LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

ADEDEJI ADELEKE v. THE STATE (2018)

ADEDEJI ADELEKE v. THE STATE

(2018)LCN/11744(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Friday, the 22nd day of June, 2018

CA/B/403C/2017(R)

RATIO

FACTORS TO BE CONSIDERED FOR THE GRANT OF A BAIL

The general criteria for the grant or refusal of bail has been laid down in good number of cases and they include:
1. The availability of the accused to stand trial.
2. The nature and granting of the offence or offences charged.
3. The probability of guilt.
4. The previous criminal record of the accused if any.
5. The likelihood of the accused committing another offence while on bail.
6. The strength of the evidence which supports the charge.
7. The granting of the punishment in the event of conviction.
8. The likelihood of the accused interfering with witnesses or suppression of any evidence that may incriminate him per SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, J.C.A.

EXAMINATION OF THE INCENTIVE TO JUMP BAIL

The direction to which the pendulum of discretion should swing in favour or against an applicant for bail depends largely on the weight the Court attaches to one or several of the criteria open to it in any given case. It is also the belief of the law that the more serious the offence, the greater the incentive to jump bail, although this may not be correct at all times vide per SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, J.C.A.

ONUS OF PROOF IS ON THE PARTY THAT OPPOSES IT

It is true that the onus is on the party who oppose an application for bail to provide some prima facie evidence to show that the case against the accused person is strong and that he is not likely to make his trial if admitted to bail. per SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, J.C.A.

JUSTICES:

JIMI OLUKAYODE BADA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

Between

ADEDEJI ADELEKE – Appellant(s)

AND

THE STATE – Respondent(s)

SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, J.C.A. (Delivering the Lead Ruling): 

By a motion on notice dated and filed on the 14th day of September, 2017, the Applicant herein prayed this Court for the following orders:
1. AN ORDER of this Court granting the Appellant bail on favourable terms, pending the final determination of their charge and or their trial on the said charge.
2. AND for such order(s) as this Honourable Court may deem fit to make in the circumstances.
The grounds for the said application were stated as follows:
(1) The ill health of the Applicant.
(2) Applicants further stay in prison will jeopardise his life.
(3) The evidence available against the Applicant is weak.

The application is supported by an 18 paragraph affidavit sworn to by the Applicant himself and attached to the said affidavit are six documents marked Exhibits A to F.

Exhibit A is a certified true copy (CTC) of a 10 count charge for which the Applicant and others are facing trial in the lower Court; Exhibit B is the copy of a medical report dated 2/10/2015 and issued by the Cottage Hospital, Police College, Ikeja; Exhibit C is the copy of another medical report issued by the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital and dated 23/10/2015; Exhibit D is a medical certificate issued on the 27/11/2015 on behalf of the Applicant. Exhibit E is the copy of a police wireless message from the O/C SARS, Ikeja to the Commissioner of Police (DOPS) Ikeja. Exhibits F combined are two letters of commendation awarded to the Applicant and a picture showing him receiving the awards.

The Respondent upon being served with the said motion on notice, filed a counter affidavit of 27 paragraphs and attached therewith Exhibits A to HH. Exhibits A to A4 are CCTV pictures of the Applicant. Exhibit B is the Certified True Copy of the Ruling of the Federal High Court, Benin and delivered on 6/12/2016.

Exhibits C to F are copies of summons for bail filed in the lower Court at different times by the Applicant. Exhibits F1 and F2 are two different Rulings delivered by the lower Court on 23/2/2018 and 18/5/2018 respectively.

Exhibit F3 is the copy of the letter of adjournment dated 25//5/2018 and written to the Registrar of the lower Court by the Applicants counsel. Exhibit G is a copy of the extra-judicial statement of the Applicant. Exhibit H is an affidavit of urgency sworn to by one SHUKROLLAH ADELEKE, wife of the Applicant. Exhibit HH is a photocopy of the statement of ATM withdrawals issued by First Bank Plc with respect to the account of one Obodeh Benson Omoizonjie.

The Applicant reacted by filing a further and better affidavit sworn to by one Ihuoma Andrew Imefoh (Mrs) and dated 7/6/2018 and to it are attached Exhibits G and H. To wit: copy of a Notice of Appeal dated 1/3/2018 as well as cost of record receipts dated 9/3/2018.

In response, the Respondent also filed an 11 paragraph further and better counter affidavit and attached two documents tagged Exhibits K and K1. They are copies of a motion on notice for bail and a notice of preliminary objection dated 5/5/2017 and 28/5/2017 respectively.

