ALHAJI BASHIRU ATANDA ARE v. MADAM AISHA MEMUDU OFFA & ANOR
(2018)LCN/12017(CA)
In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
On Friday, the 27th day of July, 2018
CA/IL/14/17
RATIO
COURT AND PROCEDURE: WHERE PRELIMINARY OBJECTION IS RAISED
“It is trite that where a preliminary objection is raised, same must be looked into and resolved first before the substantive matter if need be. The essence of a preliminary objection to the hearing of an Appeal is to bring the hearing of the Appeal to an end for being incompetent or fundamentally defective. Therefore, a successful preliminary objection terminates the appeal. When the Appellant is served with a preliminary objection, the appellant is expected to respond in his reply brief. See GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY VS. AKANDE & ORS (2010) LPELR 9356 (SC), OGIDI VS. EGBA (1999) NWLR (PT. 621) P. 42 and PLASTEX (NIG) LTD VS. MAINLAND OIL & GAS (2018) LPELR 43509 (CA) P. 14, PARAS. A – C. This simply means that a preliminary objection when raised offers the appellant (in the case of an objection to the competence of an appeal) an opportunity to respond in a reply brief. The preliminary objection in this case was raised and argued by the Cross Appellants challenging the competence of the main appeal where they were respondents.” PER CHIDI NWAOMA UWA, J.C.A.
WHERE EVIDENCE IS UNCHALLENGED OR UNCONTROVERTED
“The evidence above was not challenged under cross-examination and no contrary evidence was adduced to controvert these pieces of evidence as rightly argued by the learned counsel to the Respondents. Also, since these pieces of evidence were not challenged, they need no further proof. In the case of KAYILI VS. YILBUK & ORS (2015) LPELR 24323 (SC) at P. 36, PARA. A., his Lordship Ogunbiyi, JSC simply gave the effect of an unchallenged/uncontroverted evidence thus:
‘The law is trite and enjoins a Court to act on an unchallenged evidence.'” PER CHIDI NWAOMA UWA, J.C.A.
JUSTICES
CHIDI NWAOMA UWA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
HAMMA AKAWU BARKA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
BOLOUKUROMO MOSES UGO Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
Between
ALHAJI BASHIRU ATANDA ARE
(On behalf of Jadefo/Are family)
– APPELLANT/CROSS RESPONDENT Appellant(s)
AND
1. MADAM AISHA MEMUDU OFFA
2. BILIKISU ABDULKAREEM ALAO
-RESPONDENTS/CROSS APPELLANTS Respondent(s)
CHIDI NWAOMA UWA, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment):
The appeal is against the judgment of the Kwara State High Court delivered on 26th September, 2016, presided over by M.A. Folayan, J, in which the trial Court dismissed the claim and the counter claim of the appellant as the claimant and the respondents as the defendants/counter claimants. The Appellant was dissatisfied with the decision of the trial Court, thus this appeal. The appellant?s claim at the lower Court is as contained in his Amended Writ of Summons and Amended Statement of Claim both dated and filed on 6th March, 2015. The claims against the Respondents jointly and severally were as follows:
1. A Declaration of entitlement to the Right of Occupancy to the land and the mud house/building situate at Jadefo/Are compound, comprising of four rooms and five shops situate at Ita Ogunbo Area, Ilorin, Kwara State subject of decision in case No. 14757/71 between Jimoh Abi Allah Ile Jadefo AND Busari Akanbi Ile Jadefo decided sometimes in 1971.
2. A Declaration that late Alfa Mamudu Offa, father and grandfather to the 1st & 2nd Defendants respectively as well as their children and grandchildren having been aware, alive, around and in the same building when case No 1475/71 between Jimoh Abi Alla Ile Jadefo AND Busari Akanbi Ile Jadefo was being contested in respect of the same building in dispute and being an ordinary visitors/tenants of the claimant’s family are estoped from laying claim to the building subject of decision in case No. 1475/71 between Jimoh Abi Allah Ile Jadefo AND Busari Akanbi Ile Jadefo.
3. An Order of perpetual injunction restraining the defendants, their servants, privies, personal representatives or any person(s) deriving title or authority from them from further reconstructing or developing or laying claim to the disputed land and the building thereon.
In the Respondents’ joint consequential Statement of Defence counter-claimed against the claimant seeking the following relief:
”WHEREOF the Defendants by way of counter-claim claim against the claimant?s family to quit Jadefo Compound, remove anything have on the land (sic) and give up possession of the land of the Defendants.”
The appellant as claimant in proof of his case called three (3) witnesses as PW1, PW2 and PW3 and tendered in evidence Exhibits 1, 2, 3, 3A, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 10A – 10H, 11 and 11A – 11H. The Respondents on their part, as the Defendants/Counter-Claimants also called three (3) witnesses who testified as DW1, DW2 and DW3 and also tendered two (2) documents in evidence as Exhibits ?D1? and ‘D2’.
