LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

A. Y. RIMI VENTURES LTD & ANOR v. ALHAJI ABDULLAHI SAGIR & ORS (2018)

  1. Y. RIMI VENTURES LTD & ANOR v. ALHAJI ABDULLAHI SAGIR & ORS

(2018)LCN/11743(CA)

In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

On Friday, the 22nd day of June, 2018

CA/K/153/2016

RATIO

INTERPLEADER SUMMONS

In interpleader summons proceedings, the burden is generally on the claimant per UZO IFEYINWA NDUKWE-ANYANWU, J.C.A.

INTERPLEADER SUMMONS IN EQUITY

It is therefore said that an interpleader proceeding is an equitable proceedings to determine the Rights of rival claimants to property held by a third person having no interest therein per UZO IFEYINWA NDUKWE-ANYANWU, J.C.A.

JUSTICES:

UZO IFEYINWA NDUKWE-ANYANWU Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

MOHAMMED AMBI-USI DANJUMA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

OBANDE FESTUS OGBUINYA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria

 

Between

  1. A. Y. RIMI VENTURES LTD.
    2. A. Y. MAI KIFI & SONS LTD. – Appellant(s)

AND

  1. ALHAJI ABDULLAHI SAGIR
    2. MINISTRY OF LAND & PHYSICAL PLANNING, KANO
    3. ALHAJI SULAIMAN AHMAD
    4. YUNUSA JIBRIL
    5. COMBINE TRADE LTD.
    6. DEPUTY SHERIFF, KANO HIGH COURT – Respondent(s)

UZO IFEYINWA NDUKWE-ANYANWU, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): 

This is an appeal against the ruling of the Kano State High Court delivered on 18th February, 2016 by Hon. Justice N. S. Umar wherein the trial judge dismissed the Applicants interpleader summons to set aside the attachment of plot of land covered by a certificate of occupancy No. COM/2009/80 formally LKN/RES/90/1197.

By an interpleader summons dated 27th of August, 2015 brought pursuant to Section 34(1) of the Sherriff and Civil Process Act and Order 43 Rules 1 and 2 of the Kano State High Court Rules 2014, the applicants now Appellants prayed for the following orders:
1. An Order of this Honourable Court setting aside the attachment of plot of land covered by a Certificate of Occupancy No. LKN/COM/2009/80 formerly LKN/RES/90/1197 belonging to the 2nd Applicant.
2. And Order of this Honourable Court releasing the plot of land covered by a Certificate No. LKN/COM/2009/80 formerly LKN/RES/90/1197 belonging to the 2nd Applicant.
3. An Order restraining the Deputy Sheriff not to sale or dispose the plot of land covered by a Certificate No. LKN/COM/2009/80 formerly LKN/RES/90/1197 belonging to the 2nd Applicant.
4. And for such further Order or Orders as this Honourable Court may deem fit to make in the circumstances.

In support of the application was a 18 paragraph affidavit deposed to by one Bisola Alonge and a written address.

In opposing the Appellants application, the 1st Respondent (as judgment creditor/Respondent) filed a 10 paragraph counter-affidavit deposed to by the 1st Respondent himself. He also filed a written address in support.

The Appellants latter filed a further and better affidavit dated 23rd December, 2015.
The trial judge in delivering its judgment dismissed the interpleader summons on the ground that the Appellants predecessor in title (Rahim Nigeria Limited) cannot pass good title to the Appellants.

The facts of the case are that: the Nigeria Arab Bank was the judgment creditors in Suit No K/290/92 between Nigeria Arab Bank v. Alh. Sulaiman Ahmed, Combine Trade Ltd & Alh. Yunusa Jbirin, the judgment debtor. By leave of the Kano State High Court dated 17th February, 1995 the immovable property of the judgment debtor situate at Dan Agundi in the Municipal Administrative Area of Kano covered by a Certificate of Occupancy No: LKN/COM/2009/80 was attached. The property was auctioned and sold to one Muhammad Idris who in turn sold to Alhaji Muhammad Danasabe who then sold to Alh. Sagir Muhammad (the 1st Respondent).

The Appellants on becoming aware of the property was attached by the Bailiffs of the lower Court filed an interpleader summons claiming ownership of the said attached property. The Appellants based their root of title to Rahim Nigeria Limited, who derived title from the judgment of the High Court dated 7th April, 1997 with Suit No K/126/97 against the 1st Respondents predecessor in title. Subsequently Rahim Nigeria Ltd sold to the 1st Appellant (A.Y. Rimi Ventures Ltd). The 1st Appellant then sold the property to the 2nd Appellant.

The Appellants being dissatisfied with the judgment filed a Notice of Appeal dated 1st March, 2016 containing two grounds of appeal.

