWLR (PT.565) 185 @ 207 to the effect that ”the charge of murder is proved by circumstantial evidence notwithstanding that neither the body, nor any trace of the body of the deceased had been found, not even when the accused made no confession, he could albeit be convicted.”” PER PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE, J.C.A.

EVIDENCE: CONFESSIONAL STATEMENT

“In this regard, there is no doubt that the Appellant made a confessional statement which was admitted in evidence after a trial within trial, as Exhibit B and B1. The confessional statement of the Appellant alone is enough to secure a conviction, see NWACHUKWU V. STATE (2007) ALL FWLR (PT.390) 1380 @ 1387. A careful appraisal of the confessional statement and evidence of witnesses for the prosecution leaves no doubt that the prosecution really discharged the onus placed on it by law of proving the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.”  PER PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE, J.C.A.

 

 

JUSTICES

PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

BETTY STEPHEN Appellant(s)

AND

THE STATE Respondent(s)

 

PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment):

This appeal is against the judgment of Hon. Justice G.O. Imadegbelo of the High Court of Edo State, sitting at Abudu, in Suit No. HAB/2C/2011, delivered on the 14th Day of July 2016, wherein the lower Court convicted the Appellant and two other persons on a four count charge of conspiracy to commit child stealing, child stealing, conspiracy to commit murder and murder, punishable under Sections 516, 324,371 and 319 (1) of the Criminal Code Cap. 48 Vol.11 of the defunct Bendel State of Nigeria, 1976 now applicable to Edo State.

The brief facts of the case are as follows:

The Appellant who was the 1st accused and two other persons were charged with the offences of conspiracy to commit child stealing, child stealing, conspiracy to commit murder and murder. The prosecution in a bid to prove its case called five witnesses while each of the accused persons testified in his/her defence. The 2nd accused called two other witnesses.

PW1 Rapheal Omoaghe, the appellant’s brother-in-law testified that on his return from farm on the 24th of February 2009, he could not find Ifueko (the missing child) and when his brother’s wife failed to give him a satisfactory answer, he reported to the Odionwere of the community and finally to the police, who gave him 24 hours to look for the missing girl.

He testified further that he also reported the matter to the parents of the Appellant. The eldest sister of the Appellant accompanied him home and questioned the Appellant about the missing child. The Appellant admitted that she was the one that took the child, and that she handed over the child to the 2nd accused. Under cross examination, PW1 stated that Ifueko was not stolen in his presence, and that the Appellant admitted committing the offence before she was taken to the police. The statement of PW1 to the police was admitted as Exhibit A.

PW2 Odumamawen Osayande is a farmer and knows the accused persons, as well as PW1. He testified that on 24th of February, 2009 he was in river Orhionmwon getting water with his son when he heard the sound of a motor cycle; he raised up his head and saw the 2nd and 3rd accused persons. The 3rd accused person waved at him and he waved back.

PW3 is Stephen Omoaghe the husband of the Appellant and father of the missing child. He testified that on 24th of February, 2009 he went to his farm and on his return the Appellant informed him that she had been looking for Ifueko.

PW4 Omini Oyomo, a retired Assistant Superintendent of Police formerly attached to the State CID Benin City. He testified that at about 5-5:30pm on 26th of February 2009, a case file of child stealing was transferred from Ehor Police Division along with the Appellant and 2nd accused persons. The case was sent to his intelligence section for investigation. The Appellant and 2nd accused person were cautioned in English Language and they made confessional statements. The Appellant told the police that if PW4 and his team acted quickly they would find Ifueko the missing girl.

PW4 testified further that on 27th of February 2009, the Appellant in company of the 2nd accused took them to the bush in search of the little girl. That they combed the entire bush but there was no trace of the little girl. Based on the partial confessional statement of the 2nd accused person, PW4 and his team went to the house of the 2nd accused.

According to PW4, on getting there the wife of the 2nd accused pleaded with the 2nd accused person to disclose the where about of the little girl. It was then that the 2nd accused person said they should look for the 3rd accused person, that if they get her the little girl would be found, and that he handed over the child to the 3rd accused person. PW4 then deployed one of his men to the house of the 3rd accused person but it was discovered that she had fled to Benin City.