The Appellant formulated two (2) issues for the determination of the Appeal as follows:
1. Having regard to the state of pleadings and totality of evidence in this case, was trial Court not wrong, while placing reliance on evidence not covered by pleadings and on alleged ‘material conflicts’ and ‘un-explained circumstances’ in the appellant’s case, in holding that Exhibit ‘6’ has no probative value and that since by its location, Jadefo/Are compound is under the administrative control of Balogun Alanamu, the appellant as descendant of Afonja (Magaji Are family) did not prove that the Jadefo/Are compound is part of Afonja/Are lands? (Grounds 4, 5, 6, 7, 9 & 10)
2. Having regard to the state of pleadings and totality of evidence in this case, was trial Court not wrong in its decision on the circumstances that culminated in change of the name of the compound in dispute to ‘Jadefo’ and in its findings, conclusions and decisions that the appellant did not prove exclusive ownership of Jadefo/Are compound but rather that the appellant and the respondents are co-owners of the compound by virtue of a grant to respondents’ progenitor by Balogun Alanamu even without a proper appraisal and application of applicable principles to the appellant’s case before coming to its conclusion and decision (Grounds 1, 2, 3, 8, 11, 12, 13 & 14)
The Respondents on their part formulated the following issues for the determination of the appeal:
1. ?Whether the trial Court has not properly decided the issue of Exhibit ‘6’ as having nothing to do with the Respondents’ family.
2. Whether the trial Court has not properly decided that the Appellant failed to prove his ownership of the land with credible evidence.?
In arguing the appeal, the learned counsel to the appellant Salman Jawondo Esq., adopted and relied on his brief of argument filed on 8/3/17 and reply brief filed on 5/3/18, as his argument in urging us to allow the appeal. In arguing the first issue, it was submitted that the trial Court was wrong to have held that Exhibit ‘6’ (Proceedings and Judgment in case No: 1475/71 between ABIALA JIMOH VS. BUSARI AKANBI) had no probative value and that by its location, Jadefo/Are Compound is under the Administrative control of Balogun Alanamu, the appellant as descendant of Afonja (Magaji Are family) did not prove that the Jadefo/Are Compound is part of Afonja/Are lands. It was submitted that there were no ‘material conflicts’ and ‘un-explained circumstances’ as held by the trial Court in the case of the appellant on the basis of the evidence of the PW2, page 259 of the printed records. The material facts on which issues were joined were said to be straight forward. See F.B.N. PLC VS. IMASUEN & SONS (NIG) LTD (2014) ALL FWLR (PT. 725) 339 at 365 (PARAS. D – E). It was argued that from the evidence before the Court on Exhibit ‘6’, it is clear that the building in dispute in this case was one of the three buildings litigated upon in Exhibit ‘6’, even though the parties named therein and who fought the case in Exhibit ‘6’ are not the same as the parties in this case, the parties in the present case are privies of the parties in Exhibit ‘6’.
Thus, Exhibit ‘6’ constitutes both estoppel by res judicatam or issue estoppel or estoppel by standing by and evidence of possession by the appellant or his right to possession. See ALLI VS. ALESINLOYE (2000) 2 SCN QR 285 at 315.
On whether the parties in Exhibit ‘6’ and this case are the same, it was submitted that from the evidence before the Court, the fact that the parties in Exhibit ‘6’ are the same as the parties in the present action is settled. It was argued that there is no dispute that the appellant is a successor of Busari Akanbi, the defendant in Exhibit ‘6’ and therefore a privy of the defendant/winner in Exhibit ‘6’.
On the relationship of the plaintiff (Jimoh Abi Alla) in Exhibit ‘6’ to the respondents in this case, DW3 (2nd Respondent) testified that Jimoh Abiala is a relative of Alfa Memudu Offa, page 259 of the printed records of Appeal. It was submitted that Jimoh Abiala, the plaintiff in Exhibit ‘6’ being a relative of Alfa Memudu Offa, the respondents who are daughter and granddaughter of Alfa Memudu Offa are privies of Jimoh Abiala while the Appellant is a privy of Busari Akanbi, the defendant in Exhibit ‘6’.
Therefore, that Exhibit ‘6’ constitutes estoppel per rem judicatam against the respondents. See NDIC VS. UBN PLC (2015) ALL FWLR (PT. 783) 1790 at 1826, PARAS. D – E amongst others. The evidence of the DW1, DW2 and DW3 was reviewed to the effect that there was a case between Jimoh Abiala and Busari Akanbi, disputed in Exhibit ‘6’, and that three houses were in the compound and that one of the houses is the subject matter of this suit. It was reargued that from the pleadings and evidence before the Court, the parties, the property in dispute and the cause in Exhibit ‘6’ (i.e. ownership of buildings in Jadefo compound) are the same as in this case and the issue of ownership of the building in dispute in this case were determined in favour of the predecessor of the appellant. Exhibit ‘6’ was said to have probative value and also constitutes estoppel against the respondents who are relations/privies of the plaintiff in Exhibit ‘6’.
In the alternative, without conceding that Exhibit ‘6’ does not constitute estoppel of record or issue estoppel, it was submitted that the respondents as relations/privies of the plaintiff in Exhibit ?6? are caught by the doctrine of estoppel of standing by. With reference to the evidence of the DW1, page 253 of the records, the evidence of the DW2, page 255 and Exhibit ‘1’, pages 84 – 92 of the records, the respondents admitted that the father of the 2nd respondent was alive and in Ile Jadefo when the case in Exhibit ‘6’ was fought and lost. Thus, the evidence before the trial Court established that the 1st respondent and the father of the 2nd respondent were alive when the case in Exhibit ‘6’ was fought and lost but, they did not take any step to be part of the case. See OSUNRINDE VS. AJAMOGUN (1992) 7 SCNJ (PT. II) 79 at 110 – 111 and ALLI VS. ALESINLOYE (supra) at 324.