In moving the application on the 11/6/2018, learned counsel for the Applicant submitted that under Section 28(1) of the Court of Appeal Act, this Court can admit an appellant to bail. He further referred to the case of OKUSE VS. F.R.N. (2015) LPELR 25584 (CA) and ORJI VS. F.R.N. (2007) 13 NWLR (PT. 1050) 55; ABIODUN VS. F.R.N. (2013) LPELR 21466 (CA) and AMADIKWA VS. STATE. (Ruling delivered by this Court per Ogunwumiju JCA on 25/3/2015).
He then urged this Court to grant the application and admit the Applicant to bail.

In reply, C.O Ebosele of counsel for the Respondent opposed the application for bail. While relying on the counter affidavit and further counter affidavit, it was submitted that the application is a ploy to frustrate the trial of the applicant which is currently going on and the prosecution has called 17 witnesses before closing its own case since on 7/7/2017, thus showing that the prosecution has been diligent in prosecuting the case in the trial Court.

It was added that the Applicant had filed series of applications for bail at the trial Court which were all dismissed. Even an application for the enforcement of his fundamental right which due to the fact that same was granted exparte without putting the Respondent on notice, the Federal High Court had to set aside the same on grounds of fraud.

On Section 28 of the Court of Appeal Act as referred to by the Applicants counsel, it was submitted that it is not applicable because there is no appeal before this Court and to admit the Applicant to bail will frustrate his trial because he is likely to abscond.

While contending that the prosecution having concluded and closed its case, it behoves the Applicant to enter defence and prove his innocence. It was then urged on this Court to dismiss the application.

I have read through the parties affidavits and counter affidavits as well as the attached Exhibits. Exhibit A attached to the Applicants affidavit in support of the application show that the Applicant and four other persons are being tried on a ten count charge which includes conspiracy to commit murder, murder, stealing and extortion.
Section 118(1) and (2) of the Criminal Procedure Act provides thus:
118(1) A person charged with any offence punishable with death shall not be admitted to bail, except by a Judge of the High Court.
118(2) Where a person is charged with any felony other than a felony punishable with death, the Court may, if it thinks fit admit him to bail.

The effect of granting bail especially in non capital offences is not to set the accused person free at all times in the criminal process, but to release him from custody of the law and to entrust him with the assurance of appearing for his trial at any specific time and place. See SULEMAN VS. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE, PLATEAU STATE (2008) 3 SCNJ 1.

The general criteria for the grant or refusal of bail has been laid down in good number of cases and they include:
1. The availability of the accused to stand trial.
2. The nature and granting of the offence or offences charged.
3. The probability of guilt.
4. The previous criminal record of the accused if any.
5. The likelihood of the accused committing another offence while on bail.
6. The strength of the evidence which supports the charge.
7. The granting of the punishment in the event of conviction.
8. The likelihood of the accused interfering with witnesses or suppression of any evidence that may incriminate him.
See DOKUBO ASARI VS. FRN (2007) 6 SCNJ 192; SULEMAN VS. C.O.P PLATEAU STATE (supra).

The direction to which the pendulum of discretion should swing in favour or against an applicant for bail depends largely on the weight the Court attaches to one or several of the criteria open to it in any given case. It is also the belief of the law that the more serious the offence, the greater the incentive to jump bail, although this may not be correct at all times vide SULEMAN VS. C.O.P. PLATEAU STATE (supra).

In the instant case, one of the several charges against the Applicant is that of murder which is a capital offence. By law an accused person charged with a capital offence is not ordinarily admitted to bail as a matter of course. This means that beyond the general criteria to guide a Judge in the exercise of his discretionary powers in deciding whether or not to grant bail to an accused person. In capital offences there is the extra need for special or extra ordinary circumstances to be established before admittance to bail could be a possibility. See MUHAMMED SANI ABACHA VS. THE STATE (2002) 5 SCM 139 or (2002) 5 NWLR (PT. 761) 638.

In the instance case, the Applicant has based his prayer for admittance to bail on grounds of ill health.

In this regard, it was deposed in paragraphs 6 to 12 of the affidavit in support of the motion on notice as follows:
6. That before my arrest and detention, I have been managing life-threatening ailments for which I have been receiving treatment at Cottage Hospital and Comprehensive Health Centre located inside Police College Ikeja. A copy of the Hospital Medical Report is attached herein and marked as Exhibit B.
7. That Cottage Hospital and Comprehensive Health Centre had in January 16th, 2015 referred me to Lagos State University Teaching Hospital, Ikeja for further diagnosis and treatment. A copy of the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital, Ikeja Medical Report is attached herein and marked as Exhibit C.
8. That I have been managing these ailments and was advised to abstain from strenuous activities that may aggravate illness and maintain proximity to my doctor as to enhance my gradual recovery.
9. That since my detention in Benin Prisons, my health condition has severely deteriorated as a result of the prison condition. The prison lacks the facilities to manage my health that has now become more complicated.

