LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

ALHAJI ABDULGAFAR ALARO v. MALLAM IBRAHIM AYINLA JIMBA & ORS (2018)

ALHAJI ABDULGAFAR ALARO v. MALLAM IBRAHIM AYINLA JIMBA & ORS

(2018)LCN/11782(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Thursday, the 28th day of June, 2018

CA/IL/M.16/2018(R)

RATIO

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS SHALL SUBMIT AUTHORITIES THEY SHALL CITE IN THE COURT OF APPEAL  BEFORE THE CASE

As early as possible before the date set down for hearing of any appeal before the Court and in any event not later than two clear days before such date, all the parties or the Legal Practitioners representing them shall forward to the Registrar a list of the law reports, books, and other authorities which parties or legal practitioners representing them intend to cite at the hearing of the appeal. per HAMMA AKAWU BARKA, J.C.A

JUSTICES

CHIDI NWAOMA UWA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

HAMMA AKAWU BARKA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

BOLOUKUROMO MOSES UGO Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

ALHAJI ABDULGAFAR ALARO Appellant(s)

AND

1. MALLAM IBRAHIM AYINLA JIMBA
2. ALHAJI KADIJAT ALUKO
3. MALLAM BABATUNDE AKANBI YUSUF
(Trading under the name and style of Alama Enterprises) Respondent(s)

HAMMA AKAWU BARKA, J.C.A. (Delivering the Lead Ruling): 

By this motion brought on Notice pursuant to Order 8 Rule 18 (1) of the Court of Appeal Rules 2016 and under the inherent jurisdiction of this Court, the 1st Respondent/applicant prayed for order of Court dismissing the appellant/respondent?s Appeal in suit No KWS/123/2009 being a judgment of the Kwara State High Court delivered on the 14/12/2016 coram; S. T. Daibu J, for want of diligent prosecution.

The grounds listed in support of the application are that:
i. The judgment of the lower Court appealed against this appeal was delivered on 14/12/2016 wherein the claims of the 1st Respondent/Applicant as the Claimant before the lower Court were granted.
ii. The Applicant/Respondent being dissatisfied with the decision of the lower Court filed his Notice and Grounds of Appeal against the decision of the 10th day of March, 2017.
iii. On the 10th day of March, 2017 the Appellant/Respondent also applied at the Registry of the lower Court for compilation and transmission of Record of Appeal to the Honorable Court.
?iv. Since the Appellant/Respondent filed his Notice of Appeal and letter for compilation and transmission of Record of Appeal he has not taken any further step towards the compilation and transmission of Record of Appeal to the Honorable Court.

In support of the application is an affidavit of six paragraphs deposed to by one Hamzat Fatimah Dasola, secretary in the law firm of A. R. Aminu and company, a firm of legal practitioners engaged by the applicant. Material to the present application is paragraph 4 of the said affidavit which reproduced are as follows:
a. That the judgment of the lower Court appealed against in this appeal was delivered on 14/12/2016 wherein the claims of the 1st Respondent/Applicant as the Claimant before the lower Court were granted. Certified True Copy of the judgment of the lower Court is attached and marked as Exhibit ?A?.
b. That the Appellant/Respondent being dissatisfied with the decision of the lower Court filed his Notice and Grounds of Appeal against the decision of the lower Court on the 10th day of March, 2017. Certified True Copy of the Notice and Grounds of Appeal is attached and marked Exhibit ?B?.