Without conceding that Exhibit ‘6’ does not constitute estoppel, it is evidence of the appellant’s possession, actual or constructive, or right to possession. See NWAKONOBI VS. UDEORAH (2012) 4 – 5 SC 1 at 29. It was argued that from the pleadings and evidence before the Court, the appellant proved that Jadefo/Are Compound is part of Afonja/Are lands but that the area of the location is under the administrative control of Balogun Alanamu. Further, that administrative control or jurisdiction is not the same thing as ownership, as ownership could reside in one person while administrative control resides in another. See UBREYE VS. ESIEVO (2014) ALL FWLR (PT. 759) 1103 at 1127 (PARAGRAPH D). It was argued that the issue of the area of location of Jadefo/Are compound belonging to Afonja/Magaji Are family was pronounced upon and settled in Exhibit ‘6’, page 15, lines 26 – 31 of the Exhibit.
It was also submitted that Exhibit ‘6’ being a final judgment of a Court of competent jurisdiction, the issue of Ita Ogunbo where Jadefo/Are Compound is situate, being part of Are family land had been settled and the respondents as persons affected by that pronouncement are not allowed to plead against it or call evidence to contradict it. It was submitted that the trial Court ought not to have held a contrary view. Contrary to the view of the learned trial judge, it was submitted that the appellant failed to call any witness from Idiape to state that the appellant and his family are descendants of Are and that Jadefo/Are Compound is part of Idi – Ape land. It was argued that evidence of traditional history need not proceed only from members of the land owning family or community as long as the evidence is from a person who knows the history and such evidence is credible.
See ALLI VS. ALESINLOYE (supra) at 315. It was concluded on this issue that the appellant is a descendant of Afonja/Magaji Are and does not need any other person from Idi – Ape to attest to his origin. Reference was made to paragraph 5 of the appellant’s ‘Reply to the consequential Amended Statement of Defence and Defence to the Counter – Claim’, page 130 of the records and paragraph 4 of the Additional Statement on Oath of PW1 and PW2 respectively at pages 137 and 149 of the printed records. The decision of the trial Court was said to be perverse and we were urged to reverse same.
In arguing his second issue, it was submitted that the trial Court was wrong to have found and concluded that the appellant did not prove exclusive ownership of Jadefo/Are Compound but rather that the appellant and the respondents are co-owners of the compound by virtue of a grant to the respondents’ progenitor by Balogun Alanamu. It was conceded that both parties in this case had the burden to prove their respective claims since title is presumed and would be granted in favour of the party with a better title to the land in dispute. See HARUNA VS. ISAH (2016) ALL FWLR (PT. 818) 918 at 945.
It was argued that the appellant found his claim on evidence of traditional history, acts of ownership, possession and previous judgment while the respondents based their defence and counter claim on evidence of traditional history and possession of the building in dispute. It was submitted that the evidence of the PW1, PW2 and PW3 was unchallenged and that the appellant proved his case from the pleadings and by credible evidence led in support. It was argued that the appellant established evidence of traditional history which goes back to ancient time as required by law, that is, who his progenitor (Baba Onire) was how he founded Elewuro Compound which was later changed to Jadefo and an unbroken chain of succession from Baba Onire down to the appellant. It was argued that the appellant discharged the onus on him to prove that his progenitor founded Elewuro Compound now known as Jadefo/Are Compound and the unbroken chain of intervening successors to the ownership and possession of the compound up to the appellant.
The appellant argued that he proved his title to and exclusive ownership of Jadefo/Are Compound including the building in dispute in this case and that he was entitled to judgment. See SAPO VS. SUNMONU (2010) ALL FWLR (PT. 531) 1408 at 1439, (PARAS B – D). Further, that where title is based on ownership founded on traditional history, coupled with acts of ownership and possession, it is enough for a party to prove his title with evidence of traditional history alone.
Therefore, that the appellant having proved his title through evidence of traditional history, he was entitled to the judgment of the trial Court. See YUSUF VS. ADEGOKE (2007) ALL FWLR (PT. 385) 384 at 409, PARA. B. The evidence of the DW1 and DW2 was reviewed to the effect that out of the six (6) houses in the compound, only one house was occupied by members of the Respondents’ family, pages 255 – 256 of the printed records of appeal. It was submitted that the appellant proved a better title than the respondents and therefore, was entitled to the judgment of the trial Court.
It was further submitted that the trial Court was wrong to have held that the parties are co-owners of Jadefo/Are Compound by virtue of a grant to the respondents’ progenitor by Balogun Alanamu. It was argued that neither of the parties premised his/their claim on co-ownership but, each founded and pursued his or their case on exclusive ownership based on traditional evidence of settlement by his or their progenitor; see paragraph 55 of the Amended Statement of Claim and paragraphs 44 – 48 of the respondents’ consequential Amended Statement of Defence and counter-claim.
It was argued that, there cannot be co-ownership where opposing parties claim and counter-claim for exclusive ownership of a property in dispute but the property should be that of whoever proves better title. See AIYEOLA VS. PEDRO (2014) ALL FWLR (PT. 744) 17 at 43, PARAS. A – B and OMOTOSHO VS. SAKA (2015) ALL FWLR (PT. 782) 1686 at 1702, PARAS. F – G.
The learned counsel dwelt on the appellant’s entitlement to the judgment of the trial Court having proved his title to Jadefo/Are Compound and the buildings therein, including the building in dispute as against the respondents who were alleged to have failed to prove their counter claim. The learned counsel defined a counter claim and when it is usually resorted to. It was contended that the respondents’ case was full of contradictions on the basis of the respondents’ claim of root of title which made the respondents’ case unreliable. See OSADIM VS. TAWO (2010) ALL FWLR (PT. 534) 146 at 165, PARAS. C – D. The learned counsel to the Appellant once again faulted the respondents’ traditional history on how their ancestors found the Jadefo/Are Compound.