PW4 continued in his evidence that the mother and a relation of the 3rd accused person came to his office and informed him that the 3rd accused person had earlier lodged a complaint of threat to life at Area Command Ehor against the family of the victim. The mother and relation of the 3rd accused person promised to bring her to the State CID. On 1st of March 2009, the mother of the 3rd accused came with her to the State CID. There the 2nd accused identified the 3rd accused person as the person he handed over the child to. The 3rd accused person was then arrested and cautioned and she volunteered a statement. The statement of the 3rd accused person was admitted as Exhibit D. PW4 concluded that he investigated the complaint of threat to life, as well as the alibi put up by the 3rd accused person but it proved false.

The confessional statements of the accused persons which were obtained through the PW4 were admitted in evidence after a trial within trial as Exhibits B1, B2, C1, C2, C3 and D respectively.

PW5 is Oghogho Ibhakoanu, the mother of Ifueko, the missing child. She testified that she was separated from PW3 which necessitated PW3 living with Ifueko (the missing child). She stated that she lives in Benin City and had not visited the little girl in the past two years before she was informed that the girl was missing.

On their part, the Appellant and her co-accused persons all testified in their defence. The Appellant testified as DW1, the 2nd accused DW2, his witnesses (Monday Ogieva and Friday Agbonare) testified as DW3 and DW4 respectively; while the 3rd accused person testified as DW5. The accused persons and their witnesses essentially denied committing the offences with which they were charged.

At the conclusion of trial, counsel on both sides addressed the Court by adopting their respective addresses. In a considered judgment delivered on 14th day of July, 2016 the trial judge convicted the Appellant and the two other accused persons as charged and sentenced them to 14years imprisonment for child stealing and death for murder.

Dissatisfied with her conviction, the Appellant appealed to this Court via a Notice of Appeal filed on 16th day of August 2016. The Grounds of appeal shorn of its particulars are reproduced is as follows:

GROUND 1
That the decision of the learned trial judge is unwarranted, unreasonable having regard to the evidence led before it.

GROUND 2
That the lower Court erred in law when it convicted the Appellant of the offence of murder when the offence has not been proved beyond reasonable doubt.

GROUND 3
That the lower Court erred in law when it convicted the Appellant of the offence of child stealing when the offence has not been proved beyond reasonable doubt.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION:
In a brief of argument dated and filed on 6th of March 2017, the Appellant distilled a sole issue for the determination of the Appeal, to wit:

Whether, from the totality of evidence led by the Respondent (Prosecution), and the fundamental flaws inherent in this case, the trial Court was justified in holding that the Respondent proved beyond reasonable doubt all the offences charged against the Appellant (Grounds 1, 2 and 3)

On its part, the Respondent, in a brief dated and filed on 7th day of December 2017, identified a sole issue for determination, to wit: whether on the evidence of the prosecution witnesses and the confessional statements of the Appellant and her co-accused the trial Court was right in convicting the Appellant for the offences of conspiracy to commit child stealing, conspiracy to commit murder, child stealing and murder. (grounds 2, 3, 4 and 5).

ARGUMENT:
I have perused the issues for determination raised by both learned counsel and I have decided to determine this appeal on the issue couched as follows:

Whether from the totality of evidence, the trial Court was right to have convicted and sentenced the appellant.

Learned counsel set the tone of argument by re-echoing the settled position of the law that it is for the prosecution to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. Counsel called in aid ONUBOGU V. THE STATE (1974) 9 N.S.C.C. 358, amongst other authorities. Counsel stressed that the burden of displacing the presumption of innocence rests on the prosecution and the burden never shifts; counsel referred to Section 36(5) of the 1999 Constitution (As Amended), Section 135 of the Evidence Act, 2011 and decided cases for this postulation.

Learned counsel also cited WILLIAMS V. THE STATE (1975) 9-11 S.C. 139; ATEJI V. THE STATE (1976) 2 S.C. 79 and submitted that the Court is duty bound to evaluate the whole evidence adduced by the prosecution, and not for the Court to pick and choose which set of prosecution witnesses to believe and which to reject.

