LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

ELDER P.E. BIKO & ANOR v. SIR UCHE AMAECHI & ORS (2018)

ELDER P.E. BIKO & ANOR v. SIR UCHE AMAECHI & ORS

(2018)LCN/11760(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Wednesday, the 25th day of July, 2018

CA/OW/141/2014

RATIO

WHERE A DEFENDANT HAS NO COUNTER-CLAIM EVEN WHERE THE PLAINTIFF’S CLAIM FAILS

Where a plaintiff’s claim in an action fails and the defendant has no counter-claim, the defendant is not entitled to any declaration in his favour. per AYOBODE OLUJIMI LOKULO-SODIPE, J.C.A

JUSTICES

RAPHAEL CHIKWE AGBO Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

AYOBODE OLUJIMI LOKULO-SODIPE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

TUNDE OYEBANJI AWOTOYE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

  1. ELDER P.E. BIKO
    2. BRO. J.U. OBIA
    (For themselves and as
    representing the members of
    Dikeukwu Village in Ekenobizi
    Umuopara Umuahia) Appellant(s)

 

AND

  1. SIR UCHE AMAECHI
    2. CHIDI OKOROAFOR
    – 1ST SET OF RESPONDENTS
    (For themselves and as
    representing the members of
    Umuofoukwu Village of
    Dikenta Ekenobizi Umuopara)

AND

  1. FUGBARA JOHN
    2. IKECHI KONKWO
    3. CHIEF UWAGBOKWU
    – 2ND SET OF RESPONDENTS
    (For themselves and as
    representing the members Ngodo in Ehume in
    Umuopara) Respondent(s)

AYOBODE OLUJIMI LOKULO-SODIPE, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment):

The appeal is against the judgment delivered on 23/9/2013 by the High Court of Abia State, holden at the Umuahia Judicial Division presided over by Hon. Justice K.O. Wosu (hereafter to be simply referred to as the lower Court and learned trial Judge respectively). The instant case was instituted by the claimants (now described as 1st Set of Respondents in the instant appeal) for themselves and in a representative capacity against the 1st  3rd Defendants (now described as the 2nd Set of Respondents in the instant appeal) for themselves and in a representative capacity; and the 4th and 5th Defendants (now described as the Appellants in the instant appeal) for themselves and in a representative capacity. The claims of the 1st Set of Respondents against the 2nd Set of Respondents and Appellants, jointly and as contained in the writ of summons by which the action was commenced and the statement of claim dated 24/2/2011 but filed on 25/2/2011 read thus: –
1. A declaration that the claimants are entitled to the right of occupancy of a piece or parcel of land situate and lying in an area of land traditionally known as and called Ovoro Umuofoukwu in Umuofoukwu Dikenta Ekenobizi Umuopara in Umuahia South L.G.A Abia State, Nigeria within the jurisdiction of the Court with an annual rental value of N10.00.
2. The sum of N450, 000.00 (Four Hundred and fifty thousand Naira) being damages for trespass into the aforesaid piece or parcel of land in the possession and occupation of the claimant (SIC).
3. An injunction permanently restraining the defendants, their servants, agents and/or their workmen from trespassing into the said piece or parcel of land or interfering with it in any manner whatsoever.

The 2nd Set of Respondents who were sued for themselves and as representing the members of Ngodo in Umuopara Umuahia, in their amended statement of defence dated 2/2/2012 and filed on the same date, controverted the case of the 1st Set of Respondents and not only denied the entitlement of the said 1st Set of Respondents to the reliefs which they sought against them, but also counter-claimed against the 1st Set of Respondents as follows:

  1. A declaration that the 1st to 3rd defendant are entitled to the statutory right of occupancy of the piece or parcel of land traditionally known as and called Ovoro Ngodo verged red in the survey plan No. LD/MGZ/004/2012 filed with the statement of defence which is situate at Ngodo village, Ehume Umuopara in Umuahia South LGA Abia State of Nigeria within the jurisdiction of this Court.
    b. The sum of one million (N1, 000,000.00) being general damages for trespass into the aforesaid piece or parcel of land which is in the peaceable possession and occupation of the 1st 3rd defendant.
    c. An injunction permanently restraining the claimant relations, their servants, agents, and or workmen from further trespassing to the said piece or parcel of land or interfering with it in any manner whatsoever.

The Appellants who were sued for themselves and as representing the members of Dikeukwu village in Ekenobizi Umuopara Umuahia contested the case on their amended statement of defence dated 17/1/2012 and filed on the same date. Therein they controverted the case of the 1st Set of Respondents and denied the entitlement of the said 1st Set of Respondents to the reliefs which they sought against them. However the Appellants did not counter-claim against any of the other parties. Having set out and considered the various issues set out for determination in the case by the Defendants (i.e. the 2nd Set of Respondents and Appellants herein), the lower Court stated as follows in its judgment: –
I have carefully considered the state of pleadings of all the parties, their cases in the light of evidence adduced, the issues formulated and canvassed in the submission made by learned counsel on their behalf.
I therefore decline to treat their separate defence as contradiction in the case of the defendants but as separate defence from the 1st 3rd defendants for themselves and as representing the members of Umuofoukwu village of Dikenta Ekenobizi Umuopara and the 4th 5th defendants for themselves and as representing the members of Dikeukwu village in Ekenobizi Umuopara Umuahia.

