ELDER FRANCIS OGBUGO & ORS v. CHIEF BENEDICT AZUBUIKE
(2018)LCN/11735(CA)
In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
On Wednesday, the 20th day of June, 2018
CA/OW/264M/2016(R)
RATIO
GRANT OF EXTENSION OF TIME
What constitutes good and substantial reason(s) to justify grant of extension of time to appeal is not exclusively or conclusively defined by Courts. That leaves the issue within the confines of the discretion of the appellate Court, in each circumstance, provided the discretion is exercised properly, given the facts disclosed in the Applicants affidavit to satisfy the Court as to the explanation for the delay to appeal within the prescribed time … An application for extension of time within, which to appeal must show that special circumstances exist to justify that the application should be granted. per ITA GEORGE MBABA, J.C.A
JUSTICES
MASSOUD ABDULRAHMAN OREDOLA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
ITA GEORGE MBABA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
TUNDE OYEBANJI AWOTOYE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
Between
- ELDER FRANCIS OGBUGO
2. MARK OSHIMIRI
3. PYTAS OSHIMIRI
4. MAGNUS OGBUGO
5. PATRICK OGBUGO
(For themselves and as representing Ogbugo Family of Umudike Egbema) Appellant(s)
AND
CHIEF BENEDICT AZUBUIKE
(For himself and as representing Members of Azubuike family of Umudike Egbema). Respondent(s)
MASSOUD ABDULRAHMAN OREDOLA, J.C.A. (Delivering the Lead Ruling):
This ruling is with regard to the motion on notice dated the 23rd day of November, 2017 and filed on the 24th day of November, 2017. Therein the appellants/applicants (hereinafter referred to as the applicants) sought in the main for the grant of the following reliefs:
a) Extension of time within which to seek leave to appeal against the judgment of the Customary Court of Appeal of Imo State Coram E. C. Abosi P/J, M. E. Njoku J and V. U. Okorie J on 28/1/2014 in CCA/OW/A/ 43/2011 Ogbugo & Ors. v. Azubuike.
b) Extension of time within which to appeal against the judgment of the Customary Court of Appeal of Imo State Coram E. C. Abosi P/J, M. E. Njoku J and V. U. Okorie J on 28/1/ 2014 in CCA/OW/A 43/ 2011 Ogbugo & Ors. v. Azubuike.
c) Leave to appeal against the Judgment of the Customary Court of Appeal of Imo State above cited.
d) Stay of Execution of the judgment of the Customary Court of Appeal in CCA/OW/A/43/2011 OGBUGO & ORS V. AZUBUIKE dated 28/1/14 delivered on 28/1/14 pending appeal.
OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE
e) Interlocutory injunction restraining the Plaintiff/Respondent from entering into the land in dispute in CC/OA/14/2006 AZUBUIKE & OGBUGO & ORS CCA/OW/A/43/2011, OGBUGO & ORS V. AZUBUIKE pending the determination of this appeal.
The application was supported by a ten-paragraph affidavit, together with a further affidavit filed on the 24th day of November, 2017 and 30th day of January, 2018, respectively. In opposition, the respondent/respondent (hereinafter referred to as the respondent) deposed to and filed a five-paragraph counter-affidavit on the 20th day of March, 2018.
As directed and or ordered by this Court, the parties filed their respective written addresses in support and opposition to the application. The applicants written address was prepared by E. C. Mere Esq. It was filed on the 1st day of February, 2018. On the other side of the divide, the respondents written address in opposition to the application dated the 19th day of March, 2018 was filed on the 20th day of March, 2018. The said respondents written address was prepared by Chief Okey Ehieze (KSC).
In reply to the respondents written address, the learned counsel for the applicant filed a reply on points of law on the 23rd day of April, 2018.
For the determination of this application the learned counsel for the parties donated a sole issue apiece. The applicant’s issue is reproduced below as follows:
Whether the Applicants are entitled to grant of the Application
The respondent’s issue was couched in the following manner:
WHETHER IT IS IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE TO GRANT THE RELIEFS SOUGHT IN THE APPLICATION
The issue formulated by the learned counsel for the parties are principally the same, save for minor variation in the use of language. However, the issue as formulated by the respondent’s counsel is preferred by me and the same is adopted for the determination of this application.
