LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

B. C. ONYIUKE V. EASTERN STATES INTERIM ASSETS AND LIABILITIES AGENCY-1974

B. C. ONYIUKE V. EASTERN STATES INTERIM ASSETS AND LIABILITIES AGENCY

(1974) LCN/1866(SC)

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Thursday, October 31, 1974


Case N
umber: SC. 162/1974

RATIO

DUTY OF COURT: WHETHER A COURT IS COMPETENT TO DECLARE AN EDICT INVALID

We are in agreement with learned counsel that the courts are competent to declare an Edict invalid on the ground of its inconsistency with a Decree and that we so expressly held in the Council of the University of lbadan v. Adamolekun (1967) 1 All N.L.R. 213, at pp. 223-4:
“Dr. Ajayi (Attorney-General, Western State) has submitted that even if this section is void the Supreme Court cannot make any pronouncement that
“it is void For this proposition Dr. Ajayi sought the aid of section 6 of Decree No. 1 of 1966 which states that ‘no question as to the validity of this or any other Decree or of any Edict shall be entertained by any court of law in Nigeria’. We feel unable to accept this submission. This submission creates the situation that the Supreme Court cannot decide on an application before it whether an appeal lies to the Court or not and whether or not the Court can entertain the application before it In effect the Court is reduced to the position that if an Edict is itself inconsistent with a Decree or with the Decree No. 1 of 1966 the Court cannot make a pronouncement This, in our view, will not be giving effect to section 3(4) of Decree No.1 of 1966 and it becomes a dead letter. We feel that Dr. Ajayi’s reference to section 6 of the Decree is inept and the flaw in Dr. Ajayi’s argument lies in the fact that he has read section 6 in isolation. Reading the Decree as a whole we are not in doubt that section 6 does not preclude the courts from enquiring into any inconsistency that may arise, but merely bars the courts from questioning the validity of the making of a Decree or an Edict on the ground that there is no valid legislative authority to make one.”
And we held further:
“It is significant that in Section 3 of Decree No.1 of 1966 there is express provision in subsection (6) (quoted already) that the courts may not enquire whether the Military Governor of a Region had obtained the consent of the Federal Military Government before legislating on a matter in the Concurrent Legislative List; if nothing done by an Edict could be enquired into by a court of law, it would not have been necessary to make that express provision in subsection (6) of section 3. We think section 6 must be read together with section 3 of the Decree No. 1 of 1966, and the right view in our opinion is that the courts can enquire whether an Edict is void to any extent under section 3(4) of that Decree (no. 1 of 1966) which is the Decree authorising the making of Edicts within certain confined limits, and it is desirable for the legal advisers of a Military Governor to bear those limits in mind when drafting Edicts. ” PER ELIAS, CJN.

JUSTICES:

TASLIM O. ELIAS, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

FATAYI-WILLIAMS, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

GEORGE S. SOWEMIMO, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

 

APPELLANTS

B. C. ONYIUKE

 

RESPONDENTS

EASTERN STATES INTERIM ASSETS AND LIABILITIES AGENCY

 

RATIO

INVALIDITY OF AN EDICT

The courts are competent to declare an Edict invalid on the ground of its inconsistency with a Decree. Per Elias CJN

 

 

 

ELIAS, CJN. (Delivered by the Judgment of the Court)