It is settled that traditional evidence is one of the five recognized ways of proving title to land in Nigeria. It is also the law that a party claiming title to land is not bound to plead and prove more than one root of title to succeed. If however, he relied on more than one root of title, he may be said to have done so to make assurance doubly sure. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx In the instant case, the claimants, the 1st 3rd defendants and the 4th 5th defendants all pleaded and relied on evidence of traditional history in proof of title to the land in dispute. However among the defendants only the 1st 3rd defendants hereafter referred to as the 1st set of defendants filed a counter claim against the claimant (sic) and the 4th 5th defendants or hereafter called the 2nd set of the defendants. It is pertinent to state now that both the claimants and the 1st set of defendants/counter claimants have same burden of proof in this case much higher than that of the 2nd set of defendants who did not file a counter claim. The law is that a counter claim has the incidents of a separate suit and it treated as such both in matters of evidence and proof. xxxxxxxxxxxx I agree because that is the state of the law. From the foregoing, the first issue for determination is to find which of the traditional histories adduced by the parties in this suit is more probable. In doing so, the Court will consider what a claimant needs to prove and plead in evidence of traditional history as enunciated in Obioha V Duru (1994) 10 SCNJ 48 at 61 which are;
i. How the land was founded
ii. The person who founded and exercised acts of possession
iii. The person or (sic: on) whom the title in respect of the land devolved since its founding in resolving the issues as formulated by the Court, all the other issues canvassed by the parties will be resolved as well.
Before proceedings (sic) let me state that from the pleadings of the claimants and defendants including evidence by the parties on record, the land in dispute is well known to the parties, the parties only disagree on the actual boundaries and features on the land in dispute. The visit by the Court to the locus on 18-1-13 finally settled the issue that the land in dispute is well known to the parties.
From the review of the pleadings of the parties, evidence adduced by their witness including their suit plan, I hold that the claimants and the 1st and 2nd sets of defendants materially contradicted their evidence of traditional history as pleaded under cross-examination by their witness particularly with respect to the founder of the land in dispute which the parties call different names. It is trite law that land in dispute may be called different names in same community. The claimants call it Ovoro Umuofoukwu, the first set of the defendants call it Ovoro Ngodo while the 2ndset of defendants called it Ovoro Omaegwu. Inability of each of these parties to adduce credible traditional evidence with respect to their root of title to the land is fatal to the traditional evidence.
Learned SAN for the claimants conceded this fact as well as learned counsel for the 1st and 2ndset (sic) of defendants. On the part of the 1st set of defendants, the learned SAN for the claimants and learned counsel for the 2nd set of defendants demonstrated these aforesaid contradictions on root of title upon their detailed review of the evidence of the witnesses for the 1st set of defendants as stated earlier in this judgment. On the part of the 2nd set of defendants the learned SAN for the claimants and learned counsel for the 1st set of defendants in (sic) also (sic: in) their written address demonstrated the same fact as partly stated earlier in this judgment. I agree with each of them as they are in agreement with the records and I so hold. I therefore find and hold that the star witnesses for the claimants and the two sets of defendants gave conflicting evidence of their root of title to the land in dispute. I hereby treat their said evidence in that regard as unreliable. See MOGAJI V CADBURY NIG. LTD (1985) 2NWLR PT. 7, 393. Having reviewed and tested the evidence of traditional history adduced by the claimants and those of the 1stand 2ndset (sic) of defendants, I have no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that none is probable and conclusive. I therefore pronounce all of them inconclusive.