  1. That the Nigeria Prison Service has also issued a medical report regarding my health. In the medical report, the prison authority also stated categorically that they lack the facilities and expertise to manage my health. A copy of the medical report is attached herein and marked as Exhibit D.
    11. That based upon these factors I was granted bail by the Federal High Court but before I could perfect the bail I was arraigned before the Edo State High Court sitting at High Court No. 5 Benin City.
    12. That I have applied for bail at the High Court but the application has been refused and my health has now become unbearable.

The Respondents answer to the above set out facts are as deposed to in paragraphs 10 to 14 of the counter affidavit and are hereinbelow reproduced.
10. That in answer to paragraphs 6 and 7 of the applicants affidavit the respondent aver that Exhibits B and C attached by the applicant are not from competent authors as same were made for the purpose of this case and he has consistently used same for all bail applications he filed at the different Courts in the Benin Criminal Division and Federal High Court, Benin City as well as the first bail application he filed in this Honourable Court suit No. CA/B/390C/2016.
11. That in further answer to the above paragraphs, the respondent aver that the applicant is not managing any life threatening ailments and nothing to show that the ailments are contagious.
12. That in answer to paragraphs 8 and 9 of the applicants affidavit, the respondent aver that the applicant is not involved in any strenuous activities and he be made to enter his defence as prosecution long closed its case since the 7th day of July, 2017. The applicant as at the last date in the criminal division the 25th day of May, 2018 appeared hale and hearty and showed no signs of health deterioration as he looked very sound since the issuance of all the medical certificates.
13. That in answer to paragraph 10 of the affidavit, the respondent aver that Dr. Uzuegbu Chibuzo who signed the Exhibit D is not a competent Medical Doctor to issue same as his qualifications which would tell his competence to author it, is not stated.

  1. That in answer to paragraph 11 of the applicants affidavit, the respondent aver that the applicant got the said bail fraudulently at the Federal High Court not based on any ill health.
    (a) That in further answer to paragraph 11 of the applicants affidavit, the respondent aver that a counsel appeared for the applicant in the substantive matter at the Criminal Division, Benin City on the 3rd day of May, 2016 and yet went ahead to apply for a variation of order of the Federal High Court on the 12th day of May, 2016 after insisting on a long adjournment without putting the respondent on notice.

In the case of MUHAMMED SANI ABACHA VS. THE STATE supra, the Supreme Court admonished that whatever the stage at which bail is sought by an accused person, ill health of the accused is a consideration weighty enough to be reckoned as special circumstance. Their Lordships further emphasised that:
Everyone is entitled to be offered access to good medical care whether he is being tried for a crime or has been convicted or simply in detention. When in detention or custody, the responsibility of affording him access to proper medical facility rest with those in whose custody he is, invariably the authorities. But it ought to be understood that the mere fact that a person in custody is ill does not entitle him to be released from custody or allowed on bail unless there are really compelling grounds for doing so.
The Applicant in a bid to justify his ill health as a ground to admit him to bail relied on three different medical reports. The first is marked Exhibit B, a medical report issued by the Cottage Hospital Police College, Ikeja and dated 2/10/2015. It was stated therein that the Applicant was operated for hypertrophic scar (keloid) on the neck about two years earlier, that is to say in 2013. He was also found to have type 2 diabetes mellitus with stage 1 kidney disease and needs to be checked up every two weeks.
The Second medical report, Exhibit C: is from the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital, Ikeja and dated 23/11/2015. It stated that the Applicant was admitted for surgery relating to neck stiffness with an impression of keloid and investigations revealed that he is diabetic. A corrective surgery was effected on him and he was discharged on 10/2/2015 with the expectation of another surgery on 2/12/2015 to avoid any re-occurrence of the ailment.
The third medical report, Exhibit D is from the Nigeria Prisons Service, Benin Prison, Benin City. It is dated 27/11/2015. It stated that the Applicant was admitted into the prison on 19/10/2015 with a stiff neck. It also restated that the Applicant claimed to have been operated on the neck at the Lagos University Teaching Hospital, Ikeja on the 16/1/2015 and is equally diabetic. The report concluded that due to lack of facilities, expertise and resources in the prison to carry out further management of the Applicant, it will be better that he gets better facilities outside the prison.
My observation as per Exhibits A and B is that there seem to be some element of confusion, if not contradiction as to when the Applicant underwent surgery. While in Exhibit A dated 2/10/2015 it was stated that the Applicant was operated on the neck two years earlier, that is to say around 2013, Exhibit B on the other hand specifically stated that he was operated upon on the 16/1/2015 for the same keloid ailment.