LEGAL ARGUMENTS.
In support of the application, the applicants counsel vide their litigation clerk, Charles Obichere, deposed to the fact that the law firm of Messrs E. C. Mere & Associates, was briefed to take over the prosecution of this appeal from the applicant’s former counsel. He stated that the applicants erstwhile counsel had initially filed a notice of appeal, but the same was withdrawn by the newly briefed counsel for being incompetent. The proposed new notice of appeal was annexed to the application as Exhibit A, while the said judgment of the Customary Court of Appeal, Owerri, Imo State sought to be appealed against was also attached to the application as Exhibit B. The applicants counsel also stated that the respondent has been taking steps to enforce the judgment of the lower Court and has even commenced a committal proceeding against the applicants. He also stated that the instant application would have been brought earlier, but due to the fact that, one of the counsel in Messrs E. C. Mere & Associates, who prepared the application, as a result of pressure of work and subsequent deep involvement/pursuit of her Masters degree programme, misplaced the application, and when the said application was eventually found, it was filed but later discovered to be incompetent, consequently, the applicants counsel applied for the said application filed on the 7th day of July, 2017 to be withdrawn.
In the written address in support of the application and reply on points of law, the learned counsel for the applicants submitted, that the applicants have placed sufficient materials before this Court to sway the exercise of discretion of the Court in their favour. The learned counsel for the applicants maintained, that contrary to the objection raised by the respondent’s counsel, the instant application was properly filed pursuant to appropriate constitutional provision. He opined that though the rules of this Court under which this application was brought may have been wrongly cited or referred to because, they mistakenly relied on the provision of the old Rules of 2011 which has been repealed by the extant Rules of 2016; but with the constitutional provision being superior to the Rules of this Court, the application cannot be regarded as incompetent merely because it was brought pursuant to a wrong order and rules of Court. He referred us to the case of Sterling Bank Plc. v. Pa Oyoyo (2016) LPELR 41551 and Buhari v. Obasanjo (2003) 17 NWLR (Pt. 850) 587, among others.
On the grounds of appeal, the learned counsel for the applicants argued that all the proposed grounds of appeal are competent, on the basis that they are all predicated on questions of customary law. Furthermore, the learned counsel for the applicants submitted, that the applicants have given cogent reasons why the instant application was not filed within the time prescribed by the requisite statute. Thus, he urged this Court to grant this application.
Also, the learned counsel for the applicants urged this Court to either stay the execution of the judgment of the lower Court or grant an injunction restraining the respondent from proceeding to execute the judgment of the lower Court, in view of this application. The learned counsel submitted, that it is improper for the committal proceedings and instant proceedings to be going on simultaneously at both the Customary Court of Appeal and this Court, respectively. He then maintained that continuing with the committal proceedings would in essence be pre-emptive of the decision of this Court and thereby rob the applicants of their constitutional right of appeal.
He called in aid the cases of Mohammed & Anor. V. Olawunmi & Anor. (1993) 4 NWLR (Pt. 287) 254; Ezegbu v. F. A. T. B. Ltd. (1992) 1 NWLR (Pt. 220) 699 and Agwasim v. Ojichie (2004) 18 NSC (QR) (Pt. 1359) 367. Thus, he urged this Court once again to grant all the reliefs sought in the application.
In reply, the learned counsel for the respondent contended, that the applicants did not adduce sufficient reasons to warrant the grant of this application. He argued that the applicants who claimed that one of their counsel from the firm of their solicitors misplaced the former application, did not state when the application was misplaced and when it was found. He argued that the reason advanced, to the effect that the former draft application was misplaced is casual and not substantial enough to warrant the grant of the application. Additionally, that the reason(s) given by the applicants for the delay is/are not tenable and thereby urged this Court to discountenance the same. He referred us to the case of Chime v. Onwuegbu (2014) ALL FWLR (Pt. 723) 1874. Again, and according to the learned counsel for the respondent, that the proposed grounds of appeal as contained in Exhibit A, are not arguable to engender the grant of this application. The learned counsel maintained that the grounds of appeal are outside the judgment of the lower Court, thus they are incompetent and not arguable. He referred us once again to the case of Chime v. Onwuegbu (supra).