Having so found, the Court is now at liberty to proceed to the 2nd issue and that is which of the parties has adduced more credible evidence of numerous and positive acts of possession and ownership over the land in dispute. See OBIOHA V DURU (1994) 10 SCNJ 48 at 57. Learned counsel for the 2nd set of defendants and counsel for the 1st set of defendants had argued that the law is clear that the claimants having failed by their admission to establish title through the traditional history which they put forward, they cannot urge the Court to apply the rule in KOJO V BONSIE (1957) 1 WLR 1223 or EKPO V ITA (1932) 34/11 NWLR P.6.
I agree that this is the correct principle of law. But where learned counsel for the defendants missed the point is that the said principle applies where the Court finds the traditional evidence adduced by the other parties or the defendants more credible. Not where as in the instant case, the Court found the traditional evidence adduced by both the 1st set and 2nd set of defendants not probable and inconclusive as stated in this judgment. See IRIRI V ERHURHOBARA (supra) and ALADE V AWO (supra).
Following from the pleadings and evidence adduced by the claimants with respect to numerous acts of possession and ownership over the land in dispute in recent years which include;
1. Evidence of ownership and harvesting of palm fruits on the land in dispute through Cw1 a 70 year old whose evidence that he harvested palm fruits for the claimants on the land in dispute was not challenged and who was consistent under cross-examination that he has been harvesting palm fruits for the claimants for over 20 years ago as a result of old age.
2. Evidence of payment of compensation by NNPC for pipeline across the land in dispute to the claimants supported by their exhibit C.
3. Evidence of the two uncompleted building on the land in dispute which all the parties admit was attracted by HRH Eze Uwanamodu when he was a member of defunct Imo House of Assembly and who is from the claimants. Considering the evidence and submissions for (sic) against who performed the pouring of libation at the foundation laying ceremony of the two buildings.
I hold the evidence of the claimants more probable since parties are agreed that the said building was attracted by the HRH Eze Uwanamodu of the claimants. Besides Dw2 and Dw4 of the 1st set of defendants admitted late Ogubuike Nwosu of the claimants participated in the pouring of libation at the said ceremony. I also hold that the claimants were not bound to call the said Eze as contended by the 1st set of defendants in the light of the admission by witnesses of the defendants. After all, what is admitted need no further proof. Claimants are not bound to call him to prove other relevant issues to their case.
4. The fact of suit No. CC/00/269  Exhibit J of the 1st set of defendants with the claimants. The said suit for all practical purposes is evidence of act of possession and ownership. The claimants pleaded and gave evidence that they had previous litigation over the land in dispute at the customary Court level but the cases were inconclusive and did not result in any judgment.
5. Exhibit B and B1 receipts from broadcasting corporation of Abia State BCA dated 01-02-11 and Radio Corporation of Nigeria dated 1-2-11 respectively which support the pleading and evidence of the claimants that they caused public announcement to be made when they noticed trespassing acts of the 1stset and 2nd set of defendants into the land in dispute.
6. The pleadings and evidence whereby the claimants asserted that the native calcium nzu on the land in dispute is owned by them and that they controlled its mining by persons from within and outside the claimants village.
The 1st set of defendants relied heavily on their so called judgment of the customary Court in 1941 and that of suit No. CC/UO/26/97 delivered on 5th April, 2001 as per their exhibit J. They pleaded same in paragraph 33 of their amended statement of defence. Learned SAN for the claimants and learned counsel for the 2ndset of defendants respectively contended that the said judgment, exhibit J of the 1st set of defendants is not valid. That res judicata was improperly pleaded as stated in AFOLABI V GOV. OSUN STATE (2003) 46 WRN p. 1 at 6. That the judgment of 1941 was not proved by tendering a CTC of same.
I am prepared to concede that the 1st set of defendants captured the requirements of the Afolabis case with respect to parties, the issue and subject matter judgment given by a Court of competent jurisdiction, and that same had finally decided the issues between the parties. The reason is that what they have pleaded is their case and contention with respect to exhibit J. I agree that the 1st set of defendants failed to tender the judgment of 1941 as proof of same and no explanation was offered.
In any case, if there was one in 1941, why did they file the suit that led to exhibit J Why did the claimants according to exhibit J, first sue in 1992 in CC/UM/19/92, CC/UO/2/97 later consolidated as CC/UO/29/97 which led to exhibit J The 1st set of defendants contended that the claimants made a futile attempt to set aside exhibit J before this Court in suit No. HU/44/2011, meaning that the judgment exhibit J subsists which renders the instant suit to be struck out. I however agree fully with the reply of the learned SAN for the claimants and the learned counsel for the 2ndset of the defendants that exhibit J is null and void and no legal effect in as much as it is pleaded as estoppel against this claimants suit. The said customary Court suit was originally filed in 1992 by the claimants and judgments was delivered on 5thApril 2001. The Abia State designation of urban areas order which divested all customary Courts in Abia State of jurisdiction over lands in urban areas came into force in 1998. Also by the same order the whole area covered by this order i.e. Umuahia North and South local governments became urban areas. The said customary Court lost the jurisdiction to proceed with the case, but it proceeded with it. The legal implication is that its judgment thereafter in 2011 as in exhibit J is a nullity. The law is settled that when a Court had jurisdiction over a subject matter at the time of the cause of action (as in this case) but loses jurisdiction before judgment is delivered (as in this case) it cannot entertain such suit. See ADAH V NYSC (2004) 13 NWLR PT. 891 at 647-648, UTIH V ONOYIVWE (1991) 1 SCNJ 25 or see generally Understanding the Concept of Jurisdiction in Nigeria Legal System by Obande Ogbuinya pp 31-35. I hold therefore that exhibit J of the 1st set of defendants is of no moment in this suit. Finally on exhibit J, I must add that this Court did not pronounce on the validity of exhibit J in suit No. HU/44/2011. It was struck out on procedural grounds. I have said so to erase the impression created by the contention of the 1st set of defendants that this Court refused to set aside exhibit J on the merit. The issue having arisen in present suit, where all the parties joined issues on same, I have as the Court is entitled to, considered the argument for and against and made my pronouncement. The claimants did not have to appeal against a null judgment.
The 1st set of defendants pleaded and gave evidence that they were paid compensation by NNPC but they failed to tender any documentary evidence like receipt like the claimants. Here again, the evidence adduced by the claimants on this very important fact is more probable and I believe it. Both counsel for the 1st set and 2nd set of defendants attacked claimants (sic) exhibit C evidencing receipt of the sum of N7096.75 which claimants pleaded in paragraph 8 of their amended reply to the statement of defence of the 2nd set of defendants and given in evidence. The attack on exhibit C by counsel to the 1st set of defendants bothers on forgery of the said documents which is criminal. They ought to have pleaded the particulars of forgery and falsity as required by the rules of pleading.
But this they failed to do but purported to do so through address of counsel. It is settled law that address of counsel is no evidence. In the case of the 2nd set of defendants, they clearly admitted that they were not paid, compensation by NNPC and I do not believe their excuse that it was because they had no cassava at that time. Cassava is certainly not, the only economic crops over which compensation could be paid.
I should make this point that the 1st set of defendants pleaded and tendered Exhibit J which shows that the claimants filed the suit first against them in 1992. Page 4 of exhibit J, paragraph three (3) thereof shows the claimants secured an injunction against the 1stset of defendants part of it read ‘… before the transfer still the plaintiffs claimants) got injunction restraining us (the 1st set of defendants) I am minded that above in (sic) extracted from exhibit J that has been held to be a nullity. But it is a document before this Court which the Court is entitled to peruse in this case but more importantly there is a strong presumption that the record of the said Court shows the claimants obtained the said injunction in August 1992 when the customary Court was fully seized with jurisdiction. It follows that they were in possession of the land in dispute. The law is settled that a claim for trespass and injunction ulates at the plaintiff is in possession in law.