In accordance with the Rules of Court parties have filed their respective brief of arguments. The Appellants brief was filed on the 13th May, 2016 while the 1st Respondents brief was filed on the 20th June, 2016. No brief was filed by the other Respondents. The Appellants reply brief was filed on 27th June, 2016.

The Appellants, in their brief formulated a sole issue for determination viz:
Whether the learned trial Judge of the lower Court was right in law when he hold (sic) that Rahim Nigeria Limited cannot pass good title to the present Interpleaders/Applicants (Now Appellants).

The Respondents on the other hand, formulated two issues for determination as follows:
1. Whether the Appellants vendor can confer a valid title to them, when judgment of the lower Court is in existence?
2. Whether the Appellants are estopped from claiming title over the plot in question?

SOLE ISSUE OF THE APPELLANTS
In arguing this issue, learned counsel for the Appellants submitted that where by a judgment of a Court, property is attached and a third party emerges laying claim on the said attached property, it is the contention of counsel that the Court is required to issue an interpleader summons for the parties to attend Court to adjudicate on rightful ownership. He relied on Section 34(1) of the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act; DALE POWER SYSTEMS PLC V WITT & BUSCH LTD (2007) ALL FWLR (PT 394)353. He further submitted that in interpleader summons the onus is generally on the Claimant, as Plaintiff in the Proceedings to establish title to the property he claims.

It is the contention of counsel that in the instant case the onus was on the Appellants which they had successfully discharged. He contended that the Appellants having proved title to the attached property via Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 2, the onus now shifts to the 1st Respondent to disprove same. He contended that the 1st Respondent did not disprove the title of the 2nd Appellant but merely denied the contents of Exhibit 1 at page 128 of the record which by virtue of Section 169 and 173 of the Evidence Act is estopped from denying the contents of Exhibit 1.

He also contended that the 1st Respondent applications dated 23rd October 2013 and 18th November 2013 granting the 1st Respondent title to the property is an abuse of Court process as the 1st Respondent had filed a series of similar application before other Court and even on appeal. He referred to the case of AWOFESO V OYENUGA (1996) 7 NWLR (Pt 460)360;A.C.B. V NWAIGWE (2011) ALL FWLR (Pt 568) 944.

Based on the above submission, counsel contended that the trial judge was wrong in dismissing the Appellants interpleader summons. He thus urged this Court to allow the appeal and set aside the decision of the lower Court.

Learned counsel for the 1st Respondent on the other hand submitted that the trial judge was right in holding that the 1st Appellant or his predecessor in title cannot confer good title unto the 2nd Appellant in view of a subsisting/pre-existing judgment of the lower Court over the same property granting title to the 1st Respondents predecessor in title as against the Appellants predecessor in title (the 3rd 5th Respondent).

He submitted that in view of the subsisting judgment in favour of the 1st Respondents predecessor in title, the subsequent judgment over the same property by a Court of coordinate jurisdiction in favour of the Appellants predecessor in title and from which the Appellants based their root title is null as parties are estopped from re-litigating on same except on appeal. He relied on the case of ABUBAKAR & 2 ORS V NASAMU & 5 ORS (2012)MJSC V2-3 Pg 1; AJIBOYE V ISHOLA (2006) ALL FWLR (Pt 331) P 1214.

Learned counsel for the Appellants in his reply submitted that it is trite that an issue for determination must arise from ground(s) of appeal. He further submitted that where an issue for determination does not arise from a ground of appeal the issue is incompetent and liable to be struck out. He relied on the cases of NAWA V AG CROSS RIVER STATE (2008) ALL FWLR (Pt. 401) 811; OWHONDA V EKPECHI (2003) FWLR (Pt. 181) 1565.

It is the contention of counsel that issue 1 and 2 formulated by the 1st Respondent are incompetent having not been distilled from the Appellants grounds of appeal.
He thus urged this Court to strike out the issues formulated by the 1st Respondent together with the arguments and allow this appeal.

RESOLUTION
In interpleader summons proceedings, the burden is generally on the claimant. In this appeal, the claimant is also the Appellant after the Ruling of the trial Court. KALA V POTISKUM (1998) LPELR 1648, OLAWALE V F.B.N. (2015) LPELR 40386.
As a general rule, in this type of application by an interpleader, the interpleader as the claimant, is deemed to be the Plaintiff and bears the burden of proving that the property in question belong to him. The interpleader as always is taken as the Plaintiff and is duty bound to prove their assertion that they are not the judgment debtor on the property attached and which by their assertion, was wrongfully attached.
The judgment creditor at whose instance or in whose favour the property in question has been attached in satisfaction of the judgment debt becomes the Defendant to the interpleader application whose duty is to defend the application only. KALA V POTISKUM (SUPRA).