Finally, the learned counsel for the respondent submitted that this Court cannot order stay of execution in favour of the applicants, because there is no pending appeal upon which it could rest. He supported his position with the case of Intercontinental Bank Plc. v. Hon. Umar Isah Mungadi (2014) ALL FWLR (Pt. 728) 1016. He also argued that the application for stay is required by provision of Order 6 Rule 4 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2016 to be filed at the lower Court, before similar application can be brought before this Court, failure in respect of which has rendered this application incompetent and liable to be struck out.
Before I proceed, let me point out that the main purport of this application was to seek for the order of this Court, extending time for the applicants to file their notice of appeal against the decision of the lower Court. In addition, the applicants are seeking for an order staying execution of the judgement of both the trial and lower Courts. At this stage or point in time, it is not proper in law to start considering and/or delving into the substance of the main appeal if and when it is filed. Thus, all arguments in respect of issue(s) that may likely touch upon the substance of the main appeal are hereby discountenanced by me.
The rules of this Court have clearly and unequivocally specified the conditions required to be fulfilled in order to enable this Court exercise its discretion positively in favour of an applicant, who seeks extension of time to appeal against the decision of an appropriate Court, below this Court. The two main conditions are:
1. The applicant must give or show good and substantial reasons for failure to appeal within the prescribed period, and
2. The proposed grounds of appeal should prima facie show good cause why the appeal should be heard.
See Order 6 Rule 9 (2) of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules), Minister, P. M. R. v. Expo-Shipping Line (Nig.) Ltd. (2010) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1208) 261 and Ault & Wiborg (Nig.) Ltd. v. Nibel Industries Ltd. (2010) 16 NWLR (Pt. 1220) 486.
With regard to the instant application, the applicants stated that their former counsel, had previously filed a notice of appeal, but the same was withdrawn by the applicants newly briefed counsel, upon the discovery that the grounds of appeal contained in the said notice of appeal are incompetent, having not been predicated on question(s) of customary law. The applicants counsel also stated that an application similar to the instant one had been previously filed, but the said application was also incompetent and was subsequently withdrawn. These facts remained uncontroverted, but were expressly admitted in paragraph three of the respondent’s counter-affidavit. In essence, the applicants have been able to establish that their failure to exercise their constitutionally given right of appeal within the statutorily prescribed period was due to the serial mistakes of their learned counsel. Thus, I am of the firm view point that the applicants have been able to sufficiently set out good and substantial reasons for their failure to appeal against the decision of the lower Court within the statutorily prescribed period, and in the process satisfied the first requirement specified above to enable the first arm of this application to succeed.
On the second requirement, I have carefully examined the applicant’s grounds of appeal as contained in their proposed notice of appeal, and I am of the firm opinion that the grounds of appeal contained therein are arguable in view of the judgment in respect of which leave to appeal is being sought. Put differently, they have showed good cause why the appeal should be heard. It should however, be noted, that at this stage of the proceedings, the focus of this Court is not predicated on whether or not the grounds of appeal will succeed. It suffices if this Court, is of the opinion that the grounds of appeal are prima facie arguable. See the cases of Enyibros Foods Processing Co. Ltd. & Anor. v. Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation & Anor. (2007) 9 NWLR (Pt. 1039) 216 and Ikenta Best Nig. Ltd. v. Attorney-General of Rivers State (2008) 6 NWLR (Pt. 1084) 612.
Thus, I am also of the firm opinion that the applicants have satisfied the second requirement specified above for the success of the first arm of the reliefs sought in their application under consideration.