Learned counsel posited that there are too many loose ends in the case which ought to have made it unsafe to sustain the conviction and sentence of the Appellant; counsel cited STEPHEN UKORAH V. STATE (1977) 11 N.S.C.C. 218 and a host of other authorities to buttress the point that where doubt exists in the facts of a case in a criminal trial, same should be resolved in favour of the accused person. Learned counsel went ahead to review the testimony of prosecution witnesses. On the testimony of PW1 Counsel stated that there are material contradictions between the statement of PW1 at the police station (Exhibit A) and his testimony in Court.

Counsel submitted that PW1 should have been regarded as unreliable witness and his evidence discarded. On the evidence of PW2 learned counsel stated that his evidence was of no moment, which informed the reason why he was not cross examined. Counsel cited KPOKPO V. UKO (1997) 11 NWLR (PT.527) 94 @ 113 PARAS F-G to the effect that it is not in all instances that cross examination is mandatory. As regards the testimony of PW3, counsel contended that same is vitiated by the fact that the witness did not make any statement at the police station and his statement was not attached to the proof of evidence; counsel cited OHWOVORIOLE V. F.R.N. (2003) 176 @ 189,and GBOKO V. THE STATE (2007) 17 N.W.L.R. (PT.1063) 272 @ 305. That the evidence of the PW5 is hearsay and therefore inadmissible.

Counsel referred to Section 38 of the Evidence Act, 2011 and PHARMACISTS BOARD OF NIGERIA V. ADEGBESOTE (1986) 5 NWLR (PT. 44) 707 @ 708 Ratio 7 for this submission.

Arguing further, learned counsel quoted excerpts from the evidence of PW4 and submitted that the case was not thoroughly investigated. Counsel contended that this creates a serious doubt as per whether the Appellant?s guilt was actually established beyond reasonable doubt. Counsel called in aid AIGBADION V. THE STATE (Supra) and TAMUNO V. C.O.P. (2010) ALL FWLR (PT.538) 921 @ 925-926 RATIO 6.

Learned counsel further opined that the evidence of the Appellant denying commission of the offences for which she was charged was neither challenged nor controverted; counsel cited EZE V. THE STATE (1985) 3 NWLR (PT.13) 429 @ 431 RATIOS 12 & 13, and OFORLETE V. THE STATE (2000)12 NWLR (PT.681) 415 @ 423 RATIO 15 to buttress the point that the Court is bound to accept and act on any unchallenged evidence provided it is not incredible.

Furthermore, counsel posited that the Appellant was tried and convicted based on suspicion by PW1, on what the native doctor told them. Counsel cited OKAFOR V. C.O.P. (1965) NMLR 89 @ 90-91, LINES 53 on the fact that suspicion cannot ground a conviction. Counsel again submitted that the judgment of the Court below is at variance with the evidence led before the Court. As regards Exhibit B1 (the confessional statement of the Appellant), counsel contended that the Court below adopted a wrong procedure during the trial within trial by allowing the Respondent to address the Court first, thereby shifting the burden of proving the voluntariness of the statement on the Appellant.

Counsel submitted that this irregularity vitiated the admissibility of the confessional statement; counsel cited STATE V. OLADELE (1969) 1 NMLR 210; AUTA V. THE STATE (1975) 1 ALL N.L.R. (PT.2) 165 @169 and other authorities on this point. Lastly on this issue, counsel quoted excerpts of per Oputa, JSC (of blessed memory) in UKWUNNENYI V. THE STATE (1989) 4 NWLR (PT.114) 131 @ 156 PARAS C-E and submitted that the Respondent was not able to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt; and urged that the conviction and sentence of the Appellant be set aside.

In response, learned counsel to the Respondent submitted that the prosecution proved the charges against the Appellant beyond reasonable doubt. Citing MUSA V. THE STATE (2012) VOL.10 LRCNCC 255 @ 262 RATIO 11 & SHURUMO V. THE STATE (2012) VOL. 10 LRCNCC 1 @ 9 RATIO 16 counsel submitted that proof beyond reasonable doubt does not mean proof beyond every iota of doubt or proof beyond every shadow of doubt, but proof which conveys a high degree of probability. Counsel submitted that all that is required of a prosecution in a criminal trial in discharging the burden of proof is to establish the ingredients of the offence. That one of the ways of discharging this burden of proof is by the confessional statement of the accused person, counsel called in aid OSENI V. THE STATE (2012) VOL. 208 LRCN 151 @ 158 RATIO 9.