It was alleged that the respondents did not plead and give the name of the Balogun Alanamu that granted the land to their progenitor. Also, that the respondents did not plead and establish how Balogun Alanamu became the owner of the land allegedly granted to the respondents’ progenitor, moreso where the appellant did not admit the title of Balogun Alanamu to the land in dispute.
It was re-argued that the trial Court did not evaluate and ascribe probative value to the evidence and case of the appellant. It was alleged that the trial Court raised the issues of absence of an ‘agreement of customary tenancy’ and whether Alfa Memudu Offa paid ‘rent’ to the appellant’s family as a guest/tenant in Jadefo/Are Compound on the basis of which the trial Court came to the erroneous conclusion that the appellant did not prove that Alfa Memudu Offa was a guest in Jadefo Compound. It was argued that the Appellant’s case was not based on rent paying tenancy and on agreement of customary tenancy but, on accommodation of Alfa Memudu Offa as a guest. It was submitted that the trial Court ought to have considered the case as presented by the parties and applied the principles of law to the facts as presented by the parties. It was contended by the learned counsel that traditional tenancy can exist without payment of rent or tribute. See LAWANI VS. ADENIYI (1964) 3 NSCC 231 at 233 and MAKINDE VS. AKINWALE (2000) 1 SC 89 at 95 – 96. It was concluded that the trial Court’s failure to analyze the appellant’s case led to a miscarriage of justice and renders the decision liable to be set aside.
The learned counsel to the Respondents, A.A. Katibi on his part, relied on his brief of argument filed on 13/2/18, in urging us to dismiss the appeal. In arguing his first issue, it was submitted that the trial Court strenuously examined Exhibit ‘6’ and rightly concluded that it had nothing to do with the Respondents’ family. Also, the decision that Exhibit ‘6’ had no probative value and is not binding on the trial Court since the parties and the property involved are not the same. See ABUBAKAR VS. BEBEJI OIL (2007) 2 SCNJ 170 at 202. It was argued that none of the parties in Exhibit ‘6’ are related to the Respondents and that there was no evidence led by the Appellant to show the relationship between the parties and the Respondents. On the other hand, it was submitted that from Exhibit ‘6’ and the evidence led by the parties, the parties in Exhibit ‘6’ are members of the same family.
It was the contention of the learned counsel to the respondent that no evidence was led by the Appellant on the issue of ownership and administrative control of Ilorin or the area in question. See ABDULLAHI VS. MILL ADMINISTRATOR (2003) WRN 50 at 61 – 62. Further, that the Respondents led evidence that this dispute was reported to Balogun Alanamu and not Magaji Are who allegedly gave the land in dispute to the Appellant, pages 114 and 117 of the printed records of Appeal. It was also submitted that Jadefo/Are Compound was not mentioned in Exhibit ‘6’ but rather Jadefo Compound was mentioned, therefore, that the appellant was wrong to have made out that Jadefo/Are compound is part of Are land which was settled in Exhibit ‘6’. It was the contention of the learned counsel to the Respondents that Are has no land in Ita – Ogunbo Area but Balogun Alanamu. We were urged not to disturb the decision of the trial Court.
On the respondents’ second issue, it was submitted that the trial Court was right to have held that the Appellant failed to prove his ownership of the land in Jadefo Compound with credible evidence and did not prove his contention that Jadefo Compound changed its name from Elewuro to Jadefo and from Jadefo to Jadefo/Are.
It was contended that the Appellant was unable to establish that Alfa Memudu was a visitor or a tenant. Further, that the Appellant alleged their progenitor was Baba Onire (Baba – Oko) and that issues were joined on the name, that he is known as Suberu Ajadi (Baba Oko) who was settled in Jadefo Compound by Alfa Memudu. It was submitted that Alfa Memudu is not the progenitor of the Respondents but, one Suleman, the grandfather of Alfa Memudu (Suleman Begat Yusuf) who gave birth to Alfa Memudu and four others who are grandparents to Ahmadu Babatunde Imotoro (DW1) and Sulaiman Zubair (DW2), page 114 of the printed records, paragraph 8. It was submitted that the Appellant did not challenge the evidence of the Respondents to the effect that Balogun Alanamu granted land to their progenitor.
It was also submitted that the trial Court was right to have held that there were material conflicts in the case of the Appellant, concerning how Alfa Mamudu came to the compound, the area he occupied, the circumstances and proximity of where he occupied and the area occupied by the Appellant. These situations were said not to have been explained by the Appellant. The trial Court was said to have been right to have believed the Respondents’ version of how the name of the compound was changed from Elewuro to Jadefo.
It was the contention of the learned counsel to the Respondents that the Appellant failed to prove his title to the compound but only succeeded in proving that his family found themselves in the Jadefo compound. We were urged to hold that the Appellant failed to prove their title to the Jadefo compound.
In the Appellant’s reply brief filed on 5/3/18, it was submitted that since DW1, DW2 and DW3 admitted that the property in dispute in this case was one of the properties litigated upon in Exhibit ‘6’, the trial Court was wrong to have held that the judgment is not relevant and binding on the Court and holding that the parties, subject matter and cause of action are not the same is also erroneous. It was submitted that the Appellant proved his root of title by his pleadings and evidence led in support. Further, that Jadefo/Are is not mentioned in Exhibit ‘6’ is of no moment since the parties agreed that the compound is known as both Jadefo and Are. It was argued that the pronouncement that Are had no land in Ita – Ogunbo area is also erroneous in view of the Court’s pronouncement in lines 26 – 30 of page 15 of Exhibit ‘6’ at page 82 of the printed records of Appeal.