With regard to the prayer which pertained to an order for stay of execution or injunction, both reliefs are not granted as a matter of course; the applicants are expected to predicate the application upon the presentation of sufficient materials that would enable this Court exercise its discretion positively in their favour. Thus, the dire need exists, that they should demonstrate the special circumstances that would warrant the grant of the order. An order for stay of execution or any order that would prevent any successful party from enjoying the fruits of his judgment is not to be granted merely at the convenience of one party but on the balance of hardship or inconvenience, that may be suffered by both parties. See the cases of Akibu v. Oduntan (1991) 2 NWLR (Pt. 171) 1 and Ajomale v. Yaduat (No. 2) (1991) 5 NWLR (Pt. 191) 266. In addition to establishing special circumstances necessitating the grant of an order staying execution of the judgment of the lower Court in order to preserve the res, the subject matter of the appeal from being destroyed and or foisting a situation of fait accompli on the appellate Court, the application should also be predicated on a competent and or valid pending notice of appeal. See Shinning Star (Nig.) Ltd. & Anor vs. A. K. S Steel (Nig.) Ltd. & Ors. (2010) LPELR 4957 and SPDC v. Allaputa (2005) LPELR 12658.
In the instant case, there is no such pending appeal before this Court to enable this Court consider whether or not the application is worthy of thorough consideration. Even the reason given by the applicants for seeking this relief; that a committal proceedings has been initiated against them in a bid to enforce the judgment of the lower Court is no longer tenable as the respondent stated expressly in paragraph 4 (d) of his counter-affidavit that the proceedings had since been terminated. Thus, I am of the firm viewpoint that the applicants prayer for the grant of an order of stay of execution or injunction restraining the respondent from entering the land in dispute, the subject matter of the applicants prospective appeal, was sought for prematurely and the same is hereby struck out by me.
In the final analysis, this application is held by me to have succeeded in part, and it is thus thereby ordered as follows:
1. That time is extended till today for the applicants to seek the leave of this Court to appeal against the judgment of the Customary Court of Appeal of Imo State, Coram: E. C. Abosi P/J., M.E. Njoku J., and V. U. Okorie J., delivered on the 28th day of January, 2014 in Appeal No. CCA/OW/A/43/2011, Ogbugo & Ors. v. Azubuike. (hereinafter referred to as the lower Courts judgment).
2. Leave is thus granted to the applicants to appeal against the said lower Courts judgment.
3. Time is hereby extended for the applicants to appeal against the said lower Courts judgement within 21 days with effect from today, the 20th day of June, 2018.
4. Order for Stay of Execution and/or Injunction restraining the respondent from entering into the land in dispute is hereby refused.
5. No order is made with regard to costs. Parties are to bear their respective costs.
ITA GEORGE MBABA, J.C.A.: I have read the well-articulated Ruling of my learned brother, M. A. OREDOLA JCA, just delivered. I agree with him completely that the Application is meritorious and grantable.
I have to add that when it is obvious, as in this case, that the cause of the delay to appeal is traceable to the mistake or error of Counsel, Applicant is given the benefit of same, as he cannot be punished for the mistake or inadvertence of his Counsel, where such mistake or inadvertence is not at the root of the case, to deny him justice. See F.H.A. Vs Ejiogu (2016) LPELR – 40215 CA:
What constitutes good and substantial reason(s) to justify grant of extension of time to appeal is not exclusively or conclusively defined by Courts. That leaves the issue within the confines of the discretion of the appellate Court, in each circumstance, provided the discretion is exercised properly, given the facts disclosed in the Applicants affidavit to satisfy the Court as to the explanation for the delay to appeal within the prescribed time … An application for extension of time within, which to appeal must show that special circumstances exist to justify that the application should be granted. See Osinupebi Vs Saibu (1982) 7 SC 104… Mistake of Counsel qualifies as special circumstance. In other words, the Court would readily exercise its discretion to extend the period prescribed for doing an act, if it is shown to the satisfaction of the Court, that the failure by a party to do the act within the period prescribed was caused by the negligence or inadvertence of his Counsel. See Doherty Vs Doherty (1964)1 All NLR 299; Ahmadu Vs Salawu (1974) SC 43, … Ehighibe Vs Ehighibe (2016) LPELR 40047 CA.
I too grant the application and abide by the consequential orders in the lead Ruling.
TUNDE OYEBANJI AWOTOYE, J.C.A.: I agree.
Appearances:
- U. Maduakolam Esq.For Appellant(s)
Miss Chima Ezike For Respondent(s)
Appearances
- U. Maduakolam Esq.For Appellant
AND
Miss Chima Ezike For Respondent