One therefore wonders askance as to which of the two medical reports to accept as correctly stating the medical history of the Applicant.
Exhibit D as a fact is neither here nor there. It actually constitutes a total departure from the medical routine of prisons whereby prison inmates who cannot be properly treated in the prison facilities are taken to hospitals outside the prison on the recommendation of the prison doctor. In the instant case, the prison doctor stopped short of that procedure and simply recommended further medical attention outside the prison. It is also common for trial Courts upon application, to make an order for an accused person in custody to be taken to an outside medical facility and for such accused person to be monitored and guided by prison officials if on admission.
From the medical reports presented by the Applicant, I am not convinced or persuaded to believe that the nature of his ill health is such that cannot be managed by the prison authorities either with the facilities within or outside the prison.
As was held in ABACHA VS. THE STATE (supra) the special medical need of an accused person, whose proven state of health needs special medical attention which the authorities may not be able to provide is a factor that may be taken by the Court for consideration in the exercise of discretion to grant bail to the accused person. Such need is not brought before the Court by mere assertion of the accused or his counsel, but on satisfactory and convincing evidence. The evidence adduced by the Applicant to justify his ill health as a reason to be admitted to bail is not strong enough to invoke the discretionary powers of this Court in his favour.

What is more, during the period covered by the medical reports, that is to say in the year 2015, Exhibit E attached to the affidavit in support show that the Applicant who is a member of the Police Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS) was assigned to lead a team of other officers to Edo State to investigate a robbery incident which took place along Benin-Lagos Expressway. The said Exhibit E is a police wireless message from the officer in charge of SARS in Ikeja Lagos to the Commissioner of Police (DOPS) IKeja. The Applicant also in his extra-judicial statement made on 30/8/2015 and attached to the Respondents counter affidavit as Exhibit G gave details of his itinerary and activities from Benin to Port Harcourt in Rivers State, then to Anambra State and back to Benin in the course of the investigation of a robbery case.

The question then is, given his state of health as stated in the medical reports, would the Applicant have been able to engage in such rigorous activities in the same 2015 prior to his arrest and detention. The answer indeed further creates a dark cloud of doubt over the aforementioned medical reports which even if taken as plausible, does not put the Applicants state of health within the serious or urgent bracket that cannot be handled by the prison authorities as to justify his search for bail.

I need at this juncture, to emphasise that it is not regular for a person accused of murder to be admitted to bail pending trial because of the grievous nature of the offence. Thus, where a crime of such magnitude is committed and the evidence in support of the charge is strong and given that punishment for murder is the highest known to law, the Court will be slow in exercising its discretion in favour of admitting such accused person to bail. See ENWERE VS. COP (1993) 6 NWLR (PT. 299) 333; MUSA VS. COP (2004) 9 NWLR (PT. 879) 483; OLADELE VS. STATE (1993)1 NWLR (PT. 269) 294; ANI VS. STATE (2001) FWLR (PT. 81) 1715.

This no doubt must have informed the refusal of the Applicants various applications for bail by different Courts in the Criminal Division of the High Court of Edo State. Thus in paragraph 18 of the Respondents counter affidavit it was deposed as follows:
(18) That in answer to paragraph 12 of the applicants affidavit, the applicant did not only apply for one bail but several ones. The Respondent aver further that the applications for bail by the Applicant in the various Courts are an abuse of Court process as he has been forum shopping for bail from the various Courts in the Benin Criminal Division to the Federal High Court and he is hale and hearty. Attached here are the front pages of the various bail applications by the applicant as Exhibits C, D, E, E1, and F respectively and they were refused in the various Courts and even the one at the Federal High Court, Benin was vacated.

Another important point of note is the stage of the trial of the Applicant at the lower Court the Respondent deposed in paragraphs 21(a) to (h) and 22, 23, 24 and 25 of the counter affidavit as follows:
21. That in answer to paragraph 16 of the applicants affidavit, the respondent aver that the applicant is most likely to abscond if released on bail as the applicant does not reside in Edo State but of Lagos State.
a. That in further answer to paragraph 16 of the applicants affidavit, it is the applicant that is keeping himself in prison custody as he has refused to enter his defence since the 7th day of July, 2017 after the prosecution called 17 witnesses and closed its case.
b. That the applicant made a no case submission in respect of the substantive suit at Criminal Court 5, Benin City after the prosecution called 17 witnesses.
c. That the no case submission was overruled by the Court after same was keenly contested by both the applicant and the respondent. Attached to this counter affidavit is the said ruling marked as Exhibit F dated 23/2/18.
d. That the applicant filed a motion for stay of proceedings but withdrew same on the 20th day of April, 2018.

