-
- E. MBONU & ORS v. ANDREW NWAGBARA & ORS
(2018)LCN/11713(CA)
In The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
On Thursday, the 14th day of June, 2018
CA/OW/95/2013
RATIO
CLAIM OF OWNERSHIP OF LAND FROM TIME IMMEMORIAL
The law however requires that one who pleads that he owned land from time immemorial to go beyond that story, and paint a genealogical tree of the many family ownership of the land.per ITA GEORGE MBABA, J.C.A.
JUSTICES
RAPHAEL CHIKWE AGBO Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
AYOBODE OLUJIMI LOKULO-SODIPE Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
ITA GEORGE MBABA Justice of The Court of Appeal of Nigeria
Between
- G. E. MBONU
2. ELDER ONWUNEME ABAZIE
3. CHIEF NWORISA E. UKPABI
4. A. I. NWOKOCHA
(For themselves and all representing Members of Umuda Isingwu Community
In Umuahia North L.G.A. of Abia State) Appellant(s)
AND
- ANDREW NWAGBARA
2. ISAIAH ONUOHA
3. AKOMAS UKEJE
4. EGEONU IHEDIGBO
5. UWAEZUOKE ULOGWARAOMA
6. ONUOHA CHUKWUNYERE
(Sued as representing members of Umuyota
Umuawa Alaocho Community in Umuahia North L.G.A. of Abia State) Respondent(s)ITA GEORGE MBABA, J.C.A. (Delivering the Leading Judgment):
This is an appeal against the decision of Abia State High Court in Suit No. HU/92/2010, delivered on 12/11/2008, by Hon. Justice A.U. Kalu, whereof the trial Court dismissed the claims of the Plaintiffs, now Appellants.
At the trial Court, the Plaintiffs sought the following reliefs against the Defendants (now Respondents):
(1) A declaration that the Plaintiffs are holders of or otherwise entitled to the statutory right of occupancy in respect of the piece or parcel of land verged RED in Survey Plan No. HAS/ABD/06/2001 of 24th April, 2001, prepared and signed by Surveyor H.C. Nwagboso and filed with this Statement of claim, part of ABO UMUDA ISINGWU.
(2) A perpetual injunction restraining the Defendants by themselves/their agents, servants, workmen and heir or otherwise, however, from going into the land or committing any acts of trespass against the land or otherwise interfering with the Plaintiffs right to the land or laying any claim thereto. (See page 9 of the Additional Records of Appeal).After hearing the case and considering the evidence and addresses of Counsel, the trial Court held:
Sadly, here the Plaintiffs in their Exhibit A and in evidence have not even shown that the land area they claim aligns with the boundaries as settled in Exhibit B. Not having tied their Exhibit B to their Exhibit A, I must say that the Plaintiffs have not helped their case in any way. On the contrary, though the defendants did not Counter-claim, this Court is impressed with the defence traditional history as to how their ancestor founded this land and exercised original acts of possession over it. I am very impressed with how the defendants narrated the people on whom the title in respect of the land devolved since its founding. The Plaintiffs did not, with clear particularity, join issues with the Defendant I reject the Plaintiffs evidence as to the possession of any portion of the land in dispute. I am however satisfied that the Defendants have proved, by very compelling evidence, which I accept that they are owners of the land in dispute, as clearly delineated in the Survey Plan tendered by the defendants before me and marked Exhibit C.