It was submitted that the respondents failed to prove the grant of Jadefo/Are Compound to their progenitor. It was contended that the respondents gave evidence that was at variance with their pleadings on who the founder of Jadefo/Are Compound is, as DW1 and DW2 gave evidence that the founder of the Jadefo Compound was Alfa Memudu as against their pleadings that the founder was Sulaiman, page 253 and 255 of the printed records.
It was concluded that the case of the Appellant is that Alfa Memudu Offa was the first person in the lineage of the respondents to be accommodated in Jadefo/Are Compound which was confirmed by the evidence of the DW1 and DW2 to the effect that Alfa Memudu Offa was the founder of Jadefo/Are Compound, therefore, the first person from the respondents’ family to settle at the compound, which is in line with the Appellant’s case. It was submitted that any contradiction as to the root of title was on the part of the respondents through the DW1 and DW2. It was submitted that the respondents failed to prove the grant of Jadefo/Are Compound to their progenitor.
It was contended that the respondents gave evidence that was at variance with their pleadings on who the founder of Jadefo/Are Compound is, as DW1 and DW2 gave evidence that the founder of the Jadefo Compound was Alfa Memudu as against their pleadings that the founder was Sulaiman, page 253 and 255 of the printed records. It was concluded that the case of the Appellant is that Alfa Memudu Offa was the first person in the lineage of the respondents to be accommodated in Jadefo/Are Compound which was confirmed by the evidence of the DW1 and DW2 to the effect that Alfa Memudu Offa was the founder of Jadefo/Are Compound, therefore the first person from the respondents family to settle at the compound, which is in line with the Appellant’s case. It was submitted that any contradiction as to the root of title was on the part of the respondents through the DW1 and DW2.
The appellant’s grouse under his first issue is that the trial Court did not attach any weight to Exhibit ‘6’, the judgment of the Ilorin Area Court which the appellant relied heavily on at the trial Court, making out that the building in dispute, in this case was one of the three buildings litigated upon in Exhibit ‘6’.
The Appellant agreed that the parties named in Exhibit ‘6’ are not the same as the parties in the present case but that the parties in this case are privies of the parties in Exhibit ‘6’. Based on this, the Appellant pleaded estoppel per res judicatam or issue estoppel or estoppel by standing by. In the case of YOYE VS. OLUBODE & ORS (1974) LPELR 3531 (SC), his Lordship Ibekwe, JSC at PP. 13 – 14, PARAS. F – A. gave conditions for a successful plea of estoppel per rem judicatam as follows:
”It is well-known that before the doctrine of res judicata can operate, it must be shown that the parties, issues and subject matter were the same in the previous case as those in the action in which the plea of res judicata is raised. It is also well – settled that once the plea is made out by the party seeking to rely upon it, the claim filed by the other party would be dismissed on the ground that the Court lacks jurisdiction to allow parties to re-litigate the same issues again.”
See also ALASHE and ORS VS. OLORI – ILU & ORS (1964) LPELR 25161 (SC), EZEKIEL APATA VS. JAMES OLANLOKUN & ANOR (2013) LPELR 20938 (SC); (2013) 17 NWLR (PT. 1383) P. 221 and YANATY PETROCHEMICAL LTD VS. EFCC (2017) LPELR 43473 (SC).
The question is: were the appellants able to prove that the families of the Respondents were parties in Exhibit ‘6’ On the face of Exhibit ‘6’, the parties are: Jimoh Abi Allah Ile Jadefo and Busari Akanbi Ile Jadefo. There is nothing on record from the evidence led by the Appellant to prove that the Respondents are related to the parties.
The property in question is not the same as the property litigated upon in Exhibit ‘6’ and the issues are not the same as in the present case. It is trite law that he who asserts must prove the truth of it, in order to succeed in the action, even where pleaded, it must be proved. See MALAM AHMADU SAMBO & ORS VS. THE NIGERIA ARMY COUNCIL & ORS (2015) LPELR 40636 (CA), also ANDONG ADAKE & ANOR VS. ADAMU AKUN (2003) LPELR 72 (SC); (2003) 14 NWLR (PT. 840) P. 418; (2003) 7 SC P. 26.
In the present case, since the parties are not the same, the property in dispute and the issues, the plea of estoppel per res judicatam cannot avail the appellant. The learned trial judge was therefore right to have held that Exhibit ‘6’ had nothing to do with the Respondents’ family. Further, the appellant had made out that the issue of the area of location of Jadefo/Are Compound belonging to Afonja/Magaji Are family was pronounced upon and settled in Exhibit ‘6’.
I agree with the submissions of the learned counsel to the Respondents that what was mentioned in Exhibit ‘6’ is Jadefo Compound (There is no dispute as to how the compound became known as Jadefo) and not Jadefo/Are Compound. Also, the Appellant did not prove that any household in Ita – Ogunbo was allocated land by Magaji Are. The argument of the learned counsel to the Appellant that the judgment in Exhibit ‘6’ is binding on the trial Court is also erroneous. The learned counsel to the appellant faulted the finding of the trial Court, at page 287 of the printed records that the appellant did not call any witness from Idiape to clearly state that the appellant and his family are descendants of Are and that Jadefo/Are Compound is part of Idi – Ape land but the Appellant did not prove exclusive title to Jadefo Compound and how his family came about being exclusively entitled to Jadefo Compound through credible evidence.
The trial Court rightly preferred the Respondents? version of how the Appellant came about to occupy part of the Jadefo Compound and I cannot fault same. I resolve the first issue against the appellant.