I hold therefore that the foregoing is further evidence of acts of possession of the land in dispute by the claimants. It is also the law that mere disturbance of a party in possession (the claimants in this case) by the two sets of defendant as pleaded and given in evidence by the claimants do not render the said possession not exclusive. The law is also settled that where two person makes conflicting claims to possession of land (as it is the case in this suit), the law ascribes possession to the person that can prove better title to the land. xxxxxxx
I hold that the claimants have proved better title over the land in dispute against the 1st and 2nd set (sic: sets) of defendants.
The visit of the Court to the locus and the observations in the light of features all the parties showed the Court support the features as pleaded and given in evidence by the claimants. Ahi is a stream with a concrete bridge. A stream is a small narrow river whereas a river is a large amount of fresh water flowing continuously in a long, line across land according to BBC English dictionary. In other words, Ahi is a small river. It folIows that Ahi may be carried a river or a stream. Therefore Dw1 and Dw3 of the 1st set of defendants gave false testimony over a matter within the (sic) knowledge when they said under cross-examination, that their in (sic: there is) no bridge over Ahi river or stream whereas there is one. Dw2 of the 1st set of defendants also gave false testimony when he said under cross-exanimation that person can walk past Ahi river whereas the Court’s visit to the locus shows otherwise because there is a concrete bridge across the stream or river. I found too that the said river is the natural boundary between the claimants and the 1st set of defendants who l found reside on the other side of the bridge along the road from Umuahia Owerri tarred road/Umuopara secondary school. Dw4 of the 1st set of defendants said inter alia that his people do not have common boundary with the land in dispute. He also named four persons including Dw3, who own land in the land in dispute contrary to their pleading that the said land is commonly owned. I hold that these witnesses including the Dw3, and the 3rd defendants on record) are star witnesses for the 1st set of defendants. Their evidence under cross-examination as highlighted above leaves no room to ascribe any credibility to them in respect of issues before, the Court. xxxxxx Dw7; Chief Chibuike Iheme and Dw8 elder P. E Biko both of the 2nd set of defendants admitted that the 2nd set of defendants were not paid compensation by NNPC over the land in dispute. These piece of evidence supports the case of the claimants.
(Sic) evidence and balance of probabilities, the claimants have proved that they have title to the land in dispute much more than the defendants. When the claimants evidence on acts of possession and ownership is placed on an imaginary scale, I am satisfied the claimants have adduced a more probable and more credible evidence over and above the two sets of defendants in this. In other words, the scale tilts in favour of the claimants.
This suit therefore succeeds. Judgment is hereby entered, in favour of the claimants against the 1st & 2nd set (sic: sets) of defendants as per reliefs claimed except with respect to their 2nd relief on damages for trespass which is hereby fixed at N200, 000.000 (two hundred thousand naira) only.
The counter claim of the 1stset of defendants fails, it is hereby dismissed.
No order as to costs as the claimants counsel did not apply for any.

Being dissatisfied with the judgment of the lower Court, 2nd Set of Respondents herein (i.e. 1st  3rd Defendants before the lower Court) appealed against the same and the appeal  APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2011  FUGBARA JOHN & ORS V. SIR UCHE AMAECHI & ORS. which was argued on their notice of appeal dated 25/11/2013 and filed on 26/11/2013, was disposed of by this Court on 11/7/2016 with the said appeal being dismissed. The Appellants herein who were (the 2nd Set of Respondents in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2016 and 2nd Set of Respondents before the lower Court) initiated the instant appeal against the same judgment of the lower Court, by filing at the registry of the said Court on 11/12/2013 a notice of appeal bearing the same date. In other words, the instant appeal was lodged after that of the 2nd Set of Respondents herein was lodged.

