LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

MR. TONY IKE IFEBUNANDU v. ENGR. GEORGE OKOYE (2018)

MR. TONY IKE IFEBUNANDU v. ENGR. GEORGE OKOYE

(2018)LCN/12020(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Friday, the 27th day of July, 2018

CA/PH/142/2010

 

RATIO

APPEAL: FAILURE TO COMPILE RECORD OF APPEAL

“In MR. DENGO BENIN & ORS V EKEREMOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT COUNCIL (2013) LPELR  22869 (CA) this Court held per EKO JCA (now JSC) on the effect of appellant’s failure to compile and transmit record of appeal, as follows: –
‘There is no doubt that the Records of Appeal compiled and transmitted on 8th July, 2011 by the Principal Litigation Officer of the Court below, 160 days after the notice of appeal was purportedly filed was done in breach of Order 8 Rule 1 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2011. It is therefore incompetent. The registrar of the Court below was obligated to compile and transmit the records of appeal within 60 days after the filing of the notice of appeal. The notice of appeal in this case was filed on 16th February, 2011.” PER BITRUS GYARAZAMA SANGA, J.C.A. 

 

JUSTICES

ALI ABUBAKAR BABANDI GUMEL Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

ISAIAH OLUFEMI AKEJU Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

BITRUS GYARAZAMA SANGA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

MR. TONY IKE IFEBUNANDU Appellant(s)

AND

ENGR. GEORGE OKOYE Respondent(s)

 

BITRUS GYARAZAMA SANGA, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment):

This appeal is against the judgment of E. N. THOMPSON J. of the High Court of Rivers State Port Harcourt Judicial Division delivered on 17th October, 2008. The Respondent was the Claimant while the Appellant was the Defendant. The Claimant filed an endorsed Writ of Summons and Statement of Claim dated 13th February, 2006. He also filed an Amended Statement of Claim dated 25th February, 2008 seeking for the following: –

1: A declaration that the Plaintiff is entitled to the grant of a statutory right of occupancy over that 2 plots of land measuring 931.004 square metres which is located within a larger expanse of land known as Ebo Ngwo Mini Ngwu Ngwu or Ohia Mini Ngwu which is lying and situate along Shell Location Road, Oroazi Rumueme and which land is more particularly described and delineated by survey beacons No. SC/A176, SC/A173, SC/A174, SC/A175 back to SC/A176 in Survey Plan No. LWC/R004/2002 prepared by Surveyor L.W. CHUKWU.

2: A declaration that the grant of any certificate of occupancy to the Defendant in respect of the 2 plots of land within the area known as Ebo Ngwo Mini Ngwu Ngwu or Ohia Mini Ngwu Ngwu along Shell Location Road, Oroazi Port Harcourt is null and void.

3: The sum of N10,000,000:00 (Ten Million Naira) being and representing damages for trespass by the Defendant to the said piece or parcel of land in that the Defendant on or about the 6th of October, 2005 without the consent, authority or approval of the Plaintiff illegally broke and entered the said piece or parcel of land which has been in the actual and peaceable possession of the Plaintiff and extensively destroyed the concrete wall fence thereon.

4: An order of perpetual injunction to restrain the Defendant and his servants, agents or privies from further acts of trespass on the land or otherwise dealing in the said piece or parcel of land or any part thereof in any manner contrary to the interest of the Plaintiff. (pages 103 – 104 of the Records).

The Defendant filed a Statement of Defence dated 10th April, 2006 and an Amended Statement of Defence dated 28th May, 2008 wherein he contended as follows: –

1. That he has a registered title over the subject matter of this suit.

2. That the Claimant’s unregistered title which is later in time cannot in law supersede the Defendant’s registered title.

3. That the Claimant is not the native owner of the subject matter of this suit and cannot rely on custom as his root of title.

4. That the Defendant has exercised maximum acts of possession on the subject matter of this suit since 1993 including sand filing and fencing the land, paying land rate and fencing permit, applying and obtaining certificate of occupancy and chasing away trespassers to the land by making complaints of malicious damage to the police.

5. That the Claimant has no right or standing to complain about any defect in the Defendant?s title.

6. That even if there is any defect in the Defendant’s conveyance from Emmanuel Akaniwo (which the Defendant does not concede) those entitled to complain by their inaction have acquiesced to the conveyance are caught by the doctrine of laches and acquiescence from ever challenging the Defendant’s title. Furthermore, the Claimant’s claim is statute barred. (pages 116 – 117 of the record of appeal).