  1. That the applicant again filed a motion for the recall of 12 witnesses out of the 17 witnesses called by the prosecution.
    f. That the said motion to recall witnesses was refused and dismissed after same was again contested by both parties. Attached hereto is the said ruling as Exhibit F2 dated 18/5/18.
    g. That the case was thereafter adjourned to the 25th day of May, 2018 for the applicant to open his defence.
    h. That the applicants counsel wrote to Court for an adjournment on the 25th May, 2018 after he agreed on the date the matter came up last to open his defence. Attached to this Counter affidavit is the said letter of adjournment marked as Exhibit F3 dated 25/5/18.
    22. That in answer to paragraphs 17 and 18 of the applicants affidavit, the respondent aver that the applicant has no reliable surety as this application is brought in bad faith.
    (a) That the applicant made a confessional statement on the 31st day of August, 2015 in his own handwriting to the police as to how he used the late Bensons Obodeh’s ATM card on the 25th day of May, 2015 at Port Harcourt.

The said confessional statement is attached herewith as Exhibit G and same is Exhibit M in the substantive matter in Criminal Court 5 after it was keenly contested in a trial within trial.
(b) That the applicant also filed CA/B/390C/2016 on the 11th day of October, 2016 before this Honourable Court asking for bail instead of filing an Appeal and when it came up for hearing he abandoned it and same was struck out on the application of the respondent that it was an abuse of Court process and for want of diligent prosecution on the part of the applicant on the 20th day of January, 2016. The said front page of the bail application is attached here as Exhibit H.
23. That the withdrawals made by the applicant with the deceased Benson Obodehs ATM card are all reflected in the Bank statement tendered as Exhibit in the substantive suit at the Benin Criminal Division and its attached as Exhibit HH.
24. That the applicant is the one delaying the trial of the case at the trial Court by refusing to enter his defence for close to one year after the prosecution closed its case.

  1. That the applicant had ampl opportunity to enter his defence since the 7th day of July, 2017 after the close of the prosecutions case for the case to be decided either way and not to forum shop for bail under the pretence of ill health.

These facts were not challenged or contradicted in the Applicants further and better affidavit and they are accordingly accepted as true and correct.

Now given that the prosecution had called a total of 17 witnesses in proof of its case and has since closed its case since the 7th of July, 2017 which is about one year now, one really wonders askance on why the Applicant has delayed in entering his defence for the purpose of proving his innocence.

It is true that the onus is on the party who oppose an application for bail to provide some prima facie evidence to show that the case against the accused person is strong and that he is not likely to make his trial if admitted to bail. The Respondent herein has shown the eagerness to prosecute the case having fielded a total of 17 witnesses before closing its case since July 2017. There is therefore no element of blame on the Respondent with regard to any delay in the hearing and determination of the charges against the Applicant who should show more zeal in the conclusion of the trial so that the temporary freedom he seeks will turn out to be a permanent one if he succeeds in proving his innocence.

The conclusion of the matter therefore, is that having regard to the affidavit evidence before this Court and the documents annexed as Exhibits, there is no strong ground upon which this Court will stand to exercise its discretion in favour of admitting the Applicant to bail.

This application for bail is therefore found to be lacking in merit and it is hereby dismissed.

JIMI OLUKAYODE BADA, J.C.A.: I read in draft the Ruling just delivered by my Learned Brother SAMUEL CHUKWUDUMEBI OSEJI, JCA. I agree with him that the application for bail lacks merit and it is also dismissed by me.

PHILOMENA MBUA EKPE, J.C.A.: I had the opportunity of reading in draft the lead Ruling just delivered by my learned brother S.C. OSEJI, JCA. I have gone through the said Ruling with a fine tooth comb and I throw my weight behind the sound reasoning of my learned brother that the Appellant has delayed in entering his defence for the purpose of proving his innocence. It is also my ardent view that from the affidavit, documents annexed as Exhibits evidence before this Court there is no strong ground upon which this Court will stand to exercise its discretion in favour of granting the Appellant to bail. Therefore the application for bail lacks merit and it is hereby dismissed.

 

Appearances

Prince M.O. Osa-Oghogho For Appellant

 

AND

Mrs. C.O. Ebosele, Deputy Director, Ministry of Justice, Edo State with S.E. Okogie (Mrs), Asst. Director; Mrs. E. Ikoghode Senior State Counsel and F.I. Aidenagbon, Senior State Counsel For Respondent