The notice of appeal lodged against the judgment of the lower Court by the Appellants herein, contains five grounds of appeal and the said grounds shorn of their respective particulars read thus:
GROUNDS OF APPEAL
GROUND 1
ERROR INLAW
The learned trial Judge erred in law when he held that he will treat the evidence of the root of title of the 4th and 5th defendants/appellants (2nd set of defendants) to the land in dispute as unreliable and pronounced same as inconclusive because their star witness gave conflicting evidence on their said root of title.
GROUND 2
ERROR INLAW
The learned trial Judge erred in law when, having found as a fact that the evidence of traditional history of the land in dispute put forward by the claimants and the 1st to 3rd defendants/counter claimants were inconclusive and not probable, he proceeded to consider the parties acts of ownership and possession even when the 4th and 5th defendants did not counterclaim and had no onus of proof in law under thecircumstances of this case.
GROUND 3
ERROR IN LAW
The learned trial Judge erred in law when without proper analysis and evaluation of the evidence adduced by the parties in Court, he held while finding for the claimants, that the acts of ownership and possession pleaded by the claimants were more probable than that of the 4th and 5th defendants and also that the claimants were not bound to call Eze Uwannamodo (sic) who featured prominently in the matter, to give evidence in the light of the admission by the defendants.
GROUND 4
ERROR IN LAW
The learned trial Court erred in law when it entered judgment for the claimants, holding that they have adduced more probable and credible evidence and that on the preponderance of evidence and balance of probabilities the claimants proved better title than the 4th and 5th defendants.

The reliefs which the Appellants seek from this Court as contained in their notice of appeal are: (i) to allow this appeal and set aside the judgment of the lower Court given on the 23rd day of September 2013; and (ii) to enter judgment for the Appellants by dismissing Suit No. HU/21/2011 in its entirety with costs.

The appeal was entertained on 3/5/2018, parties having filed and exchanged their respective briefs of argument before then.

Learned counsel, Emma Ukaegbu, in urging the Court to allow the appeal, adopted and relied on Appellants brief of argument dated 11/2/2015 and filed on 23/2/2015; Appellants reply brief of argument dated 12/3/2015 and filed on same date, filed in response to the brief of argument of the 1st Set of Respondents; and Appellants reply brief dated 11/3/2015 and filed on same date, in response to the brief of argument of the 2nd Set of Respondents.

In the same vein, learned leading counsel C.N. Nwokorie, in urging the Court to dismiss the appeal adopted and relied on the brief of argument of the 1st Set of Respondents dated 5/3/2015 and filed on 6/3/2015; while the appeal was deemed as having been argued on the brief of argument of the 2nd Set of Respondents dated 26/2/2015 and filed 3/5/2015 as they were absent and not represented by counsel at the hearing of the appeal, even though they were served with the hearing notice in respect of the appeal, on 10/4/2018.

Learned leading counsel for the 1st Set of Respondents also relied on the unreported judgment of this Court in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014 in support of the stance of the 1st Set of Respondents that the appeal should be dismissed.

The Appellants formulated three issues for the determination of the appeal from their four grounds of appeal and the said issues read thus: –
(a) Given the fact that the appellants did not counter claim, whether the trial Court properly placed the onus of proof on them and properly evaluated the evidence of traditional history they put forward. (Covers ground 1 of the grounds of appeal).
(b) Whether the trial Court was right under the peculiar circumstances of this case where there are three parties, to have proceeded to consider the parties acts of ownership and possession when the evidence of traditional history or root of title put forward by the parties who respectively claimed and counter claimed were admittedly conflicting, inconclusive and improbable. (Covers ground 2 of the grounds of appeal).
(c) Whether the trial Court was right to have found the claimants acts of ownership and possession more probable than that of the appellants even when they withheld the evidence of a vital witness which may have assisted the Court to arrive at a contrary decision. (Covers grounds 3 and 4 of the grounds of appeal).

Three issues were formulated for the determination of the appeal by the 1st Set of Respondents in their brief of argument and they read thus: –
(i) Whether the trial Judge was right in treating the Appellants evidence of the root of title of the land in dispute as unreliable (elicited from ground one (1)).
(ii) Whether the learned trial Judge was right in considering the evidence of acts of ownership and possession given by the parties in this case having regard to the trial Judge’s conclusion on the evidence of traditional history of land in dispute adduced by the parties in this case (elicited from ground 2).
(iii) Whether the learned trial Judge was right when he held that the evidence of acts of ownership and possession over the land in dispute adduced by the claimants (now 1st Set of Respondents in this appeal) is preferable to that of the 2nd Set of defendants (the Appellants in this appeal).

The 2nd Set of Respondents having first observed in their brief of argument that the Appellants did not formulate any issue for determination from ground four in the notice of appeal and that this ground is therefore deemed as abandoned, proceeded to formulate two issues for determination of the appeal. The issues read thus: –
(i) Whether the learned trial Judge was right when he decided that the root of title pleaded and relied upon by the respondents (1st to 3rd defendants) is inconclusive just as those of the claimants and the appellants in this appeal (Ground 1)
(ii) Whether the learned trial Judge was right in entering judgment in favour of the claimants having regard to the evidence on record. (Ground 2 and 3).