It would be important to glean from the briefs of both parties, the history of this case. It would appear that the 4th Respondent Yunusa Jubril is undoubtedly in the middle of this legal battle. The 4th Respondent took out a loan with Arab Bank and neglected or failed to honour his obligation of paying off his indebtedness with the bank. The bank thereafter took out a claim to recover their money given with the 4th Respondents land, the subject matter of this appeal in Suit No. K/290/1992. During the pendency of this suit, unknown to the parties the 4th Respondent on the pretext that he had lost the originals of the documents with the bank applied for another with the Ministry of Lands. With this subsequent certificate obtained by false representation sold the property to Rahim Nig. Ltd. on 7th April, 1999.

It would be recalled that this property was originally registered as LKN/RES/90/1197 now LKN/COM/2009/80.

After the sale to Rahim Nig. Ltd. on 7th April 1999, Exhibit 1 on page 128 of the Record of Appeal, it now sold it to 1st Respondent on 12th March 2009 Exhibit 1 on page 128 of the Record of Appeal. The 1st Respondent later sold to the 2nd Respondent on 11th February, 2011 Exhibit 2 on page 101 of the Record of Appeal. The 1st Respondent in his brief claimed that Exhibit 1 on page 128 of the Record of Appeal was a judgment obtained in Suit No. K/126/1997; whereas, the predecessors in title to the 1st Respondent got judgment in Suit No. K/290/1992. From the numbers on the suits, it is obvious that the suit of the 1st Respondents predecessors was first in time. This lays credence to the fact that the 4th Respondent Yunusa Jibril sold the same plot deposited as collateral to Arab Bank to the predecessors in title to the Applicants/Appellants.

Both parties have filed multiple processes in Court trying to hold on to the property and understandably too.

The Appellants from the foregoing have bought themselves a law suit as it has panned out. The 1st Respondents predecessors bought the Res from an auction after the judgment in Suit No. K/290/92. The Suit No. K/290/92 was heard and determined by N. S. Umar, J who also heard this application of the Appellants. The learned trial Judge was already acquainted and ceased of the facts of the suit in the High Court.

The application by the Appellants for interpleader proceedings was to determine who amongst the two warring parties is the rightful owner of the Res, the land in dispute.

It is therefore said that an interpleader proceeding is an equitable proceedings to determine the Rights of rival claimants to property held by a third person having no interest therein. KALA V POTISKUM (SUPRA).

In an interpleader proceedings as said, the burden is generally on the claimants, in this case, the Appellants as the Plaintiffs, to establish his title to the property in dispute, or where his claim is not absolute title, he must prove the precise interest or title he claims.
However, where the claimant is in possession of the property in issue at the time of its attachment, the judgment creditor shall be deemed a Plaintiff and that the burden of proof shall be on him. KALA V POTISKUM (SUPRA), OLATUNDE V O.A.U. (1998) 5 NWLR (PT. 549) PG. 178.

In the present appeal, the Appellants were already in possession of the property. The 1st Respondent was applying to be put in possession. The burden ordinarily would have been on the 1st Respondent to prove his title. This is not applicable here because; the interpleader summons is in the same Court where the trial Judge is ceased of all the facts of this case.
It would be right to conclude that the 4th Respondent who is in the middle of this fray had fraudulently sold the property to Rahim (Nig.) Ltd. when he knew he had given it to the Bank as collateral.

Therefore, the 4th Respondent had nothing to give Rahim (Nig.) Ltd. (nemo dat quod non habet).
The trial Judge was therefore right in refusing the application of the Appellants as Rahim (Nig.) Ltd. did not acquire any title to pass to the Appellants.
This appeal is devoid of any merit. It is dismissed. The Ruling of the trial Court is hereby affirmed.
Cost to the 1st Respondent is assessed at N50,000.00.

MOHAMMED AMBI-USI DANJUMA, J.C.A.: I have been availed a preview of the lead judgment articulated by my brother. Uzo l. Ndukwe Anyanwu, JCA in this appeal and I concur that the applicant/appellant in the inter pleader proceedings at the trial Court had purchased a law suit.

He had no title abinitio; as the Ruling to the effect that the rival claim in respect of the property i.e. is lay in favour of the defendants/respondents. Nothing existed to be transferred to the appellant through his donor or predecessor in title, who actually, only got a fake or nonexistent title by a prior purported transfer of title that had effectively been alienated before the transaction. .
Appeal is dismissed.

OBANDE FESTUS OGBUINYA, J.C.A.: I had the privilege to peruse, in draft, the leading judgment delivered by my learned brother: Uzo I. Ndukwe-Anyanwu, JCA.

I endorse, in toto, the reasoning and conclusion in it. I, too, penalise the appeal with a deserved dismissal. I abide by the consequential orders decreed in it.

Appearances:

Abubakar Mohammed Esq.For Appellant(s)

–For Respondent(s)