In conclusion, I am unable to convince myself on the evidence that a declaration of title can, with fairness and propriety, be granted to the Plaintiffs. The fact that the Defendants apparently abandoned an earlier Suit in which they were claiming title to the land, does not offer any help to the Plaintiffs. The onus remains on the Plaintiffs to prove their case, and this they have failed to do. I have no option but to dismiss the Plaintiffs case in its entirety. I award costs of N50,000.00 in favour of the Defendants against the Plaintiffs. (See page 89 of the Records of Appeal).Dissatisfied with the above decision, Appellants filed Notice of Appeal on 12/1/2009 (Pages 100 to 103 of the Records of Appeal), disclosing four (4) grounds of Appeal. They filed their brief of Arguments on 30/11/2016, upon the Records of Appeal being deemed duly filed on 18/10/2016. They distilled three (3) Issues for the determination of the Appeal, as follows:
(1) Whether the Learned Trial Judge approached the evidence before him, indeed the whole trial, in a proper and satisfactory manner. (Ground 1).3
(2) Whether, having regard to the pleadings the totality of the evidence and the material before him and the law, the Learned Trial Judge was right in dismissing the claim of the Appellants. (Ground 2).
(3) Whether the Learned Trial Judge was right in awarding an outrageous cost of N50,000.00 against the Appellants. (Ground 3)Appellants did not distill an issue from the ground 4 of the appeal, which was on the weight of evidence, and was in my opinion, superfluous, as the entire appeal appear to revolve round evaluation of evidence by the trial Court. The said ground 4 is therefore struck out, accordingly. See Kayode Vs State (2016) LPELR 40028 (SC).
The Respondents filed no Brief, and when this appeal came up on 19/4/2018 for hearing, the appeal was deemed duly argued, and there was evidence of service of hearing notice and the Appellants brief on the Respondents.
Arguing the Appeal, J.N. Kanu Esq., who settled the Appellants brief, on Issue one, said the trial Court was wrong to dismiss the claim of the Plaintiffs; he said that the trial Court did not evaluate the evidence adduced, properly and therefore slipped into error in its conclusions; that a Court has the duty to consider all the admissible and relevant evidence and issues raised before it. He relied on the case of Olufosoye & Ors Vs Olorunfemi (1989) NWLR (Pt. 95) 26 at 37; Ekwealor & Anor Vs Obasi & Ors (1990) 2 NWLR (Pt. 131) 231 at 260.
Counsel said the trial Court was perverse in its evaluation of evidence before him and findings of fact; that it was really bizarre for the Court to hold that the Plaintiffs were relying on acts of long possession and enjoyment of the land to prove their ownership; that the Court failed to confine itself to the case and claim of the plaintiffs/Appellants, and got carried away by the defence of traditional history put forward by the Defendants/Respondents. He referred us to page 87 of the Records and pages 5 9 of the Additional Records.
Counsel said that the trial Court failed to consider the evidence of the PW1, relating to the decision of the traditional arbitrators/mediators on the land (Exhibit B), which was accepted by the parties; that the trial Court was wrong to discard the said decision even where it was observed by the Court that the parties placed reliance on it and the decision in the Exhibit did not conflict with the evidence in Court. (Page 88 of the Records of Appeal).
Counsel also referred us to paragraph 22 of Appellants pleadings relating to the previous claims of Respondents (HU/1/2000) on the land, which was struck out because Respondent abandoned it, and the evidence of PW1, on page 31 of the Records, thereon, which established the claim of the Appellants; he argued that the trial Court failed to properly evaluate the same, especially as the Respondents (DW1) affirmed the said evidence and tendered Exhibits E and F as the processes (Suit No HU/1/2000), struck out. Counsel said the failure of the trial Judge to consider those pieces of evidence, worked great injustice to the Appellants.
On Issue 2, Counsel said the trial Court was wrong to dismiss Appellants claim. He said that Appellants had relied on long possession of the land, from time immemorial and had founded on arbitration decision which mediated and settled or affirmed the boundary between the parties, and this decision was accepted by the parties (See paragraphs 11 to 13 of the Appellants pleadings page 6 of the Additional Records). He added that the Respondents, both in their pleadings and evidence, did not deny the arbitration by the Ohuhu Traditional Rulers. He referred us to paragraphs 28 and 29 of Statement of defence by Respondents (page 18 of the Additional Records of Appeal). He also referred us to the Arbitration Report (Exhibit B) on pages 36 to 48 of the Additional Records of Appeal as well as to the evidence of DW1 (1st Respondent) on pages 43 44 of the Records.