c. That on the 10th day of March, 2017 the Appellant/Respondent also wrote a letter to the Registrar of the lower Court for compilation and transmission of Record of Appeal to the Honorable Court. The said letter is attached and marked Exhibit ?C?.
d. That since the Appellant/Respondent filed his Notice and Grounds of Appeal and letter for compilation and transmission of Record of Appeal he did not take further step towards the prosecution of his appeal rather on 28/11/2017 he filed a motion on notice for stay of execution of the judgment of the lower Court which motion was not in the Court file as at 6th day of February, 2018. A copy of the Motion on Notice served on 1st Respondent/Applicant through his counsel on 28th day of November, 2017 is attached and marked as Exhibit ?D?.
e. That the Motion on Notice referred to in the preceding paragraph was hurriedly filed when the 1st Respondent/Applicant took steps towards enforcement of the judgment of the lower Court by the issuance and pasting of writ of possession on the property the subject matter of this suit.
f. That from the inquiry from Registrar (Appeal) of the lower Court (Mr. Bunmi Edundiran) at the High Court Registry, Ilorin on 6th day of February, 2018 at 10:30am he was informed that the Appellant/Respondent had not deposited money for compilation Record of Appeal.
g. That the Rules of the Honorable Court provide that the Record of Appeal shall be compiled by the lower Court and transmitted within 60 days from the date the Notice and Grounds of Appeal is/was filed, that is, 11/03/2017-09/05/2017.
h. That if the Registrar of the lower Court failed or neglected to compile the Record of Appeal, the Appellant shall compile the Record of Appeal within 30 days after the Registrar of lower Court has failed to so compile, that is, 10/05/2017-08/06/2017.
i. That 90 days provided for both Registrar of lower Court and Appellant/Respondent to compile and transmit Record of Appeal to this Honorable Court lapsed on 08/06/2017 without the Record of Appeal been compiled and transmitted to this Honorable Court.
j. That the Rules of the Honorable Court provide for the Applicant/Respondent to apply for dismissal of the Appeal.
k. That the Appellant/Respondent is not interested in the prosecution of his appeal, but wants to frustrate the 1st Respondent/Applicant from reaping the fruit of the judgment given in his favor.
l. That the Appellant/Respondent is not residing in the property, the subject matter of this suit, but rented them to rent paying tenants and has been collecting rent from them despite the judgment of the lower Court.

Also hinged on the application papers are the following exhibits titled as;
Exhibits A, the judgment of the lower Court in suit No. KWS/123/2009, delivered on the 14th of December, 2016.
Exhibit B, a Notice of Appeal against the decision of the lower Court in suit no. KWS/123/2009, between; Alhaji Abdulgafar Alaro and Mallam Ibrahim Ayinla Jimba and 2 ors, dated and filed on the 10/03/2017;
Exhibit C, a document titled Application for Compilation, Production and Transmission of record of Appeal in suit No. KWS/123/2009, Mallam Ibrahim Ayinla Jimba vs. Alhaja Kadijat Aluko and 2 ors dated the 13th of March, 2017, and
Exhibit D, a motion on notice filed on the 28|11|17 seeking for order of stay of execution of the judgment of the lower Court, in suit No. Kws/123/2009, delivered on the 14th of December, 2016.

In opposing the application, the appellant/respondent filed a counter-affidavit of 15 paragraphs deposed to by Abdulrahman Ibrahim, a legal practitioner in the law firm of Jawondo and company, the law firm representing the Appellant/Respondent.

Paragraphs 3 – 4 of the counter-affidavit being material, are reproduced thus:
3. That I know that the judgment of the lower Court, the subject of the appellant/respondent?s Appeal was delivered on the 14th day of December, 2016 which judgment is exhibit A attached to the applicant?s application.
4. That dissatisfied with the judgment of the lower Court, the appellant/respondent by a Notice of Appeal filed at the Registry of the lower Court on 10th day of March, 2017 appealed to this Court which Notice of Appeal is exhibit B attached to the applicant?s application.
5. That while it is true that the appellant/respondent has not produced and transmitted the Record of Appeal in this case to the Court within the maximum of 90 days allowed to by the Rules of the Court, the failure is not deliberate, but due to unexpected health problems experienced and still being experienced by the appellant/respondent.
6. That shortly before the delivery of judgment of the lower Court the appellant/respondent was already experiencing some health challenges which was eventually diagnosed as diabetics couple with hypertension.
7. That even though the appellant/respondent instructed his counsel to appeal the judgment he could not perfect the instruction as result of his health challenges which took and is still taking its toll on his financial and physical capabilities and capacities.
8. That I know that the appellant/respondent?s lead counsel, Ayinla Jawondo Salman Esq., on compassionate ground, prepared and filed the Notice of Appeal as aforesaid so as to prevent the appellant/respondent being out of time.
9. That I know that in anticipation that the appellant/respondent would recover in good time, the appellant/respondent?s counsel wrote a letter dated 13th day of March, 2017 directed to Deputy Chief Registrar seeking for compilation, production and transmission of Record of Appeal which letter is exhibit C attached to the applicant?s motion.
10. That I know that due to his health challenges the appellant/respondent could not meet the financial expenses required for the production and transmission of the Record of Appeal in this case until a friend of the appellant/respondent by name Abdul-Rahaman Ayinde came to his aid in January, 2018 by depositing the funds with our firm for delivery to the Registry of the Court below.
11. That following the payment to the Registry of the Court below of the money required for the Record, the Registry of the Court below commenced work of the producing the Record which is still ongoing but being hampered by difficulties being experienced in reading and understanding the manuscript of the learned trial Judge.
12. That I know that the Motion on Notice filed before the lower Court for stay of execution and injunction pending appeal filed on behalf of the appellant/applicant(attached to the applicant?s application as exhibit D) was part of the compassionated steps taken by the appellant/applicant?s lead counsel to prevent the property in dispute from being caused to be demolished by the applicant.
13. That the failure to cause to be produced and transmitted and or produce and transmit the Record of Appeal to the Court within the time stipulated by the rules of the Court was not a deliberate act of either the appellant/respondent and his counsel but as a result of health challenges which has and is still having devastating effects on the appellant/applicant physically, financially, psychologically and mentally.
14. That I know that it is in the interest of justice to refuse this application and the applicant/respondent will not be prejudiced by the refusal of this application.