The appellant in his second issue challenged the trial Court?s evaluation of the evidence before it in concluding that Balogun Alanamu granted the land at Jadefo to the progenitor of the respondents.
The Appellant alleged that there was no pleading and evidence in support and that the name of the Balogun was not given by the Respondents, but at page 104 of the printed records of appeal, the Respondents in paragraphs 24, 25, and 26 pleaded how they got to be in Jadefo Compound.
24. The Defendants avers that Sulyman is the first settler in Jadefo Compound who was settled there by Balogun Alanamu who allocated land in that Area of Ilorin.
25. It was Sulyman that gave birth to Yusuf who gave birth to the following:
1. Iya Ile Palaere
2. Mariam
3. Alfa Memudu
4. Aishat
5. Sambo
All of the above except No. 5 have their descendants living.
26. The Defendants avers that it was during the reign of Alfa Memudu, as the Magaji Jadefo that Suberu Ajadi the progenitor of the claimants was admitted to Jadefo Compound.
Part of the evidence in support of the above pleadings is at page 113 of the printed records, in paragraphs 4 and part of 5 (statement on oath of the 2nd Respondent) it was stated thus:
4. Balogun Alanamu is the Customary Head of Alanamu ward which include Ita – Ogunbo where we have our compound. Our Great grandfather called Sulaiman is the first person to live in Jadefo compound and he is the one the place was given by the then Balogun Alanamu.
5. Alfa Memudu is the father of 1st Defendant and my Grandfather. He is a native of Ilorin born and brought up in Jadefo Compound, Ita Ogunbo, Ilorin.
The evidence above was not challenged under cross-examination and no contrary evidence was adduced to controvert these pieces of evidence as rightly argued by the learned counsel to the Respondents. Also, since these pieces of evidence were not challenged, they need no further proof. In the case of KAYILI VS. YILBUK & ORS (2015) LPELR 24323 (SC) at P. 36, PARA. A., his Lordship Ogunbiyi, JSC simply gave the effect of an unchallenged/uncontroverted evidence thus:
”The law is trite and enjoins a Court to act on an unchallenged evidence.”
Similarly, in OMOREGBE VS. LAWANI (1980) LPELR 2655 (SC) P. 16, PARAS A – D, where his Lordship Idigbe, JSC held that:
”where evidence given by a party to any proceedings was not challenged by the opposite party who had the opportunity to do so, it is always open to the Court seised of the proceedings to act on the unchallenged evidence before it (see ODULAJA VS. HADDAD (1973) 11 S.C. P. 35; NIGERIAN MARITIME SERVICES LTD VS. ALHAJI BELLO AFOLABI (1978) 2 S.C. 78 at 81 – 82; see also the Privy Council on the Nigerian case of ADEL BOSHALI VS. ALLIED COMMERCIAL EXPORTERS LTD (1961) ALL NLR 917 per lord Guest).” See alsoESENE VS. STATE (2017) LPELR 41912 (SC).
From the reliefs sought by the Appellant at the trial Court, title of the land claimed with the buildings in Jadefo Compound is in issue. For the Appellant to succeed, he must prove exclusive title to the Jadefo (compound) also partly occupied by the Respondents. He must succeed on the strength of his case. No doubt the appellant occupied part of the Jadefo Compound but has not proved through evidence how he got to the compound, and who gave him and his Jadefo/Are family the entire compound they are claiming to be exclusively theirs. The Appellant claimed through Alfa Memudu, whereas the Respondents pleaded and led evidence to the effect that their progenitor was Sulaiman, the grandfather of Alfa Memudu and that Sulaiman was the first to live in Jadefo Compound, having been given the land by Balogun Alanamu. Sulaiman had Yusuf who had Alfa Memudu and it was proved by the Respondents (the trial Court preferred their version of the story as more reliable) that they are the grandchildren of Yusuf and that they are not related to the Appellant but granted the Appellant’s progenitor the portion the Appellant occupies.
The Appellant was unable to prove exclusive title to the land in Jadefo Compound as to entitle him to an order of perpetual injunction or restraining order against the respondents as well as any declaratory relief as sought but is entitled to claim ownership of his houses in the Jadefo Compound same having been granted to their progenitor, while the Respondents also remain in their houses in the same Jadefo Compound as rightly held by the learned trial judge and are free to improve or renovate their mud houses, pages 290 – 291 of the printed records of appeal. I cannot fault the conclusion of the learned trial judge that the Appellant failed to prove his claim. The Appellant’s second issue fails and is resolved against him.
Having resolved the appellant’s issues against him, I hold that the appeal fails and is hereby dismissed. I affirm the decision of the learned trial judge dismissing the Appellant’s claim.
CROSS-APPEAL
The background facts to the cross appeal are the same as the main appeal. The Respondents/Cross Appellants were also unhappy with the decision of the Kwara State High Court of 26th September, 2016 in which the counter – claim was dismissed.
A sole issue was distilled for the determination of the Cross Appeal thus:
”Whether the trial Court was right to have refused to grant the counter – claim of the Respondents.?
On the part of the Cross Respondents, a sole issue was distilled as follows:
Whether or not the trial Court was not right to have dismissed the Cross – Appellants’ counter – claim.?