Thus, Counsel said the decision of the trial Court, having ignored the arbitration decision, which was valid, subsisting and binding, promoted miscarriage of justice and should be set aside. He relied on Ngene Vs Igbo (1991) 7 NWLR (Pt. 203) 358; Adelaja Vs Alade (1999) 6 NWLR (Pt. 608) 544.
On whether the cost of N50,000.00, awarded against them, was proper, Appellants answered in the negative. Counsel admitted that the trial Court had power to award cost to a successful party, but added that cost is meant to indemnify the party, is not a bonus, nor made as punishment on the losing party.
He relied on Order 27 Rule 7 of the Abia State High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 2009. Counsel added that the N50,000.00 cost awarded was outrageous, in the circumstances. He urged us to resolve the issues for the Appellants and to allow the Appeal.
RESOLUTION OF THE ISSUES
I think the main issue for the determination of this Appeal, as earlier stated, is whether the Learned Trial Court had properly evaluated the evidence adduced before it, to reach its conclusion, dismissing the claim of the Appellants and awarding N50,000.00 cost against them (which Appellants described as outrageous).Appellants case (as Plaintiffs) was for declaration of title to land, and injunction, saying they were entitled to the Statutory right of occupancy in respect of the piece or parcel of land, verged RED in the Survey Plan No. HAS/ABD/06/2001 of 24/4/2001; they also sought perpetual injunction restraining the Defendants, therefrom.
In their pleading, paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Amended Statement of claim, Appellants stated that:
(6) The land in dispute is part of a larger parcel or piece of land known as and called ABO UMUDA ISINGWU, itself is part of still larger vast area of land, known as ABO.(7) The Plaintiffs have, from time immemorial, been owners in possession of the ABO land.
Appellants also stated how hostility started over the land, leading to the Court action, thus:
(8) Sometime, before the Nigerian Civil War, the Defendants attempted to make incursions into the said ABO land. The attempted incursions were repelled by the Plaintiffs. The Plaintiffs still remained owners in possession of ABO land
(10) The Plaintiffs aver that the Defendants continued the forays until the year 1983, when Ohuhu Traditional Rulers and Elders intervened and mediated between the two parties the Plaintiffs and the Defendants.
(11) The Plaintiffs aver that following the said mediation of the Ohuhu Traditional Rulers and Elders, the Plaintiffs ceded to the Defendants a portion of the said ABO land. The said portion ceded to the Defendants by the Plaintiffs out of the said ABO land is verged blue in the Survey Plan filed with the Statement of claim
(12) The proceedings of the mediation and judgment of the mediators which was reduced into writing is hereby pleaded. Plaintiffs copy of the Record of proceedings and judgment given to them by the mediators shall be relied upon at the trial of this Suit.
(13) Both parties, the Plaintiffs and Defendants, accepted the findings and decision of the Ohuhu Traditional Rulers and Elders (See pages 7 8 of the Additional Records of Appeal)Of course, Appellants, as Plaintiffs, led evidence in line with the above pleadings and tendered the proceedings and judgment of the Ohuhu Traditional Rulers and Elders Arbitration/Mediations Report as Exhibit B. (See pages 27 36 of the Records of Appeal).
It is clear from the above, how the Appellants came to claim ownership of the land in dispute that they had been in long possession of the same, from time immemorial.
The Respondents had denied the paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Appellants pleadings, and rather stated that the Defendants: founded and deforested the land from its virgin state by the Defendants progenitor called AWA, who is now late and who upon deforesting same took possession of same as the owner and was using same for farming purposes without let or hindrance from anybody, including the Plaintiffs or their ancestors, during the life time of the said AWA (see paragraphs 9 to 12 of the Statement of defence of the Respondents on pages 17 to 18 of the Additional Records).