The Appellants by the instant appeal are clearly not appealing against the judgment of the lower Court dismissing the counter-claim of the 2nd Set of Respondents that was tried in the main case. Indeed, I am of the considered view that they (Appellants) cannot even properly do this. This is because the 2nd Set of Respondents herein (i.e. 1st Set of Defendants before the lower Court) in their amended statement of defence on which the case was fought specifically counter-claimed against the 1st Set of Respondents herein who were the claimants before the lower Court, only. I am fortified in this view, given the settled and if I may say immutable position of the law to the effect that a counter-claim, though tried in the main action in which it has been brought, is an independent action and hence that a Court must necessarily give a judgment thereon. See the case of OROJA V. ADENIYI (2017) LPELR  41985(SC) wherein the Supreme Court dwelling on nature of counter-claim, stated per Peter-Odili, JSC; thus: –
There is a rich case law on the meaning and purport of a counter-claim and I shall have recourse to a few in aid at this point in time. See Effiom v Ironbar (2000) 1 NWLR (Pt. 678) 341 where it was held thus
“A counter-claim is an independent action and it needs not relate to or be in anyway connected with the plaintiffs’ claim or raise (sic) out of the same transaction. It is not even analogous to the plaintiff’s claim. It need not be an action of the same nature as the original claim. A counterclaim is to be treated for all purposes for which justice requires it to be treated as an independent action.”
See also the case of Okonkwo v. C. C. B. (2003) FWLR (Pt.154) 457 at 508, the nature of a counter-claim had been clearly spelt out as follows:-
“Counter-claim though related to the principal action is a separate and independent action and our adjectival law requires that it must be filed separately. The separate and independent nature of a counter claim is borne out from the fact that it allows the defendant to maintain an action against the plaintiff as profitably as in a separate suit. It is a weapon of defence which enables the defendant to enforce a claim against the plaintiff as effectually as an independent action. As a matter of law a counter claim is a cross action with its separate pleadings, judgments and costs.”
This is because a counter claim is a different action from that on which the main claim is predicated which translates to two separate actions for which there must be two distinct judgments which can be in the same process or suit or another date and process. There is no running away from the distinction. See Akinola v Unilorin (2004) NWLR (Pt.885) 616; Obi v Biwater Shellevbear Nig. Ltd (1997) 1 NWLR (Pt.484) 722.

Guided by the position of the Supreme Court in the case cited above, I am therefore of the considered view that if the Appellants in the instant appeal, were desirous of appealing against whatever decision the lower Court gave in respect of the counter-claim of the 2nd set of Respondents vis–vis the case of the 1st Set of Respondents against the said 2nd Set of Respondents, (but which I am of the considered view that they (i.e. Appellants) cannot do) (as the 2nd Set of Respondents never counter-claimed against the Appellants at the lower Court), it behoved them (i.e. Appellants) to have specifically actuated their grievance(s) against the same in their notice of appeal and not by doing so obliquely, by appealing against the whole of the judgment of the lower Court; thereby opening the gate as it were, for the 2nd Set of Respondents (whose appeal against the judgment of the lower Court had been dismissed since 11/7/2016), while praying that the instant appeal be dismissed, to argue against issues that had been decided against them in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014 and thereby wittingly or unwittingly constituting this Court as presently empanelled as an appellate Court over its judgment by seeking to have reversal of findings made by this Court against them under the issues formulated for determination in the aforementioned appeal. The fact that all the 2nd Set of Respondents have set out to achieve in the instant appeal (which they would appear to have misapprehended as an appeal against the dismissal of their counter-claim against the 1st Set of Respondents), is the reversal of findings made against them by the lower Court but which have been held as correct by this Court in the resolution of some issues which they formulated for determination in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014, are the portions of their brief of argument in respect of their issues 1 and 2 in the instant appeal. The relevant portion in respect of their issue 1 on pages 15 reads thus: –
The appellants have taken the position that because they did not counter-claim judgment should have been entered in their favour. With all due respect to them they are mistaken. The correct statement of the law as handed down by the Supreme Court is that where a plaintiffs claim in an action fails and the defendant has no counter-claim, the defendant is not entitled to any declaration in his favour. See OGOLO VS OGOLO [2003] 18 NWLR (Pt. 852) 494 at 515 A.
We urge with all respect that this issue be decided against the claimants, the appellants and in favour of the 2nd set of respondents (the respondents), who were the 1st to 3rd defendants on record at the trial.

While the relevant portion in respect of their issue 2 on page 20 of their brief of argument reads thus: –
It is submitted with all due respect that the findings which the learned trial Judge made against the respondents in this case are not justified by the facts on record. The respondents proved their counter-claim on balance of probability against the claimants and the appellants.
The complaints made by the appellants in this appeal are not justified to the extent that the final judgment in this case went against them. We therefore urge that this issue be decided against the appellants but in favour of the respondents/counter-claimants.

Issue 1 of the 2nd Set of Respondents in the instant appeal is: –
(i) Whether the learned trial Judge was right when he decided that the root of title pleaded and relied upon by the respondents (1st to 3rd defendants) is inconclusive just as those of the claimants and the appellants in this appeal (Ground 1);
while their issue 2 reads: –
(ii) Whether the learned trial Judge was right in entering judgment in favour of the claimants having regard to the evidence on record. (Ground 2 and 3).