The Cross Appellants’ brief of argument was filed with the Respondent?s brief filed on 13/2/18, paragraphs 6.0 – 7.0 of the brief. The learned counsel to the Cross Appellants A.A. Katibi, relied on the said brief of argument as well as the reply brief filed on 21/3/18 with the Respondents’ brief in the main appeal in which a preliminary objection was raised and argued. We were urged to uphold the preliminary objection and allow the cross-appeal. It was submitted that the Cross Appellants led credible and believable evidence, with which the trial Court was in agreement, in proof of their counter-claim which the trial Court ought to have granted, reference was made to the finding of the trial Court at page 286, lines 21 – 26 of the printed records of appeal to the effect that the trial Court had found the story of the Cross Appellants more realistic and believable as to how their progenitors came to the land. Also, as to how Elewuro compound was changed to Jadefo Compound, the Cross Appellants’ version was believed, pages 288 – 289 of the records (lines 1 – 13 and lines 1 – 13 respectively). Further, on how the Cross Respondent got to Jadefo Compound, the Cross Appellants’ version was said to have been believed, page 287 of the records, lines 20 – 25.
It was submitted that the Cross Respondent did not know anybody in the history of Jadefo Compound beyond Alfa Memudu. It was argued that it is uncontroverted evidence that Alfa Memudu was not the first settler in Jadefo Compound, he had Yusuf and his grandfather was Sulaiman, the first settler. It was argued that the fact that Alfa Memudu granted possession of the land to Suberu Ajadi (Baba – Oko) through Yahaya Olola was uncontroverted and that there was no other requirement to prove customary tenancy. See YAKUBU AUTA VS. ABDULMUMINI LIMAN & ORS (2014) LPELR 22570 (CA). Further, that by the nature of the parties’ co – existence, recognition of the Cross Appellants’ rights to the title of the property was the only incidence of the tenancy. It was argued that by the present action, the Cross Respondent has denied the Cross Appellants’ rights, thus the claim for forfeiture of his tenancy right by the Cross Appellants. See CHIEF THOMAS OKPALA & ORS VS. M.U. OKPU & ORS (2003) LPELR 2513 (SC). We were urged to set aside part of the judgment of the trial Court refusing the counter claim of the Cross Appellants and instead grant the reliefs sought therein.
The Cross Respondent’s brief of argument was argued with the Appellant’s reply brief filed on 5/3/18. In response to the Cross Appeal, the learned counsel to the Cross Respondent Salman Jawondo, relied on his brief of argument filed on 5/3/18, in urging us to dismiss the cross appeal and strike out the preliminary objection which should have been argued in the Respondents’/Cross Appellants’ brief of argument. In arguing his sole issue, it was submitted that the cross appellants failed to prove their counter claim while the cross respondent proved his claim. It was submitted that the Cross Appellants did not prove title to Jadefo/Are Compound, and the trial Court was right to dismiss their counter claim. See HRH MOMOH VS. HRH UMORU (2011) 6 – 7 SC (PT. 1) 80 at 109. Further, that the Cross Appellants’ case is full of contradictions in that the Cross Appellants claimed that the founder of Jadefo/Are Compound was Suleman while the DW1 and DW2 claimed that the founder was Alfa Memudu Offa, which destroyed the Cross Appellants’ claim, thus failure to prove their root of title and cannot therefore claim acts of possession.
See UKAEGBU VS. NWOLOLO (2009) 1 – 2 SC (PT. 1) 21 at 42, OSU VS. NWADIALO (2008) ALL FWLR (PT. 409) 479 at 497, 499 and AJIKANLE VS. YUSUF (2009) ALL FWLR (PT. 475) 1712 at 1745. It was concluded that the Cross Appellants having failed to prove their title to Jadefo/Are Compound, their claim for forfeiture was rightly refused by the trial Court.
In the Cross Appellant’s reply brief filed on 21/3/18, a preliminary objection was raised and argued challenging the competence of the main appeal in that the Notice of Appeal upon which the main appeal was founded upon is incompetent. The Grounds for the objection were as follows:
1. All the grounds of Appeal upon which the Notice of Appeal stands are grounds of fact and mixed law and fact which requires the leave of Court.
2. No leave either of the trial Court or of this Court was sought and obtained before the appeal was filed.
In a nutshell, it was argued that in the main appeal, the grounds of appeal were of mixed law and fact and or fact alone and that the appellant ought to have applied for the leave of the trial Court or this Court, in line with the provisions of Sections 241 and 242 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, (as amended). We were urged to dismiss the main appeal as no valid issue can be formulated from an incompetent notice of appeal and decide only the cross appeal.
The Cross Appellants’ reply brief is a re-argument of the cross-appeal, therefore I would not review it again.
It is trite that where a preliminary objection is raised, same must be looked into and resolved first before the substantive matter if need be. The essence of a preliminary objection to the hearing of an Appeal is to bring the hearing of the Appeal to an end for being incompetent or fundamentally defective. Therefore, a successful preliminary objection terminates the appeal. When the Appellant is served with a preliminary objection, the appellant is expected to respond in his reply brief. See GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY VS. AKANDE & ORS (2010) LPELR 9356 (SC), OGIDI VS. EGBA (1999) NWLR (PT. 621) P. 42 and PLASTEX (NIG) LTD VS. MAINLAND OIL & GAS (2018) LPELR 43509 (CA) P. 14, PARAS. A – C. This simply means that a preliminary objection when raised offers the appellant (in the case of an objection to the competence of an appeal) an opportunity to respond in a reply brief. The preliminary objection in this case was raised and argued by the Cross Appellants challenging the competence of the main appeal where they were respondents.