Issues having been joined, the matter went to trial. The Claimant testified as C.W. 1 and called two witnesses who testified as C.W.2 and C.W.3 respectively. The following documents were tendered in evidence, admitted and marked as exhibits by the Claimant.
1. Agreement dated 19/06/2002 . Exhibit ‘C1’ (tendered through C.W.1 on 16/10/2006 page 119 of the records)

2. Deed of Conveyance between Emmanuel Akaniwor and All states Home Finders . Exhibit ‘C2’.

3. Deed of Conveyance between Omunakwe Akaniwor and All states Home Finders Ltd.  Exhibit ‘C3’. (these two documents were tendered through C.W.2 Mr. Thomas Kalaiyo an Estate Surveyor on 19/10/2006 on page 122 of the Records).

4. The following six documents were tendered through C.W.3 on pages 125 – 126 of the record of appeal.
a. Letter dated 20th July, 1992. Exhibit ‘C4’.

b. Proceedings before Justice I.N. Ndu in Suit No. PHC/378/92. Exhibit ‘C5’.

c. Caveat Emptor on page 2 of the Tide Newspaper of April 19, 1997. Exhibit ‘C5’.

d. Statement of Claim in Suit No. PHC/378/92. Exhibit ‘C7’.

e. Consent Judgment in Suit No. PHC/519/92. Exhibit ‘C8’.

f. Proceedings before the Remueme Council of Chiefs. Exhibit ‘C9’.

The defendant testified for himself as D.W.1 and tendered the following documents in evidence:
a. Receipt No. 0667 of 18th Nov. 1993 – Exhibit ‘D1’.

b. Receipt No. 086 of 22nd Dec. 1993 – Exhibit ‘D2’.

c. Page 10 of Daily Sunday Newspaper of 11th March, 1996. Exhibit ‘D3’.

d. Certificate of Occupancy No. 67, page 67 Volume 286 of 15th August, 2003. Exhibit ‘D4’.

e. Chartered Bank Cheque of 26th April, 1994 for N70,000.00 in favour of Mr. Emmanuel Akaniwo. Exhibit ‘D5’.

f. Land rate and Fencing Permit receipt No. 435149 of 25/08/1995. Exhibit ‘D6’.

g. Deed of Conveyance dated 2nd Jan. 1995. Exhibit ‘D7’. (Pages 131 – 134 of the record of appeal).

Learned counsel to the parties filed, exchanged and adopted their respective Final Written Address. Judgment was delivered on 17th October, 2008. (pages 183 – 195 of the record of appeal). The learned trial Judge adopted the issues canvassed by learned counsel during pretrial conference as follows: –

1: Whether from the state of the pleadings and evidence of the parties, Claimant’s un-registered conveyance can vitiate the Defendant’s registered Certificate of Occupancy in respect of the subject matter of this suit.

2: If issue (1) is resolved in the positive, whether the Claimant by credible evidence has proved that the Defendant trespassed on the subject matter of this suit.

3: Whether the suit is statute barred.

Learned trial Judge started by considering the third issue since it touches on the jurisdiction of the lower Court. He resolved the issue by holding thus: –
”The Defendant’s contention that the action is statute barred because he has allegedly been in possession of the land since 1993 does not stand because the Claimant did not purchase the land the subjection matter of this suit until 2002. It was after the purchase that he allegedly took possession which possession he claimed was disturbed by the Defendant.

Time cannot start running against the Claimant before he acquired interest in the land the subject matter of this suit.

I find in the circumstances that this preliminary issue is of no moment and hold that the Claimant’s action is not statute barred. It is very much alive. The issue of laches and acquiescence was not argued. It is obvious that the defendant abandoned same. (pages 189 – 190 of the record of appeal).

On issue 1 the learned trial Judge held as follows: –
”I hold therefore that the Claimant having successfully established his root of title and being in possession of an unregistered titled document has acquired an equitable interest in the land which can only be defeated by a prior purchaser of the legal estate or a subsequent purchaser of the legal estate without notice of the Claimant’s equitable interest.

The Defendant who has no valid legal estate cannot defeat the equitable interest of the Claimant..
In the case of ADOLE V GWAR (Supra) in which none of the officers named by the Defendant sued, the Supreme Court held thus: ‘consequently where it is proved’, that another person other than the grantee of a Certificate of Occupancy had a better title to the land, the Court may have no option but to set aside the grant discountenance it as invalid, defective or spurious as the case may be?.