On the 30th of May, 2018 when this application came up for hearing, Mr. Kamaldeen Isiaka for the applicant identified his application filed on the 8th of February, 2018 and the processes accompanying the application. He specifically drew the Court?s attention to paragraphs 4(a)-(l) of the affidavit in support which he submits were not countered, and remaining unchallenged in urging the Court to grant the application dismissing the Appeal, for want of prosecution.

Mr. Jawondo for the appellant/respondent also drew the Court?s attention to the counter-affidavit filed by him, stating that the records could not be filed in time due to the ill-health of the appellant. That the fees for the collection of the records having been paid to the registry, the inability to transmit the records is no more that of the appellant, but that of the registry. In the alternative, learned counsel who had earlier complained that the handwriting of the lower Court was not easily comprehended, prayed under Order 21 of the Rules of this Court that the rules of the Court with regards to compilation of records should be waived and the Court to refuse the application by the applicant.

I have given careful consideration to the submissions of both learned counsel, the affidavit evidence and the exhibits annexed thereto. The application to me calls for determination, the provisions of Order 8 Rule 1, 4 and 18 of the rules of this Court as well as Order 20 Rule 2, 3 and 4 of the same Rules, and whether this Court should in the circumstance, dismiss the appeal before it. The enumerated rules are produced hereunder for clarity:
Order 8 Rule 1
The registrar of the Court below shall within sixty days after the filing of a notice of appeal compile and transmit the Record to the Court.

Order 8 Rule 4
Where at the expiration of 60 days after the filing of the notice of appeal the registrar has failed and or neglected to compile and transmit the Records of Appeal in accordance with the preceding provisions of this Rule, it shall become mandatory for the Appellant to compile and transmit to the Court within 30 days after the registrar?s failure or neglect.
Order 8 Rule 18
If the registrar has failed to compile and transmit the Records under Rule 1 and the appellant has also failed to compile and transmit the Records in accordance with Rule 4, the Respondent may by notice of motion move the Court to dismiss the appeal.
Order 20 Rule 2
The Court may direct a departure from these Rules in anywhere this is required in the interest of justice.
Order 20 Rule 3
(1) The Court may, in an exceptional circumstance, and where it considers it in the interest of justice so to do, waive compliance by the parties with these Rules or any part thereof.
(2) Where there is such waiver of compliance with the Rules, the Court may, in such manner as it thinks right, direct the Appellant or the Respondent as the case may be, to remedy such non-compliance or may, notwithstanding, order the appeal to proceed or give such directions as it considers necessary in the circumstance.
(3) The Registrar shall forthwith notify the Appellant or the Respondent as the case may be of such order or directions given by the Court under this Rule where the Appellant or the Respondent was not present at the time when such order was made or directions were given.
Order 20 Rule 4
As early as possible before the date set down for hearing of any appeal before the Court and in any event not later than two clear days before such date, all the parties or the Legal Practitioners representing them shall forward to the Registrar a list of the law reports, books, and other authorities which parties or legal practitioners representing them intend to cite at the hearing of the appeal.
A combined reading of Order 8 Rule 1 and 4, makes provision for the time within which the records of appeal may be compiled. It provides for 60 days for the registry, and a further but mandatory period of 30 days, for the appellant to compile and to transmit the records, should the registry default in doing so. Rule 18, goes on to prescribe the penalty for failure to adhere to the provisions of Rules 1 and 4 of Order 8, which is the dismissal of the appeal. See Uyaemenan Nworah & ors vs. Nweke Nwabueze & ors (2011) 15 NWLR (pt. 1271) 467, Registered Trustees of Tipping Trailers Owners Union & Anor vs. Nigerian Union of Mine Workers (2013) LPELR 20200 CA. First Bank Plc vs. Yerima & ors (2017) LPELR 43125 CA, Nigeria Postal Service vs. Alfred Ezekiel Idioho (2013) LPELR 20820 CA.