In paragraphs 20 to 23, the Respondents pleaded, as follows:
(20) The Defendants aver that as time went on, these Umuda people saw that the land at Umuda Okpuala could no longer accommodate them for two major reasons, namely:
(a) Increased population of the people of Umuda and
(b) The area occupied by them was surrounded with big gullies, making expansion impossible.
(21) The Defendants aver that as a result of (a) and (b) above, the people of Umuda of the Plaintiffs approached the people of Atta Ibeku Community Umuahia to accommodate them within the land of Atta Ibeku people. The people of Atta Ibeku allowed them a place at Ohohu Ukwa where they settled.
(22) The Defendants aver that as time went on the people of Umuda continued to experience increase in population, they further approached and requested for a grant of land to enable them to be properly accommodate and the request was granted that till date, some people from Umuda Isingwu such as Umu Uchendu are residing at the land shown to them by the people of Atta Ibeku situate at Atta Ibeku, Umuahia.
(23) The Defendants aver that as time went on the people of Umuda of the Plaintiffs further approached the people of Umuyota kindred of the Defendants for land to enable them to be properly accommodated and the people of Umuyota kindred of the Defendants granted their request and granted them part of the ALA ABO UMUYOTA and thereafter on the agreement of both parties, a Survey Plan indicating the area granted to the Plaintiffs by the people of Umuyota of the Defendants was prepared and the beacons planted.The Respondents also denied the paragraphs 8 to 13 of the Appellants pleading, but admitted the mediation by the Chief of Ohuhu, when there was trespass into part of the ALA ABO UMUYOTA LAND of the Defendants, now in dispute and there was a serious problem, which resulted into the intervention of some traditional rules ad Chiefs in Ohuhu. See paragraphs 25 to 29 of the Statement of defence, and in the said paragraph 29, Respondents said
The two parties were called to state their case and thereafter, the panel visited the land for inspection. In the night after the visit by the panel and the parties to the land in dispute, i.e. the locus inquo, one of the witnesses who testified for the Plaintiffs during the inspection, one Ezekiel Ogwuilu, died and the day the case was fixed for further hearing and judgment, the Plaintiffs community became afraid and refused to appear but sent a message to the panel that they were no longer interested in the matter. The panel therefore did not conclude and deliver their decision in the absent (sic) of the Plaintiffs. The Defendants continued to remain in possession of the land until 1999, when they observed that one Chief Onyenweaku Maxwell Nwaigwe was trespassing on the land and when he was challenged by the Defendants, he told the Defendants that he bought the land from the Plaintiffs. The Defendants stopped him from building on the land and he reported to the Police. The Defendants were arrested and charged to Court. After the trial, the Defendants were all discharged. (Page 20 of the Records).
Of course, Respondents also gave evidence in line with their pleadings.
Appellants had pleaded and stated in evidence that the parties (including the Respondents) accepted the findings and decision of the said Ohuhu Traditional Rulers and Elders; that the Defendants, up till now, have not challenged the findings and decision of the said Arbitrators/Mediators. The story of the Respondents, that somebody in the camp of the Plaintiffs died, after inspection of the locus inquo by the Arbitrations/Mediators, and so the Plaintiffs community became afraid and refused to appear and sent message to the panel that they were no longer interested in the matter, sounds ridiculous, considering the fact that the same Plaintiffs claimed by Respondents, to have frustrated the conclusion of the arbitration, or who allegedly wrote to call off the delivery of the judgment by the panel, are those pleading and relying on the decision/judgment of the Ohuhu Traditional Rulers/Elders, asserting that the panel heard the case to conclusion and made award in (Exhibit B) which was accepted by all the parties!