On the other hand, issues 5 and 6 (which this Court treated together) in the appeal of the 2nd Set of Respondents (i.e. APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2016) and under which the question of the inconclusiveness of traditional histories of the parties and the correctness of the judgment of the lower Court on the evidence on record (both of which were resolved against the present 2nd Set of Respondents) read thus: –
Issue 5 – Whether the learned trial Judge was right when he failed to 1st evaluate the evidence of the Respondents (as Claimants) and determine if they made a strong case of title to the land in dispute to warrant shifting the burden to the Appellants to prove their own case (Ground 11) and
Issue 6  Whether the final judgment of the trial Court against the Appellants and in favour of the Respondents is justified by evidence on record (Grounds 2, 3. 8, 10, 12 and 14).

Suffice, it to say that this Court having resolved the questions of the inconclusiveness of the traditional histories of the parties against the 2nd Set of Respondents, in their own appeal whether or not the instant appeal is against the counter-claim of the 2nd Set of Respondents against the 1st Set of Respondents (which the Appellants have nothing to do with), it cannot have any legal basis to renege from its earlier positions in respect of the self-same issues in an appeal in which the issues had previously been considered and resolved. This is more so when it is the 2nd Set of Respondents whose traditional role in the instant appeal should be to defend the judgment of the lower Court appealed against that are the ones seeking for a reversal of the findings in question. I am of the considered view that the better option the 2nd Set of Respondents should have taken at the stage when parties were settling their respective briefs in the instant appeal and in the knowledge that they too had taken out their own appeal against the judgment of the lower Court and cannot conceivably support the said judgment, was not to have filed any brief of argument in the instant appeal.

Flowing from all that has been said is that I do not intend to further dwell on the issues for determination of the instant appeal as formulated by the 2nd Set of Respondents and ipso facto, their arguments thereon, designed for the resolution of the instant appeal in their favour and which would obviously be contrary to the position of this Court in their own appeal (i.e. CA/OW/4/2014) in which the judgment of the lower Court entered in favour of the 1st Set of Respondent wherein was not only affirmed but the dismissal of their counter-claim as well.

The Appellants herein were the 2nd Set of Respondents in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014 in which the 2nd Set of Respondents herein, were the Appellants. In the said appeal the position which the instant Appellants took was to support the position of the present 2nd Set of Respondents, in that appeal. That is, contrary to maintaining the traditional role of a respondent to an appeal (and which is to support the judgment appealed against), they sought for the reversal of the judgment of the lower Court (now on appeal at their instance) in the said APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014 for the appeal of the said present 2nd Set of Respondents, to be allowed. In clear evidence of the position of the present Appellants as stated above, is that in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014 which ex-facie the judgment delivered therein, was entertained by this Court (consisting of MBABA, IGE and OHO; JJ.CA) on 14/4/2016, the present Appellants were noted to have adopted the seven issues formulated by the 2nd Set of Respondents as Appellants therein, for the resolution of the said APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014. Under issues 5 and 6 in the said appeal which were treated together (and which have been re-produced hereinbefore), this Court in the said judgment, stated in respect of the issues thus: –
Responding under Issue 5 the Learned Counsel to the 1st set of Respondents started off by stating that all the Appellants are saying is that the trial Judge misplaced the burden of proof against them in evaluation of evidence. He submitted that the trial Judge complied with the principle of evaluation of evidence as laid down in Oguanuhu V. Chiegboka (2003) 25 WRN 11 at 126. He also submitted that the evaluation of the Traditional History of the land in dispute by the parties in this case is correct and proper. He also relied on the findings of the Learned trial Judge on page (sic) 319 and 320 of the record on the matters relating to evidence of traditional history. That the principles in the case of NKADO V. OBIANO (1997) 5 SCM 33 at 53 supports (sic) the views held by the trial Judge. That all the perceived inadequacies in Appellants Case are not correct.

On the implication of Appellants Counter-Claim and onus of proof in this case, the Learned Counsel to the 1st set of Respondents stated that the trial Judge meticulously observed the principle on onus by proof and evaluation of evidenceon page 318 of the record.
On Issue 6 the Learned counsel to the 1st set of Respondents stated that the position of Ahi Stream/River in the land in dispute in this case and the evaluation of the evidence of traditional land in dispute in this case were raised by the Appellants under Issues No. 4 and 5. He adopts his submissions on them as his argument under Issue 6
In his own response the Learned Counsel to the 2nd set of Respondents strongly submitted that since the claimant/1st set of Respondents failed in their evidence of traditional history which the trial Court treated as unreliable that should have been the end of the road for the 1st set of Respondents.
The Learned Counsel to 2nd set of Respondents also hit the Appellants/Counter Claimants in the same vein. That the trial Judge also held that the evidence of traditional history put forward by Appellants was unreliable inconclusive and improbable. He postulated that since the Counter-Claim is a separate action on its own, it must be proved as a distinct action.
He relied on the Case of AKANDE VS. ALAGBE (2000) 15 NWLR (Pt. 690) 352. That the Lower Court ought to have dismissed the Counter-Claim of the Appellants and allowed 2nd set of Respondents to remain on the land. That both Claim and Counter-Claim should have been dismissed by Lower Court.
On Issue 6 the 2nd set of Respondents also submitted that since both Appellants and the 1st set of Respondents failed to prove their traditional histories on which they based their respective claims the Lower Court was in serious error to have resorted to Rule in KOJO V. BONSIE (1957) 1 WLR 1223. He concluded that the judgment of the trial Court was not justified. He urged this Court to set aside the judgment.
Now contrary to the submissions of the Appellant (sic) that the trial Judge found claimants traditional history to be contradictory and unreliable the case of the 1st set of Respondents ought to fail instead of the trial Judge placing burden of proof on them as if they were the Claimants, what the trial Judge actually found is that the traditional evidence adduced by Claimants and the two sets of Respondents are inconclusive.
The Appellants erroneously believe that there was no onus on them to proof (sic) anything until the 1st set of Respondents established a prima facie case strong enough to warrant calling upon them to adduce evidence that will show the 1st set of Respondents did not prove their title forgetting that they (Appellants) are Claimants in their own right claiming title to the land in dispute. They are in the same category as the 1st set of Respondents in terms of burden and standard of proof as to who owns the land. As a matter of fact the Appellants having put forward a Counter-Claim they have a duty also to show a better title over the 1st set of Respondents.
What then is the position of the law consequent upon the findings of the trial Judge that the traditional evidence of parties were inconclusive