This is an appeal against the judgment of Douglas, J., delivered in the Port Harcourt High Court on March 9, 1973. The judgment is sequel to a motion filed by the defendant/respondent in this appeal praying that the court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit on the ground that the action was not maintainable because it was a legislative act of the then Government of Eastern Nigeria that was being challenged. The plaintiff’s claims in the Port Harcourt High court are for: 1. A declaration that the former Eastern Nigeria Edict The Detention (of Persons) Edict, 1966 otherwise known as Edict No. 11 and all subsequent amendments thereof and the Eastern Nigeria Notice No. 1304 published thereunder are illegal and of no effect as they contravened Federal Republic of Nigeria – Decrees 1 and 3 of 1966 and Republican Constitution. 2. A declaration that the seizure of the plaintiff’s properties in December 1966 under the orders of the then Military Governor of the then Eastern Nigeria the predecessor of the defendant is illegal, void and of no effect. 3. A return to the plaintiff by the defendant of the under-mentioned articles or their equivalent value:  Cash…………………………….. £2, 086 : 6 : 10d  Consul Corsair Saloon  (Brand New Car) and  its key or its value…………………. 999 – –    Compensation for:  Two 16mm small rolls of cinema films at £10,000  each or ………………………… 20, 000 – –  One 35mm (Large) roll of cinema film at £25,000  each or…………………………. 25, 000 – –  Royalty paid on the 3 cinema films for 3 years…….. 10,000 – –  Two 16mm projectors at £25 each…………………………….. 500 – –  Total…………………………… £58, 581 : 6 : 10d   PAGE| 3 All materials purported to be confiscated by the then Eastern Nigeria Government by virtue of the aforesaid illegal Notice No. 1304.”