I think the trial Court erred greatly when it failed to locate the Exhibit B, properly, in this case, and rather hurriedly dismissed it when it said:
The Exhibit B entitled Judgment of land Dispute between Umuana and Umuyota Alaocha, deilivered by Ndi Eze Ohuhu on Monday 28th November, 1983 which the parties made heavy weather of, does not even seem helpful to the Plaintiffs, even if we ignore the objections of the Defendants to its authenticity. I say so because a reading of the document shows that it does not conflict with the evidence before the Court (See page 88 of the Additional Records)Did the trial Court expect the proceedings and decision in the Arbitration/Mediation Report to conflict with the evidence before the Court for the Report to be helpful to the Appellants That sounds strange to me!
The trial Court even found some positive points about the said Arbitration Report (Exhibit B), when it said on the page 88 of the Additional Records of Appeal:
Whatever be the case, the parties share a common boundary on this land called Aboh. Now, a reading of paragraphs 1, 2 and 4 of Exhibit B shows that the arbitrators accepted the common boundary between both parties on this land called Aboh and proceeded to do a boundary demarcation of the Aboh land.Surprisingly, after the above profound findings, the trial Court relapsed into a grave error in my respectful view, when it said:
Sadly, here the Plaintiffs in their Exhibit A and in evidence have not even shown that the land area they claim aligns with the boundaries as settled in Exhibit B. Not having tied their Exhibit B to their Exhibit A, I must say that the Plaintiffs have not helped their case in any way. On the contrary, though the Defendants did not Counter-claim, this Court is impressed with the defence traditional history as to how their ancestor founded this land and exercise original acts of possession over it. I am very impressed with how the defendants narrated the people on whom the title in respect of the land devolved, since its founding. The Plaintiffs did not, with clear particularity, join Issues with the Defendants on the point. (See page 88 of the Additional Records of Appeal).With the above findings and holding, it appears to me that the trial Court clearly misconstrued the case it was called upon to determine, and it was misled, or carried away by the evidence of DW1 (defence), who set up a complete different case for the Court to try (without Counter-claiming formally to place that case before the Court).
Whereas Appellants line of claim of title to land, as per paragraph 7 of their pleading was long possession of the land, from time immemorial, the Respondents did not challenge that line of claim, but rather stated their case being right of ownership by traditional history; that their ancestor, Awa, having found/deforested the land and the same devolved right down to them! They also claimed the Plaintiffs were granted the land they occupy/possess by the ancestors of the Defendants! (See paragraphs 12, 19 23 of the Statement of defence and the evidence of DW1).
Even the above evidence by the Respondents, in my view, tends to corroborate the claims of the Appellants as to their rights of ownership, by long possession from time immemorial! This is not to say that Appellants admitted that the property was a grant to their fathers by the Respondents ancestors. But even if that were so, would the Respondents have the vires to rescind the decision of their alleged ancestors, and deny Appellant their right of ownership and enjoyments of the land purportedly granted to them The answer in my opinion is a Capital NO!
See the case of Ekpa & Ors Vs Utong (1991) LPELR 1084 SC; Ezenwora Vs Ezenwora (2018) LEPLR 43944 (CA); and Ashilonu & Anor Vs Ohale & Anor (2018) LEPLR 44267 CA, where this Court relied on the case of Ekpa & Ors Vs Utong (Supra) to say:
Appellants therefore had the evidential burden of not only establishing their title to the said parcels of land by traditional evidence but also that even the portions of land allegedly given to the ancestor of the Defendants by the ancestors of the Claimants (or bought subsequently by members of the Respondents family) were revertible to the Claimants. See the case of Ekpa & Ors Vs Utong & Ors (1991) LPELR 1084 (SC):
I think it has to be conceded that a person is completely without power or competence to revoke a completely constituted gift of land made inter vivos by his ancestor who let the donee into possession some one-and-a-half centuries ago, unless, perhaps, he can show that such a gift was null and void ab initio or that the gift was subject to a condition which has been broken. But none is the case here. Such a gift of land completed with delivery of possession according to custom is a transfer of ownership of the land to the donee and extinction of the rights of those who claim through or under the donor.The law is trite on the five ways a person can establish title to land, namely:
(1) By traditional history/evidence;
(2) By production of title documents to the land;
(3) By acts of ownership numerous and positive, extending over sufficient length of time to warrant the inference that the person is the true owner;
(4) By acts of long possession;
(5) By proof of possession of adjacent lands in the circumstances which render it probable that the owner of such adjacent lands would, in addition, be the owner of the disputed land. See the leading case of Idundun Vs Okumagba (1976) LPELR 1431 SC; Orlu Vs Gogo Abite (2010) NWLR (Pt. 1196) 307; Atanda Vs Ajani & Ors (1989) NWLR (Pt. 111) 511; Ayorinde & Ors Vs Sogunro & Ors (2012) LPELR 7808 (SC); Nwabuoku & Ors Vs Onwordi & Ors (2006) LPELR 2082 SC; Ezerioha Vs Mgbeajulu & Ors (2018) LPELR 43811 CA.I have already stated that Appellants elected to establish their title to the land by pleading long possession of the land, from time immemorial. The Learned Trial Judge in my opinion was wrong to confuse that way of proving title with that of traditional history, whereof a party pleads that his ancestor founded the land and/or deforested it and traces the devolution of the land from his said ancestor to himself, as the Respondents attempted to do, even when they actually had no case to prove!
I think Appellants did not have to counter the Respondents or to join issue with the Respondents on such frolic as the trial Court erroneously held. Appellants duty in my view was only to trace their long possession and exercise acts of ownership on the land to as long as they could remember, and/or beyond recent memory.What is meant by from time immemorial means, beyond living memory; that the acts of possession of the land has always been enjoyed by the parties beyond their living memory, without challenge, and it may not be really traced to any recorded time! It may mean several generations ago. (Allison & Anor. Vs S.C.M Ltd (2017) LPELR 42837 SC).
The law however requires that one who pleads that he owned land from time immemorial to go beyond that story, and paint a genealogical tree of the many family ownership of the land. In the case of Dagaci of Dere & Ors Vs Dagaci of Ebwa & Ors (2006) LPELR 911 SC, my Lord Tobi JSC (of blessed memory) said:
In land matters, it is easy for a Plaintiff to claim that he owned the land from time immemorial. But that is not the end of the story. The story must go further and paint a genealogical tree of the family ownership of the land. It is usually a long story of the members of the family in ownership of the land from the past to the present. The Plaintiff paints a picture of genealogical lines and names, spreading like the branches of a tree, telling a consistent and flowing story of undisturbed ownership or possession of the land. And the flowing story which should first be told in the pleadings should mention specific persons as ancestors before the witnesses give evidence in Court to vindicate the averments in pleadings. See also Gwantu Vs Yaki & Ors (2013) LPELR 21416 (CA); Anyanwu Vs Mbara & Anor (1992) NWLR (Pt.242) 386.
But I do also think proof of ownership by long possession should be distinguished from ownership by historical evidence of ancestral founding/deforestation of the land and genealogical devolution of land. When one considers that land can be acquired by conquest or settlement and or grant, and the succeeding generations keep enjoying peaceable possession/occupation of the land undisturbed, it would be wrong and unfortunate, in my view, to require the persons who have exercised such long possession and ownership of the land, over the years, or from time immemorial, to trace the original person who settled on the land or acquired it and the succeeding generations that enjoyed the land, before the interruption by a mischief maker, giving rise to the Suit.I think in such a situation, the mischief maker, or person who seeks to unsettle the peaceful enjoyment of the land, should be the one to prove better title to defeat the claim of long possession. See Iseogbekun & Anor. Vs Adelakun & Ors (2012) LPELR 15516 (SC); Ogbechie Vs Onochie (1988) 1 NWLR (Pt. 70) 570.
This case involves two Communities/Villages, and a panel of Traditional Rulers and Elders of the whole area (Ohuhu Communities) met to mediate and came to conclusion affirming the rights of each side to their lands and that the dispute was about boundary and settling the contending issue of the land boundaries for them, and they accepted the settlement. I think that such settlement should mark the end of the story/challenge of parties to their respective lands as well as the dispute as to the boundaries.
