LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

ANDREW EDOGE OGHENEVWETA V. THE STATE(1982)

ANDREW EDOGE OGHENEVWETA V. THE STATE

In The Supreme Court of Nigeria

On Thursday, the 11th day of February, 1982

SC.1/1980

 

JUSTICES

GEORGE SODEINDE SOWEMIMO    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

MOHAMMED BELLO    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

CHUKWUNWEIKE IDIGBE    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

ANDREWS OTUTU OBASEKI    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

AUGUSTINE NNAMANI    Justice of The Supreme Court of Nigeria

Between

 

ANDREW EDOGE OGHENEVWETA  Appellant(s)

AND

THE STATE  Respondent(s)

 

  1. S. SOWEMIMO, J.S.C.:  I have read and considered the proceedings in both the trial court and Court of Appeal. The appellant was found to have killed his mother, by chopping off her head with an axe, as well as inflicting other injuries. The learned trial Judge considered the defences of insanity and/or insane delusions and rejected both. He accepted the confessional statement made by the appellant although retracted in court. He convicted the appellant for murder and sentenced him to death. The Federal Court of Appeal considered the proceedings in the court of trial, on appeal before them and dismissed it. Both counsel before us have nothing useful to urge in favour of the appellant. Having read the whole proceedings in the  lower court, I agree with them and considered that this appeal ought to be dismissed. The appeal is hereby dismissed. The conviction and sentence of death are hereby affirmed.

    M. BELLO, J.S.C.:  The appellant was convicted of murder of his mother. There was no eyewitness and the conviction was founded on his confessions. His sister found the appellant by the corpse of their mother whose head had been shattered. He informed his sister that he had killed the deceased by striking her head with an axe. The sister saw the axe stained with blood at the scene.The appellant also made confessions to his step-father and police. He told the police that he had killed her because she had given him some medicine which worried him. He retracted his confessions at the trial. His defence of denial was rejected by the trial Judge. Although the defence of insanity was not raised, the trial Judge considered it and rightly, in my view, rejected it. He accepted the case for the prosecution and convicted the appellant. I agree the appeal has no merit and it is dismissed. Conviction and sentence are re-affirmed.

    C. IDIGBE, J.S.C.:  I agree that the appeal should be dismissed. The facts presented by the prosecution were adequately and properly considered by the learned trial Judge who found rightly, in my view, that this was a case of deliberate and brutal murder of the mother by the appellant. The learned trial judge rightly, in my view, held that the defences of insanity and/or insane delusion which he considered suo motu were not available to the appellant; his appeal to the Federal Court of Appeal was, in my view, also rightly refused. For the reasons stated above, I would dismiss this appeal and it is hereby dismissed.

    A. O. OBASEKI, J.S.C.:  I agree with both learned counsel that the appeal lacks merit having studied the record of proceedings in the court of trial and the Federal Court of Appeal. The appellant, for no apparent reason, decided to end the life of his mother and turn his sister and himself motherless. To this end, he got an axe and used it repeatedly on the head of his mother. He then took his sister’s child living with his mother to the sister and when the sister returned with him to the scene, he admitted killing the mother. His confessional statement to the police, though retracted in court, was rightly accepted by the learned trial Judge and together with other extra-judicial confession and evidence conclusively established the guilt of the appellant.The defence of insanity was not established and the learned trial judge properly so found. There is no merit in the appeal and I hereby dismiss it and affirm the conviction and sentence passed by the High Court and affirmed by the Federal Court of Appeal.

    A. NNAMANI, J.S.C.: This was again a brutal murder of appellant’ mother by the appellant. The appellant set upon his mother with an axe and butchered her for no apparent reason. I have carefully gone through the records of proceedings and I agree with both learned counsel for the appellant and the respondent that nothing can be urged in law in favour of the appellant. I agree with the finding of the learned trial Judge that the defence of insanity which the appellant raised was an afterthought. By his own admission, though he had mental illness he was cured by August 1976 while the murder took place in October, 1976. In any case the burden of proof of such a defence lay on him and it certainly was not discharged. I agree that the appeal lacks substance and ought to be dismissed. It is hereby dismissed. The decision of the Federal Court of Appeal, Benin dated 18th October, 1979 is hereby affirmed.

 

Appearances

Chief Funmi Jibowu For Appellant

 

AND

Mr. G. E. Edokpayi, Deputy Solicitor-General, Bendel State For Respondent