This motion to dismiss the plaintiff/appellant’s suit was brought by learned Senior Counsel under 0.29, r. 1 of the former Eastern Nigeria High Court Rules which are still applicable in the Rivers State. The motion is supported by an affidavit the relevant paragraphs of which read as follows:   “3. That this Honourable Court has no jurisdiction to grant the plaintiff any of the reliefs sought in his writ of summons. 4. That the Military Governor of Eastern Nigeria who made the Edicts and the Orders complained of was duly so appointed by the Federal Military Government. 5. That Edict No. 11 of 1966 (published as Eastern Nigeria Gazette Notice No. 115 of 1966) as amended by Edict No. 32 of 1966 was concerned with the powers of detention of persons and confiscation of property which are matters in the Concurrent Legislative List. 6. That the Orders of detention (published as Eastern Nigeria Gazette Notice No. 1302 of 1966) and of confiscation (published as Eastern Nigeria Gazette Notice No. 1304 of 1966) complained of were legislative acts of the said Military Governor duly made under Edict No. 11 (as amended by Edict No. 32) aforesaid. 7. That both the Edicts and the Orders aforesaid were legislative acts duly and lawfully made by virtue of the provisions of Decree No. 1 of 1966 that, subject to Section 3 (2) of Decree No. 1 of 1966 and the Constitution of the Federation of Nigeria, the Military Governor of a State or Region is given power to legislate to preserve peace, order and good government of the State or Region of which such a Military Governor is in charge.   8. That there is no inconsistency between the Edicts aforesaid and any Decree of the Federal Military Government. 9. That by Section 3(6) of Decree No. 1 of 1966 the question whether an Edict touching a matter included in the Concurrent Legislative List was made with the consent required by Section 3 (2) of Decree No. 1 of 1966 cannot be inquired into by any court of law. 10. That it was the opinion of the then Military Governor that the properties so confiscated were held for the purpose of endangering the security, peace, order and good government of the State. PAGE| 4 11. That Edict No. 11 of 1966 and Section 1(2) (b) of Decree No. 28 of 1970 deprive Law Courts of the Federation of the power to inquire into the validity of any Decree or Edict promulgated by the Federal Military Government or a Military Governor. Mr. Oyero, learned counsel for the appellant, sought and was granted permission to argue the following eight grounds of appeal: “1. The learned trial Judge erred in law when he held that the Detention (of Persons) Edict, 1966 otherwise known as Edict No. 11 of the former Eastern Nigeria and all subsequent amendments thereof and the Eastern Nigeria Notice No. 1304 published thereunder are valid.  2. The learned trial Judge erred in law when he held that the Detention (of Persons) Edict, 1966 of the former Eastern Nigeria otherwise known as Edict No. 11 is not inconsistent with Federal Republic of Nigeria Decrees 1 and 3 of 1966. 3. The learned trial Judge erred in law when he held that the Detention (of Persons) Edict, 1966 of the former Eastern Nigeria otherwise known as Edict No. 11 and all subsequent amendments thereto and Notices made thereunder are not consistent with Section 31 subsection 1 of the Nigerian Constitution. (4) The learned trial Judge misdirected himself and erred in law when he held that if a Military Government has power to make laws the courts cannot go behind Edicts to discover whether particular Edicts are valid.   (5) The learned trial Judge erred in law when he held that the Government of the former Eastern Region was right in confiscating the property of the plaintiff if it decided that the property might be used to further criminal acts of the plaintiff, which criminal acts were unspecified. (6) The learned trial Judge misdirected himself and erred in law when he held that there was a difference between confiscating the property of a law abiding person and that of a person held to be a criminal and that since Edict II stated that he had committed a crime he (the plaintiff) was a criminal when the plaintiff had not been charged, tried and adjudged a criminal by any court of law and contrary to S. 22 of the Constitution.  (7) The learned trial Judge erred in law in holding by implicating that the plaintiff and all other persons detained by the Ojukwu regime during the recent civil disturbances and antecedent crisis were criminals when they had not been charged with any specific criminal offence, tried and convicted by any court of law as provided by S. 22 of the Constitution.  (8) The learned trial Judge erred in law when he ignored the point made on behalf of the plaintiff that he was not given any hearing before his property was seized in defiance of the laws of Natural Justice.” With respect to the fourth ground which learned counsel argued first, he submitted that there was no authority for the decision of the learned trial Judge that, if a Military Governor has power to make laws, the courts cannot go behind Edicts to discover whether particulars Edicts are valid. He referred to the Federal Military Government (Supremacy) Decree No. 28, 1970, and submitted that the words in brackets in Section 1(2) (b) give the courts power to look into the question whether an Edict is inconsistent with the provision of a Decree under Section 3(4) of the Constitution (Suspension and Modification) Decree No. 1 of 1966. We here set out the provision of Section 1(2) (b) of Decree No. 28 as follows:-   “1(2) It is hereby declared also that – (b) with a view to assuring the effective maintenance of the territorial integrity of Nigeria and the peace, order and good government of the Federation, any decision, whether made before or after the commencement of this Decree, by any court of law in the exercise or purported exercise of any powers under the Constitution or any enactment or law of the Federation or of any State which has purported to declare or shall hereafter purport to declare the invalidity of any Decree or of any Edict (in so far as the provisions of the Edict are not inconsistent with the provisions of a Decree) or the incompetence of any of the governments in the Federation to make the same is or shall be null and void and of no effect whatsoever as from the date of the making thereof.”   To be read along with it is this provision of Section 3(4) of Decree No. 1, 1966; “3(4) If any law – (a) enacted before 16th January 1966 by the legislature of a Region, or having effect as if so enacted, or having effect as if so enacted, or (b) made after that date by the Military Governor of a Region, is inconsistent with any law – (i) validly made by Parliament before that date, or having effect as if so made, or (ii) made by the Federal Military Government on or after that date, the law made as mentioned in paragraph (i) or (ii) above shall prevail and the Regional law shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be void.” We are in agreement with learned counsel that the courts are competent to declare an Edict invalid on the ground of its inconsistency with a Decree and that we so expressly held in the Council of the University of Ibadan v. Adamolekun (1967) 1 All NLR 213, at pp. 223-4:  “Dr. Ajayi (Attorney-General, Western State) has submitted that even if this section is void the Supreme Court cannot make any pronouncement that it is void. For this proposition Dr. Ajayi sought the aid of Section 6 of Decree No. 1 of 1966 which states that ‘no question as to the validity of this or any other Decree or of any Edict shall be entertained by any court of law in Nigeria.’ We feel unable to accept this submission. This submission creates the situation that the Supreme Court cannot decide on an application before it whether an appeal li