Pages 13 to 18 of the Records carry the proceedings and decision of the panel of Arbitrators, over the land dispute (Exhibit B). Their Ruling (on pages 75 77 of the Additional Records of Appeal) was:
Whereas the essence of this major land dispute between the two friendly neighbor villages is to bridge the gap of strained relationship between them arising from the conflict which was later decided by and agreed upon by both parties to submit to an arbitration panel for a lasting peaceful settlement.
In view of the foregoing judgment as shown here above and in as much as every aspect of the whole case have been fully looked into and carefully studied in the spirit of give and take good judgment. We therefore unanimously passed our judgment and ruled hereby that the boundary adjustments and demarcations made by us as on 12th November, 1983, and made explanatory in the inspection demarcation exhibits Shown as A for Abo B for branch of Abo or part thereof lastly O for Okota. All these areas to belong and remain as demarcated by the panel on the said date being 12/11/83.
Finally, in considerations of the friendly and blood connections amongst the two factions and in the interest of peace and good Government and remembering the future generations yet unborn.
We ended this case by urging the two Communities to co-operate with us and accept this judgment in the best interest of mankind with malice towards none.Signed
Signed
His Highness Eze R.A. Onyemo Eze III
Uhu I of Umuhu
Signed
His Highness Eze I. Nwadinobi OFR.
Uga I of Nkwoegwu
Signed
Signed
His Highness Eze Elect I.B. Nwachukwu
Achiuga of Okaiuga.The law relating to traditional arbitration is well known and same in my opinion is applicable to this case which is that an award is binding on the parties when it satisfies the following conditions as set out in the case of DURU & ORS Vs DURU & ORS(2017) LPELR 42490 CA, where it was restated:
Any party relying on a decision of customary arbitration must, as the Respondent stated, plead and establish, by evidence the following:
(1) A voluntary submission of the matter in dispute to an arbitration of one or more persons;
(2) An agreement of the parties either expressly or by implication that the decision of the arbitration will be accepted as final and binding;
(3) That the said arbitration was in accordance with the Custom of the parties of their trade or business;
(4) That the arbitrators reached a decision and published their award; and
(5) That the decision or award was accepted at the time it was made.
See also the case of Eke and Ors Vs Okwaranyia & Ors (2001) LPELR 1074 SC; Ohiaeri Vs Akabeze (1992) 2 NWLR (Pt. 221) 1 at 24.In my view, the above conclusions were satisfied in the Exhibit B, and so the arbitration decision was binding on the parties and should have been given effect to by the trial Court, having held that paragraphs 1, 2 and 4 of Exhibit B shows that the arbitrators accepted the common boundary between both parties on this land called Aboh and proceeded to do a boundary demarcation of the Aboh land and that a reading of the document (Exhibit B) shows that it does not conflict with the evidence before the Court. The evidence before the Court shows that both parties communities own portions of the land called Aboh. (See page 88 of the Records of Appeal).
With the above findings and holding of the trial Court, it appears contradictory, when the trial Court, subsequently held:
Sadly, the Plaintiffs in their Exhibit A and in evidence have not even shown that the land area they claim aligns with the boundaries as settled in Exhibit B.”That was conflicting and perverse. It would appear the holding of the trial Court had settled the parties ownership of their respective areas, when it said:
The evidence before the Court shows that both parties communities own portions of the land called Aboh. The defendants claim that their ancestor deforested the whole Aboh land and that along the line the defendants say their ancestors made a gift of a part of the Aboh land to the Plaintiffs.The Plaintiffs dispute this defence evidence as to gift, but failed to plead or lead evidence as to how they and their ancestors came to own this land. Whatever be the case, the parties share a common boundary on this land called Aboh. Now a reading of paragraphs 1, 2 and 4 of Exhibit B shows that the arbitrators accepted the common boundary between both parties on this land Aboh and proceeded to do a boundary demarcation of the Aboh land.
