LawCare Nigeria

Nigeria Legal Information & Law Reports

A.U. DEDUWA & ORS. V. EMMANUEL AMOMA OKORODUDU & ORS.-1976

A.U. DEDUWA & ORS. V. EMMANUEL AMOMA OKORODUDU & ORS.

(1976) LCN/2235(SC)

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Friday, October 15, 1976


Case N
umber: SC.74/1974

 

JUSTICES:

DARNLEY A. R. ALEXANDER     JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

ATANDA FATAYI-WILLIAMS     JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

GEORGE S. SOWEMIMO     JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

AYO G. IRIKEFE     JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

CHARLES O. MADARIKAN     JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

MOHAMMED BELLO     JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

CHUKWUNWEIKE IDIGBE     JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF NIGERIA

BETWEEN

APPELLANTS

1. A.U. DEDUWA

2. CHIEF S.O. OLOGIDE

3. CHIEF P.O. ARUNURE – (SUIT NO.W/22/68)

4. DOGBOR OROBIROKA (for themselves and on behalf of Eribregbe family of Ogunu Village)

AND

RESPONDENTS

1. EMMANUEL AMOMA OKORODUDU.

2. LAYE ATIYO ARUBU (for themselves and on behalf of Yonwuren and Agbeje families of Ugbuwangue)

3. ITSEKIRI COMMUNAL LAND TRUSTEES

4. ETSITSO AGBAMU

5. ORITSETIMEYIN AGBAMU

6. OGBE AGBAMU

7. ASATU DENEDO – (SUIT NO. W/28/69)

8. EREWA OFOLU

9. JOHN OJI OBORO

10. KENERA OLUYEMI DENEDO

11. SAMUEL OJEH OFOLU

12. SAMPSON EDUN AFIEKPONE

13. SOLOMON MENE (For themselves and on behalf of the Ubeji Community)

RATIO

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – FAIR HEARING: Concept of “Fair Hearing”

“A fair hearing must, of course, be a hearing that does not contravene the principles of natural justice. Evershed M.R. said in Abbot v. Sullivan (1952) 1 KB189, at page 195 ‘ “The principles of natural justice are easy to proclaim, but their precise extent is far less easy to define”. However, the two essential elements of natural justice with which we are concerned in this appeal are that ” (1) no man shall be Judge in his own cause; and (2) both sides shall be heard, or audi alterem partem.” Per Alexander, C.J.N. 

COURT – “BIAS”: The test of ‘real likelihood of bias’

“The test of a ‘real likelihood of bias’ was also explained and applied in Obadara & Ors. v. Commissioner of Police (1987) NMLR 39 and in Oyelade v. Araoye & Attorney-General (1968) NMLR 41 confirming Obadara’s case, but in somewhat different circumstances. In Obadara’s case Brett, Ag. CJN., said at page 44 – “The principle that a Judge must be impartial is accepted in the jurisprudence of any civilised country and there are no grounds for holding that in this respect the law of Nigeria differs from the law of England or for hesitating to follow English decisions” Per Alexander, C.J.N.

COURT – BIAS: Test for ‘the real likelihood of bias’

“the examination of the allegation of “interest” or ‘bias’ or real likelihood of bias on the part of the trial Judge in the conduct of the proceedings before him goes much further than this. Although the smallest pecuniary interest will disqualify a Judge, there are other grounds based on public policy on which bias or the real likelihoood of bias may disqualify a Judge “The law, in laying-rule has regard not so much perhaps to the motives which might be supposed to bias the Judge as to the susceptibilities of the litigant parties. One important object, at all events, is to clear away everything which might engender suspicion and distrust of tribunal, and so to promote the feeling of confidence in the administration of justice which is so essential to social order and security”. Again, in Metropolitan properties v. Lannon (1969) 1 QB 577, Lord Denning M.R., said at page 599 – “In considering whether there was a real likelihood of bias, the court does not look at the mind of the justice himself or at the mind of the chairman of the tribunal, or whoever it may be, who sits in a judicial capacity. It does not look to see if there was a real likelihood that he would, or did, in fact favour one side at the expense of the other. The court looks at the impression which would be given to other people. Even if he was as impartial as could be, nevertheless, if right-minded persons would think that, in the circumstances, there was a real likelihood of bias on his part, then, he should not sit. And if he does sit, his decision cannot stand “. Nevertheless, there must appear to be a real likelihood of bias. Surmise or conjecture is not enough “. There must be circumstances from which a reasonable man would think it likely or probable that the justice, or chairman, as the case may be, would, or did, favour one side unfairly at the expense of the other. The court will not enquiry whether he did, in fact, favour one side unfairly. Suffice it that reasonable people might think he did. The reason is plain enough. Justice must be rooted in confidence, and confidence is destroyed when right-minded people go away thinking: “The Judge was biased”.” Per Alexander, C.J.N. 

 

Alexander, C.J.N. (Delivering the Leading Judgment): The appellants were the plaintiffs in Suit No. W/22/68 filed in the High Court of Mid-Western State (now Bendel State) of Nigeria at Warri in the Warri Judicial Division, while the respondents, including Shell-BP Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited, hereinafter referred to as “Shell-BP”, were the defendants in that suit.  On the other hand, the respondents, excluding Shell-BP, were the plaintiffs in Suit No. W/28/69 filed in the same High Court, also at Warri in the Warri Judicial Division, while the appellants and Shell-BP were the defendants in that suit.  In Suit No. W/22/68 Shell-BP was the 4th defendant, while in Suit No. W/28/69 Shell-BP was the 5th defendant.  The plaintiffs in Suit No. W/22/68 (now the appellants) claimed against the defendants (now the respondents) as follows:  “(1) As against the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 5th to 14th defendants jointly and severally a declaration of title to all that piece or parcel of land lying and situate in Ogunu territory verged in pink on survey plan No. AR.663 filed in support of this action.  (2) An order for payment over to the plaintiffs of the sum of 10,623.10 pounds or any sum paid or payable by the 4th defendant as first annual rent and or compensation in respect of 4th defendant’s occupation and/or user of the piece or parcel of land described and shown as in (1) above.  (3)   An order that the plaintiffs as owners and/or persons formerly in occupation (i.e. prior to the 4th defendant’s occupation and/or user as from February 1968) of the piece or parcel of land aforesaid are entitled as against the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 5th to 14th defendants to all rent and/or compensation due from and payable by the 4th defendant’s occupation and/or user of the said piece or parcel of land. (4)    An order that the 4th defendant do pay over to the plaintiffs the sum of 982 pounds already assessed by plaintiffs and 4th defendant being compensation due to the plaintiffs for their mangrove and other economic trees growin