Learned counsel enumerated the ingredients of the offences with which the Appellant was charged, referred to Sections 7 and 8 of the Criminal Code Act and submitted that by the evidence of PW1-5, the confessional statement and attestation form of the Appellant (Exhibits B & B1) it shows that the Appellant not only actively participated in the commission of the offence, but that she also procured others to do so.

Counsel referred to the evidence of PW1 to the effect that the 1st accused confessed before her elder sister that she gave the victim (Ifueko) to the 2nd accused. Counsel posited that this piece of evidence was neither challenged nor contradicted during cross examination, and no evidence was proffered in rebuttal; counsel cited GAJI V. PAYE (2003) 8 NWLR (PT.823) 583 to the effect that failure to cross examine a witness on a particular matter is a tacit acceptance of the truth of the evidence of the witness.

Arguing further, learned counsel relied on Section 27 (1) of the Evidence Act, Cap 112,1990 and UCHENNA NWACHUKWU V. STATE (2002) 12 NWLR (PT.782) 543 and submitted that the principle that govern admission of a confessional statement are whether it is free, voluntary, true, positive and probable. Counsel cited SAMSON EMEKA V. STATE (2001) 14 NWLR (PT.734) 666 and submitted that where an objection is raised on the admission of an extra judicial statement on the ground of involuntariness; the only option open to the Court to test the voluntariness is to conduct trial within trial. Counsel contended that the trial judge thoroughly evaluated the evidence of PW1 and DW1 (during the trial within trial) and arrived at the right finding that Exhibits B and B1 were not only made by the Appellant but that they were voluntary, free, positive and direct. Counsel cited PETER DURUGO V. STATE (1992) NWLR (PT.255) 525.

In a further argument, learned counsel relied on ESSIEN IBOK ESSIEN V. THE STATE (2017) LPELR 42762 (SC) and submitted that an accused person can be convicted solely on his confessional statement and it is not mandatory that there must be cogent and corroborative evidence outside the confessional statement. Counsel stated that the evidence of PW1-5 and exhibits B & B1 sufficiently established the ingredients of the offences with which the Appellant was charged. Counsel cited OGUNNIYI V. THE STATE (2012) VOL. LPELR 8567 to the effect that if the essential ingredients of the offence have been proved by the prosecution, the charge is proved beyond reasonable doubt.

RESOLUTION:
It is imperative to refer to the case of ABOKOKUYANRO V. STATE (2011) ALL FWLR (PT. 597) 700 @ 719 – 720 PARAS B – A, where this Court quoted the words of Ogundare JSC in ADEPETU V. STATE (1998) 9 NWLR (PT.565) 185 @ 207 to the effect that ”the charge of murder is proved by circumstantial evidence notwithstanding that neither the body, nor any trace of the body of the deceased had been found, not even when the accused made no confession, he could albeit be convicted.”

Having said that, the Appellant in her brief has argued extensively that since none of the prosecution witnesses witnessed the Appellant killing the victim (Ifeuko) that their evidence is inadmissible, being hearsay, and raises doubt, which ought to be resolved in favour of the Appellant. With due respect to the learned counsel, that submission flies in the face of the law. As eloquently captured in the above authority, the Court can convict for murder on the basis of circumstantial evidence. Without mincing words, the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, can not by any stretch of the imagination be said to be hearsay. The evidence of the prosecution witnesses are credible and sufficiently pins the Appellant and her co-accused persons as having committed the offences with which they were charged, tried, convicted and sentenced.

It is elementary law that in a criminal trial, all that is required of the prosecution is to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. In ABOKOKUYANRO V. STATE (SUPRA) @ 723 PARAS E-G it was held inter alia thus: proof beyond reasonable doubt does not mean proof beyond all shadow of doubt. If the evidence is strong against a man as to leave only a remote probability in his favour, which can be dismissed with the sentence; ”of course it is possible, but not in the least probable? the case is proved beyond reasonable doubt”.