The above shows the area of land in dispute was identified and ascertained, and that the boundary problem was settled by the demarcation, made by the Arbitrators for them, and they accepted the settlement! The issue of the ownership of the parties to the sides they occupied appeared also established and settled by the trial Court, and so it amounted to a somersault, in my view, for the trial Court to say put in simple language, I reject the Plaintiffs evidence as to possession of any portion of the land in dispute page 88 of the Records.
The parties knew the land and the area that was in dispute, the issue being actually boundary problems, which was settled by demarcation by the Arbitrators. There was therefore no more issue of identity of the land in dispute, and/or Appellants failure to align their Exhibit A with the boundaries as settled in the Exhibit B. Generally, identity of land ceases to be an issue in a case, where the land in dispute is well known to the parties. See Iroegbu Vs Abazie (2017) LPELR 42617 (CA); Ayuya Vs Yonrin (2011) ALL FWLR (Pt. 583) 1865 (SC); Dakolo Vs Dakolo (2011) LPELR 915 (SC).
In the case of Duru Vs Duru (2017) LPELR 42490 (CA), this Court held:
the parties knew the exact portion that was in dispute and the Court was never in doubt about it. The law is that where the parties have identified the land in dispute and each knows the land in contention, identity of the land cannot be an issue, again. See Bachirawa Vs Abdullahi (2016) LPELR 41170 (CA); Enyinnaya Vs Otikpo & Anor (2015) LPELR 25529 (CA); Edjekpo Vs Osia (2007) ALL FWLR (Pt. 361) 1617; Jimoh & Ors Vs Akande & Ors (2009) LPELR 8087 (SC).I think the trial Court was also in deep error when it held:
I am however satisfied that the defendants have proved, by very compelling evidence, which I accept, that they are the owners of the land in dispute as clearly delineated in the Survey Plan tendered by the defendants as Exhibit C. (Page 8 of the Records).There was actually no case set up or canvassed by the Defendants at the trial Court, and so there was none for Respondents to prove, in view of the evidence adduced in the case. The trial Court was therefore trying to make a case for the Respondents, which is not permitted. See Otu & Anor. Vs Ani & Ors (2013) LPELR 21405 (CA); Obi Vs A.G. Imo State (2014) LPELR 24280 CA; Suberu Vs The State (2010) LPELR 3120 (SC).
I therefore resolve the issues for the Appellants, that the appeal is meritorious. I do not see any point discussing and considering the issue of N50,000.00 cost awarded by the trial Court to the Respondents, since the said judgment is no longer valid. But it should be stated that cost is always awarded at the discretion of the trial Court, and should be properly exercised to indemnify the successful party not to punish the unsuccessful party. See Nwawka Vs Adikamkwu (2014) LPELR 22927 (CA); Shanusi & Ors Vs Odugbemi & Anor (2017) LPELR 43377 (CA); Saeby Vs Olaogun (1999) 10,12 SC 45 at 59; Akinbobola Vs Plisson Fisko Nig. Ltd (1991) 1 NWLR (Pt.167) 270 (SC).
I allow the appeal and set aside the decision of the trial Court delivered in HU/92/2000 on 12/11/2008, dismissing the Plaintiffs case. I rather enter judgment for the Appellants (Plaintiffs at the Court below) in the case, going by the arbitration report (Exhibit B), which was binding on the parties. Appellants were entitled to the statutory rights of occupancy and injunction sought. They are also entitled to the cost of this Appeal, assessed at Fifty Thousand Naira (N50.000,00) only, payable by the Respondents.
RAPHAEL CHIKWE AGBO, J.C.A.: I agree.
AYOBODE OLUJIMI LOKULO-SODIPE, J.C.A.: I agree.
Appearances
J.N. KANU, ESQ.For Appellant
AND
No Representation For Respondent