The preliminary objection was argued in the Respondents Cross Appellants’ reply brief filed on 21/3/18, along with the reply brief to the argument of the Appellant/Cross Respondent. Clearly, the preliminary objection argued in a reply brief is incompetent because it does not give the other party an opportunity to react to it. Secondly, in this case, the preliminary objection is challenging the main appeal in a reply brief in respect of the Cross Appeal. It is noteworthy that a Cross Appeal is independent of the main appeal. See MAGNA MARITIME SERVICES LTD. & ANOR VS. S.A. OTEJU & ANOR; 14 NWLR (PT. 945) P. 517; (2005) 5 SC (PT. 1) P. 55.
Therefore, the competence of the main appeal cannot be rightly challenged in the cross appeal which is what the Cross Appellants have done. As rightly argued by the learned counsel to the Cross Respondent, the preliminary objection ought to have been raised and argued in the Respondents’ brief in the main appeal. The objection ought to have been raised and argued under the main appeal, having been wrongly raised, it is incompetent and it is hereby struck out.
With the Cross Appeal, the sole issue is: whether the trial Court was right to have refused to grant the counter – claim of the Respondents’ It is apt at this stage to point out that a counter claim is by itself, a substantive action which must be proved to the satisfaction of the Court for a counter claimant to be entitled to judgment. In OGBONNA VS. A.G. IMO STATE & ORS (1992) LPELR 2287 (SC) P. 33, PARAS. B – G, his Lordship Nnaemeka – Agu, JSC at P. 33, PARAS. B – G in defining the nature of a counter – claim held thus:
”I believe it has been settled by several decided cases that a counter-claim is to all intentents and purposes a separate action, although the defendant, for convenience and speed, usually joins it with his defence where a Court so grants leave. Indeed, not only can a defendant apply for summary judgment on his counter-claim but also a plaintiff may counter-claim on defendant’s counter claim. (See RENTON GIBBS & CO. VS. NEVILLE (1990) 2 Q.B. 818).”
See also OROJA & ORS VS. ADENIYI & ORS (2017) LPELR 41985(SC), PP. 11 – 13, PARAS. E – B and MUDA ANWOYI & ORS VS. JOHN BANKOLE SHODEKE & ORS (2006) LPELR 502 (SC) P. 17, PARA. B; (2006) 13 NWLR (PT. 996) P. 34; (2006) 6 SC. P. 38.
The Cross Appellants by their claim are claiming exclusive ownership of Jadefo Compound and that the Cross Respondent should give up the portion occupied by him and his family to the Cross Appellants. It is therefore the duty of the cross appellants to prove their entitlement to the exclusive ownership of the Jadefo Compound. The learned counsel to the Appellant/Cross Respondent rightly argued that where a party seeking a declaration of title found his root of title on grant by another person or source, unless the title of the alleged grantor is admitted by the adversary, the party must prove the title of his alleged grantor.
The Cross Appellants who relied on traditional evidence had the duty to prove how the land was found and by who, the history of the devolution of the land till it got to them as well as how they are entitled to exclusive ownership without the cross respondent’s presence on the land/Jadefo Compound. No doubt the Cross Respondent has been occupying part of the Jadefo Compound and gave an account of how he and his family got there but failed to prove his exclusive title to the entire Jadefo Compound which does not mean automatic grant of title to the Cross Appellants, who were defendants in the main claim; each claim is independent of the other. The Cross Appellants as counter-claimants must succeed on the strength of their case.
The evidence led by the cross appellants is that their progenitor gave land within Jadefo Compound to the Cross Respondents to occupy. The Cross Appellants alleged that the Cross Respondent is their tenant in Jadefo Compound but, no evidence was led to prove that the Cross Respondent’s progenitor was a tenant to the Cross Appellants’ progenitor, there was no evidence of any type of tenancy between the Cross Respondent’s progenitor or family and the Cross Respondents’ progenitor or family which would have given rise to forfeiture of the Cross Respondent’s tenancy right. The learned trial judge was right to have held that the historical evidence given by the Cross Respondents did not show that the Cross Respondent’s progenitor paid rent or tribute to the progenitor of the Cross Appellants, at page 290 of the printed records of appeal, where the learned trial judge also rightly held as follows:
”I therefore hold that the two family (sic) comprising the Jadefo Compound are occupying their respective houses and shops as of right without evidence of one descendant having superiority over the other on their present respective houses and properties. The two families have right to their possession, to live a dignified life within the compound without one disallowing the other from exercising their respective right of ownership of the portion of the compound they are occupying…. The uncontroverted facts are that the compound was first known as Ile-Elewuro then Jadefo and later Jadefo Are to show that there are two unrelated families living within that compound.”
I cannot fault the correct view of the learned trial judge. Since the Cross Appellants did not prove that the Cross Respondent’s progenitor was a tenant in Jadefo compound, a challenge of the ownership of his landlord as alleged, could not have arisen. The learned trial judge was also right to have held thus:
”There is no evidence before me also upon which this Court can order the claimant to vacate their houses in Jadefo Compound and hand over possession to the defendant.”
The counter claim was bare to say the least, as there was no evidence in support of it to warrant the Cross Respondent to quit the Jadefo Compound and give up possession to the Cross Appellants. I hold that the Cross Respondent has every right to remain in possession of his part of the Jadefo Compound.
The Cross Appeal is without merit, I dismiss it. The judgment of the learned trial judge dismissing the counter claim is hereby affirmed.
The parties are to bear their respective costs.
HAMMA AKAWU BARKA, J.C.A.: I agree
BOLOUKUROMO MOSES UGO, J.C.A.: I agree
Appearances:
Salman Jawondo with him, Abdulrasheed Isiaka and Abdulrahman IbrahimFor Appellant(s)
A.A. KatibiFor Respondent(s)