I have painstakingly read over and over, the brief of argument of the present Appellants in the instant appeal, and what is clear to me therefrom, is that the substance of their issues 1 and 2 (or (a) and (b)), was placed before this Court in their submissions in respect of issues 5 and 6 in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2014 and that their positions in respect of the said issues, were resolved against them. This is so, as this Court found in its judgment delivered on 11/7/2016, that what the lower Court actually found in its judgment appealed against, is that the traditional evidence adduced by claimants (i.e. the 1st Set of Respondents in the instant appeal) and the two sets of Respondents (and the Appellants herein, are one of the two sets), are inconclusive. It was on account of this specific finding, that this Court proceeded to pose the question as to what then is the position of the law consequent upon the findings of the trial Judge that the traditional evidence of parties were inconclusive; and having cited relevant authorities, thereafter concluded that the learned trial Judge was therefore right in having recourse to the Rule in Kojo v. Bonsie (supra).

I am of the settled view that inasmuch as the position of the law is that this Court is bound by its previous decisions (except in specified situations that are clearly not present in the instant appeal), I am bound to abide by the clear findings of facts made in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2016 as they relate to the present Appellants. This is more so as the present Appellants would appear to have lost sight of the fact that even though they did not specifically counter-claim for title, their title to the land in dispute was glaringly in issue in the instant case,given the case of the 1st Set of Respondents against them; and also as they (Appellants) claimed to be in possession of the same and that for this reason their removal of beacons planted on it, could not amount to acts of trespass. In other words, the Appellants, given their defence, put their title to the land in dispute in issue in the instant case; and the lower Court having found the traditional histories of the parties regarding their roots of title inconclusive, the lower Court was obligated to resort to the rule in KOJO V. BOSIE (supra) in resolving the question as to which of the parties established a better title to the said land. See the cases of ARE V. IPAYE (1990) LPELR  541 (SC); OLOHUNDE V. ADEYOJU (2000) LPELR  2586 (SC); and AKANBI V. SALAWU (2003) LPELR  316 (SC) amongst many others.

Flowing from all that have been said above, is that Appellants issues 1 and 2 must be resolved against them, and are hereby so resolved.

Appellants issue 3 in the instant appeal, in my considered view, also does not require any elaborate consideration. This is because the self-same issue as it were, was considered by this Court in APPEAL NO. CA/OW/4/2016 and this Court having regard to the printed record, found the lower Court to have based its findings that the recent acts of ownership by the 1st Set of Respondents herein, justified the finding in favour of the said 1st Set of Respondents to the effect that they were/are in exclusive possession of the land in dispute and that they proved better title to the land much more than the 2nd Set of Respondents. Suffice it to say, that these findings, in my considered view, mutatis mutandis, are applicable to the present Appellants. In any event, the lower Court without the evidence of Eze Uwanamodo (who the Appellants claimed to have been withheld) cannot be said to be wrong in its conclusions/findings regarding the recent acts of ownership by the 1st Set of Respondents, as the said Court glaringly demonstrated, in the portion of its judgment that has been extensively set out or re-produced hereinbefore in this judgment, a proper evaluation of the relevant evidence placed before it and on which it based the findings in question.
Appellants issue 3, is therefore resolved against them without further ado.

In the final analysis, the instant appeal is highly unmeritorious and it fails as all the issues formulated for its determination by the Appellants have been resolved against them. The appeal is accordingly dismissed; while the judgment of the lower Court appealed against is affirmed.
Costs in the sum of N100, 000.00, is awarded in favour of the 1st Set of Respondents and against the Appellants and 2nd Set of Respondents, jointly and severally.

RAPHAEL CHIKWE AGBO, J.C.A.: I agree

TUNDE OYEBANJI AWOTOYE, J.C.A.: I agree

Appearances:

Emma UkaegbuFor Appellant(s)

C.N. Nwokorie with him, Cynthia Umetiti – for 1st Set of Respondents

2nd Set of Respondents absent and not represented by counsel.
For Respondent(s)

 

Appearances

Emma Ukaegbu For Appellant

 

AND

C.N. Nwokorie with him, Cynthia Umetiti – for 1st Set of Respondents

2nd Set of Respondents absent and not represented by counsel.For Respondent