In the final analysis I find issue 1 in favour of the Claimant’. (page 193 of the record of appeal).

On issue 2 the learned trial Judge held thus: –
‘In the instant case, the Defendant who had no better right to possession disturbed the Claimant’s possession of the land in dispute. I hold that the Claimant has established trespass’.

The learned trial Judge concluded his judgment by holding as follows:-
In the final analysis judgment is entered for the Claimant and I make the following orders: –

1. It is declared that the Claimant is entitled to the grant of a statutory right of occupancy over that 2 plots of land measuring 931.004 square metres which is located within larger expanse of land known as Ebo Ngwo Mini Ngwu Ohia Mini Ngwu Ngwu which is lying and situate along Shell Location Road Orazi Rumueme and which land is more particularly described and delineated by survey beacons No. SC/A176, SC/A173, SC/A174, SC/A175 back to SC/A176 in Survey Plan No. LWC/R004/2002 prepared by Surveyor L.W. CHUKWU.

2. It is further declared that Certificate of Occupancy registered as No. 67 page 67 Volume 288 issued to the Defendant in respect of the land described above is null and void.

3. The Defendant shall pay to the Claimant N100,000 being and representing damages for trespass.

4. The Defendant, his servants, agents or privies are hereby perpetually restrained from further acts of trespass or otherwise dealing with the said land in a manner contrary to the interest of the Claimant.

5. N20,000.00 costs to the Claimant. (pages 190 – 195 of the record of appeal).

This decision by the learned trial Judge irked the Defendant. He filed a Notice of Appeal containing 16 grounds of appeal on 28th November, 2008. (pages 196 – 205 of the record of appeal). The record of appeal was compiled and transmitted to this Court on 20th April, 2010. Learned counsel to the Appellant Chief J.C. Ifebunandu filed the Appellant’s Brief of argument on 24th May, 2010.

As can be noted above the record of appeal compiled and transmitted to this Court on 20th April, 2010 was transmitted out of time by 2 years 5 months from 28/11/2008 when the notice of appeal was filed pursuant to Order 8 Rule 1 of the Court of Appeal Rules 2007 which was the applicable rules of Court as at 2008. There is no application by learned counsel to the Appellant to regularize the said Records.

In MR. DENGO BENIN & ORS V EKEREMOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT COUNCIL (2013) LPELR  22869 (CA) this Court held per EKO JCA (now JSC) on the effect of appellant’s failure to compile and transmit record of appeal, as follows: –
‘There is no doubt that the Records of Appeal compiled and transmitted on 8th July, 2011 by the Principal Litigation Officer of the Court below, 160 days after the notice of appeal was purportedly filed was done in breach of Order 8 Rule 1 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2011. It is therefore incompetent. The registrar of the Court below was obligated to compile and transmit the records of appeal within 60 days after the filing of the notice of appeal. The notice of appeal in this case was filed on 16th February, 2011.

The Records of Appeal being incompetent is hereby struck out. The effect of the Records of Appeal being incompetent and struck out is that there are no Records of Appeal. The Appellants failed or refused to act under Order 8 Rule 4 to discharge their obligation therein. The appeal has consequently been abandoned and it is hereby dismissed for want of prosecution”.

See also: THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TARABA STATE -V- SELIHIN CONSULT LIMITED (2016) LPELR  40817 (CA) per SANKEY JCA on Pp. 6 – 7 paragraphs C – E.

In the circumstances the Records of Appeal in the instant appeal filed on 20th April, 2010 is incompetent having been filed out of time and there is no application by learned counsel to the appellant for extension of time to deem the said Records as duly compiled and transmitted. The said Records of Appeal being incompetent is hereby struck out. Since the said Records is struck out it means there is no records of appeal and the appeal is therefore abandoned. Sequel to this state of affairs the appeal is hereby dismissed for want of prosecution.

ALl ABUBAKAR BABANDI GUMEL, J.C.A: I have had the privilege of an advance reading of the leading judgment of my learned brother Sanga JCA. I fully agree with his reasoning and conclusions. I also agree that this appeal ought to be dismissed and abide by all the consequential orders of my learned brother.

ISAIAH OLUFEMI AKEJU, J.C.A.: I have read the Judgment of my learned brother, BITRUS GYARAZAMA SANGA JCA and I agree with the reasoning and conclusion therein. I dismiss the appeal for want of prosecution.

 

Appearances:

No appearanceFor Appellant(s)

No appearanceFor Respondent(s)