In the instant case, and from the averments made by both the applicant and the respondent, it is certain that both the registry of the lower court as well as the appellant have defaulted in the compilation and transmission of the records of appeal from the time the Notice of Appeal was filed on the 10th of March, 2017 to date. It is also evident as can be seen therefrom that the 90 days allowed by law has since lapsed, with no visible effort from the appellants towards the compilation of the records. I am not unaware of the respondents averments seeking to advance reasons for the non – compilation and transmission of the records, hinged on ill health and other challenges hampering the compilation of the records.

The question rightly agitating the mind of this Court is, whether the discretion of the Court could to be exercised in granting the application and thereby dismissing the appeal, going by the entire circumstance of the facts established by affidavit evidence, in spite of the plea by the respondent to the contrary. This calls for a judicious consideration of the facts laid before the Court. I do agree with the applicants that the facts enumerated by them in their affidavit in support remained unchallenged, equally going by the averments in the respondents counter affidavit, it is not shown how his failure to transmit the records, can be addressed, having failed to do so as stipulated by the rules of Court. Indeed even his plea to be allowed to proceed under Order 21 of the rules of this Court, for the waiving of the rules as to the compilation of the records, is hounded by his oral submission to the effect that the handwriting of the trial Judge cannot be understood/deciphered regardless of the fact that exhibit A relied upon by the applicant and the respondent, being the judgment of the said Court was reproduced by the applicant.

The application for the alternative prayer to my mind would not assist the respondent, in such circumstance. My consideration of the facts establishes a clear disinclination by the appellant of timeously compiling and transmitting the record of appeal, and thus the prosecution of same. It is in that consideration that I feel the exercise of discretion in favor of the respondent, will be a discretion exercised in vain. Consequently, and from my consideration of all the facts before the Court, I hold the view that the application ought to and is hereby granted, dismissing the appellant/respondents appeal, filed against the judgment of the lower Court in Appeal No. CA/IL/M.16/2018, and filed on the 10th of March, 2017, for want of diligent prosecution. Where the respondent feels or is ready to assume the prosecution of the appeal, he is at liberty to employ or utilize the window granted by the provision of Order 8 Rule 20 of the rules of this Court.
Costs of twenty thousand naira only awarded to the Respondent/applicant.

?CHIDI NWAOMA UWA, J.C.A.: I read in advance the draft of the Ruling delivered by my learned brother, HAMMA AKAWU BARKA, JCA. I agree with his reasoning and conclusion arrived at in dismissing the appellant/respondents’ appeal for want of diligent prosecution. I abide by the order made as to costs.

BOLOUKUROMO MOSES UGO, J.C.A. J.C.A.: I was privileged to read in advance the ruling of my learned brother HAMMA AKAWU BARKA, JCA, and agreement with him on his reasoning and conclusion. I also grant the application and abide by all the consequential orders made by my brother including that as to cost

Appearances:

Isiaka Kamaldeen, Esq.For Appellant(s)

Salman Jawondo, Esq. with him, N. A. Sulyman, Esq. and Abdul-Rasheed Isiaka, Esq.For Respondent(s)

 

Appearances

Isiaka Kamaldeen, Esq.For Appellant

 

AND

Salman Jawondo, Esq. with him, N. A. Sulyman, Esq. and Abdul-Rasheed Isiaka, Esq.For Respondent