I have dutifully perused the evidence of PW1-5, and the confessional statement of the Appellant; there is no scintilla of doubt in my mind that the Appellant and her co-accused persons actually committed the offences for which they were tried, convicted and sentenced. In this regard, there is no doubt that the Appellant made a confessional statement which was admitted in evidence after a trial within trial, as Exhibit B and B1. The confessional statement of the Appellant alone is enough to secure a conviction, see NWACHUKWU V. STATE (2007) ALL FWLR (PT.390) 1380 @ 1387. A careful appraisal of the confessional statement and evidence of witnesses for the prosecution leaves no doubt that the prosecution really discharged the onus placed on it by law of proving the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.

The learned counsel to the Appellant has made heavy weather of the admissibility or otherwise of the confessional statement, alleging that the procedure that led to it being admitted is flawed and amounts to breach of fair hearing. As rightly argued by counsel to the Respondent, the Appellant throughout the trial was represented by counsel. There is also no doubt that the said counsel consented to the procedure adopted by the Court. In IBATOR V. BARAKURO (2007) ALL FWLR (PT.371) 1669 @ 1687-1688 PARA C-B it was held inter alia ?Where a party has adopted a procedure by consent, he will not be heard on appeal that the procedure he adopted is prejudicial to him, or had occasioned a miscarriage of justice?. In this wise, the Appellant consented to the procedure adopted by the Court in the trial within trial and in my view, it is too late in the day to object.

Worthy of note also is the fact that there is no appeal on the ruling of the lower Court admitting the confessional statement in evidence. The law is settled that any finding of a trial Court that has not been appealed against or challenged by a ground (s) of appeal is subsisting and valid, see ATUFE V. OGHOMIENOR (2004) ALL FWLR (PT.224) 2061 @ 2076 PARA B. In the instant appeal, I have perused the notice and grounds of appeal, and I have observed that none of the grounds challenges the admissibility of the confessional statement. Having not raised the issue in the grounds of appeal, the Appellant is precluded from canvassing argument on that issue. It follows therefore that the confessional statement was validly admitted in evidence.

Learned counsel for the Appellant has argued vigorously that there are contradictions in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses. I have considered the said pieces of evidence on record. Perhaps what counsel is referring to as contradictions are the minor discrepancies in the testimony of the witnesses. In OGUNBANYO V. THE STATE (2002) 15 NWLR (PT.789) 76 @ 93 PARA G-H, it was held thus ”it is not every contradiction that would be sufficient to daminify a witness. For the contradiction to be effectual, it must be on a material point that goes to the root of the case, that is, a contradiction in the evidence of a party that will be fatal to his case and not a miniature contradiction which merely scratches the surface of an inconsequential or innocuous point”.

In the same vein, in DIBIE V. STATE (2007) ALL FWLR (PT.363) 83 @ 106, PARA G-H it was thus held ”Evidence of witnesses is not an exact thing like a triangle in geometry. Human beings will see the same object and describe it in different ways with some personal embellishment here and there that colour the object in some inarticulate difference”. In my view, there are no contradictions in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses to prove fatal to the case of the prosecution.

In conclusion, I am of the view that the prosecution discharged the onus of proving the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The trial judge on his part diligently evaluated the whole evidence presented before the Court. There is no need for this Court to interfere with the finding of the trial Court. This Appeal is without merit and ought to be dismissed.

In consequence, this appeal is adjudged unmeritorious; it fails and is hereby dismissed. The Judgment of the trial Court in Suit No. HAB/2C/2011, delivered on the 14th Day of July 2016 is accordingly affirmed.
Appeal dismissed.

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, J.C.A.: My learned brother P.M. EKPE, JCA afforded me the opportunity of reading before now a copy of the lead judgment just delivered.
I agree with the reasoning and conclusion that the appeal lacks merit and should be dismissed.
I also dismiss the appeal and I affirm the judgment of the trial Court delivered on the 14th day of July, 2016.

MOORE ASEIMO ABRAHAM ADUMEIN, J.C.A.: I had the privilege of reading before now the judgment just delivered by my learned brother, Philomena Mbua Ekpe, JCA.
I am in agreement with the reasons and the conclusions reached therein. I also hold that the appeal lacks merits and it is hereby dismissed.

I affirm the judgment of the lower Court.

 

Appearances:

O.T. Okeke, Esq. (Legal Aids Officer (P.D.S.S.)For Appellant(s)

Oluwole O. Iyamu, Esq. (S.G. Edo) with him, Mrs. R.O. OaihimireFor Respondent(s)